New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Death knell of the single iron plane?

Posts

Death knell of the single iron plane?

#1

David Barnett

Death knell of the single iron plane?

David Barnett

That is, with what has now been demonstrated in the Kato-Kawai video and papers, rather convincingly, in my opinion, the inevitable question arises, is there any remaining or compelling reason to choose a high-angle single-iron bevel-down tight-mouth bench plane?

Is there any significant elevated performance of such a plane over a quality double-iron plane, wooden or metal, assuming a good blade and a well-fitted chipbreaker? Can it be claimed that a single-iron plane will significantly outperform a properly set double-iron plane?

Lastly, what advantage, if any, would there be in choosing a well-performing wooden-bodied single-iron traditional smoother over a well-performing double-iron metal-bodied smoother, such as a Lie-Nielsen or Veritas or a double-iron wooden smoother such as the Primus Reform, other than personal sensibilities or aesthetics (with which I have no quibble)? Historical authenticity?

What say you? And, as always, name and town, name and town, name and town, if you wish to opine.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#2

No death knell in my opinion

Steve Elliott

There are a number of issues here, which I hope I can sort out.

First, for some species of wood I believe a high angle is more effective than a well-adjusted cap iron. Both Derek Cohen and I have reported better results using a high cutting angle (around 60 degrees) for brittle tropical timbers, in my case Bolivian rosewood. I don't claim to have found the optimum cap iron setting for this timber but that would take considerable experimentation, and increasing the cutting angle was quick and effective.

Second, wood-bodied planes are a joy to use due to the low friction of a wooden sole. When I started using infill planes I kept applying wax to the sole to try to overcome the greater friction of the steel sole. Now I apply wax some of the time and just live with the increased friction most of the time.

My Ulmia Reform smoother (double iron, lignum vitae sole) is a good plane but the blade is too near the center of the sole for my taste. I don't want my smoother to act like a jointer plane and just take off the high spots. Also, the throat of the plane is fairly narrow due to the mechanism to adjust the mouth. Shavings don't jam when the plane is well tuned, but they don't fall out of there easily either. Sometimes I resort to using compressed air to clear out shavings caught at the sides where there's a small gap between the blade and the side of the plane. These aren't fatal flaws, but still leave me less than completely satisfied with that particular plane. My infill planes are better in those respects.

Then there's ergonomics, the feel of the plane. I like unhandled planes because they put my hand right behind the blade. Krenov-style planes (short ones) have this advantage and Bailey-style planes don't. My low angle bevel-up smoother is especially bad in this regard and skewing the plane puts the force pushing the plane forward out of line with the blade in a way I find unpleasant.

No style of plane will suit every wood or every woodworker. I'm working on my own ultimate plane, a wooden one with a relatively low bed angle, a double iron, and an adjustable mouth. Pretty much a round-sided wooden plane shaped like a Spiers unhandled smoother with a 40 degree bed angle and an adjustable mouth that doesn't make the throat narrow. I'll post pics if I ever get it made.

P.S. I forgot the name and town part. Steve Elliott in Seattle.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#3

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

TomD

"That is, with what has now been demonstrated in the Kato-Kawai video and papers, rather convincingly, in my opinion,"

I fall in the "what is new?" category. So I don't see any need to change. Some people will probably want to wait a while and see whether the few practical experiments of this program are more widespread. And how it all shakes out in the real world. Not to mention some will not have gotten the word

" the inevitable question arises, is there any remaining or compelling reason to choose a high-angle single-iron bevel-down tight-mouth bench plane?"

Why only bevel down? (I continue to assert my rights to the idea of a breaker that works on bevel up planes.)

I think the argument is the same as aways, they are faster to cycle, and therefore unless they are failing to do the job why would they not continue to sell. What is more, many planes can use either blade, I have a Bevel down LV plane that has both breaker and no breaker blades. Had it for quite a while. (I assert my right to the plane that uses both types of blade). So I don't see why the easier to use version will not persist.

