Re: use of a vise
roger lance
Bill....there is a full moon!!....biggest of the year!....just don't spill any of that coffee/brandy on that bench
.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: use of a vise
roger lance
Bill....there is a full moon!!....biggest of the year!....just don't spill any of that coffee/brandy on that bench
.
Re: use of a vise
Pam Niedermayer
I'll never forget the night 30 years ago we moved from DC to Boston, via rte 95. I was asleep, Jack driving east just south of Baltimore. I woke all of a sudden to this huge red sphere, scared the dickens out of me, terrifying. And then there was the time in Hiawatha Park on Lake Superior, sleeping on the beach when these pulsing lights really scared me. Now I sleep with my glasses on. 
Pam
this may be the silliest thread ever.....
Bill Tindall
Here is Mr. McKay actually making something(first post of someone making something in months) and from the number of drawer parts it must be something substantial. I am unconcerned how he, or anyone else, holds the parts unless he/they has developed some novel and beneficial way that others might consider adapting. Nor would I suffer a critique of how I hold parts or care how they were held in 1720 unless I was trying to be period correct. How one fixes stuff to a bench depends strongly on the details of the bench construction.
There is no one on this Forum that makes enough stuff to be concerned with whether it takes 8 or 12 seconds to fix the drawer side to the bench, saw horse, what ever. Anybody making something that has that many drawers, and of the apparent quality of construction, has probably made enough stuff that they have settled on a successful method. There is likely no significant room for improvement.
I submit that the conversation should be about what is being made, not some irrelevant detail of how. I am curious what it is to be. What is the design, joinery, wood, finish or even who it is for and where the idea came from-the important stuff.
They don't, which is why...
David Barnett
... for such tasks, sometimes a screw or that which works similarly is a sound choice. Point is, I still believe the joiner's bench to be superior and more versatile, and simple alternatives exist when not using a vise to allow me to choose, like Tom, not to drive screws into my maple top. If someone tells me that a screw is more versatile than a vise, should supplant my vise, then I'm going to think they're full of beans.
By the way, I've also fixtured thin and oddly-shaped challenging wood with pitch, glue, shellac, wax and I don't even recall what else. I'm not against improvised holding methods and devices when they're needed. But for holding darned near everything but thin stock, there's nothing as versatile as vises and holdfasts, in my opinion (we really shouldn't have to say in my opinion). Again, others are welcome to disagree, but I'm not going to respect that, just tolerate it.
The tread is now complete....
roger lance
Bill has entered with his usual unique way of summarizing the follies of the masses. However, I do agree that there should be more display of things being made....but people discuss what they want to discuss....be it vises or cap iron position....and generally without it being referred to as being silly. Live and let live....vows of tolerance....diversity....acceptance....inclusion....its a big tent....can't we all get along?? No, but it is an election year.
.
not quite complete.
McKay
My original problem was, how do you plow a board w/o the use of a vise? If I try to plow a bottom groove with a stop, then the thing walks all over the bench. I am REALLY sorry that this post went wrong. I have worked professionally for 33 years, (albeit with power tools for 25 of those years.). I just had a question, that is all.
How true...
John in NM
One of those internet subjects....
Isn't it funny how worked up we all get over how other people do things 
If some don't care for screws, that's fine with me, I tend to use them or whatever else is needed to get the job done, including a vise.
I make nice little knurled threaded inserts (8-36, can't buy them), perhaps I should make a bunch of 1/4-20 in brass for those who would like to try using a screw stop without looking like they're somehow "faking" it. Could counter bore the top face so the screw head could sit flush with the top 
Fun, though.
David Barnett
"(first post of someone making something in months)"
You've mentioned a couple times lately and more so previously that people here don't make things, or if they do, don't post them. I'd fall into the latter category although the number of things I've made in the last few years has fallen off sharply.
Problem is, I don't use hand tools primarily to get where I'm going, these days, caring less about process than product. What's more, I tend not to make things out of wood alone or even primarily wood, at least not in furniture-sized pieces.
I mean, I've built elegant speaker cabinets in MDF covered in veneer and then parchment, and an audio amplifier and separate power supply in stacked plywood and aluminum (which I did post but can't find in the archives). Nothing for show and tell here and no exposed wood to show on the other side. Still, I do use and enjoy my planes, chisels, rasps and files, a couple small saws and so on.
