(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested
#26
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Understood
Texchappy
I once had one of my company commanders that got nervous around knives. When the XO found this out he started to bring out his knife whenever he thought it was time for this CPT to go. He told me so I started to do it too with the knife I carried when we flew into combat. One time he, the Sergeant Major, and I were talking. I brought out my knife during the conversation to which he said to the SGM, "do you see what he's doing to me?" To which the SGM brought out his knife and responded, "don't know what you're talking about?" Ah the good times harassing people in the name of God 
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested
TomD
Thanks Pam. I haven't seen that before. A lot of detail there.
Re: Front sight, front sight...
TomD
Cool. Always wanted to go to Gunsight, but I am such a recluse, I could never get the recommendations together. Anyway, not a real thing up here.
Re: Just grab your boots and pull
TomD
""I'm wondering about the adage - it takes a bench to build a bench?""
That was how I got into power tools. I figured i could buy the bench I needed, or the tools and wood to build it for about the same price. Which was a sorta truth.
There are quite a few benches that would work well enough that you could make for a few hundred, out of HD materials, and just leave behind the cheap large bits if you move. Taking stuff like vises and hardware with you. A base that is 100% solid can be made for almost nothing, in almost no time, and with almost not tools. The top can be made out of plywood and that can be bought sawn from HD, most of those stores have very nice panel saws. Take your plugs.
Power tools have a lot of bad habits, noise is not always all that bad. You can have to endure a lot of relative noise doing stuff by hand, that would be over a lot quicker and muffable if done with a power saw.
I think working all by hand is achievable for most, if they make stuff that allows it. If you have a project orientation, then health, energy, gear, etc... have to be hugely ramped up.
Building a bench without a bench
wilbur
I know of three ways to tackle this issue.
Bob Rozaieski has a really excellent series of videos on building a workbench without using a workbench. Even more impressively, he builds a workbench without a workbench even though he has a fully functioning workbench just a few feet away from where he’s working.
http://www.logancabinetshoppe.com/podcast-the-workbench.html
Take a large beam or bench top, place it on sawhorses, and rig up a way to butt the bench top/sawhorses against a wall or some other immovable object.
http://giantcypress.net/post/567995425/building-a-workbench-without-a-workbench-ii-or-who
Glue up the workbench top first, while clamping the unused boards together to make a temporary work surface.
http://giantcypress.net/post/583759933/building-a-workbench-without-a-workbench-iii
Do have something - can I make it work?
Texchappy
This is what I'm using now:
http://www.gladiatorgarageworks.com/skip/workbenches/6_ft__modular_workbench_gawb06mtrg.pro?scr=category&activeCategory=0&activeSubCategory=0
I actually got it for garage use and building my balsa models on. Can I make it work for woodworking without having to alter it too much that I can't use it for car stuff anymore?
Watching the Logan's CS as I took a time out to post this. Great videos. Thanks Wilbur.
Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested
Guillaume Dery
2. Rip trying to pull saw out of hand; blister forming...
Sounds like it's getting timber bound, binding in the cut as described above. First off, use two hands on the saw. This will help your overall ergonomics, because it will spread the ripping load over many more muscles in your body--think first about letting your combined arm weight pull the saw through the cut, and secondly, lean in slightly with the downstroke to get more muscles and your weight into play. Try to use gravity and the large muscle groups on both sides of your body.
I haven't played with the bigger Japanese saws but your reply to Tex has me a bit confused.
Don't all japanese saws cut on the pull stroke? Why would you want to lean in on the return stroke to get body weight into it???
Never Mind, I misread your post
Yes you can!
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
There is a lot you can do with that bench--it's a good size, good height (for your back), a good clamping surface, you can drill it for dogs, hold downs and other appurtenances, and you can hang vises on it if desired. But first, three questions:
Question 1: By how many inches does the top overhang the legs--on both the front and the sides?
Question 2: When you plane along the long axis, does the bench rock side to side, or get springy, in response to your planing force?
Question 3: What is the depth in inches of the legs? Depth of leg from front face to the back face?
If the gladiator bench does tend to deflect with planing force, first try using the back side--the side with the steel upper rail--as the front. Does the bench still deflect when you plane along the side with the rail? If yes, there are ways to make it rigid. Here are two: (a) set the bench against a garage wall and lag bolt it through the steel rail or legs into the framing (there are better and worse ways to do this, but first we need to know setback of the legs from the top edge); (b) on the other hand, if the bench needs to be freestanding, then make your own top rail. Face-glue two 2x8's from the big box store, with the rear 2x8 a tight fit between the two legs, and the front 2x8 overlapping the legs and running the length of the bench (6 ft). Counterbore and bolt the front 2x8 through the legs, with upper and lower bolts on each leg. The inner 2x8 is acting as a shoulder to resist the side-to-side racking.
