We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I don't have much to add since I don't know what all I'd have to learn but I will make some observations on what is my about month long woodworking course.
1. We all learn differently. I'm a visual learner, others are auditory, others need to do. Even as a visual learner, I'm finding that I have to put it into practice more than I do in my academic pursuits.
2. I've found that I'm reading and re-reading the books that were recommended to me as I started. Things that I missed or didn't understand open up more and more as I go back after having tried (and often failed). Many times I will have missed something or disregarded something as unimportant that really helped when I went back and read.
3. I feel very ill-prepared for the wily ways of wood. I'm not sure if I could get much from books but even then there isn't much in the ones I've read that start me down that road.
My 2p (not adjusted for inflation or exchange rates).
You could learn all that you need to know about woodworking in a one month course. Shouldnt take any longer than that! .....
..... Not about teaching a comprehensive course about making all kinds of projects. That of course you will spend your lifetime on.
how long would it take to get a good summery of all of the most important points of woodworking to enable someone to go and learn the rest. To be able to do their own reading and exploring but with a solid understanding of the foundation of woodworking.
So a course that would teach things like:
Wood structure: Cell structure, Moisture content, Shrinkage and expansion,
Engineering properties of wood: Working with wood, structural properties, joinery explained
Tools: a thorough understanding of how tools cut wood, both hand and power tools.
Dressing and prepping lumber: precison marking out, and establishing processes and procedures for organising and completing work.
Mark, I think that you are onto something.
It is important to recognise, however, that some here have been through formal training, which provided a sequential investment in the areas involved in working wood. Others, like myself, have dipped into this and that, returning to a skill area as needed, before sometimes pressing on to others prematurely. Both groups may have forgotten how they experienced the path they trod.
If you were to put together a 1000-piece jigsaw puzzle, where would you begin - at the corners and edges, or randomly in the centre? Working from the outline inward offers context and a foundation for what comes later. Unfortunately too many of us - myself included - jumped in boots and all, and deal with issues without the context to look ahead and see where we are going.
"Method" of working wood is often confused for what we do. There are just so many methods from which to choose. We can debate endlessly whether we should use handools or power, which plane, chisel or whether the chip breaker makes a difference. All these are advanced skills for when they make a difference. Before they may be reached it is important to know which wood one can use, how to use the wood (orientate the grain), which joints are best, and what they look like (not how to make them) ... in other words, the corners and edges of the jigsaw puzzle.
I think that a solid month is more than enough time. In fact, I think that it is not about time, per se, but about how best to structure a course in woodworking: where to begin, what comes next ...
Will this learning style appeal to everyone? Probably not. There are some that will want to follow a plan, laid out step-by-step (like painting by numbers). There are others that will enjoy seeing how things work by manipulating them with their hands or watching others do the same (which is why pictures work better than words). And there are the tinkerers who independently enjoy discovering the information for themselves. Creating a structure first, is likely to be a big ask, but I do believe that it the right way.
I used to do a course called how to saw, plane, and chop to a line. There are a lot of people who know how to sharpen a chisel, or get a shaving from a plane but have no idea how to make things happen with hand tools. Just today I was discussing a particular chisel task and I was left wondering whether there was a basic comfort level about how to make stuff happen to wood with a chisel. Like a person is OK if it is a dovetail because there are lots of detailed explanations on how to dovetail, but if you just asked them to take away some wood with the chisel, they wouldn't know how to do it accurately and efficiently in a range of circumstance.
Whatever the case, there is a lot you can teach a person about those three tools in a half day. So yeah if you had a month, and went methodically though the basic tools, their maintenance, and how to read plans, or develop a design, and lay out, you could really revolutionize their abilities in a short period of time. Of course, the problem is amateurs don't like working on skills, they like hands on projects, and they don't have a month in most cases. And pros don't use hand tools for the vast most part, which is why there is a super surfacer business among others. Pros in other parts of the world do, but then some of them also have apprenticeship systems.
I remember hitting a point where it became easy. Nothing was really a problem. This is the point where difficulty is no longer an issue, you just know it is going to turn out. I still run up against perfectionist tendencies on certain projects, like one in two. Worry about how it will turn out, and maybe stop for a while, or procrastinate. But it isn't the physical part of the job any more. All the tools and skills are there, or can be quickly crossed over to. If every project is something new, it takes a while to get the right idea, or to be confident I am headed in the right direction, but it isn't a problem with controlling the medium.
