New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Two Stone Sharpening....

Posts

Two Stone Sharpening....

#1

Two Stone Sharpening....

roger lance

Derek, David, & Stu et al....based on our recent talk of Shaptons and Sigmas, how does the following two stones look for a sharpening system??:

1) Sigma Power ceramic 1200 (Select II) since the Shapton Pro 1000 has become hard to find in the USA. This stone will easily handle O1 and A2 and other more exotic metals that I might acquire in the future.

2) Shapton Pro 15000 (cream stone) - this stone is sometimes referred to as a 12000 but always cream color (yellow).

I still have a King 6000 for an intermediate stone if needed....and I'm open to suggestions of any great intermediate stone....I'm just not aware of one that has emerged from the pack.

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#2

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

david charlesworth

Roger,

Going from King 800 to King 10,000 works very well for me. I raise about 2 degrees when going to the polishing stone.

I also go from K 800 to Shapton pro 15,000 sometimes, and it works fine with the 2 degree angle change.

The work done on the polishing stone is minimal, maybe four pull strokes.

This is all being done with an Eclipse type guide and a low, 23 degree grind.

With my method, intermediate stones are required for new tool, back preparation, only.

Best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#3

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

david weaver

It would work fine.

It doesn't really matter what the stones are, as long as the first stone is somewhere in the neighborhood of 800-1200 grit and the finish stone is somewhere around a micron.

if I use the hollow for reference, i tend toward the shapton because it's a bit more coarse than the sigma power finish stone (which generally means a tiny bit faster). If you're using a jig, it makes no difference how fine the finish stone is because you can reduce the projection from the jig a tiny amount and cut a good microbevel as David Charlesworth does.

I haven't yet found a branded finish stone that's in the 1 micron range that doesn't do a good job, so don't get too swept up in what the final stone is. Hard is nice for the first stone, i think, because you'll find yourself wanting to use it freehand at some point, and at the same time wanting to avoid gouging the stone with small tools that require the freehand sharpening (small knives, gouges, etc).

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#4

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

Archie

Good counsel.... I like intermediate steps, but that's merely a preference.With that said, my Sigma Power 6k followed by simple leather strop does everything but endgrain. For end grain, I move up to my Sig 13k--which leaves a fabulous edge. The Sigma 1200 is harder and better than the 1000--but not that much different. My experience with the 1k is far more extensive; I'm just breaking in and testing the 1200. But, it already shows some improvement--especially in the area of hard for free-handing. If hollow grinding, any quality stone over 6k should give you a great finish; if not HG, then go for Stu's three stone special and swap the 1200 for the 1000. The 1.2/6/13000 should be unbeatable in both price and performance; and, I say that with several Choseras that I love to use. The Sigma products are fantastic bang for the buck!!!! The Choseras are harder, make more slurry (naturally), work a tad more quickly (magnesia base I suppose), and, for me, yield slighty sharper edges (for the same time). Had I not bought used or clearance, I would never have tried them. So, at the level functional use, my Sigmas are trouble free, worry free, much CHEAPER, and produce excellent results--especially at 6k and 13k. YMMV

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#5

The choseras

david weaver

I probably would not buy the choseras again, either, but they sure are nice.

I figured finding a 10k unused for around $200 was worth a shot, and it is a lovely lovely stone, but it does benefit a lot from a short soak, and I'm never thinking that far ahead.

The 3k is bone hard, I like that. But I don't use a 3k stone that much.

Archie - do you know if the besters soak indefinitely? If you don't know, I'll find out. I have two that are almost the same grit, and I can waste one if it comes to that.

(It's always easier-at least for me - to say I wouldn't buy something again after I already bought it. but if I'd never tried it, I probably would buy it again, anyway :\ )

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#6

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

roger lance

Archie....is the 1200 Select II proving to be dish resistant as advertised??

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#7

Re: The choseras

Brian Greene

I would prefer the bester 700 over a king 800 for A2 steel.

My Besters at home and at work have been in water most of the time for over a year without issue.

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#8

Re: The choseras

Archie

Yep, the Bester 1200 continuously soaks and works just fine.