If you go this way, you also now have a front apron which could be made flush with the top edge (that's why i asked about the amount of setback of legs from front edge), and could serve as rear jaw of a twin-screw vise.
Many more options of course, but no point getting too far ahead before we know answers to the three questions.
Wiley
Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Tony said,
".... I had a 270mm/300mm rip kataba on my wish list. I was hoping the 210mm could handle 1/2" stock. Everything you said sounds exactly like what I was experiencing. I'm going to try coming from the other side of the board and go back to basics as it were and see if I can make it work."
1. Size of saw. While I recommend a 270mm kataba (sometimes 'kataha'), you don't need it for 1/2" stock. It's just a good size for a wide range of situations. Not all 270 kataba's are created equal--for example, mine has 6 points per inch (ppi), while one sold by Japan Woodworker for $100 has 11 or 12 ppi. For rough cutting to size, having too much saw is way better than having not quite enough, in my opinion. By the way, I may as well say it here: David Barnett's recommendation to get a bandsaw may be the best recommendation you will ever hear. I truly second it. It's not as loud as a table saw, and the decibels are lower frequency. You just will not want to make a career out of hand ripping every stick of wood that goes into a project. I say this in part because I have never found an ergonomically sensible way to rip using a Japanese saw.
2. 'back to basics'. In order of priority, I would say (a) two hands, but as loose a grip as will work--you have to feel the friction on the saw sides; (b) think 'I've got all day, gonna take it easy'--this to avoid crowding the cut; (c) think about how you're setting your stroke to minimize the friction on the sides of the saw--visualize and feel the saw sides in the kerf; (d) when you feel the saw starting to bind or see it creeping off line, quickly flatten out the saw and extend your kerf where you want it.
This last point is key to all sawing IMO: You're not being passive; you're not hoping the saw goes straight this time; you're going to actively make leading cuts to guide the saw to where you want it to go. Think of it this way: when you saw, you're constructing a miter box as you go, so that the saw blade will be properly guided. If you let the saw decide, it will find the path of least resistance. Because the smaller (210) Japanese saw has little beam strength and the ryoba has zero relief, you will have to go slowly. A heavier saw, and a saw with relief (kataba) is far more forgiving and efficient in the ripping or resaw job.
Good luck!
Wiley
Re: Yes I can - later
Texchappy
Wiley, I'll have to get those answers for you later. Not able to get down to the basement right now. One thing I have realized that would have made my life a lot easier is that the back skirt is facing out - d'oh.
The Gladiator Stats for Wiley
Texchappy
For those of you seeking the colosseum results for Wiley, this ain't it.
Question 1: By how many inches does the top overhang the legs--on both the front and the sides? --- 4 inches
Question 2: When you plane along the long axis, does the bench rock side to side, or get springy, in response to your planing force? --- so far it's been solid but haven't really planed hard or long on it.
Question 3: What is the depth in inches of the legs? Depth of leg from front face to the back face? --- they that 3 inches square.
Re: The Gladiator Stats for Wiley
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Tony,
Thank you! The biggest news (for me) is that the bench is steady under planing at the moment. That moots the other questions for the time being, since they concerned the details of how to stiffen the bench.
David has said it--now you're up to work holding. There are as many different work-holding schemes as there are woodworkers in the world, so hopefully others will show what they do. Wilbur has a very effective stop system for planing, for example. Others--Derek and Roger Lance come to mind right away, have made heavy wooden twin-jaw vises that are removable additions--take them on or off. I myself like the Veritas Twin Screw Vise, and their Hold-down. [Statement: I have no relationship with Lee Valley, other than I send money, they send me stuff. However, they do have really useful stuff, and if the item doesn't suit for any reason, they make right.]
In your case, because you're moving in a matter of months, I would suggest not undertaking a big bench project, but rather work with what you've got, and add a few simple appurtenances that will assist give you another pair of hands for your most frequent operations of planing, sawing, chiseling.
