New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

Posts

Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#1

Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

Texchappy

I was working on my box yesterday and ran into a couple of things I need help with.

First, I had to do a rip cut to square up my boards. I had trouble staying on the line and need to figure out how to fix that. Also, I had trouble with the rip trying to pull the saw out of my hand even with I narrowed up the angle of attack. I stopped with I start to feel my palm getting warm so I would get a blister - what am I doing wrong?

Second, my left hand is very week from my injury. I had trouble holding my try square and straight edge steady and so my lines were all over the place. Any tips?

TIA,

Tony

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#2

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

david weaver

I've used and still use a japanese saw a lot, but not to rip.

I've always found western carpenters saws to be a better solution for hand ripping, especially in wood with any signficant hardness and wood in a length long enough that you can't easily stand it up in a vise.

My suggestion is to invest in one carpenters rip saw and set it up with minimal to moderate set (so it does a tidy job), and see if you like it better. It'll work better with one-handed use, too, or in a situation where one hand is stronger than another.

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#3

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

Texchappy

Confession time. When I had trouble yesterday I called Mark Harrell and he had one of his hybrid filed 12" dovetail/tenon saws that someone had returned for hand size so I ordered it. We'll see how it goes. I have a Stanley handsaw I got many years ago hanging out in the garage and I might try it but I doubt it's what will help me with this project.

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#4

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

david weaver

Presumably the stanley saw is a crosscut saw or combination filed saw. Unfortunately, you'll not get the experience of how excellent a good cabinetmaking rip saw is until you're able to get a dedicated rip saw.

If you like to work larger furniture, something in the 5 1/2 tpi range is nice.

If you work only smaller stuff and want extra tidy work, something in the 7-8 tpi range is nice.

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#5

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

TomD

As much as we all have preferences in saws, the solution to a sawing problem, or any other similar problem is not just to buy a different saw. Sure new tools sometimes have that something that makes them better for us. And a saw that is not effective needs to be addressed. But I didn't rip perfectly to a line the first time I tried it out either. Practice is the key, get some wood and start turning it into books. I realize that could be a problem if you have challenges. Ripping along with planing is probably one of the main things that drives one to power tools.

One of my nags is that I think people do not practice enough. Each individual will decide how much, but I think it is bad for a raft of reasons I am happy to expand on, to mix projects with tool learning skills. for one thing when you are practicing a bad cut it just part of the process, but when you are doing a project it is a ruined piece of posiibly expensive wood.

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#6

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

Texchappy

Thanks TomD: got plenty of wood left to go ;) This box is sort of my practice with a purpose piece. Worst case scenario is I've turned some inexpensive wood into future practice scrap wood.

I probably did jump the gun on getting another saw but I've been thinking about it a bit and wanted to compare how the ergonomics of each tool works for my needs - same as I'm doing with planes. I'm committed to hand tools so I'll have to learn to rip some how and some way. Itching to get back to my project to give it another go but had physical therapy yesterday and I'm unable to get out of my recliner today.

PS: I know the ryoba would probably work better for ripping in a traditional position - across two small horses - and leaning down to rip it as pictured in Odate. However, I can't bend down that far (couldn't lean down to lift the toilet lid today for reference).

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#7

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

david weaver

One thing is key for sawing, you have to start on the waste side of the line when you're a beginner and give yourself enough room if you care about using the piece. Maybe drawing two lines is a good idea - one "line that counts" and one that is your target that's an eighth away or something. Then you can practice cutting on or beside the target line and then plane off the waste, until you get comfortable enough that you can eliminate the target line.

I haven't, though, found that ripping with a ryoba in volume is very practical, even if I'm standing on the wood. I've tried it several times, and I'm still looking for something that works as well.

Even on youtube it is monstrously hard to find someone using a ryoba or kataba to rip a long board of something medium hard or hard. It is a teeth chattering experience, and definitely not something I'd want to do with one good hand and one somewhat compromised.

I would love to be proved wrong about it, though, because I have several ryobas and two katabas that would be great for ripping. Just not if they're going to ultimately be less comfortable to use and slower than a carpenter's saw.

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#8

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

TomD

"First, I had to do a rip cut to square up my boards."

Just to be clear, we are taking about cutting the sides, not the ends, right?

"I had trouble staying on the line and need to figure out how to fix that."

Normally ripping for width one is going to follow up with a plane, so a modest amount of error is no biggie. One issue is how agressive is the saw. A lot of replaceable blade saws have softwood teeth, if you are using a hard wood then they will feel harsh in the cut, and may cause problems. Try some practice on soft wood to see where the issues are.

Notwithstanding what I said earlier, hand strength wise western saws are probably better, overall horsepower wise, Japanese saws are probably better. Most western bodies will probably achieve hold downs easier with western saws. If you have a decent bench, then either can be served. Actually, before you spend a fortune one high end tools, I would recommend getting shop furniture first.

