New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Death knell of the single iron plane?

Posts

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#26

Re: Don McConnell first

TomD

Well all of this will now have to go back in the hopper. Possibly the reason why some people had the opinions they did about his planes is because, apparently "nobody" knew what they were doing. So how can we trust that any comparison made was actually an intelligent one. There was a time when if you had done one good dovetail joint you were an internet go-to god. Everyone does them today. Same thing will happen with planes. Apparently nobody had the memo. And doing seminars this was obvious to me also. Stop cuts or whatever they are called, nobody knew about that. Lots of people fell for the curved blade stuff (good stuff) because apparently they didn't know squat about free hand planing. One problem about the internet is that you can go blue in the face trying to lead someone to water, but video is probably the only thing that will do it. In fact I learned the stuff Charlesworth eventually got across from the Krenov video. So I had a 10 year jump. I have read several hundred books, and say 1000 magazines, and never saw word one about it.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#27

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

Joel Moskowitz

I'm convinced, I'm putting cap irons on all my chisels.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#28

Shaving...

david weaver

I put one on my straight razor this morning :b

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#29

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

Curt Putnam

ROTFLMAO

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#30

Double iron jack

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Charles, I have hardly ever used a Bailey jack plane. I use a double iron jack that I made in 1978. I also use a double iron trying plane (Sandusky) that I bought in 1979. The wooden planes are lighter and probably more comfortable. These two planes are used much more than jointer or smoothing planes. I have never had to monkey with the mouth.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#31

Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.

James Watriss

Finally! We've found the one, PERFECT way to do EVERYTHING!

Hogwash.

They've proven that this method is viable. That doesn't invalidate anything else that already has a proven track record.

I don't know why people get so caught up in the pursuit of the immaculate tool... Something that is hyper-demonstrably superior to everything else. Can't you just look for 'a good way to get the job done?'

You're skinning that cat all wrong.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#32

Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.

Kees

I think you didn't really read any of the responses. :D

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#33

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

wilbur

You can already do that, Joel. It's called a card scraper. :D

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#34

Re: Death knell - not yet

North of the Border

Power tools haven't killed hand tools, despite the tremendous advantages of the former over the latter, in terms of speed, efficiency and learning curve in general terms. Innovative and modern plane designs haven't destroyed the traditional and old models, either. I don't foresee the chipbreakers spelling the death of anything.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#36

Re: Double iron jack

CStan

I use the jack for a wide variety of tasks, hence the frog adjustments which take about twenty seconds to perform.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#37

Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.

CStan

A single iron bevel down wooden plane is totally a one-trick pony. As long as the wood cooperates, great. If it doesn't you're left standing there with your you-know-what in your hand looking sort of dumb. What's the next move? Call and get on a six-month waiting list for a plane that'll do a better job on the work sitting on your bench right now?

I want to at least FEEL like I have a fighting chance, something to adjust, some sort of alternative.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#38

Re: 1802 double iron chisel

joel moskowitz

I'm floored - where is that reference from?

And after all these year of using my cap irons to get rid of wrinkles in my hat I feel I have missed so much opportunity.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#39

Re: 1802 double iron chisel *LINK*

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Joel, I got my first shipment from your house this afternoon. A friend sent me the Seaton Chest book, a gift.

I remembered this book when I saw your post. A treatise on the culture and management of fruit trees. W Forsyth 1802. You can buy it on Amazon.


Fruit trees

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#41

Re: 1802 double iron chisel

joel moskowitz

Thanks for the link. Considering how much effort we go through to make classic tools for woodworkers I wonder what the demand amongst modern gardeners would be for a chisel with a cap iron.

Who would have thunk it.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#42

craigd

Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.

craigd

A single iron bevel down wooden plane is totally a one-trick pony.

That statement suggests a very limited experience with wooden planes, I think you need to get out more and expand your horizons a bit.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#43

Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.

CStan

I own a half-set of Clark & Williams hollows and rounds and several other moulding planes. They are all great and I wouldn't be without them.

My comments speak to wooden bench planes and I'd be happy if you would inform me what your technique is, especially when smoothing, when you run up against something that the plane just won't handle. Scraping is always an option and I wouldn't hesitate. Have you found the Holy Grail plane that can handle anything or do you have some super-secret technique you're willing to share with the world?

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#44

Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.

CStan

Here is a post from another forum by Gary Blum. It's is posted here in its entirety:

Great video and great discussion. Regarding the different effects at various planing angles, I have been doing a lot of experimenting lately with bedding angles, chipbreaker angles and chipbreaker distance settings. I recently made a 35 degree ( I can't get Alt 241 to work ) frog for my low angle block as well as a miter plane, so have been able to try the close chipbreaker setting with it. Amazingly, it works just as well even at that very low angle. All this has made me rethink my standard bedding angle for my planes. I just recently went to 47 degrees from 50, and probably should have just went to 45. Gee, maybe the old boys actually knew what they were doing.

