New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

Posts

Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#1

David Barnett

Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

David Barnett

For the Lost Knowledge crowd:

The very first issue of Fine Woodworking, Winter 1975, Volume 1, Number 1, the article, Hand Planes - The care and making of a misunderstood tool by Timothy E. Ellsworth, states:

"The chip breaker should be set back 1/64 to 1/16 inch from the cutting edge of the iron. The closer setting would be used for the very fine shavings on finish work and for hard-to-plane woods. Setting the chip breaker back 1/32 to 1/16 inch would be for rough work and large shavings."

1/64 inch is .4 mm (0.396875 mm), which is ballpark for Kato-Kawai. Not much later, as I recall, 1/100" (or .25 mm) was offered as an ultrafine setting, if not in FWW, in something else I have lying around.

Nothing new to see here, folks. Move along. Move along.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#2

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

david weaver

Well, with what FWW has become, those of us new to the game have no reason to go back and read the old issues unless someone tells us about that.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#3

Stephen Shepherd

Vol 1 No 1 is a very interesting publication


Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#4

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#5

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

Mark Hennebury

If you have a hand plane, and a need to understand it,

you would find FWW Winter 1975, Volume 1, Number 1.

If you will wait for someone to show or tell you wont learn much.

You have a hand plane in front of you.... in your hands! You didnt have to invent it or develop it, someone else did all that, all you have to do is understand it.

That responsibility is yours.

You have to look, analyze, test, explore, research, test and analyze some more, think about it, question and prove or disprove that which you are told.

With woodworking being the worlds second oldest trade, a handplane is a very old and simple tool with only a few variables, there should be nothing left to learn.

in my mind the most important point in this whole chipbreaker thing is;

if so many can overlook this about handplanes that are in their hands being studied, tuned, used and debated on a regular daily basis,

What else have we overlooked?

What have we ignored, dismissed overlooked, not noticed, closed our minds to.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#6

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

David Weaver

?? who was that to?

I haven't read any of the classic makers and thus far have generally relied on my own hands and experience to both use and make tools, with some exceptions like moulding planes (i relied on larry's experience to learn how to make those).

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#7

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

Mark Hennebury

There is a lot of good information in the FWW back issues, I, like David got the first 100, then gradually dropped off occasionally getting the odd one and haven't had any for years.

Well, with what FWW has become, those of us new to the game have no reason to go back and read the old issues unless someone tells us about that.

If you look for information on the internet you can find just about anything you want. including everything ever written about handplanes, So what I am saying is that you dont have to wait until some tells you about a specific article in a specific magazine to find it. You just start looking.

My second point was about what else we might have missed, which I think is a pretty big issue. We have noted that information that has been long known and widely published can exist largerly unnoticed or ignored, in this the age of information. I find that a pretty interesting topic. I think it would be interesting to try and understand why that is and to see what else we have overlooked.

We all have handplanes, and have no doubt tuned them up to get them working.So we know a fair bit about them. Some of the less obvious things like how close to set the chipbreaker have been written about many many times, as in FWW so why is it not common knowledge? how many times does it have to be written before it is universally known? What has to be done to make some basic information about woodworking and handtools common knowledge?

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#8

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

CStan

I highly recommend that you acquire all of the black and white issues for your library.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#9

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#10

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

CStan

The whole 'chipbreakers are good for nothing,' as far as I know is totally an internet phenomenon.

I've never read such a thing in the reputable woodworking press by a reputable, notable craftsman. If such articles exist, they are dwarfed by sources like David mentioned (and those that I mentioned in another thread), both in number and reputation of the writer.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#11

In defense of hand plane ignorance

Bill Tindall

Summary for those uninterested in the details- the ability to plane surfaces with grain reversals is unnecessary to build most anything so many will not make much effort to learn this skill, or maybe even know it can be done, to what ever extent it can be done.

Like most of the woodworkers I personally know, I am focused on building stuff for myself or family. Early in my building career I tried planing something and was unsuccessful and never touched a plane again for 20 years or more. I found ways around this and other deficiencies, and still do. Things were sawed or sanded to size and assembled. And I built lots of stuff, around 100 pieces of furniture and counting.

As my projects became more complex I discovered(during my first visit to a professional run shop) that planing to fit was advantageous which led to the discovery that properly sharpening a plane made it useful for my fitting tasks. Then I tried preparing surfaces by hand planing and found that the risk of unexpected tear -out made surface preparation unreliable in my hands. By carefully selecting wood, tear-out issues during fitting operations was made tolerable. Sanded surfaces were equivalent to planed ones for my finishing schedules so there was zero motivation to devote any effort to better planing, either through expensive equipment purchases or improved technique.