"Second, my left hand is very week from my injury. I had trouble holding my try square and straight edge steady and so my lines were all over the place. Any tips? "

Is this the same operation? Or have we moved on to crosscutting the board? Japanese try squares do sit with a lot less wiggle, and they are light. They have a figure of 8 section to them, so that they sit on two points of the beam, and those points do not skid around. Another thing you can do with any flat square be it Japanese or a framing square, is lie it entirely on the top of the board, then use a fence to the back, possibly a bench hook, for alignment. Having a bench hook/shooting board, will also help with sawing and squaring. Do you have a table saw? Because the fence and table make good reference surfaces for aligning your square.

By the way, are the physical issue you have, made better or worse, over time, by exercise.

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#9

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

Texchappy

David Weaver: The two lines idea is good. I keep giving myself too little room. This particular cut I do have some wiggle room however.

TomD:

Just to be clear, we are taking about cutting the sides, not the ends, right? --- right

Try some practice on soft wood to see where the issues are. --- Poplar is on the soft end of hard woods right? Or do I need to go softer?

I would recommend getting shop furniture first. --- As in a bench? If so, I was trying to hold off until after we move in January but I may have to reconsider.

Is this the same operation? Or have we moved on to crosscutting the board? --- both actually. I still haven't found a good way to get the line straight for ripping - didn't have a straightedge long enough.

Japanese try squares do sit with a lot less wiggle, and they are light. They have a figure of 8 section to them, so that they sit on two points of the beam, and those points do not skid around. --- I was using a tiny Japanese square.

Another thing you can do with any flat square be it Japanese or a framing square, is lie it entirely on the top of the board, then use a fence to the back, possibly a bench hook, for alignment. Having a bench hook/shooting board, will also help with sawing and squaring. --- I'll have to try that.

Do you have a table saw? nope and don't want one ;)

By the way, are the physical issue you have, made better or worse, over time, by exercise. --- yes. It's a trade-off - I need to keep as strong as possible but it comes at a price of pain for a day to several.

Thanks again for the in depth look at what I was asking.

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#10

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Tony said....

First, I had to do a rip cut to square up my boards. I had trouble staying on the line and need to figure out how to fix that. Also, I had trouble with the rip trying to pull the saw out of my hand even with I narrowed up the angle of attack. I stopped with I start to feel my palm getting warm so I would get a blister - what am I doing wrong?

Second, my left hand is very week from my injury. I had trouble holding my try square and straight edge steady and so my lines were all over the place. Any tips?

_______

1. Staying on line.... Two thoughts: Bigger saw makes ripping easier, and kataba makes ripping easier. 210 ryoba is inherently a problem for distance rip or crosscut. There are two reasons: (a) the saw will have no relief as soon as it gets more than half the blade width into the cut--you can only steer it by going to a very shallow angle and extend kerf far ahead to try to guide the saw; (b) 210 has little beam strength, or set. This will make a difference the farther the saw goes into the cut. The saw will follow grain or otherwise find the path of least resistance, due to lack of beam strength and set, and as it wanders it becomes timber bound because it is sawing a curved line in the wood. As it binds, it's harder to pull and also resists the return. And again, you can't effectively steer away from this condition, because you have no relief once the saw is well into the cut.

2. Rip trying to pull saw out of hand; blister forming...

Sounds like it's getting timber bound, binding in the cut as described above. First off, use two hands on the saw. This will help your overall ergonomics, because it will spread the ripping load over many more muscles in your body--think first about letting your combined arm weight pull the saw through the cut, and secondly, lean in slightly with the downstroke to get more muscles and your weight into play. Try to use gravity and the large muscle groups on both sides of your body.

Second, it would help you a lot to have a 270mm kataba if you're gonna hand rip 4/4 material. Saw is tapered from teeth to back for relief, plus more set and more beam strength. There's a reason why people don't hand rip any more--it's tough duty, and unforgiving. In a close fight between saw and wood, saw will lose.

3. Holding square steady; lines all over.....First, for marking your rips, use your combination square. I'm gonna assume work has one straight side. Register your square on that side. You know that slot down the blade on one side? Arrange the square with that slot down on the work. The slot will now trap a pencil point. Using two hands, one holding pencil, one holding square, run the square and pencil down the board. Second, for marking crosscuts, maybe it would help you to pull the stock of the square against the work, rather than push it--or vice versa.l

Either way, as Tom said, it sounds like the overarching issue is one of work holding, and at an elevation that your back can support. You would benefit from a setup where the work is held still, and you can get both hands into play, without using one of them for work holding. If you're always straining somewhere, then hand tool woodworking may worsen your condition (I'm obviously guessing, but this needs to be said somewhere). Is it best for you to work standing up straight? Or sitting down? Would a back support vest help?

