We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
My first simple project has two sides one end a banana and another end that is a now two small from the sharp camber I put on the top (see the post).
I think it was Cstan that mentioned a larger scale project might be easier to get my hands on (skill and literally I believe). So what would be a good project for me to take on as project 1B?
One thing I've thought of is a Japanese style tool box but I'm open to suggestions in just about any avenue that you guys would think would be a good place for me to start.
A Japanese toolbox needn't be complicated or dovetailed or elaborate. Bob Le's toolbox is a great example. While his is dovetailed, a couple simple box joints would work just fine, and it all gets nailed together. This one is Mr. Le's.
I made one last year to cart a small assortment of hand tools to work, thinking I would replace it with a much more elaborate one. I haven't seen the need to do that yet - this one works really well.
It would be useful to know what skills you have and what skills you want to use this project to evolve.
Or orthogonally what needs you want this project to fullfill and what needs you have already satisfied.
For example if you need a tool chest ..... build a tool chest
If you need to learn about dovetails ...... make a simple dovetailed box.
Skills: I can make a board into a banana with saw and plane, haven't discovered any other wood working skills yet.
Goals: To turn that skill into making me the next Nakashima, Krenov, etc. Ok, kidding but I would like to be able to build some nice furniture for our family.
Needs: Closest would probably be a tool chest but I had hoped in future to build an anarchist one. I don't have high hopes for the prettiness of the first project and might aspire to squareness. I did a list a while back of several projects I'd like to do.
Bottom Line: I need a good t-ball hit project to give me a start to practice some skills and to gain some confidence (if not competence).
Something to add to the later queue but I'm not sure it fits as a good first. Thought I'd throw it out there just in case.
My son does Legos and my wife has talked about doing something she saw online - two of those plastic shelf units on wheels with a board on top with lego baseplates on top.
Of course I'm reimagining this with edges to keep the little pieces from falling off and maybe a stud tray on a side or back. Then I got to thinking that instead of the plastic bins I could make two boxes for shelves for it to rest on.
Might be a first project but one thing I was hoping for that it doesn't have is a pre-done plan that takes away one thing that I don't have to think about (design).
Make a box out of 3/4" or 7/8" material. Make it big enough to hold something. Hand cut the rebate joints and nail it all together in a very craftsmanlike/workmanlike way. Harder than you think! A rebate joint is less forgiving of inaccuracies than the dovetail joint. You'll learn a lot about tool handling, layout, etc.
Make it out of Poplar and plan a very tastefully done painted finish. Do not use lumberyard pine. It's crap. It's like trying to cut joinery on a kitchen sponge. You would need Toshia Odate to come over and sharpen your tools to get them to a point able to cut crisp detail in Borg Pine.
By the time I had my first shop I had been making my living working with wood for 7 or 8 years so I had a few skills and a smattering of tools. for my first project I chse to make a work table. I used kiln dried 2x4 and 2x6 and a sheet of 3/4 particle board for the top. It was a simple design with butt joints and lap joints that were glued and screwed. It was not a particularly challanging project skills wise but due to the lack of a work bench, or vise and a lack of tools it was still a challange to get the top flat.
once I had a sturdy work table I made a work bench and from then on the projects have never stopped.
It is not just what you build, but the skills you develop along the way. For this reason, while I think a box is a good idea, I would like to see you learning to 4 square the pieces that will be used. This will involve cross cutting with a saw, planing across- and with the grain, planing end grain, and using a marking gauge.
Build the "packing box" in The Joiner and the Apprentice - just add nails. This would be a good start.
It's not anything I would push, but a fun project with a little more scale and a few joints is a step stool. Sorta a carcass, but not as much work as something involving doors and drawers etc...
http://www.steveweb.net/shaker_stool.htm
I made several moser ones around 81.
A simple design. Our library has a tape for Tommy Mac Rough Cut woodworking, and the details on his similar stool are a little neater. Simon Watts has an even nicer one, but it is not particularly easy, Franz Klaus has one with a handle and the plans for that are out there.