The mostly wood things I do make with hand and power tools I don't want others to copy (we've had this conversation before). The internet can be brutal that way. Some of my stuff is amazing, fabulous even, but you'll just have to take my word for it. Or not.
I have posted shop furniture, benches, and so on in the past, and while these were made mostly with power tools, they were to be used in the service of hand tools, so seemed not out of place.
"I submit that the conversation should be about what is being made, not some irrelevant detail of how."
I get your point, but one person's irrelevant... you know how it works.
"What is the design, joinery, wood, finish or even who it is for and where the idea came from-the important stuff."
Substance? I'd agree, that would make sense, and this coming from one of the least substantial posters. Mea culpa.
If you show me yours, I'm still not going to show you mine, though.
Re: Fun, though.
eliot d
Certainly would like to see some of your amazing and fabulous work. Maybe just one of them. I'm not being facetious.
sorry......
Bill Tindall
I didn't understand that you were asking a question in the original post. It seemed you had a vice solution and were being second guessed by critics of other thinking.
But the question remains, what are you making?
Re: They don't, which is why...
Pam Niedermayer
I responded to the original message, to wit:
On another blog site, the question was posed as to the necessity of a vice. Personally, I could not do without them. The crochet(sp?) is ok, but I find my time better spent using my dogs and end vise. Because of my back, I dovetail with a Moxon vise. (it raises it to the correct height). One respondent spoke of hammering in a nail as a stop. This makes me shudder. A planing stop would work, but I do not want any more holes in my bench. What do the wizards here think?
Pam
Re: this may be the silliest thread ever.....
Pam Niedermayer
Again, here is the original post:
On another blog site, the question was posed as to the necessity of a vice. Personally, I could not do without them. The crochet(sp?) is ok, but I find my time better spent using my dogs and end vise. Because of my back, I dovetail with a Moxon vise. (it raises it to the correct height). One respondent spoke of hammering in a nail as a stop. This makes me shudder. A planing stop would work, but I do not want any more holes in my bench. What do the wizards here think?
Steve asked about how we do things, Bill. Now I could have gone into a long diatribe about the stuff I'm making, but that would have been non-responsive.
And I agree with David, I almost never post stuff I'm working on or have made. It's intentional.
Pam
Work...
John in NM
For me recent work has been mostly gunstocks and grips, a combination of machine work and hand work. I post pictures on a gun forum but not here, some people just don't like to see them. Also you folks could probably give me some serious competition, which has been absent since I've been doing it 
Re: Work...
Bruce, a MN Galoot
That one set of grips you did post looked pretty darn spiffy.
I start on my next project this week, but it will be nearly entirely machine tool work. Well, maybe the paint will count for some hand work. That and fitting joints, which is always hand work. I'll post it here, but only if people promise not to complain that it's not a hand tool project.
Yes, but...
David Barnett
...you went further than that. 
Re: use of a vise
john sayles
Now the truth is revealed - Ms. Niedermayers attitude is the result of repeated alien abductions.
Alien abductions?
Pam Niedermayer
Nah, just a massive red moon rising over the harbor and the northern lights.
Pam
Perhaps too many years of too much Zappa!
david weaver
Strange lights in the sky!
Or, borrowing from one of his favorite staff guitarists (steve vai), light without heat. ....the first one was from steve vai, too, I guess.
The new Occupy Wall Street hero? Why not?
I have found...
Bob Hackett
That a red moon ( known as a "chapped ass" up here) brings on both a decline in attitude and an increased amount of ducking and running by my (former ) friends for me as well.
The good news is that Gold Bond makes a very effective lotion for that. 
No such thing
Bob Hackett
As "too much Zappa" unless you`re speaking in reference to the mixing board and you`re either the engineer or the producer. 
Re: use of a vise
Stephen Shepherd
Make a board with a rebate/rabbit the thickness of your drawer sides, but with a bit of a taper. Then turn it upside down and hold it fast to your bench with a holdfast.
Simply jamb your pieces under the rebate and against a dog in one of your existing holes. The only time you need to move the board is for different widths of drawer sides, so the fence of the plow plane is over the edge of the bench.
Stephen
If you absolutely must get screwed
Bob Hackett
at least make it a brass screw.
If you miscalculate distance to target your sole (and perhaps your iron) will thank you for it. 
Re: Perhaps too many years of too much Zappa!
TomD
You can't have too much Zappa, or at least not so far.