More talk on work holding and work posture might help here. I have some thoughts about a rudimentary bench, but don't know what you have now, or what your working posture needs to be.

Wiley

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#11

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

Texchappy

Wiley, thanks for your response. Let me dig into it...

Bigger saw makes ripping easier, and kataba makes ripping easier. ---- I had a 270mm/300mm rip kataba on my wish list. I was hoping the 210mm could handle 1/2" stock. Everything you said sounds exactly like what I was experiencing. I'm going to try coming from the other side of the board and go back to basics as it were and see if I can make it work.

In a close fight between saw and wood, saw will lose. -D'oh.

First, for marking your rips, use your combination square. --- don't have one, it's on the list.

I'm gonna assume work has one straight side (3 right now ;) ). I'll definitely take these tips to heart.

Either way, as Tom said, it sounds like the overarching issue is one of work holding, and at an elevation that your back can support. --- Yep, really realizing the limitations of what I was trying to do.

You would benefit from a setup where the work is held still, and you can get both hands into play, without using one of them for work holding. --- were you watching me (he says in his best paranoid voice).

Is it best for you to work standing up straight? Or sitting down? Would a back support vest help? --- I've got a back brace and I can stand (depending on the day) for up to about 15 minutes at a time. The only real no-go for me is bending more than about 10* (i.e. a little above knee level).

I have some thoughts about a rudimentary bench, but don't know what you have now, or what your working posture needs to be. ---- my current bench (gladiator garage not woodworking) is about 36 - 37 inches tall. I'm average height (5'9") and build.

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#12

David Barnett

Hand vs. band

David Barnett

Maybe not the remedy you might at first want to hear or expect on WC Hand Tools, but one you may eventually need to consider. Anyway, what you've said resonates with me. I get it. So what I say here is not to discourage; quite the opposite.

Eventually, after giving it a fair shot, you may find it is simply impractical to rip much lumber, not to mention resaw it by hand. Many have added bandsaws to their repertoire to overcome limitations, both physical and temporal. It's not cheating, you know. There's no such thing as cheating in woodworking unless you set personal criteria to define it that way, such as strict historical authenticity and adherence to a period where electrically powered tools did not yet exist. You might also decide that it's hand tools or nothing, simply on your sense and sensibility to hand tools vs. power tools. I'm not judging.

At any rate, there's a whole lot of room between the historical immersion or a pure hand tool aesthetic, between being heavily front-loaded to hand tool and hand powered sensibilities and a totally automated CNC home shop. It's all about what works for you.

Quite simply, one can gain much by using hand tools to do the bulk of the joinery and fitting and finishing while leaving the rough dimensioning to 'tailed' apprentices, that is, using power tools to accomplish what would've likely been left to other less-skilled (but not always) laborers. At some point, you'll have to decide these issues for yourself and make a separate peace with externally supplied power beyond The Body Electric. You'll have to draw the line at what you can physically do and where you wish to take your pastime. It's your hobby and your health, and compromises will have to be made.

It could very well be that you will find enough pleasure in accomplishable tasks that require considerable hand-guided finesse without pushing yourself beyond your physical limits. For example, the bigger I've become the smaller I've worked, which has actually led me to new creativites in many areas, both woodworking and otherwise.

Although I prefer not to concentrate on my and others' physical limitations, they're there; the 800-lb gorilla in the room. It's these that will ultimately parameterize what gets done, but woodworking is a huge, expansive hobby where limitations in one venue may steer you to venues where you'll hardly notice them, such as luthiery, small box and case making, hand-shaped utensils, and so on.

Like I said, my compromise is to work smaller and use others to do the larger, more physically demanding tasks, allowing me to do what I do best. Not everyone has this advantage, of course, but you'll find your balance point if you remain open to it.

Even for ripping, you may find it easier to use a standard Western ripping saw in a more vertical position where a board is held horizontally along and overhanging the length of the bench. Although it's best as a two-handed operation, I've seen it done with one. The strong hand powers the cut and the weaker helps guide it. Still not doable?

Well, there is the bandsaw, and a well-tuned bandsaw can be a relatively quiet, accurate, even elegant tool that can enable and empower you to do much, to free and save your hands for plenty of skilled hand-powered work. It's your call, of course, which is the beauty of woodworking as a hobby in the modern age. I personally wouldn't let my preferences and sensibilites for hand tools hold me back from what I love using and doing, but that's me. That's my separate peace.

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#13

Re: Hand vs. band

Texchappy

Thanks for the insight David. The hand tool thing isn't about period accuracy or any noble purpose; I just hate the noise. One good thing about hand work is that I can leave it and come back whenever I need to. I'm trying not to rip too much. I was planning on using the dimension of the board describe the size of the box but when I got it cut to length for the side I discovered that the 'top' of the board had a pretty good angle on it. It went from about 7" down to about 4.5" in 24".