I see lots of torn grain on regional antiques made from walnut and cherry. Nobody I knew, or know, personally could demonstrate planing proficiency on surfaces with grain reversal. I was not convinced tear-out could be reliably prevented. I remain unaware of what can be done by an experience planer because I have never personally seen anyone successfully plane anything with grain reversal except Mr. Kees.

My situation boils down to the fact that I don't know what can be done so I don't know now far away from proficiency I am at. I am as good as the peers I have contact with so it is easy to become convinced that planing lumber with grain reversals is impossible. All you folks that plane and never post any pictures never provided an example of a higher bar for achievement. Whatever planing skills I lack are not hampering my making stuff. There are lots of skills I lack that are hampering making stuff- line and berry inlay for my next piece for example.

It comes down to allocation of time. If learning about planing is made difficult, involves expensive equipment, or if the skill is difficult to master or takes lots of time to master as Warren suggests, screw it. I have more important things to learn. Planing is not standing in the way of anything I need to do. I don't climb mountains because they are there (and difficult).......unless I find I need to for some practical reason.

However, if planing something with grain reversal is as easy as Kees made it I'm going to try it when the need comes up. If I have success I will try something more difficult and the process of grater planing proficiency will continue.

The challenge to my learning woodworking skills is to see some measure of what can be done. I simply don't have local access to highly skilled professionals to see what can be done. Once I encountered a properly fit drawer I was soon making well fit drawers. But, until I saw a well fit drawer I was as clueless as someone telling me to "set the cap iron close".

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#12

So, is this the "death Knell"...

Bob Hackett

for the death knell? :D

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#13

Re: In defense of hand plane ignorance

roger lance

I can completely relate to what I think you are saying about not having a mentor that you can go to and see techniques demonstrated, get questions directly answered, and profit and learn from their superior experience and knowledge. I often feel that I am reinventing the wheel (and making mistakes that the proper direction of a mentor would avoid). I'd love to know a couple of like-minded woodworkers that I could have coffee with and talk furniture....doesn't happen....I have friends who are turners, metal workers, machinists....not flat furniture makers. That being as it is, is one of the reasons I turn to forums for insight and direction. So my furniture making will only progress just so far....I'll try to make pieces as well as a "self taught" maker can go....but there will be limitations. I can accept that.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#14

+1 on Home Furniture

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Really liked that magazine, still sad they dropped it...

DC

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#15

Re: In defense of hand plane ignorance

Mark Hennebury

I too am self taught, but i read books and magazines and i tinkered. I learnt a lot, on my own in a small community with no direct mentor. But I had books by Krenov, nakashima, Maloof, Frid etc.. I built furniture that they had built and i learned what i could I took from them what worked and dropped what didn't and moved on.

I also got all of the industrial magazines like wood and wood products, Furniture digest etc..

One thing that i learned is not to trust what i read, not to accept that which was taught, not to assume that things are designed by people who knew what they were doing. I learned to learn by taking from all the sources available to me and testing and questioning them.

If people dont want to push the boundries, explore, and progress thats fine for them.

Its not for me, every job I did made me want to start the next one to try and do better.

Every tool or machine that i used i wanted to tune up and see how good it could do.

I started woodworking with nothing but handtools, tuning my handplanes, filing sawteeth, cutting all the mortises with my boxwood handles chisels and mallet. Eventually I got shop machinery thats really when things started to get frustrating: trying to understand them, trying to get them to work, trying to get people to sharpen the blades.

I have a thousand stories that you probably wouldn't believe;

I went to a woodworking machinery show, 10,000 visitors, 8 people were in the free seminar on wood structure giving by leading wood scientist.

I complained to a sharpening shop about my planer blades not being sharp his comment was "you dont want them too sharp they will get dull to quick"

I read wood and wood magazine every month, a particularly sad part was the Jerry metz column where woodworking plant managers would ask questions mostly about delaminations and warping of panel stock, Jerry usual answer was "did you check the moisture content" Aparrently you dont need to know anything about equilibrium moisture content to run a multi million dollar wood shop.

There was one article i read about a guy running a CNC router and calling the tooling salesman because the router was belching thick black smoke from the cut in a MDF board, when the salesman arrived and checked he noticed that the operator had not put an insert tip into the router bit. He didnt look or check , just called the salesman.

