New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Woodworking Course

Posts

Woodworking Course

#1

Woodworking Course

Mark Hennebury

You could learn all that you need to know about woodworking in a one month course. Shouldnt take any longer than that!

Anyone like to offer an opinion.

Re: Woodworking Course

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Woodworking Course

Jack Guzman from Maine

I hope you are joking. You couldn't learn all there is to know about woodworking in a lifetime. There's always something else to learn. I consider myself a perpetual student. I don't think I'll ever stop learning.---You asked for opinions.That's mine.---Jack

Re: Woodworking Course

#3

Ellis Walentine

Hmmm

Ellis Walentine

Perhaps you need to qualify that statement with your notion of just how much we need to know about woodworking. :) I'm still learning after fifty years.

Ellis

Re: Woodworking Course

#4

Re: Woodworking Course

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Never having taken a course, I don't know...perhaps a one month intensive course could be enough for you to learn on your own from then on. But that's wild, without-basis opinion on my part.

With the crafts and the arts, I think you're never actually done being anything until you die; you're always becoming whatever it might be.

Re: Woodworking Course

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Woodworking Course

Jack Guzman from Maine

I reread your post and I noticed that you said "all you NEED to know about woodworking" My answer is still the same but I guess it depends what you need to learn it for. For instance:a one week course in windsor chairmaking gives you the basics but you still need years of practice to get all the smaller details,and even then I doubt you'll ever get all there is to learn on the subject.

If what you are asking is will a month of classes be enough to get you started in business making furniture then I would say it all depends on which classes you take and what you want to build ,then maybe.Depends on how good the teacher is and how well you learn.---Jack

Re: Woodworking Course

#6

Sure it would...

John in NM

If you've already spent 20 years building stuff :D :D :D

If you've never done any woodworking, that 1 month course will make little sense to you.

I say the same thing about differential equations - if I'd only known in high school algebra what I know now, all those word problems would have been so easy!

Re: Woodworking Course

#7

Re: Woodworking Course

CStan

Carving, veneering, turning, chairmaking?

Maybe one month if you're talking about the very basics. Ridiculous if including the above.

Re: Woodworking Course

#8

Maybe

Bob Hackett

Unfortunately that particular one month course is booked solid for the next twenty years so I guess I`ll never know for sure.

All the rest of the courses I`ve seen take at least a couple of months of intensive study to teach you the basics and then you have to follow up with a lifetime of refining what you really want to do before you can decide what you truly need to learn and who you need to learn it from.

Even if you finally arrive at that point where you have learned everything you need to know about a particular aspect of the craft, there`s no guarantee that you`ll still be moving in that same direction when you wake up the next morning.

Each new tree, new project, new tool and new technique bring an opportunity for additional learning experiences. Crank in a little metal, stone or other material besides wood into the mix and and you now have several lifetimes worth of learning to contend with.

Can I change my answer to no? :)

Re: Woodworking Course

#9

Clarification

Mark Hennebury

I said, all you need to know, not all there is to know.

And I agree that we should all be perpetual students.

I should expand a bit on what i was thinking:

I have over the course of the past month on this forum been involved in the discussions about hanplanes, and most of my comments have been about learning, and the random and haphazard way in which get information, both good and bad information. I know that it took me many years to learn some simple things that i could have in a hour or two, and this chipbreaker thing is one good example.

So what i was thinking:

Not about teaching a comprehensive course about making all kinds of projects. That of course you will spend your lifetime on.

how long would it take to get a good summery of all of the most important points of woodworking to enable someone to go and learn the rest. To be able to do their own reading and exploring but with a solid understanding of the foundation of woodworking.

So a course that would teach things like:

Wood structure: Cell structure, Moisture content, Shrinkage and expansion,

Engineering properties of wood: Working with wood, structural properties, joinery explained

Tools: a thorough understanding of how tools cut wood, both hand and power tools.

Dressing and prepping lumber: precison marking out, and establishing processes and procedures for organising and completing work.

This is not a complete list of course, but i dont think that it would take very long for me to have accquired enough information to have set me on the way. I could have learned in a month what took me 10 or 15 years to learn on my own.

I think that in a month you could have all the basic information that you would need.