Whenever I have a work holding issue, my first stop is Lee Valley, to see what they've got, and usually there are a couple three new things they've added since I was there last. This time is no exception. I went to my usual two stops: Index>Benches>Accessories and Index>Vises. Go to Vises and Bench>Accessories. Here are two items IMO you would never regret having in the future, and which would be of immediate help to you right now:
Vertical clamp: http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=57059&cat=1,41637
Small vise: http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=31144&cat=1,41659,41665&ap=1
Many, many applications but one I will mention that is problematic is distance ripping with Japanese saw, in that you need to do it standing up straight. What I've found is that to do this, you want the work held vertical and angled slightly away from you, so that your saw is cutting from top to bottom, and is a little higher than belly button. As you cut, move the stock up in the vise. When you get half-way, turn the work end for end, and make a new start from the other end, and meet in the middle. Advantages: Your back is straight, but major muscle groups can be used; gravity is on your side; takes only a slight movement to adjust the cut angle and extend the kerf down the board. That small vise will let you do that--I would line the jaws with leather pieces for grip--hold with two-sided tape.
For joinery sawing, you will have to experiment to see whether you prefer to have the work flat on the table and extending off, or whether you want it held more or less vertically: either the vertical clamp or the small vise will do this for you.
As David said, you will need to drill the bench top with 3/4" holes, to accept various hold downs and dogs.
The above are merely my thoughts on how you might proceed. There are many, many other ways to go. Perhaps Wilbur will show his bench stop approach--it is a practical and efficient method for hemming in the work, especially for planing.
Wiley
Depth for Hold Fasts
Texchappy
Am I right in assuming that the hair short of 2 inch maple top is not deep enough for hold fasts?
Re: Depth for Hold Fasts
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
1-3/4" will grip holdfasts, for sure. If you get one with smooth shanks (the kind you set and release with mallet blows), you may need to roughen the shanks with a file (or you may not), but that is the most that would be necessary. The LV ones have milled shanks and get a death grip.
Wiley
Couple more work holding ideas
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
These hold-downs have gotten good comments from users:
This Moxon vise would be very useful for joinery sawing--didn't know you could buy it til I saw it at Joel's:
Wiley
Re: Depth for Hold Fasts & moxon
Texchappy
Been hesitant in thinking this through to drill the top but if it can do hold-fasts I might do it. I like the idea of blacksmith made holdfasts (the whole artisan made, know who's hand was on it).
Also, I've been thinking about making a moxon style vise to clamp on.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: For that matter...
Texchappy
Yeah, cheaper than: http://www.benchcrafted.com/MoxonVise.html
What size holes do I need to drill? I would have asked Gov. Palin but she wasn't handy.
Said I wouldn't ask any more questions but...
Texchappy
Where would you put the dog holes in this bench i.e. how would you lay them out?
PS I will try to find an appropriate forum for new woodworker questions in future.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Round Dog Sizes?
Texchappy
Looks like 3/4" is the way to go for the dog holes - the Gramercy hold fasts and all the lee valley stuff is that size. Wonder why Lie Nielsen (which looks like well made dog) is for a 1" hole?
Learning curve
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Tony and all,
Leave yourself room for learning as you go. If you come up with a theory of work, and drill a grid of holes, it will turn out to be very right or very wrong.
Before drilling anything, I would first prototype your basic operations, making do with the clamps you have and other props: How do you want to crosscut? Where? Now try it and see if the theory works. What if it's a wider or narrower or thinner or thicker board--does it still work? Finally got it settled? Then mark in pencil--but don't drill yet--the one hole or two holes necessary to do that operation, and label them crosscut.
Now do the same for sawing tenon cheeks and tenon shoulders--is a pattern emerging? Obviously, you're also figuring out what kinds of work holding devices you want to use as you're doing this.
After this set of exercises, you're ready to order a couple of work-holding devices--you're not gonna drill anything before you have your starting kit on hand, right?
Once you get your stuff, retest to see if what you've developed so far needs to be adjusted some--it will! Once that's done, do a basic operation--crosscut a board, saw a tenon, chop a mortise do you need underlayment? How does that change stuff?
Drill one hole, or two holes if required. Will this hole permit just one operation or more than one? How much use can you get from this hole? Answering that will tell you the limitations, and point you to the next hole, and where it has to be.
The above is intended to lay out a thought process and approach, not a cookbook: think, then prototype using stuff you have, then order a piece or two of your starting hold-downs/vises/etc, then test them on operations you're going to do a lot.
At some point a pattern may emerge and you may want a grid to make life better. But drill no hole before there is a tangible and practical need for it, in order to perform an operation.
2 cents.
Wiley
P. S. Exception to this is a row of dog holes along front, if you install a wagon vise or equal to hold work for planing.