I have seen references in some old sources of the chipbreaker being called a 'shaving thickness regulator'. This always puzzled me somewhat. However, now that I have 'discoverd' setting the chipbreaker much closer, suddently this makes sense. If you set your shaving thickness at .002, and you set your chipbreaker at .002 from the edge( or even further back because of the blade angle versus depth difference) , you are then limited to a .002 thick shaving. The chipbreaker then becomes just like the mouth, pressing down right at the cut. As the blade wants to dive deeper from hitting reversing grain, the downward pressure on the wood right at the cut actually increases and makes the chipbreaker even more effective. This is the opposite of what happens with a really tight mouth. The tight mouth is working just fine in normal grain, but when the blade hits that reversing grain, and the edge dives down some or the plane bed deflects down some, the tight mouth becomes LESS effective because the distance from the blade edge to the mouth increases.

In my experience, a tight mouth seems totally irrelevant when you are using your chipbreaker. I never bother changing mine and in fact am considering removing the mouth adjusting screws as this just adds another layer of complication, especially for a beginner.

When you get into heavier shavings, I think the chipbraker is still very effective if it is matched to the shaving thickness and wood species. I think this is what Warren has been referring to when he's talking about the learning curve in using them. There is no learning curve when using fine shavings, just set that sucker as close as you dare ( or even closer ) and you will be amazed at what you can plane. And I have found that the shaving can be thicker than you would think. I set my chipbreaker where it just barely shows any blade, and I can still take a nice shaving.

As to the chipbreaker angle, for my shop purposes I refer to the total angle from horizontal, like you refer to the bedding angle. This eliminates the differences that are caused because of different bedding angle of the blade. Most Stanley planes I have are about 90 degrees. This is quite steep. Most of my old wooden planes are more like 60-70 degrees. When I was first prototyping my plane, I started milling the chipbreak portion of the frog at 100 degrees. It wouln't cut at all. It wouldn't cut until I had lowered it below 90. However, like the video shows, you can get by over 90 if it is a very small microbevel. I use about 110 degrees on that microbevel, but try to always keep it small. In the video they may get by with that extreme negative bevel because of the power feed of the planer.

Well, now that Isee this written down, it's no wonder I can't sleep at night trying to figure out all this 250 year old technology.

Gary Blum

--------------------

www.blumtoolco.com

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#45

Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.

CStan

If, for some reason, the imprimatur of history makes you feel better about double-ironed planes there is an utterly fascinating and detailed exposition of the history of them at this thread:

http://www.forums.woodnet.net/ubbthreads/showflat.php?Cat=&Number=5925160&page=0&view=collapsed&sb=5&o=

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#46

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#47

Re: "Shaving thickness regulator"

CStan

It is intriguing and sort of backs up what happens, for me at least, when I move the chipbreaker down a little when thicknessing/jack planing figured stock. As I mentioned in another post, I do most of my "adjusting" to a jack plane.

In my hands, a single iron, relatively open mouthed wooden jack, leaves behind a trail of devastation on figured wood. I have to back off the iron so much I'm basically smoothing my way to planned thickness.

My bungling idiocy aside, I'm glad to have an iron jack with all the adjustments to use on stock like this. It can take a bit of a greadier chip and still not blow the wood apart.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#48

Re: "Shaving thickness regulator"

cstan

s/b "greedier"

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#49

Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.

TomD

The one thing about that I would want to require as much scientific support for as for other contentions here, is the idea that the edge dives down enough to eliminate the effectiveness of the mouth. I mean really!? Prove it. Could we see this in any of the video recently circulated. Even if they had chip breakers, that would not necessarily mean there would be no diving. Chip breaker increase dynamic and static edge loading for one thing.

Also .002 is about 5 times thicker than I like to finish at and a very good shaving to work with and get no tear-out. But still one of these uncontrolled variables.

There are still a lot of factors not in the soup here.

Low angle planes improve cutting power. 35 degree planes are very good on figured woods, and if you do not get tear-out what is not to like. However, I have had good results at that level with single blades. There are a lot of factors here we are not controlling for in this discussion so it is relatively meaningless.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#50

craigd

Re: Proof of the ongoing pursuit of Excalibur.

craigd

RE: Bench woodies that work.

I own five single iron BD woodies, four HNT Gordons (try, jack, two smoothers) and a wooden shoot board plane. The low angle shoot plane is indeed a one trick pony. The Gordons (at 55 - 60º) are as general purpose as any of my metal bench planes (> 10).

Technique - I'm not sure I have any, not that I understand and can explain anyway (which is why this forum is so helpful). If I run into something they are unable to smooth (rare but happens), I try a different plane (instead of sharpening), if that doesn't work or I really can't afford tear out, scraper or sandpaper.

IMO, there is no holy grail plane, no secret sauce, no magic. Like everything else, know your tools, their strengths and limitations and practice, practice, practice.

Of course, if I would only eat my own dog food, I could hand cut dovetails too.