New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Help me pick a project

Posts

Re: Help me pick a project

#26

Hey Tom

Ron in Kokomo

You are of course correct about Maloof. I lifted him up because he is an Icon and an incomparable artist. There are a few on this side of the pond who have taken the rather bizarre attitude that furniture is somehow diminished unless it is "pure" hand tool created. What arrant nonsense.

I really don't care if you cut dovetails with a chainsaw. It is your business, and I have no right to tell you what you should do. And even then I must be careful and say "here's how and why I do things this way. Your mileage may vary"

I overreacted to a post above that was actually a very helpful post. I was wrong.

Re: Help me pick a project

#27

David Barnett

Totally understand...

David Barnett

...and totally accepted. Now I see where that came from. No problem. I knew your post was sincere which really had me puzzled.

I can be pretty terse at times and forget this medium sometimes needs extra compensation. Although I tried to do that up front, upon rereading, it really didn't take enough off the unintended edge, and for that I apologize. Of course, I know what I mean so I imagine everyone else knows, too.

For the life of me, I can't grasp why anyone would get exercised over anything Chris says in his book. Now you've aroused my curiosity enough to download his .pdf version. No pleasing everyone, of course, but that book is a particular person's outlook, their unique way of viewing a craft from the framework of every modern woodworker dedicated to the craft. It's nothing if not inspiring. That uniqueness is what I meant by idiosyncratic, by the way; one's own (from the Greek ἰδιοσυγκρασία) as in one's own highly individual way of approaching something.

Thanks for clarifying, and no hard feelings.

Re: Help me pick a project

#28

There's nothing wrong with small...

John in NM

Small or big, its a matter of practice. I believe most of the suggestions of small projects are due to mobility limitations, correct?

I would agree that Jack has some good advice there (depending on how simple the box is), keep repeating until you can do it. Or follow Charles' suggestion of 4-squaring a board first off before you start building. If you like, practice 4-squaring on a scale that will later be useful for the box.

By all means, butt the corners and nail them, not every box needs a fancy joint. Try a splined miter after that, or a miter with cross pins (I once made one with K&S brass tubing for the cross pins).

For what it's worth, I made lots of small projects (mostly boxes) when I started WW'ing. It was all I had the room and the time for - I was in college and seeking activities more interesting than studying :D This didn't stop me from learning to make bigger stuff later, and one of the 1st full pieces I made when I later worked in a furniture shop was the biggest piece I ever made (12' long buffet with lots of drawers). Size is quite irrelevant IMHO, its more a matter of attitude and the willingness to make mistakes so that you can learn from them.

Funny thing about the internet - there are all these pictures of what appears to be perfect work, and all these people professing to complete perfect work. Yet I've never made a perfect thing in my life, but I sure have learned from a lot of mistakes :D I bet it would be a lot less daunting for beginners if that were the sort of thing we discussed here all the time.

Re: Help me pick a project

#29

Re: The Tolpin book

Texchappy

Guillaume (hope I spelled that right). I get what you are saying on one level about the premium tools. However, I think I’m not understanding why ‘understanding the nuances’ of a good tool necessarily means I need to start out with a less expensive tool. Why would that be beneficial?

As to why I’m getting some of the more expensive tools; it’s not to say that I have such and such but instead to support artisans. If I get a tool hand made by Dave Jeske instead of going down to woodcraft and picking up something off a rack I feel less connected to the great group of craftsman that are making things available for all woodworkers. May be a load of crap but it gives me a good feeling ;)

I do have a bailey style plane that just arrived in the mail today. It’s is a vintage #5. Man is it heavy. That is part of the reason I started researching wood planes - both Japanese and American. I was VERY fortunate to end up with an Old Street Smoothing plane. The fact that I could call up and talk with Don there in Arkansas about it and what would work best for me was a great resource. That’s why I ordered the other two essential planes from them. It will be what I need and exactly what I need.

I’m going to keep working on the box. It probably will end up with a lot of the squaring exercise and I may well exceed the 100 saw cuts.

I would like to thank everyone for all their suggestions and help; you have my deepest gratitude.

Re: Help me pick a project

#30

Re: There's nothing wrong with small...

CStan

My only slight quibble with your thoughts is that there is a point where work holding on the bench becomes more of a logistical problem than a beginner needs (small-ish parts). Ditto for a project whose scale demands thinnish materials.

A somewhat beefy box that could be used in the shop using stock no thinner than 5/8" would be my choice. 3/4" might be better or even 7/8ths - something to drive a nail into with some room for error.