A man that worked in the lumber association promoting North American lumber sales in Japan, told me that the Japanese wont buy finished lumber from us because the dont trust us not to screw it up. I can completly understand that, when i get lumber delivered it often is thrown in the back of a truck and has gravel stuck in it. I can't joint or plane it until i have spent ages picking all of the grit out of it.

I tried to get a set of blades sharpend a few months back. These were blades for and old fashioned tenon machine, a Poitras, like a millbury. The cuttereheads have two large heavy knives about 5" x4" x 1/2" thick put in at a skew angle, so its a tricky job. The guy at the sharpening shop screwed them up I am not sure if it was two or three times, he just couldn't get his head round it, in the end I had to do them myself.

I tried to get a Japanese router bit sharpened to the quality that it was originally done, none of the four shops that i went to could do it. One man explained to me that it would take to setups, one rough grind and one secondary lapping. That would require twice the work and a very expensive lapping wheel..... and no one had ever asked before, their customers had been quite happy with the " rough" grind that they had be doing all along.

So how come you see Germany and Japan raising the bar and pushing the limits and North Americans dont. How come we dont need to know our trade, where is our pride? How come we can deliver dressed lumber dragged across the gravel, and send out "sharpened" planer blades that you couldn't slit your wrist with.

What is with this "good enough" stuff.

We marvel over the magnificient hand tools, and kitchen knives made by the great masters in Japan.

This exists because of a cultural attitude not just a personal one.

We wont have that if we dont raise the bar and demand more on and industry and an individual level.

I think that people have a duty to know their trade.

But then I come from a three class country where they need tradesmen to build nice homes for the rich, so they make sure that your value system is to take pride in doing good work. So my background is a part of my cultural imprint.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#16

craigd

Re: In defense of hand plane ignorance

craigd

If you don't need a skill/tool to accomplish a goal, why acquire it? Why learn to ride a horse when you can drive a car? I just like everything about hand planes, their use, the way they look, etc so I'm pretty motivated to learn how to use them. To me, it is a method of work I like, just as I'd rather ride my bicycle somewhere than drive.

An example of reversing grain and knots and no tear out or shaving bender:


Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#17

Re: In defense of hand plane ignorance

Mark Hennebury

Beautiful handplane.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#18

I had to look up the meaning of "death Knell"


Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#19

Requiem for the Death Knell, perhaps?


Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#20

Misconception

CStan

Just to be clear - I don't believe any of these methods will completely eliminate tear out, certainly not in any timeframe that makes even hobby woodworking feasible. Maybe with enough tinkering and adjusting one could.

We're just trying to do a better job and eliminate it as much as we can whilst still getting on with the work.

File this under: "I haven't thrown my card scrapers out."

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#21

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

John McPhail

Hasten the DKOLK ( Death Knell of Lost Knowledge ) by employing:

- More listening, less talking.

- Experimentation.

- Imagination.

Don't worry about the right way, the wrong way, or any other way, or wasting time. Try it yourself, if you reinvent the wheel you've proved that you are the equal of our forebears. Sometimes you just have to do the work to understand it.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#22

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

Mark Hennebury

I agree with you 100 %

I have reinvented many things only to find they have existed for a long time, I dont mind that at all because like you say, its a journey to understanding.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#24

What are the expectations? Warren?

david weaver

I haven't been burning up the shop in the last few months, but I've had to dimension a few panels, and what the local lumber supply place calls FAS is pretty trashy to me (it's not as straight and clear as you'd expect).

What I always wanted when I built an infill was a plane that I could basically sharpen and take through shavings with. at 55 degrees, it's lacking a little for things like a dovetailed case with lots of tails, I guess, but otherwise I haven't used any "regular wood" and gotten any appreciable tearout with it.

I haven't used a card scraper in about 3 projects. I'm not a fan of scrapers or scraping planes.

I expect based on what I've seen of the millers falls smoothers that I picked up on the cheap, that I should not see any difference in another week when I get hot and heavy on some casework (if I use them instead of an infill).

for things like moulding planes, where I want no tearout and I don't want to go past a thickness target, the infill smoother has been a great addition. Weight makes sizing and smoothing beech easier, than say what it looks like Larry is doing in his videos where he's skewing a smoother to avoid tearout and then having to provide all of the momentum on a short run.

Anyway, I don't see the need for a card scraper as a speed issue, more a surface quality issue. If the smoother is doing well and the iron is prepared right, there shouldn't be lines to deal with nor tearout to deal with.

Warren, have you got any thoughts on this? Do you follow your smoothing often with scraping?

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#25

That plane is fantastic!