"Is there any significant elevated performance of such a plane over a quality double-iron plane, wooden or metal, assuming a good blade and a well-fitted chipbreaker? Can it be claimed that a single-iron plane will significantly outperform a properly set double-iron plane?"

Well obviously this has been claimed by Larry Williams at some level only last week, I think it was, right here. I think if this avalanche of "new" information continues to flow it may prove difficult for a number of single bit planes that have done very well over recent times to stem the flow. But not because they aren't good concepts.

"Lastly, what advantage, if any, would there be in choosing a well-performing wooden-bodied single-iron traditional smoother over a well-performing double-iron metal-bodied smoother, such as a Lie-Nielsen or Veritas or a double-iron wooden smoother such as the Primus Reform, other than personal sensibilities or aesthetics (with which I have no quibble)? Historical authenticity?"

Leaving aside high angle molding planes that produce finished work...

I find the question confused, How does the wood factor into it? Other than trying to bait Larry? Obviously wooden planes are better, though some don't agree. Presumably when they get around to reading more Japanese papers or something, they will get it. Single or double bit, are what they are. High angle wooden bodied single bit planes will be better when they are better. Larry has an opinion on this, but at very least they will work great where cycling is more important than breakers, and where people have seen the light on wooden planes. Since the truth about breakers has always been know, and breaker are not universally used, or required, and if anything have fallen out of favour. I think there will remain a wide range of use.

On historical authenticity, I have always had a problem since my random exposure does not suggest that single blades are more authentic. Larry seems to believe they are. I believe larry know a whole lot more about that than I do, but every plane you would slap a breaker on in any likelyhood, has one in the older planes I have studies. So I believe him but don't know why. I assume he is reaching further back than pioneer times, but I don't see that as more authentic, just a different time in the evolution of wood

My own view is that breakers enter the fray where figured woods or crap woods are prevalent Which is why we don't have them on molding planes, even though there are there for finishing. Etc... And actually in pioneer times they probably had good but less fancy wood and a lot of breakers, so who knows.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#4

David Barnett

Interesting

David Barnett

Excellent answer. I, too, have a Primus Reform and yes, I know what you mean about the mouth position and the tendency for trapping fibers at the mouth edges. I use a dissecting tool to clear it away.

I only have the one high angle bench plane now, but many of my moulders are high pitch and that makes a real difference on some hardwoods. I asked specifically about bench planes, of course, because I wonder how the double-iron compares with the single-iron, especially as regards the tightness of the mouth.

Egonomically, there's hardly anything more comfortable than Krenov planes and shaped mine for best grip as I still have lingering nerve issues in both hands. Ease of holding, powering and lightened mass are all important. But again, my Krenovs are all double-iron, so that still doesn't answer my question on single-iron utility and performance.

As regards your low-angle wooden plane, that's very interesting and I would like to see it if you ever make it happen.

Thanks for answer. Very helpful.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#5

Oh, goody!  We haven't had a good fight

Bruce, a MN Galoot

In about a week or so! :D

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#6

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

Kees

Of course, the single iron high angle plane is also a valid approach to the goal of reducing tearout. It works too. Just look around in the Versailles to see what kind of furniture they could make with single iron planes.

But is it better?

It certainly is simpler to cycle like Tom wrote. It might not clog as easilly. But I kind of doubt the latter, because the shavings are so straight when the chipbreaker is in the sweet spot.

Old street tools make beautifull planes in high quality and they do work. So you won't buy a dud.

And how about Japanese planes? They tame the tearout with solid bedding, tight mouth and that special shaped sole to get pressure where it's needed. That's valid too, obviously.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#7

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

TomD

One thing about Japanese single blades is that the shaving will go straight up without a breaker, under the right circumstances.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#8

From a maker's point of view.