For a mortise project a semi-challenging one, and I have made a couple of these is the Simon Watts crib. It is the kind of thing you either need or don't, I suppose like anything, but it is a fun build. There is a picture of someone else's version on this site.
When I started out, this was one of my favorite books. It is unusual because it is perhaps the best book written that covered a reasonably wide range of household furniture, at this level, and gave all the plans for them. There are better designer craftsmen, and there are tons of plans, and there are books with a wide range, but this one might be the only one to put it all together. That said, the plans are not all equal. Anyway, however one looks at it, it is a pretty good book. And the tables are pretty nice, very much as you might want. I guess Tage Frids book is pretty good, though only two of the pieces appealed to be strongly.
Do the project you just completed again. And again until it is perfect in your eyes. If you change the subject you'll never learn that particular lesson. To me every project is a lesson. Once I master it it's boring to repeat.--my simple opinion---Jack
If a good looking project is the goal, skill development can suffer. No reason you can't use a project to develop skills, but keep it simple and cheap. Don't be afraid to burn it and start over.
If you are doing this entirely by hand, you need to be able to make a square board with hand tools. I would pick a board about 8/4 thick and maybe 12" wide and 19-7/16" long. This is the finished size, so you would want to start with something bigger. Make sure it has interesting grain. Rip, crosscut and plane to the finished size, flatten and smooth, bevel the edges, finish nicely and hang on the wall. If the first one doesn't turn out right, try again.
Tex, you've discussed mallets and shooting boards, boxes, some project in which apparently has some banana shape (don't know if this is a joke or not).
Take a deep breath. If you've already blown a project, decide if it's worth redoing. If it's not (and they most certainly always are not). Forget about it and move on. Throw the parts away. Put it out of your mind. Start with a clean slate. Go out in your shop. Organize and clean the hell out of it. Take stock of the tools that you have, and build something useful. Don't build a shop implement right now. I can promise that a shooting board, and a mallet too, will probably be failures. Find a simple box plan and build it with hand tools. Four square the boards, cut the joints, assemble the box. I'd suggest a nailed project, maybe with hand cut rabbets, maybe not. You decide. Just four-squaring the parts by hand will probably be an accomplishment at this point. Nothing to be ashamed of. Nail it together. Nailing isn't as easy as it seems either. I can guarantee you there are guys around who can cut beautiful dovetail joints who couldn't reliably nail a simple box together without dinging it, splitting a part, or otherwise making a mess of it. Build your skills from the ground up. The day will come with some certain Mr. or Ms. FancyPantsDovetails is going to need to drive a nail and he or she will butcher it all to hell. You'll learn how to cut dovetails in due time. Some people have built a career, if not an internet following, around them. They are just one joint out of many that need to be learned. You need to learn how to hold work, layout work, assemble and glue work, all of these things before tackling dovetails. And when you do, you'll be a success and simply be adding these to your repertoire and moving on instead of becoming fixated on them as if you've reached some sort of woodworking nirvana because you can cut a dovetail.
Learn how to four-square parts and nail a butt joint together. You will be better for it.
Find Charles Hayward's Junior Woodworker used on Amazon and build the box projects in it. They are of increasing complexity up to building a small dovetailed tool chest.
DO NOT be put off by the title, for no matter how old you are that's where you are skill-wise.
The Schwarz has an awesome writing ability. His article and viewpoints are refreshing, especially since he is self deprecating and points out almost all the time that your opinion may differ from his, and if what you are doin is workin for you, by all means keep at it.
No, he is not a hand tool woodworking purist, neither was Maloof.
Please don't try to change the Schwarz. If you don't like him, read somebody else. Lots of us like him just like he is.
Feel free to differ, although I think you've misunderstood what I said and why I appended an "[edit]", to avoid misinterpretation. Apparently, didn't work.
