New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

Posts

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#26

Re: What are the expectations? Warren?

CStan

If you are getting consistent tear-out free performance across the board then I wouldn't change a thing.

Period.

Frankly, I'd work wood like a demon until the good luck runs out.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#27

Re: In defense of hand plane ignorance

CStan

Not one of the furnituremakers in your post would hesitate to sand if it was necessary - just to keep the record straight and not let this whole thing gravitate too much to 'wax-on/wax-off' mysticism.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#28

That is PROFOUND

roninkokomo

Yes... it is the inventing and tinkering that we learn. And especially for the true amateur ( defined as one who does the thing because he loves it) the learning is a large part of the thrill.

One of the real joys for me is figuring out how to do something when I do not have the exact tool for the job. You know what I mean.

Some of the most exciting things about pieces that I have made are things that only I know about.. i.e. challenges overcome, new techniques learned....etc.

Ron

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#29

Re: Internet epistemology

Mark Hennebury

I read a few pages and it looks very interesting , its rather along read so I will get back to it this evening.

Thanks for the link.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#30

Re: What are the expectations? Warren?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

When I was young the woodworking books I was aware of recommended planing, scraping, and sanding for the finest surfaces. When people bring up early and mid 20th century texts on cap iron use for fine planing it should be noted that it was often in this context of preparation for scraping and sanding, not as a finished surface. At the time I thought that 18th century workers routinely scraped and abraded finish surfaces.

As I became more skilled with the plane I noticed that both the scraping and the sanding were degrading the surface and abandoned them by 1978. Since then I have seen old work that has the subtle evidence of planing only and also old work that has evidence of scraping on troublesome areas; I think the effect is better if the guy had the skill to do a fine job with the plane. Some people probably cherish the irregularities that come with less than stellar planing. Frankly, if the furniture has stylish mouldings, fine proportions, good stock selection, charming carving or scrollwork, we should perhaps value these things more highly than surface preparation.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#31

Re: What are the expectations? Warren?

david weaver

I agree 100% with the last sentence.

99% of the time I have a quibble with a piece of furniture, it's how it was designed and why it doesn't "look good" from 20 or 40 feet away.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#32

Re: What are the expectations? Warren?

CStan

I think the standard has been to do as good as job with the plane as possible, then scrape and sand if necessary. Some folks sand as a matter of course in order to homogenize the surface to accept a film forming finish. Nothing wrong with it. At all.

Nothing about the "newfound" chipbreaker information changes any of this.

FW did a test a few years ago and nobody could distinguish a planed vs. a sanded surface when both were viewed under a film finish.

Of all the professional craftsman who wrote for FW in its heyday, I don't think there is/was a single one who claimed not to ever use sandpaper.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#34

Most definitely agree with that...

John in NM

That is what relates good design in Georgian or William and Mary furniture with Biedermeyer furniture, Arts and Crafts, Shaker, you name it (even Danish modern, maybe :D )

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#35

craigd

Re: That plane is fantastic!

craigd

Thanks everybody for the complements, these experiments are my way of rediscovering the Lost Arts of the Plane.

Re: Death knell of the "Lost Knowledge" theory?

#36

Re: That plane is fantastic!

Tom Colligan

Hi Craig, how 'bout a few words about your plane.

Would you be the maker of it? If so, is it made out of a solid block of apple? Or, would there be elements of the Krenov method of plane making?

And, importantly, how 'bout a few more pictures? It would be appreciated by all. TIA, Tom.