Kees

When you want to make your own western wooden planes, I think it's wiser to go the double iron route. They are a little less critical in the bedding and the size of the mouth. Of course you want to do a good job, but when you only make a few planes it's hard to reach perfection. And old laminated double irons are plentifull on the second hand market.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#9

Re: Interesting

TomD

"but many of my moulders are high pitch and that makes a real difference on some hardwoods. I asked specifically about bench planes, of course, because I wonder how the double-iron compares with the single-iron, especially as regards the tightness of the mouth."

Perfectly fair question. I was just wondering if the molding planes answered any part of it by showing that where wood is selected for even tempered grain, the high angle plane works fine. Because it is an actual case of two coexisting finishing planes that take different approaches.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#10

David Barnett

Well, it was a catchy subject title *LINK*

David Barnett

Firstly, your assertions and claim to plane features not yet in production should be recognized as published prior art on Wood Central. :)

"Why only bevel down? (I continue to assert my rights to the idea of a breaker that works on bevel up planes.)"

Only because I have a few bevel up planes and have played with different bevel angles. I've got a few vintage single-iron bench woodies, two which I patched to close up the mouths, and have fairly pleasing performance from each, although I've never produced what would be called gossamer shavings.

"So I don't see why the easier to use version will not persist."

While not having concerned myself much with cycling, as speed has rarely been integral to my work style, I found your cycling thread interesting. Your explanation of how you set your blade by pressure and feel is entirely natural and similar to my own. Never thought about it so overtly until I read your explanation, however.

"Well obviously this has been claimed by Larry Williams at some level only last week, I think it was, right here. I think if this avalanche of "new" information continues to flow it may prove difficult for a number of single bit planes that have done very well over recent times to stem the flow. But not because they aren't good concepts."

I'm inclined to take it on faith and testimony that Larry makes very fine planes indeed; but would remain dubious of an asserted innate single-iron superiority over the best double-iron plane.

"I find the question confused, How does the wood factor into it? Other than trying to bait Larry?"

It may seem confused and perhaps it is, but no disrespect to Larry is intended. It's mostly because I'm thinking that a very well-made single-iron wooden plane, by virtue of its craftsmanship may actually equal a double-iron plane and wanted to provoke arguments to that effect. In a recent post where this was discussed, I was left wondering whether such a plane was characteristic of the era or excels other single-iron planes from that same era.

That is, would Larry's or other fastidiously made single-iron contemporary wooden planes exceed the quality of typical high-end planes from the past? Are modern infill makers, the best of them, that is, making a superior infill to those upon which they are modeled? It would seem likely that they are.

The post that piqued my curiosity, the reason I started this thread, contains Joel's thought-provoking observation:

"In planes it's pretty easy to see that an Old Street single iron planes perform just about better than just about any plane you can buy. But that doesn't mean every single iron plane made in the 18th century was anywhere near as good. As a matter of fact I would bet that mostly they weren't."

So no, I'm not baiting Larry. In fact, quite the contrary. If what Joel alleges is so, then Larry's planes may be unique outliers, exceeding the performance and quality of the very 18th century planes upon which his are modeled, which more than a little interests me.

The thread title was really the only provocative element in my post, and was intended to get people to read it and respond.

"On historical authenticity, I have always had a problem since my random exposure does not suggest that single blades are more authentic. Larry seems to believe they are. I believe larry know a whole lot more about that than I do, but every plane you would slap a breaker on in any likelyhood, has one in the older planes I have studies. So I believe him but don't know why. I assume he is reaching further back than pioneer times, but I don't see that as more authentic, just a different time in the evolution of wood."

This is thoroughly interesting and candid paragraph. Stuff like this makes me read your posts, even when I don't want to. Believe it or not, I do try to keep an open mind. Okay, not so open my brain rolls out, but I'm willing to rethink and reappraise. Now and then.

These last weeks, the discussions here, esp. those on Kato-Kawai, and further esp. Joel's posts, have inspired me to re-examine what I know or think I know. Have no idea where I'll end up but after a long period of dormancy, my interest is rekindled.

Here's the link to one of the better threads of late. The exchange between Joel Moscowitz and David Weaver was something I read several times.