Had I known I'd have to write this, to further explain myself, I'd have avoided commenting on Tony's book list altogether. I certainly didn't intend to offend anyone.
"The Schwarz has an awesome writing ability. His article and viewpoints are refreshing... "
Did I say otherwise?
I have nothing bad to say about the writing; just that getting the information that would best address the issues that Tony is dealing with in context of his first and current project, his difficulties in squaring a board, does not require all the personal or philosophical insights Chris has to offer. I was only speaking to the outcome of Tony's project.
Obviously, the personal insights, philosophy and so on that makes Chris' book readable and valuable to you and others is not what I'm criticizing (and I'm not using criticizing in the way you probably interpret it). By the way, I rather enjoyed what I read, although I thought the retooling of "anarchist" to be a little elastic and tenuous, but that's easily overlooked once you accept the author's explanation.
So I considered Tolpin's book to be more accessible, again in context of Tony's recent experience, even though I personally find Tolpin somewhat boring. Point is, it's a different kind of book (don't you think?) which is why I asked Tony what he had, to determine whether or not he had a basic beginner's how-to book.
Do you find "The Anarchist's Tool Chest" a bare-bones how-to book?
"Please don't try to change the Schwarz. If you don't like him, read somebody else."
Really quite a leap there, Ron. Where are you getting this? And don't you think that's just a little testy and unfair? At any rate, I'll read whom and what I please, and offer my opinion as I see fit.
My distinction was simply reading for specific information versus reading for enjoyment and enrichment, all which are certainly to be had from Schwartz. If someone asked me for information on whale oil rendering, I might very well tell them to read Moby Dick but steer them to read it on that level, for the specific information and to get the sense for what it was like on a whaler of that era rather than for the allegorical layers that make Melville Melville; hardly a putdown. That's all. Nothing more, nothing less. Capice?
I second the Tolpin book. I actually bought it out of curiosity and it is well thought out. It takes you through all the basics and has you build skills up in a thoughtful manner. I was a bit let down by the lack of depth (I thought I'd get nore out of it) but for a beginner, this book is awesome. Plus you will walk out with some shop tools that you made yourself which will serve you well going forward.
Just supplement with some exercises (like the 100 cuts exercise and 6-squaring a board). Remember that you have tyo teach your body new tricks and that nothing will be perfect from the get-go. Give yourself time and do some practice exercises to develop muscle memory.
This is essential to sawing and planing, less so for chisel use but still good practice.
Also, as an aside, I notice that you seem to be getting best of breed everything. I think that there is a certain amount of wastage there and also some lsot opportunities.
While we may wax philosophical about good white steel japanese chisels and have the equivalent of a book written on this board discussing placement of chipbreaker, the reality is that you aren't at that point yet and cannot appreciate the nuances that the premium tools offer. In all honesty, a couple of baley planes picked up on flea-bay or at the flea market, a set of marples blue chip chisels and four saws should take you a long time to outgrow. As you build your skills, you will know where to go next for tools and when and where your money is going for premium.
I am also a big proponent of rehabbing old tools like planes. By doing so, you become intimately familiar with it, it's workings and you will therefore be more attuned to the feedback it gives you.
By all means, keep the premium tools you have Tony but you should be able to get by with a $300-500 TOTAL cash outlay for quite a while.
And not to jump into this fight, , He has Charlesworth videos that cover squaring up stock in detail that should be enough for anyone.
By the way, my sense is that Maloof in particular was more a freehand woodworker, and power tool woodworker. He used whatever got the job done, and found workarounds around most of the classical hand methods, and used mostly only hand shaping tools. Which is cool.
I apologize for my apparent misinterpretation. I have recently seen Chris trashed on Lumberjocks and a couple of other places and I am very weary of it. I guess I jumped too quickly to the wrong conclusion. Yes, I agree with you wholeheartedly that it is way too early in Tony's journey for the Anarchist's Tool Chest. And yes Tolpin's book is much more appropriate.