New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Chest or cabinet?

Posts

Chest or cabinet?

#1

Chest or cabinet?

Ron in Kokomo

I am suddenly fascinated by the diversity in tool storage set-ups that I see in blogs or project photos. I know that the Schwarz has built a strong rationale for his tool chest. I have recently had my hands on it, and contrary to my first impression from just reading about it, I know that I could easily work from such a chest. I am now looking at Andy Rae's tool cabinet that was featured in Tolpin's book. I really do believe that I prefer the standing cabinet for several reasons. Yes, it will take quite a bit longer to build, and if I "pretty it up" with inlays, etc. it will cost a bit more. My overriding concerns are accessibility, and being able to tightly close the tools away from ambient dust when not in use. I donor believe there is a "right" answer. It is a pins or tails, western saw or pull saw thing. A matter of training and habit.. I have adequate storage now, but it is open, and has built over a twenty year period with no attention paid to harmonization. So I am toying with a fairly serious tool storage system. Anybody else wrestling with this? For me skills are not the issue. And really cost isn't a deal killer either. One thought that does concern me is that I am soon to be 67 and I have no body coming after me who will give a rat"s behind about infill planes, hundred and fifty year old plow planes or any of the rest of it. So do I build a wonderful tool cabinet that will be sold at a garage sale?

Talk to me about this.

Ron. Kokomo Galoot

Sent from Xfinity Mobile App

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#2

Re: Chest or cabinet?

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

Which one do you want to build?

They both have their place.

If you use both electric and hand tools, ie you have electric routers etc. The chest wont work well for holding those. if you don't use planes then perhaps a cabinet is better. I liked the cabinet that the wife of the luthier had in the toolbox book by jim tolpin. Then again andy rae's cabinet was next to a set of cubby holes for power tools, with lids/doors that could give serious dust control. There are plenty of good examples of cabinets that are more flexible and useful than the chest. The chest has what I consider to be a few limitations, ie the height for storing planes determines to some extent how tall the chest is. And that area would not be very good for storing a mix of hand and power tools. I have close to 10 routers.

Some live in drawers ala norm abrams workshop hutch. While some are in metal cabinets.

To me the chest is good for a woodworker who is not a tool collector. Or one who is reducing the set. The chest appears very limited in capacity.

I do like the idea of a chest. But I am troubled by the above.

As for the issue of what happens later, a little estate planning and documenting would help get it sold to the right people for the right price or at least better than firewood.

Good luck with your endeavours and please post pix either way!

Just my 2 cents worth.

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#3

I prefer a cabinet, too.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Bending over to fish through a box just doesn't work for me.

When I first got Tolpin's book, I remember drooling over Andy Rae's design for a long time. My own (built before I saw Tolpin's book) bears a very slight resemblance, only inasmuch as it's a wall cabinet with open storage. Not a display grade, it gets rearranged occasionally, depending on the addition of new tools and my constantly changing sense of organization. My shop is very small, space is at a premium and flexibility is king. The next storage addition is going to bear a strong resemblance to this Gerstner cabinet:


For my purposes, the strong points are that it can be easily moved and will hold a lot of the small stuff like measuring and layout tools, etc. It will also house small electric tools, like drills, sanders, etc.

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#4

Re: Racks

TomD




Except make them prettier...

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#5

Re: Chest or cabinet?

Curt Putnam

I, too, am struggling with the question. But I am rapidly coming to a conclusion(s). I will be 68 this year and just got my DP (handicap) plates today. Talk about a philosophical war in my head! Anyway, I can't bend and my mindset is not yet at the tool minimization point CS is. At the moment, I intend to convert a practice 36" w x 24" high x 24" deep blanket chest into a rolling tool chest. I will stand it on end if I can make the #8 fit otherwise it will be on its side. Regardless, it will be on casters with the top surface intended as a "finish" honing station (3 or 4 stones + strop.) Above that will be something akin to a wall cabinet but mounted to the rear of the chest. The sides of the chest should serve as a saw till.

That should hold the complement of tools that I use regularly right beside the bench and get all my planes off my parts bench top. Such a rolling chest might even be something my son will want after I depart. It should work well to hold all my planes (out of harm's way), all my chisels and measuring/marking tools as well as saws and other stuff. Think a mechanic's roll-away for the bottom and a traditional wall cab for the top on a rolling base. I'll bet it will work for me.