Historical Evidence for the double iron

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#11

The reports of their death are greatly exaggerated

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well, I imagine that is what Mark Twain said when he read the title of this thread.

Firstly, are you referring to jacks, fore planes, block planes, mitre planes, molding planes, and jointers in addition to smoothers? How would chip breakers serve to improve the performances here?

While I have no doubt that a chip breaker can improve the performance of a BD double-ironed smoother, I hasten to remind everyone that other types of planes are equally capable - perhaps more capable depending on the wood type - of such performances on reversing grain. The simple example being a plane - either BD or BU - with a high cutting angle.

Having experimented a bit now, I am not convinced that we have a one-size-fits-all situation, as some are proposing. I experience the "chip breaker effect" having variable results on different woods. And while some will argue that they get excellent results with their common angle Stanley #4 on interlocked hardwoods, it just goes to support my point that the results are variable. This may be due to my inexperience in setting the chip breaker, however this leads to the next point ...

Outside a relative few voices, so far there has not been many cries of excitement when this topic is raised around the world (I wrote positively about it on the Oz forum. The response was lukewarm at best). Habits die hard, and there are many who will continue doing what works for them. I'm no different - I appreciate the information, and I like the idea that my performance on the relevant planes will improve, however I have other planes that work as well .... and with far less faffing around.

Setting up a chip breaker-less BU or high angle BD plane is far easier than setting up a BD plane with a chip breaker. This, I suspect, is what will limit the current interest to a minority of woodworkers, and especially those new to the field will look elsewhere (notwithstanding the argument that the chip breaker effect can reduce costs in setting up a tool kit - beginners are unlikely to start out on interlocked hardwoods).

The research has concentrated on the effects of the chip breaker on the type of shaving, and its relationship to the quality of the surface of the wood. While this has been written about over the centuries, in recent decades the focus moved to the size of the mouth and the cutting angle. It is important to note that all these factors have been demonstrated to work ... just not always together (as in the case of the chip breaker effect). I think that there is much danger in "throwing the baby out with the bathwater". There are so many factors yet to understand, that making decisions about the future of plane design seems to me to be plain (sic) impulsive.

Anyway, I like the idea of choice.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#12

craigd

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

craigd

As far as I can tell, Kato-Kawa studied one configuration and showed it works quite well. That says nothing about how other configuration work. I suspect there are many variants that can work just as well. At this point in [hand] plane evolution, implementation is probably more important than configuration.

I have planes in all kinds of configurations and prefer the single iron BD tight mouthed bench planes simply because they have much better construction and ergonomics than my Stanley's (which I consider be of somewhat crude manufacture). If I had LN/LV/Old Street/S&S/Marcou planes I might feel differently.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#13

David Barnett

Death knell was a tongue-in-cheek overstatement

David Barnett

"Firstly, are you referring to jacks, fore planes, block planes, mitre planes, molding planes, and jointers in addition to smoothers?"

Only smoothers, jacks, foreplanes and jointers, with my interest leaning heavily to smoothers and diminishing with increasing length.

"Having experimented some, I am not convinced that we have a one-size-fits-all situation, as some are proposing."

My Speedo experiences refute any such one-size-fits-all notions.

"And while some will argue that they get excellent results with their common angle Stanley #4 on interlocked hardwoods, it just goes to support my point that the results are variable."

Of course, for the most difficult woods I've had BU planes with adjustable mouths and various bevel angle irons, and also the Primus Reforms. But I did most of my planing with closely set chipbreakers and frogs set to provide full support against the sole. The mouth was never a factor. Only rarely did I need to use anything other than Bailey planes.

"Outside a relative few voices, so far there has not been many cries of excitement when this topic is raised around the world (I wrote positively about it on the Oz forum. The response was lukewarm at best)."

Which only confirms what I've always thought about people who live on the wrong side of the world. Seriously, I do realize Wood Central is a mere sliver of the pie, but forgive the conceit that it's now and then the vanguard for some hand tool issues.

