OK, thanks.
Two Stone Sharpening....
Posts
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#27
Balsa and beyond
David Barnett
"We are way into esoteric land now!"
I've used wax laps for final polish on certain softer minerals (sphene, fluorites, calcites) that are challenging to facet. The wax gives a perfect scratch-free polish but can round the edges of facets if not properly performed. Of course, the wax laps I used were round and spun at very low rpm, but I should think that an unpowered rectangular wax lap should work nicely for tool steel edges -- better than balsa I'd think.
For gem work, diamond or tin, chromium, cerium oxides work nicely. I've used a lot of round 3M diamond film laps, both regular and imperial, but for steel, when I go smaller than 1μ, I prefer friable diamond paste in 60,000 or 100,000 mesh, nominally .5μ and .25μ. I've tried .1μ (200,000 mesh) film on steel but prefer spray diamond on a ceramic lap better than the polyester film backing. Frankly, I've never found that going smaller than .5μ made a whole lot of difference in the resulting cut, but it does look better under magnification.
It is easy to slice the films if you're not careful or too aggressive. Also, I'm not a big fan of PSA backed films.
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#28Re: Balsa and beyond
david weaver
0.5 - i agree, and I don't use the chromium oxide powder on the tools - it's not necessary for anything that I've ever done in the shop. But it's about the stopping point I go for razors, too - there must be something about the shape of the chromium oxide that makes it nicer for razors.
My horsehide strop will probably impart enough wear on an edge to remove any difference between 0.5 chromium oxide and diamonds a lot smaller than 100,000 mesh, and I know better than to shave straight off a diamond edge with no stropping - chromium oxide without stropping is plenty harsh enough.
This stuff never goes into my shop because it's critical that the balsa lap stays clean of anything other than metal particles from its own use. I think that itself should illustrate why chasing after that kind of edge in the shop is esoteric - it takes too much effort and doesn't really return anything practical.
But I am curious enough about the 0.1 film that I can pull the razor on it with light pressure the first try or two to avoid the chance of cutting it. I found 0.3 micron film to be lacking compared to the chromium oxide on balsa, despite the smaller size also. It makes great tool edges, though, but it requires care in use, and i don't so much like that in tools.
I really like the 1 micron stones. It's unusual that I use anything but them and a medium stone, unless I have a novelty stone out.
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#29Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
david charlesworth
Derek,
I grind at low angle (23 degrees), get wire edge with King 800 or Sigma 1,000 (at say 30 or 33 degrees), shorten projection by approx 2mm, and polish tip of honed bevel with about 4 pull strokes on King 10,000 or Shapton 15,000 (at 32 or 35 degrees).
At no point will I need a medium stone to raise a wire edge.
The system is quick, and I probably regrind about every 7 to 10 sharpenings.
Best wishes,
David Charleswsorth
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#30Just how do I become one of those guys....
roger lance
that tool makers/retailers send tools to try....for free....and often??? Do I have to become some kind of recognized world class expert or something???
. Well, like everything else there is no "perfect" set of stones. The Sigma II's that LV sells might work....they have to be soaked....and they dish quick....but they cut fast and handle a wide range of metal with A2 being no problem....and if they dish quick, they must be easy to flatten. LV has the Sigma II's in 1000, 3000, & 10000 stones....and input on these choices?? Stu has the 1200 & 6000.
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#31I'd think..
david weaver
...a novice edge chaser probably couldn't get a better level of sharpness from stones for a better price than the 3 stone + atoma set that stu has.
While I'm a fan of the shapton pros, they haven't exactly innovated since they released them, and they appear to want to push the glasstones, which makes no sense to me at all from a buyer's standpoint.
What else is there then? None of the stones out there are perfect and cheap, and good sharpening certainly could be done with very little money, but if I had no stones ......
.....who am I kidding. I'd beg someone out of their shapton pros when they moved on to stus stones.
But everyone else would probably prefer the set that stu has.
The edge chasers on the razor side have left stones as a prefinish step a long time ago, though, and though there are many ways to spend a lot of money for the best natural finish stones, powder on balsa will better them all. But it is over the top for tools and a waste of time.
Why do we talk about all of this sharpening stuff over and over!!!
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#32Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
eliot d
How to respond to that? But i see what you mean. I often tell people that my world is getting smaller and smaller -- going down to my shop and spending hours sharpening a chisel or whatever. I mean I used to do serious mathematics, ran a company, consulted for the US Navy, all kinds of stuff. Now I sit here sharpening these $*&*#@* chisels! I guess it just pleases me.;that's about it. I like hanging out on this site; I can't keep up, but I like it anyhow. You're right: common sense and logic has nothing to do with it.
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#33Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
Brian Greene
Why do you need to change?
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#34Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
eliot d
How do you prepare the balsa? Do you plane it flat? I suppose you don't let any kind of sandpaper near it. Am I right?
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#35Re: Just how do I become one of those guys....
Brian Greene
The Sigmas do not dish quickly.
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#36to answer the question.....
Bill Tindall
"Why do we talk about all of this sharpening stuff over and over!!!"
Because "we" aren't busy making stuff. What I see is that people highly motivated to make stuff quickly settle on something that is "good enough" and it is nearly impossible to get them to even consider anything else for fear it will slow them down from making more stuff.
That said, the discussions from those that have tried and continue to try lots of stuff are valuable to those yet undecided. The risk is that the undecided become gridlocked with indecision, or worse, fret that it is a $300 set of stones that stand in the way of their being able to make stuff. I would bet that a skilled cabinet maker could make a drawer as good as any of us with a hack saw to saw the dovetails, a Stanley butt chisel, a #5 plane and a garage sale Norton India stone.
How long has it been since somebody posted a piece of furniture on this Forum? How many have never posted a picture of furniture on this Forum?
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#37Re: to answer the question.....
david weaver
I haven't posted a picture of any furniture on this forum...I think. At least not in years.
I do have a couple of basic furniture pieces in progress by wife demands. I just can hardly get interested in making it at all. I'd rather make tools. Much rather.
I'm pretty sure I could cut a very tight set of dovetails with a well tensioned hacksaw, and if time counted on sharpening, I'd use a trizact belt and a round disc of leather with buffing compound on it. I already use those on curved irons - very fast and effective.
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#38Re: to answer the question.....
roger lance
Bill....does your participation here indicate that you are not making stuff??
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#39Re: Just how do I become one of those guys....
roger lance
Brian....the LV catalog describes these stones in the following way, "while these stones wear at a more rapid rate than those with stronger bonds....".....common sense would lead one to believe that they would "dish" quickly....but my conclusion must have been in error.
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#40Re: Just how do I become one of those guys....
david weaver
Dishing quickly is a relative term. Compared to a lot of other stones, they dish quickly, especially if they are very wet. At least the 3000 does.
No stone on the market that I've dishes so quickly that they can't be used effectively, though.
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#41Re: Just how do I become one of those guys....
Archie
There's another thread addressing this issue. Refer to it. But in short...
I've bought and love Stu's 1/6/13 set of the Sigma Powers (not SelectII's). So far, no regrets. The II's are faster but dish more. The basic ceramics dish less, wear slower, and cut O1 & A2 equally well. I recently bought the Sigma 1200 and am currently testing it out. Apparently, above 3k, the Sig power and II's are pretty much equal. Below--well, there's no magic bullet.
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#42Re: Just how do I become one of those guys....
Brian Greene
read the rest of the sentence: "...this is offset by the extremely fast cutting action, resulting in reduced stone wear..."
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#43Re: Just how do I become one of those guys....
David Weaver
the word "partially" needs to be in there somewhere.
Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
#44Re: I would agree.