I'm still learning what to expect from what I get from the lumber place. I asked for s4s and they said, 'sure we can plane it for you for $5.' now I know what that meant.

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#14

Re: Hand vs. band

Texchappy

Just to add, I'm not against a bandsaw or anything else but I'd prefer that to be a further down the road resort.

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#15

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#16

Re: That makes total sense to me...

Texchappy

One other factor with getting power tools for me - one last Army move. I believe that the movers find the things you want least to loose and break them first - like my balsa wood airplane models that they decided to put under books in a box.

That's part of the reason I haven't been looking at workbenches or workbench designs too much. I was hoping to get by with what I had. Think that's going to turn out to be the greatest obstacle/mistake.

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#17

Oh and one important thing I forgot

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Tony,

I'll reply further but am in hurry.

Do want to get one other main thing out though: What everyone does starting out, and what is guaranteed to cause a wandering saw, is to crowd the cut. To force the saw. Forcing the saw, over cutting, begs the saw to flex and get off line. Think about the saw sides in the kerf, how they're just barely touching.

Wiley

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#18

Re: Oh and one important thing I forgot

TomD

+1

When practicing I prefer not to use a line at all. just let the saw fall where it wants to cut, and keep it moving.

With Japanese saws, and any of the saws currently being made with low set, you want to pay particular attention to starting the saw. There comes a point after the saw is only somewhat into the board where the saw will be difficult to redirect. This can be after only a few strokes. What a lot of line watching can end up as is getting started until it appears that the saw is off line. The real action starts far earlier than that, if the saw isn't on line from the beginning, it will be a lot more difficult that it needs to be flighting back and forth over the line.

If you are in the army Tex, then perhaps you have had some experience with handguns, and know about focusing on the front sight only. I like to say that when shooting in self defence, the responder is likely to be blind, angry and surprise, when the shot goes off. The main point being that it isn't necessarily what one would expect. So where is the point of focus in sawing. I don't know and I have never really heard it discussed. What I do though is. 1) I watch the start up phase relative to getting the saw started, this is not aiming, but it is what it has to be as already discussed; 2) I transition to watching the gap between the board and the saw to be sure that the saw is cutting in a straight line, and the whole thing is flowing. I do not mean I am looking at how the saw is cutting down the line, I am looking to see that the saw plate is not binding; 3) I look at a point a bit lower than the cut, that is the point that I want to arrive at. There is quite a lot one can do to dissect that, but just looking down the road will get the car running straighter.

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#19

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer

Agreed on practice. Here are Mark Grable's exercise.


Mark Grable's sawing exercises

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#20

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#21

Put your legs into the saw stroke

wilbur

I don't have a great handle on long rip cuts with a Japanese saw. It's like the final frontier of sawing for me, and quite honestly I think that's why God invented bandsaws. :D

But there are some things that I've tried that seem to help, although I don't know if they are at all traditional.

First, sawing on low horses is the way to go, unless your bench is ridiculously low. I know you have problems with your back, so try different heights. Maybe one will be more suited to you than another. It will be a very quick and easy job to prototype a low horse just to find a good height for you, and then you can build a nicer one.

Second, use two hands on the saw and use your legs. I find that sawing on low horses using arms only gets old fast, probably because I am out of shape. :D Regardless of why, I find that if you bend your knees slightly as you put the saw into position for a cut, and stand up slightly as you make the cut, you get a lot more power without giving up control. My guess is that if I put my legs into sawing, it's about 75% legs and 25% arms.

Again, I need to stress that I have no idea if putting your legs into it is traditional practice or not. But once I started doing that it seemed so effortless and natural that I think there may be something to it. Similarly, pulling a Japanese plane is as much about the legs and torso as it is the arms.

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#22

Re: Front sight, front sight...

Texchappy

My problem is I'm a Chaplain. They won't let me carry any sort of weapon. I can bless or curse the saw depending on how it behaves but I can't shoot it ;)

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#23

Possible bench

Texchappy

I had noticed on lee valley and went back to find it. Is the Sjoberg compact bench worth the $319 to get it? I think I can find space in the basement for it and it's not too much that I'd be horribly upset if it didn't survive the next trip. I figure my kiddo (who used to watch this old house with rapt attention as an infant) can have it when I build a bench for myself in the future (or use it as a planing bench or something).

Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#24

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Ryoba Ripping Remedy Requested

#25

Re: If you have no other solution, ...

Texchappy

Not a big HF fan but I'm definitely open to other options. I'm wondering about the adage - it takes a bench to build a bench? I think I remember Roy Underhill had a portable bench I saw somewhere that didn't look too hard to build. Other options out there either in plans or smaller workbenches for sale?