"Setting up a chip breaker-less BU or high angle BD plane is far easier than setting up a BD plane with a chip breaker."

This isn't something I had considered. It seems so easy to me, but then I've done it for years. I've never timed myself pulling the blade, honing it, setting the chipbreaker and replacing the iron. A little slower than a BU, sure, but not something that would annoy me. I don't really even think about it. Or didn't until recently. I guess cycling, as Tom calls it, matters much more to some than it does to me.

Part of my blasé attitude about planes and planing may relate to my overwhelming evolved preference for woods with little to no figure, to the extent that busy figure actually repels me. Give me pear any day, or boxwood, or holly, and so on. In fact, I bleach most any wood to reduce figure, contrast and saturation. I can deal with a bit of fine stripe, but that's enough figure for me (and my favorite color is pale Lüscher grey, go figure).

And I fully agree, it's good to have choices.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#14

David Barnett

I get queasy...

David Barnett

...when I hear "this is the only way to do it", or "this is superior to all others", and so on.

I've long used Bailey designs with a tightly-set chipbreaker to good effect, but I've also had success with BU LA designs with various bevel angles. I've tried infills but they fell short of my expectations. Good, but didn't really do it for me. I do, however like the Primus Reform, which exceeded my expectations. I bought two. I lack experience with single-iron planes, at least the top tier examples, but the high-angle single-iron with a tight mouth has its advocates and I would assume, for good reason.

"But is it better?"

My suspicions are aroused when someone says a simple tool is better than all the rest, but this could be so. My guess is that one paradigm's as good as another if one has mastered sharpening and knows how to get the most out of that particular plane design. Maybe best isn't really the most useful concept, but it sure is fun to kick around.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#15

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

CStan

The question itself has probably already been answered. I'm sure the number of double iron planes sold, both new and on the antique and auction markets (EBay), already far outstrip sales of single iron planes. The single iron plane market is totally niche, and that's fine, and it's not going away, nor should it.

For me, I never had tons of 'luck' with the single-iron smoother I did own. I've been told it was my 'technique' but for the life of me I was never sure what that mean beyond being an insult (which is ok, I dish it out I can take it). There's not a whole lot to adjust on one of these buggers and I was capable of adjusting it for a fine shaving.

Many of us stumbled upon a capiron setting that allowed us to get work smoothed (on figured stock) all the while the pundits were telling us is was quite impossible to have done so with a run-of-the-mill Bailey. I freely admit to having revisited close settings and did discover that I could move it even closer and change results. That's great to know and I appreciate having that information. It confirms the pedestrian investment in planes I've made. It's good to know it all hasn't been a figment of my imagination, pretty good results that is - with good 'ole Stanley and Record planes (mostly Record in my case; love the blue). I also won't hesitate to scrape. Nothing works 100% of the time.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#16

David Barnett

Lucky for me...

David Barnett

"Many of us stumbled upon a capiron setting that allowed us to get work smoothed (on figured stock) all the while the pundits were telling us is was quite impossible to have done so with a run-of-the-mill Bailey."

... I didn't know those limitations. I got a lot done with Baileys before I decided to try a smoother with a steeper pitch. As far as I can tell, nearly every plane I ever worked with had its strengths and sometimes weaknesses, but could be made to give passable if not exceptional results.

I tuned up my planes, scraped the soles flat, scraped the mating surfaces for the frog, added a couple Hock irons and that pretty much got me where I needed to be. After adding a L-N LA jack and LA smoother, mostly because I just wanted them, I really haven't run into anything that can't be handled. Mostly I plane to remove power tool marks, fit joints or prep for finishing, these days, so doubt I'll add to what I have.

With all the reprised excitement about chipbreakers, I was surprised that some actually considered setting a chipbreaker as something esoteric or forgotten lore. I was also wondering if anyone had become any less enthusiastic about higher pitch and/or their single-iron planes. It would appear not.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#17

Re: Simple

david weaver

I know the post was tongue in cheek.