Now the above took a long time. It is all the stuff like developing skills, and developing a sense of how a tight fit will occur, and stuff like that. It takes a while. Like 10 to 15 years.
Thats more of what i'm talking about the foundations, the simple stuff that you use in everything you make.
Understanding wood and how a chisel cuts it, that kind of stuff. Teaching people to have the ability to look at what they are doing and make informed judgements, the stuff that you will call on in the rest of your journey, while you are learning and deveolping skills.
We all know that developing those skills and refining of judgement take a lifetime.
I, like you jumped in boots first and figured it out along the way, but there was a lot of basic information that i missed, picking up bits here and there,. Not getting comprehensive understanding for many years, and i am sure i could got most of the important stuff in a few weeks in a well structured course.
Back in the eighties I used to run a series of night classes in my shop, they were 3 hours one night a week, for eight weeks, so 24 hours in total. Maximum of eight people to a class.
I strongly encouraged everyone to take the beginners course first.
That was about wood; cell structure, grain formation, early wood and latewood, annual rings, water and wood, shrinkage and expansion, equilibrium moisture content, mechanical design and build considerations, how wood is cut and dried, different species. Etc..
I saw this as the single most important course to take, like opening a window to understanding.
This gave students an intimate knowledge of the material that would serve them for a reference the rest of their lives. They would never look at wood the same way again. They would always look at wood from a different perspective, one of respect and understanding; anytime the saw wood they would look for clues to identify it, they would look for grain direction and cell structure.
The second 24 hour course that I taught was tuning up a handplane;
Most of this course was spent lapping the sole, and then filing, tuning, sharpening and setting it up, but the best part was at the end of the course when they made magnificent shavings. You wouldn’t believe the excitement, joy and pride of people running around the shop showing each other a perfect shaving that they had just made, with their own plane that they had just tuned up. These are pivotal moments for people. They dont forget these.
This is the type of thing that I am talking about: teaching the foundations, opening the minds and eyes to the wonders of wood and the beauty of a handplaned, surface, the thrill of doing it, and the pride in having done it.
Once you learn this appreciation, you can’t unlearn it.
I never did do a fully comprehensive one month course like I am suggesting, but having given it some thought I think it could give you all of the essential tools to go climb any mountain.
Many people came back to take various project classes, building every thing from little boxes to dining room tables etc..But to me the first two classes were the ones that made them woodworkers.
You absolutely could teach all the basics in a month, maybe less than that. The problem is 98% of your students wouldn't comprehend what you taught them until years later. In a class of 20, some would only learn by reading, some by video or lecture, and some by doing. I have an IQ of 120, so I am not so bright maybe but I am not stupid either and it took me years to really comprehend wood structure and how it is affected by moisture and humidity. I took 2 years of high school shop class and almost everything I know about woodworking comes from books I read later in life. Yes, someone with 10 or 20 years experience in woodworking, you could take and teach them a lot in a month. But to pull a rank amateur off the street and into class, good luck with that.
People do learn in different ways and at different rates, and they all wont remember everything, but i guess i am talking about imparting a good solid understanding of the concepts rather than all of the specific details.
Many of us spent 10- 20 years to get a full understanding of wood, but I believe that it shouldn't take 20 years to learn. If presented well, most of it could be learned well within a month, it doesn't require a twenty year course to explain wood structure.
"2. I've found that I'm reading and re-reading the books that were recommended to me as I started. Things that I missed or didn't understand open up more and more as I go back after having tried (and often failed). Many times I will have missed something or disregarded something as unimportant that really helped when I went back and read."
That is precisely the point I was making with an earlier analogy to mathematics. Problems I couldn't solve in HS seemed trivial to me towards the end of college. Much of the problem comes down to context - you don't always realize that a technique is a vastly easier method until you've struggled the hard way a few times. I too have noticed the same thing in WW'ing.