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#6

Re: Chest or cabinet?

Texchappy

This is timely for me as well. I have eyed doing the A tool chest in the future too. However, I also like the idea of having them more accessible since I can't bend either. I've read in a few places that many/most colonial/older wood shops had their tools out and readily available. What did they do with dust etc? Also, it seems there is some evidence in Odate's book that Japanese craftsman did this similarly.

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#7

Cabinets and Racks

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ron

I'd love to build a chest and fill it with 18C tools ... just because I think it would be a nice idea. I'd use the tools, as well ... however this is not how I would prefer to organise my shop.

I use cabinets to store most of the tools. I also use racks to hold the tools that I need all the time - marking and measuring, gauges and hammers. I use the wall for these, which keeps them close to my bench. The bonus it that there is a place for them that keeps them off the bench top. Plus pretty tools are an inspiration in themselves.



Recently I added a wall-based tool tray. I did not wish to have this attached to the bench as it would affect the use of clamps. This holds planes and chisels and saws ..




The cabinets are both above the bench and along the walls. If you look carefully you will see my bench dog keeping a close eye on proceedings :)


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#8

Re: Chest or cabinet?

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

Last night after I wrote my first reply to chest or cabinet, I went upstairs to get ready for bed and while playing with one of my cats I got a reminder message from my lower back that I am no longer young. WHich brings me back to the concept that I have been leaning away from a chest as I don't like the idea of bending over to hunt for tools in a potentially "randomly" organized chest.

But Why have a chest? It appears that our woodworking ancestors used them for tool organization and security. They also provide a means of dust protection. A chest would make it easier to move from job to job. Yet it would require the services of at least one additional person or perhaps 3 to move it to a form of conveyance. If one believes strongly in working the same way our ancestors worked consider that the master of a shop may not have used a chest but had his tools on racks. (I would like to see more proof of this theory though.) As it was his shop and he had not need to move to another shop. His tools would likely bear his distinctive brand/mark.

Why use a cabinet? It could be vertical. For those of us with un-young backs it would prevent a measure of painful reminders of times gone by. A cabinet could be organized for greater ease of access. But for those who do woodworking as a hobby and not a living , there is no longer the need to move from job to job.

In one of Jim Kingshotts videos he talks about his chest he made as young man and yet at the time of the making of the video he works in his own shop and most of his tools are scattered around the shop.

I would like to have my shop as orderly as his appears though.

Another 2 cents in the pile.

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#9

Re: Chest or cabinet?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I did spend a relatively short amount of time traveling as a journeyman from shop to shop and like almost all patternmakers I have a chest as well as a gerstner chest of drawers. The shops all provided a bench and the bench was outfitted with racks. On the first day at a new shop I would remove the necessary tools from my chest and place them in in the racks and then stow the chest under one of the benches. There would always be tools in the chest that I rarely used.

The most used form of storeage for me has always been the gerstner chest. I don't have the space for racks but if I did I would also have a few as they are an excelent way of keeping the most often used tools at hands reach and should be strongly considered as a companion storage solution to any formal type of chest or cabinet.

Robin

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#10

Re: Chest or cabinet?

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

As a gunsmith, a "sport" more closely related in current times to machinists, I too have a set of Gerstner uppers. They sit upon a roll-away made of walnut that I made. Drawers and body all made of wood. With full extension drawer slides. Interior customized for my needs as a gunsmith. I keep all my machinist type tools in the Gerstners.

I do find that the rollaway with the gerstner uppers works far better for me than the prospect of using a chest. Gunsmiths of old used a chest not unlike a cabinetmakers chest. Instead of a cabinetmakers set of molding planes a gunsmith would have tools for working metal including metal taps and dies.

I think of the roll-away and the gerstner uppers like a cabinet. It is on wheels however.

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#11

Heirloom furniture?

Bill Tindall

Clearly it depends on one's objectives but an alternative approach would be to spend the time making stuff with a higher probability of someone using for the next 100 years. I treasure all the furniture that has been left to me for at least the last 4 generations and my plan is to add to the stash with some I make.

Working on grandmothers china cabinet this weekend to pass on to daughter next time she visits.

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#12

Tools you use don't gather dust.


Re: Chest or cabinet?

#13

Re: Chest or cabinet?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Would you please post a pic of that chest on rollaway? That sounds just like I envision for myself.