They'll never go away, of course. If you can get a quality tool made, like a single iron plane that's tight enough to mostly eliminate tearout, it's nice to use.

It's still probably easier for me to use the infill that I built to smooth wood than it is even a stanley style bench plane (which to me is the easiest double iron plane to use, because it's pretty much air above the mouth as opposed to apparatus that may block a chip).

But it's not hard to use a stanley bench plane for anything now, so something a tiny bit easier doesn't make a difference, and if I knew what I know now, I probably wouldn't have built it (how many other things could you do with 60+ hours of time?). I also like the surface off of the bench plane on stuff that I usually work.

Beginners will always go toward single iron planes, be the BU or whatever. Niche buyers (like those wanting 18th century only stuff) will always go toward that type of plane. People making their own planes will probably often make single iron planes.

Composition of single vs. double iron is unlikely to change much, but it sure would be nice for it to be universal that even relative beginners would know how to use their double iron planes properly.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#18

Absolutely not

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There is one type of single iron plane that remained in production throughout the 19th century. Some of these planes were very high quality. Some were made of special woods like boxwood, apple, or rosewood. These planes were called gent's planes. Certainly a lot of amateurs must have known how to use a double iron, but for some it probably wasn't worth the effort. Today there is a great trade in gent's planes .

Derek Cohen enjoys tinkering. Many are not so able or so tireless in learning new skills. I think Derek was brave to write about his early efforts with the cap iron. However after just four sessions he writes "a higher cutting angle still seen to be important for hard woods with interlocked grain", seemingly already able to judge. And already Steve Elliott has made reference to Derek's work on this matter. I have written before that the ability to use the double iron well is not something one can learn in a weekend workshop. James Krenov called the plane a cabinetmaker's violin. I know from experience that a real violin sounds much better than an ipod. However I have no doubt Derek (or any body else) could prove me wrong after four sessions with a violin in his shop.

A list of experts who do not know how to use a double iron plane would include many of our most celebrated planemakers. Some of these have dismissed the double iron plane on their websites. I don't think this will change any time soon.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#19

Re: Lucky for me...

CStan

I don't think it was so much a case of forgotten lore as it was a case of believing those who had a vested interest in saying so that capirons simply don't work, the design is 'garbage' etc., etc. And the backdrop of all of this is that every book I have on woodworking mentions adjusting the capiron to handle difficult stock. All of these sources from apparently talented craftsmen. I can't find a "hardcopy" source mentioning capirons were crap and not to bother. It appears to me that this was/is totally an internet phenomenon. Those who get or have gotten all of their information regarding planes from the internet can be excused for being confused.

It's not an either/or proposition. Moulding planes are structured to be single-iron. You go with what you have. I don't intend to be guilty of the reverse bias. Single iron planes work. That's doesn't logically extend to say that double iron planes are crap. I think you'll agree.

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#20

Re: Lucky for me...

CStan

...and with bevel down planes you can have a 50* frog, a tight mouth (if you so choose), and a close capiron (if you so choose)....

Unless I'm mistaken, these options pretty much cover the waterfront, no?

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#21

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#22

Re: Lucky for me...

CStan

Totally agree with that... and wood on wood to boot!

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#23

Re: Absolutely not

CStan

You know, you get what you get when you buy a single-iron wood plane. The mouth opening is the mouth opening. Obviously, there is no cap iron to bring to bear. One iron, one mouth aperture. That's it. Sometimes there is beauty in simplicity. Sometimes not. I guess it's beautiful as long as the planing is going well. If it's not I'm not quite sure what one would do except to insert one's thumb in a place where it doesn't belong and hope that somehow something changes.

I end up adjusting the mouth opening on my No. 5 probably more than any other plane. Maybe I'm just kidding myself that this has efficacy. Sure seems to work those times when I feel the need to close it down a little. I'm sure there are many who would chalk this up to me simply not understanding how to plane, the "proper" use of a jack/fore plane, and all of that. And they may be right. But I can still walk out to the shop and change the mouth aperture. If I feel like it. Whenever I feel like it. Cap iron setting too.