"3. I feel very ill-prepared for the wily ways of wood. I'm not sure if I could get much from books but even then there isn't much in the ones I've read that start me down that road. "
Here again is the importance of gaining experience. Mistakes are not some tragic waste to be avoided at all costs - they are how you learn most effectively, a crucial part of that "ah-ha!" moment when you figure out the way to avoid the mistake next time around. Even after more than 20 years of this hobby and a rational understanding that there will always be things I wish I'd done better, I too often feel ill-prepared. The trick is to not let that stop you
I can teach you all you need to understand right here:
Lesson one: You'll never stop learning. One door leads to another, and if you're lucky, you'll have enough time to go through enough of them.
Lesson two: If you want to learn, make sure the projects you choose will challenge you on both mental and manual levels. Dovetailing yet another box after months of dovetailing boxes will not stimulate, or teach you anything new.
Lesson three: The list of fundamental skills will continue to evolve and grow as you do.
Lesson four: Just because a master woodworker makes it look easy, does not mean that it is easy.
That just about covers it. Study that for an entire month if you want.
North Bennet teaches 'fundamentals' of hand tools in about 2 intensive weeks. That covers basic tool tuning, (chisels and one hand plane) and cutting basic joinery. Wood movement is a half-day lecture, with joinery taught as a way to deal with that movement. That was enough to get me off and running on my own. I think the rest starts to make sense in context, and is best absorbed that way, because the information has direct relevance.
One month to give a thinking man or woman enough information to get started is probably about right. But that assumes that they're interested enough in the process to keep moving on their own. There are a lot of others who aren't inclined to learn from scratch, and need the platter handed to them.
Thats a problem that i am finding with the forum method of communication: determining tone and intent is not always easy. I will try to take a deep breath and wait a while longer to answer if in doubt.
I teach students furniture making to BA(Hons) level. After three years the best students start to show they understand the theory and can put it into practice. I'd say that for those really good students they'll be getting pretty good as practising furniture designers and makers after another three or four years of continuous study and practical application.
Mark, I think your one month mantra is basically, er, uhm, out by at leat 2 years and 11 months, ie, at least that much shy of the time needed.
Of course, what do I know, I'm still a beginner really after nearly forty years in the profession, with nine of those years as a teacher of the subject. Slainte.
I am sure that you know a lot after all that time.
Before i go any further, i would ask if you have read all of my posts in this thread , as i didnt give enough info in my first post. Its was way too vague, and may be the reason for your negative assessment of my one month suggestion.
if you have read them and still feel the same way, I would like to discuss it further with you.
With due respect to an obviously extraordinarily accomplished craftsman and designer, what is the point of hammering away at this 'one month' idea? If you're talking about the very basics, and you seem to restrict the range of topics with each post you make, then yes, you probably could make a little headway in one month with some of the elementary, foundational topics.
Otherwise and without the aforementioned restricted lesson plan, as Richard Jones (Sgian Dubh) has said, and I'm sure other full-time woodworking instructors would tell you as well, the whole thing is absurd on its face.
There is no point other than to have a discussion and get some points of view. Which is what i thought you did on forums, i am new here so if i missed something maybe you could expain it to me. Is there some special point to all of the other threads on this forum that is missing in this thread?
I had no intention of restricting the range at each posting,just discussing the
content.
I however dont think that it is in the least absurd, thats my opinion and i wanted to see if anyone was interested in discussing it and offering their opinions, which i thought was going quite well.
You are of course welcome to your opinion, and I for one appreciate your contribution to the discussion.
You must be aware of course that the thread will die when people stop posting, so it would seem counterproductive for you to comment if you wish the thread to stop.
If Roger prefers to refer to himself as a something else who am i to argue. I have no way of guessing his real name if he doesn't wish to use it, but thanks for passing that bit of information on to me.
I just find the whole one month thing odd, at best, and don't quite understand the point of it.
In a month, you could teach a subset of the skills required to perform heart surgery - maybe some of the surgical knots one would need to be able to tie, some of the basic handling of standard surgical instruments, the anatomy of a heart. You certainly haven't trained a heart surgeon in one month and you have not trained a cabinetmaker either in that amount of time. We all obviously understand that cabinetmaking is not life or death, but really, the necessary skill set is huge and the entire 'one month hypothetical' is just silly.