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#9

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

Archie

Don't know just yet; I haven't spent enough time on it. I'll respond back at a later date.

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#10

Re: The choseras

roger lance

Brian....I believe you work for LV....any chance they will be selling the Sigma Select II 1200??

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#11

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

eliot d

No one mentions Nortons. Are these others really superior?

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#12

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

Brian Greene

The Bester-Imanishi stones blow the Nortons out of the water.

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#13

Re: The choseras

Brian Greene

I expect you meant 12,000, not 1200. We already sell 1000, 3000 and 10,000. I'm not aware of plans to add to the line more than we have. I prefer the Bester-Imanishis but it's possible I haven't given the Sigmas a fair shot.

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#14

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek, David, & Stu et al....based on our recent talk of Shaptons and Sigmas, how does the following two stones look for a sharpening system??:

1) Sigma Power ceramic 1200 (Select II) since the Shapton Pro 1000 has become hard to find in the USA. This stone will easily handle O1 and A2 and other more exotic metals that I might acquire in the future.

2) Shapton Pro 15000 (cream stone) - this stone is sometimes referred to as a 12000 but always cream color (yellow).

I still have a King 6000 for an intermediate stone if needed....and I'm open to suggestions of any great intermediate stone....I'm just not aware of one that has emerged from the pack.

Hi Roger

Both David and Stu are far more knowledgable in this area, but I will give you the benefit of my experience to date.

As I understand, the Select II 1200 will replace the 1000. I have the 1200. Stu sent this to me to test out. I had no need at the time of another 1000-range stone as I was happy with the Pro Shapton 1000. I am still happy with the Shapton (as it cuts well), but the Select II 1200 is better overall. The Sigma has to be the hardest stone I have ever used! Flattening it on a extra coarse diamond stone took three times as long (at least!) as the Shapton 1000. It holds its flatness very well, as one might expect.

Both the Shapton and the Sigma will raised a wire edge very quickly on the toughest steel you can throw at it (yesterday I threw a 10V chisel at it, and it did not blink).

The Pro Shapton 12000 is a good stone for O1 but only just gets by on A2. The Sigma II is in another class altogether. The reason I was after Sigmas was to work more efficiently on the more abrasion-resistant steels, such as M2 (HSS), M4, and other PM steels. The Shapton was really not getting these sharp at this level, even with the Pro 5000 as an intermediate grit (I think that this stone is a dog on anything other than O1).

Yesterday I sharpened a hard A2 smoother blade from LV (which was always a struggle on the Shaptons, so had put it aside). This was from the woodie range, not the BU range of blades. The Sigmas (1200/6000/10000 or 13000 - the 1200/13000 is a new-to-the-market double stone that Stu sent me. I purchased the 6000/10000 separates) handled this blade in a way that I could not believe possible. It was effortless, and the result was a really sharp blade that performed at the highest level (I was smoothing some interlocked Jacaranda).

I also had the opportunity to hone 3V, M4, and 10V chisels. The 3V and M4 were like sharpening A2 on the Shaptons. Absolutely hair-popping sharp in a couple of minutes. Keep in mind that I am running through the full compliment of Sigmas at this stage, even though they are hollow ground, rather than reducing the number - still getting to know the stones. My recall is trying the same on the Pro Shaptons was never this good. While the 1000 was able to create a wire edge in a couple of strokes, the 5000 and 12000 did not improve the edge much after that.

I have given away my King stones below the 8000 Gold. They really bring very little, if anything, to the table. They dish rapidly - which is deliberate since they need to expose fresh grit all the time. While I do not get that anal about flatness when freehanding the bevels, I certainly am when honing the back of blades. Honing a microbevel on the back of the bevel because the stone is hollowed ... and then having to lap the blade flat again ... well that is more work than I want. I am not interested in King stones.

The downside to the Sigma II is that they all need a little soaking. Actually I am not sure that this is really a downside since, according to Stu, the Shaptons also benefit from soaking, even if it is just a few minutes. The thing about a sintered Sigma versus other stones is that they are unaffected by water. Consequently, you can leave them lying in a shallow Tupperware container (as I am) without danger of damaging them. So no time is lost to soaking.