And all for about 45 bucks, used (I prefer "broken in").

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#24

Don McConnell first

roninkokomo

Before I ruled out the Single iron plane, I believe I'd try one that Mr. McConnell has made. I have one on my wish list. I have heard gushy reviews of their performance. I have met Mr. McConnell more than once and have seen his work. I believe he would be making a smoother as good as one can be made, or he would forego the experience.

Ron a Kokomo Galoot

Re: Death knell of the single iron plane?

#25

Re: Lucky for me...

TomD

"I don't think it was so much a case of forgotten lore as it was a case of believing those who had a vested interest in saying so that capirons simply don't work, the design is 'garbage' etc., etc."

I don't think anyone has an actual vested interest in that in a sense. I did wonder why C&W were taking this "shortcut" when I read it on their site. I was delighted to discover they were doing it because it sorta paralleled my practical experience. Inamoto said something similar though there he may have been sparing the students since the sub blade installation is not difficult, but it is a one shot or Ooops! deal. + other problems. With C&W I also thought that they had a lot of bench planes where the work would not require breakers, even if the planes of an earlier day may have had them. They actually offer a real range, where a lot of other makers are like chisel makers who sell only 1/4" mortise chisels.

I now understand, or think I do, that LW is actually saying that single blades where the highest evolution at one point in time, for which he is my only source, if I have that idea right.

So yeah, people now have vested positions, with all the BUs out there, and C&Ws and so forth, but those things came into play for real reasons.

" And the backdrop of all of this is that every book I have on woodworking mentions adjusting the capiron to handle difficult stock. All of these sources from apparently talented craftsmen. I can't find a "hardcopy" source mentioning capirons were crap and not to bother."

+1. But while I always knew about setting breakers close, and don't know where I got that. I am in light of the craziness of the last few weeks, looking at a few of these sources, and it is true that some that ought to know better like Fink (recently checked not picking on him). Do not mention the real reason. So while some of these sources are as you say, they didn't necessarily know what they were talking about.

Krenov is another. Ever look at the blades he used in his planes, pathetic, right? He came out late in his life and rejected the whole path he put us on and so we have continued alone. So what did he really know?

" It appears to me that this was/is totally an internet phenomenon. Those who get or have gotten all of their information regarding planes from the internet can be excused for being confused."

Yeah, but this is one of those cases where the internet is better. I have more knowledge of planes than any of these guys who wrote books. And so do quite a lot of people. Why? Because I read everything say Krenov said, did the video the seminars, and for 30 years went places he did not want to go (for quite possbly good reason). The most important reason is because I am trying to do something he did not try to do. Along with millions of others. My third plane took shavings of 4 tens, it sucked but that is a high performance level. I have been at it another 30 years. I am perfectly willing to criticize the nuttiness of modern planes, but that is what we are talking about. Think about it. Krenov did not use veneer, during the period that made him famous. So he did not need planes that would plane some burl. In a lot of areas of human activity the amateurs of today are better than the pros of yesterday.

I was on the internet looking for pictures of this climb called English Breakfast crack. The only picture I had seen was of "god" Henry Barber climbing it in mountain magazine int he 70s. Found a picture set from someone's vacation. Pretty average sounding bunch of people who just cruised it as if it were nothing.

"It's not an either/or proposition. Moulding planes are structured to be single-iron. You go with what you have. I don't intend to be guilty of the reverse bias. Single iron planes work. That's doesn't logically extend to say that double iron planes are crap. I think you'll agree."

It is obviously a little more difficult to make moulding planes that have double irons, but if it were necessary, that is what we would have. It isn't necessary, so what does that say? I think double irons are crap if they are just there but not being used. And that is the exact case for those who wrote the books, and sold planes for a long time. They were there, and there wasn't even a good story as to why.