Thanks.

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#14

Re: Chest or cabinet?

Ron in Kokomo

I green Brian

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#15

Re: Chest or cabinet?

Ron in Kokomo

I mean I agree

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#16

Re: Cabinets and Racks

Ron in Kokomo

Great looking shop Derek. Thanks for the input

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#17

Thank you all

Ron in Kokomo

Lots of great input. And again Derek lots of good ideas. I think I will have to build my cabinet in two halves ( top and bottom ) so I can get it out of my basement when I move. I will also build some trays and racks like Derek's. But specific project daily holding spots for tools of the day. Give me a few months then photos

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#18

Re: Tools you use don't gather dust.

Charles Stanford

You must not have a lathe in your shop or if you do, one heck of a nice dust collection arrangement.

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#19

Re: Chest or cabinet?

Charles Stanford

The chest is a journeyman phenomenon. The shop owner with an established business would have a tool cabinet for his kit, the employees would have chests.

In today's terms, a tool chest would go into the back of a pickup truck, if necessary, in the same orientation it would have had in the shop - sitting on its bottom fully packed. A standing cabinet would have to be unpacked and laid down flat.

I think an essential accompaniment to a tool chest is a bench with a well and integral tool rack. Tools used constantly belong in the well (ruler and gauges), a favorite chisel or two in the rack along with a 10" tenon saw. Put 'em up at the end of the day if you care to. If a journeyman was let go, he could pack and be out of the shop in fifteen minutes.

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#20

Re: Thank you all

Charles Stanford

Neither chest nor cabinet will work, really have any chance of holding all of your tools or even a good portion of them, if you suffer from the 21st century woodworking disease most of us have - multiple copies of essentially the same tool - two or three coping saws, couple or three tenon saws, several dovetails saws, more than one brace, multiples smoothers, jointers, and jacks - tools where the difference is basically esoteric though we may have convinced ourself that it's not.

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#21

You've got that right.


Re: Chest or cabinet?

#22

Re: Chest or cabinet?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Charles

That is my understanding as well.

I really don't get the chest thing. Then again, I really do not have the space for one, my tools would not fit (although I do not have any duplicates like you :) ), and I am not strong enough to lift it without help. Actually, the entire family - if I could persuade them - would not be capable of lifting a filled chest.

The guys who used chests must have been very strong! ..... on the other hand, chest are good .... :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#23

Re: Chest or cabinet?

Charles

My sense is that the average chest from the 18th century, when full, was certainly heavy but not nearly as heavy as some folks' 'modern' chests featured in the woodworking press over the last fifteen or twenty years.

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#24

Re: Chest or cabinet?

TomD

Main point is that they didn't have dusty power tools. I have some crazy number of stationary tools in my shop. Say 30, about fifty fifty metal and wood. I just don't use the dusty ones. For 10 years I didn't have a table saw at all. But I found it so useful when it was my only tool at shop 2, that I did get one. However it only gets used out of doors. Planer is dusty, but easy to extract, jointer and bandsaw are medium easy to extract but produce little dust. Routers pretty much only get used outside. Wood turning, an early love of mine is the one casualty. I have to do a bunch soon, but I just can't do bowls on a regular basis in the shop. Metal working tools are a real problem they are covered with oil, so any dust is a bad deal.

Re: Chest or cabinet?

#25

Re: I knew an old lady who swallowed a fly

TomD

+1 Charles.

I have several cultures worth of tools. Mostly either japanese, or English pattern, though I have a half kit of German. For the most part though, my racks hold just the one set of tools. That is why I like somewhat flexible racks so that better tools can enter or leave as they arrive.

The other aspect, more admirable if one likes, is that most of us are not limited to one craft. A shop that only did molding would be one thing. A long term plan of mine is to do moldings but first to do the molding planes. I also make the irons, and I made the forge the irons where HTd on. And I made the burner for the forge, etc... Plus I make guitars, bikes, large boats, etc... This week I made a bridge crane to lit my leather sewing machine onto the second floor, and I will need to mill specialty feet for it. I need to make a new version of the folk song "I knew an old lady who swallowed a fly", except about the endless connections of things I make.

So Chris has his thirty tools, but that only works if you make a startlingly limited range of things. I can go away for a few months every year, and take less than thirty tools with me, and that is fun too.