Re: Woodworking Course

#10

Re: Woodworking Course

Stuart Johnson

I don't know about everything you need to know but I do know from experience you can get a basic foundation.

I took a series of courses at Homestead Heritage conducted by Paul Sellers and Stan Beckworth. They consisted of a one day, two day and a couple six day courses with each building on what was taught in the prior ones. They ranged from from basic dovetails, small dovetailed boxes, dado cutting to a coffee table and finally a rocking chair. These were all done with hand tools. I've since built small dressers, cabinets and so forth using both hand and power tools.

Prior to taking the classes I had never built anything other than a plywood trash can in the eighth grade. So yes I think you can learn the basics in a month but you will have a long way to go before you are a craftsman. The big plus is you can learn to enjoy yourself and have fun in under a day.

Re: Woodworking Course

#11

Re: More Clarification

Mark Hennebury

I am not talking about learning to make projects of any kind, but learning about the principles that you will apply to all of your projects.

Locked in a room for a week, I am pretty sure that i could show anyone everything about wood structure that they would ever use in woodworking. So that they would have an understanding of the material from its cell structure to working properties etc. etc. So that they had enough knowledge and critical thinking to be able to apply this to projects that they would build in the future.

I made alot of mistakes designing and building furniture because i lacked this basic knowledge. It took me many years to understand wood, but its not a lot to understand not really, it could be taught in a week.

I wish someone had given me that course the first month that i started,i would have saved a lot of time and dissapointments.

The same with tuning, setting up, using and understanding tools and basic machinery, marking out, priciples and processes etc.

Re: Woodworking Course

#12

Re: Woodworking Course

John Pappas

I'm a self taught woodworker (40+years) and have often said that I could have learned what I know is less time if I had just had a good mentor. But gosh, I didn't realize just how slow I am! Sigh!

Re: Woodworking Course

#13

part 1. Understanding wood

Mark Hennebury

I believe that armed with the book Understanding Wood by Bruce Hoadley a few samples of various woods, an eye loupe, digital callipers, chisel, hammer, clamps etc… One could get a thorough understanding of wood in a week.

do everything to the wood, bend it break it, weigh it, split it, dent it, crush it, chop it, slice it, saw it, sand it, plane it, twist it, soak it, dry it, rip it apart, drill it put nails and screws in it, glue it together, bust it apart, scrape it, slice it one way then another, shine a light on it from one direction then the other etc etc…you get the idea. just observe, examine and analyze the results and continually refer to “The Book”

I think that with someone to guide you would gain enough of an understanding of wood to be able to guide you the rest of your life as you worked on future projects.

I had a man come to my shop about 15 years ago looking for me to teach him woodworking in exchange for working for free for a month, during the summer break from his 3 year heritage restoration course at the local college. I told him that there was a lot to learn and there would be lots of studying to do and homework, he said okay, so I gave him a block of wood and told him to take it home and read it and come back Monday and tell me everything about it.

He never went back to college but stayed with me for several years saying that he learned more in the one month with me then the entire first year of his college course.

So I think that a specifically designed course could teach a thorough foundation of woodworking in a month.

Re: Woodworking Course

#14

Re: Woodworking Course

Mark Hennebury

If I asked you to condense all that you know about woodworking into what you consider have been the most important principles that you use on most every project, could you teach that in a month?

Re: Woodworking Course

#15

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Adult Learning

Jim in Burlington ON

It's not just content that matters. Baby boomers, X Geners and Y generation all learn differently. While you could easily teach the basics and some theory to woodworking, having a take home computer based disc package with many hours of video would be the best. Off the top of my head having about 1000 hours of instruction in any medium of your choice you still need 500 hours of time spent with someone of great skill. This coupled with 3-4000 hours of practice would be closer to the real picture. Given tools like tablets and face time you could concievably work through several problem over that time and perhaps lower the time spent directly with a mentor but this has proved out to be rare. Background and context to receive the information and configure it in yoru own mind requires some time. Having read thousands of pages of instruction manuals, operating manuals and maintenance manuals I always say take into context my comments are from my point of view some of which are questions as is my answer here.

