New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Death knell of the single iron plane?

Posts

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#51

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

TomD

Odate has some stuff on this. I re-read while looking up Bill's quote. He suggests that while knowing about tear-out and breakers, a lot of Japanese craftsmen felt that single blades gave a finer finish. Also seems to be a gearhead thing where you get more props for finishing with a single blade.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#52

David Barnett

Oh, the ringing, the incessant bloody ringing

David Barnett

As I've said in several recent posts, I knew about chipbreakers before I ever put plane to wood, thanks to generous phone conversations with Patrick Leach nearly two decades ago and his inclusion of excellent printed instructions when he sent my first planes, so I was entirely surprised any of this was news to anyone on Hand Tools.

I had not paid much attention to chipbreaker threads and was not really aware of disputes. What Odate said makes sense, that many Japanese woodworkers favored single-iron planes, but with the penchant for doing things the old way, both in Japan and even here, I can understand coaxing high performance from a single iron might have considerable cachet among those who hold such things dear.

I have no difficulty believing that both systems can produce excellent results and can understand that makers of single-iron planes might look down upon double-iron planes and their advocates. To make a plane that performs like an Old Street takes considerable expertise (as Joel explained in his posts), and certainly, widely-available cheap and more easily-made planes could be viewed as unworthy rivals. I'm not so sure I buy into the theory that information supporting chipbreakers was suppressed on the internet by those who would promote an agendum to better their own position, however.

Although I can appreciate what it must take to make a single-iron plane of exceptional quality, I can't say that it would offer any advantage to me when I get entirely adequate results from even the plainest vintage Bailey, and I'm sure that must be true for most others. From my own plebian leanings, I can see why CStan regards the Old Street as a niche product and appreciate how David Weaver has advocated for the well-tuned Bailey.

"Ford and the world Fords with you. Rolls and you Rolls alone." -- Oliver Wendall Holmes

Obviously, there's room for both planing systems. I'll stick with what gives me satisfying results and let others explore the subtleties of high-pitch single-iron bevel-down smoothers. Besides, I have so many other things to take my money; gem rough, cool materials, crucible furnaces, and so on.

Anyway, I suppose the Kato-Kawai is a big deal for those who never knew about chipbreakers or who abandoned them too early when internet consensus pronounced them humbugs. Perhaps, though, there is some truth to the way wildfires of opinion sweep through fora, overwhelming the non-rigorous to accept consensus dogmas, but I don't foresee their impending demise so long as damned fools like us insist on stirring the embers.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#53

Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.

Gary Blum

Since this is my first post on WC, the first thing I would like to do is say how much I enjoy the discussions here. This chipbreaker 'thing' is a good opening to join in some.

If you can get a 35° BD single iron plane to handle any grain other than a 'with the grain' board, you've really got something there. My ideal plane would be a single iron, BD plane with an adjustable mouth. Easy pushing, great surface quality, no second iron to fiddle with, grind the iron about 30°, maybe around 40-42 degree bedding. Kinda sounds Japanese, huh? I even built a metal adjustable mouth mechanism that was adjustable front to back as well as up and down, so it would put extra pressure right at the mouth. Needless to say, it's hard to adjust the blade depth accurately when you're ' extra pressure adjustable mouth mechansim that sticks a littlle below the sole' thingy is in place. I can provide pictures if anyone wants to pursue that futher.

The 64,000 dollar question then is: why doesn't the tight mouh work to prevent teaarout. I guess I should keep this personal here and say ... it doesnt't work for me. And people who say it does always seem to combine it with some other condition like ' tight mouth along with a super sharp blade' or tight mouth combined with high angle' or tight mouth and uber tuned plane, or tight mouh and .0004 ( .002 divided by 5) shaving. It always gets put back in some mystical notion, where we want to believe that someone, somewhere can build something so fine as to defy the laws of physics.

In trying to answer that question, I just try to use my own experience. I have always used Stanley #62 block planes in my work. I have 4 old ones I have worn out on my shelf. They all have a crack at the corner of the mouth going back. I know from using them that I can set the mouth practically rigjht on top of the blade, and when I hit reversing grain, it's going to stop.When you hit reversing grain, you are in effect wedging that piece between the blade and mouth. A wedge has tremendous power. Steel is not as stiff as people think. Deflection can easily happen. The other thing happening, where the video is so helpful, is to see the wood lifting ahead of the cut. It's easy to see that some additional pressure right at the mouth would be helpful here.

I thiink that is why this chipbreaker discussion has such traction and interest. You can see the phycis happening. As a planemaker, I tried the really close chipbreaker setting a couple of years ago after reading the Kato papers. It was a revelation to me, but others read the same thing I did and came to the opposite conclusion that the thing had to be set to the 'ridiculous' distance of sub .008 to have any effect at all, and therefore was originally designed as a blade stiiffener. I was a little hesitant to admit that , as a planemaker, I had never tried setting the chipbreaker really close, but that's the truth. Now that I have seen others like David Charlesworth and Philly say the same thing, I don't feel so bad.

I admire David Weaver for pursiing this and sharing his experiences. Thanks to Bill for the video. I really do think, for a lot of people, seeing is believing. Warren and I were involved in the 'chipbreaker thread " on Woodnet a couple of years ago. While I think we had some excellent (ha) arguments, in the end , not only couldn't we convince anyone that chipbreakers were effective, we couldnn't even convince them that they were more than just 'blade stiffeners'.

Back to work. My job this afternoon is planing quartersawn white oak drawer sides for a bedroom set. 15 drawers. I always leave my sides proud of the front and back, so I can fit the front and back to the opening first, and then just plane down the sides till I reach the dovetails. The white oak is local burr oak. Very squirrly and many pin knots. My plane is set up so I can plane these with absolute confidence and no tearout. Thanks, Kato.

Kind Regards,

Gary Blum

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#54

Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.

Kees

Thank you for your post Gary.

It kind of agrees with my experience with a tight mouth: not very effective on a standard angle plane.

But now of course we need to start experimenting how tight the mouth needs to be to be effective and how practical that really is.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#55

Mouth size/position of CB/cutting angle.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Gary

Good to see you here! :)

Interesting .. if a tight mouth makes little difference at a common angle. Is that regardless of chip breaker setting? - then it makes not difference at all. I think that this needs to be qualified - position of chip breaker/size of mouth/cutting angle.

It was always the common angle, or close, that the tight mouth was seen to be optimum. A tight mouth is increasingly unimportant as the cutting angle increases. At about 55 degrees - definitely 60 degrees - it make no difference at all. Terry Gordon (HNT Gordon planes) has written about this, and it is my experience as well.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#56

Re: Mouth size/position of CB/cutting angle.

Gary Blum

Hi Derek,

Thanks. Aren't planes fascinating? I have been passionate about planes since 1975, and I just 'discovered' this close chipbreaker setting thing 2 years ago. So, yes, I think there is plenty to investigate regarding mouth size-chipbreaker setting effectiveness.

I was referring to my 'ideal' plane specifcally when I was talking about not being able to stop tearout by closing down the mouth. This was sans chipbreaker and with a light smoothing cut. I believe a mouth does come into play when you move the chipbreaker back and especially when the shaving thickness starts increasing also. And I agree that it comes more into play with the lower angled planes and less so as the angle increases. I guess my main point was that, IME, I cant' get a tight mouth on a low or mid (45-50°) plane to stop tearout like I can with the chipbreaker. That's why I was saying it always has to be combined with some other more esoteric thing which keeps planes so 'mysterious'. Maybe that's a good thing, but it's not if it frustrates people and makes them think they need some special knowledge that only a few of the masters possess.

Kind Regards,

Gary