Re: Woodworking Course

#16

I don't agree, not even close

Bill Tindall

I took a one week class at a working shop making something that included veneering a panel, a drawer, a door , case construction, French feet, cock beading. Without considerable experience going in I would not have gotten nearly as much out of it. In the week we failed to finish the door nor do any finishing.

Still to learn would be finishing, carving, turning, other foot types -Queen Ann, Bracket, etc., design. bending, inlay, various machines, etc.

I am thinking something like 2 years to cover enough that one could do it professionally.

Re: Woodworking Course

#17

Ellis Walentine

Basic information

Ellis Walentine

I think that in a month you could have all the basic information that you would need.

I could possibly agree with that, but only to address the most basic of woodworking decisionmaking. I have a feeling that your test subject, after a month of the intensive training that you've outlined, would shortly, on his/her first project, find himself (herself) up against the wall on decisions that go beyond the pale of your proposed Cliff Notes sort of course in woodworking, or they wouldn't be able to transfer that learning to situations at hand.

I totally agree that it is possible to learn a lot more from an actual instructor; in fact, it might not be possible to learn more without one.

I've been wrong before.

Ellis

Re: Woodworking Course

#18

Re: Adult Learning

Mark Hennebury

I am not talking about turning you into a high cabinetmaker in a month, just about giving you the all of basic tools to begin your journey.

I understand that people learn in different: I for one could not learn from books or DVD's alone.

I could not sit and read Hoadleys book, I can refer to it as i am working and experimenting to clarify things.

I could not be taught math by simply being given the formula, I would need to understand the hows and whys of how it applied, so that I undestood it.

I can see that all of the hours that you talk of are great for learning and practicing specifics, but that is not what i meant.

Re: Woodworking Course

#19

Re: Basic information

Mark Hennebury

Of course the test subject would have to gain confidence, make decisions, practice and make mistakes, but I think that they would recover faster and understand where they went wrong and why.

Examine what you consider when making your decisions, i would guess they are all of the basics, shrinkage, fibre direction, what type of joint to use, that kind of stuff. These are all the type of things that we learn over many years of trial and error, but they are not difficult things, they are just not known, or understood fully, and it takes years of building projects and having things shrink, split or come loose etc, to beat them into us.

Re: Woodworking Course

#20

Re: Woodworking Course

John Pappas

Mark, you poise a very intriguing question. With the emphasis on "the most important principles"... yes, I think that in one month I could teach all of the important principles that I know and use.

Re: Woodworking Course

#21

Re: I don't agree, not even close

Mark Hennebury

You are talking about projects and developing specific skills, I was talking about understanding how a chisel cuts and what wood is and how it works, which are fundemental to making use of your accquired skills.

I have seen many people build very nice peices or woodwork wrong!

Because they dont understandthe wood. You know that they will have problems come the next season and everythings shrinks and opens up, I have done it before myself.

Its a lack of knowledge not skills. I am talking about imparting the basic knokledge to be able to examine and interpret and extrapolate

Re: Woodworking Course

#22

Re: Woodworking Course

CStan

A lot of the essentials of the craft could be DEMONSTRATED to students in four weeks. The students most certainly could not LEARN it all (as in do it all themselves at a reasonably high level of proficiency) in four weeks.

You see, it would take the entire four weeks to SEE a lot of the essentials. There would be no time to practice them for your own proficiency.

Re: Woodworking Course

#23

My view is closer to Bill's

Ron in Kokomo

Mark... Here is what's wrong with your theory. We learn in stages that build on each other. The content that you are planning to teach in a month will not be learned because it does not have the experiential scaffolding to build it on. You have to know that the content of the craft is skill based and we do not acquire the skills of the craft that quickly. Apprentices worked for seven years? I know you tried to divorce projects from your thesis. My point is, you can't.

Re: Woodworking Course

#24

Another learning issue

Bill Tindall

This point is more relevant to learning the skills to do various furniture making tasks. There are invariably many ways to accomplish a task, build a drawer for example. I find that the best source of this information are people that have done it professionally for many years. They have settled on methods that are both reliable and quick, my favorite method attributes. These aren't necessarily the people that do the most of the teaching or writing.

However, some professional methods are more difficult to learn, dovetails for example. Pins first makes a lot of sense but it arguably is more difficult to learn and maintain proficiency. So ease of learning can be important to the amateur furniture maker.