Just a comment on 2-stone systems. I think it is a mistake to aim for this. Sure, you can hone a microbevel on most steels using just two stones. However you will need a third stone as the microbevel gets larger, and indeed there are some bevels that benefit from being left flat. It takes less time to hone a hard steel using an intermediary grit since you are not spending extra - unnecessary - time on a higher grit to do the work of a lower grit. Get a third stone.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#15

Re: The two stone thing.

david weaver

OK, I guess nothing is really clear without a video, which I am not set up to make.

Here's my thought on the two stone thing (as a hollow grinder also, which can refresh an edge any time).

If the steel that you're using is compliant, you can side sharpen with the medium and fine stone without any issues. Just walk to the grinder once every few hard honings (if the edge is touched up often, it'll be more than 3).

If it's not compliant - if you have an iron that is hard and large, or a chisel for that matter, the idea is to lift the edge only a tiny amount, with the thought that you would only remove as much metal as you would otherwise do if you honed the reference flats (for lack of a better term) down. If it seems hard to hold an angle like this, then the strokes can be shortened, all the way down to working on a spot a half inch long or whatever. Actually, short strokes work better, anyway, because you don't remove more metal than you need to.

By only running a tiny amount off with the polishing stone, you can still easily raise a wire edge on the reference flats later, but you have no compromise in sharpness.

It is much faster to do this than it is to run through a progression of stones, and you don't lose the geometry of the edge (like you would if you chased a measurably steeper microbevel wider and wider). It also allows the use of weaker polishing stones. I can get a fantastic edge with a purple llyn melynllyn (a novelty stone of sorts) which cuts so slowly with oil that it wouldn't be usable like a modern stone on anything but razors.

It does take a little bit of touch to learn how little you can remove to get a good uniform edge without affecting geometry, but not much. If someone did it for a couple of days in the shop, they'd have the method down.

It sounds like you know more about the new stones than me, Derek. Of the sigmas, all I have is the 13k and a SPII 3k that I use as an aoto. It's like a turbocharged aoto, and soft like one without a greasy mud that comes from the blue tanba aotos.

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#16

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

david weaver

The nortons are good stones (except the 220, which is horrible), but they are a bit more coarse at their ratings than the ceramic stones that have arrived in the last few years, and softer. It makes sense that they were touted as fast cutting in the FWW test because of that extra coarseness vs. the chosera, shapton and SP stones.

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#17

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

eliot d

I guess I better get some! I looked up Imanishi Bester stones, and there are numerous grits.

Given that I already have Nortons in 200, 1000, 4000 and 8000 -- and Spyercos 'fine' and 'ultra fine', which grits of the Imanishi Bester would you recommend? Could I , for example, use the Nortons up to ,say, 1000 and then finish with one of these at 8000 ( or some other combination) What would you recommend?

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#18

A little clarification

Pam Niedermayer

Derek, you seem to say that Shaptons are both good and bad for A2 edges. It just can't be both, so would you mind clarifying this for me?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#19

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

david weaver

the ultrafine sypderco puts on a better polish than the norton, right?

I don't think you have any need to upgrade stones if you already have nortons.

I might think about getting modern ceramics over nortons if I didn't have stones already, but were I in your shoes, I would stick with the nortons and sypdercos, and if you want a finer finish, then perhaps you might want to try green chromium oxide on MDF. It's almost free to use (if you have any scraps of MDF around), and it will cut anything (including HSS) and leave a finer edge than any stone except for a shapton 30,000, and perhaps it's finer than that, too.

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#20

Re: A little clarification

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

I re-read my post and realised that it must confuse a little.

Where I wrote "The 3V and M4 were like sharpening A2 on the Shaptons", should read ".... O1 ....".

Then it should make sense. :\

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#21

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

eliot d

Yes, the ultra fine Spyderco does put a better polish than the Nortons. (But I read here somewhere that the polish look is not necessarily a sharper edge.) Anyway, I guess I'll take your advice and stick to what I have and finish with the green stuff on MDF. But here's another question: if the Nortons, or something similar and inexpensive + green compound is that good with the green compound costing next to nothing, why is everyone waxing poetic about all these expensive stones?

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#22

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

and if you want a finer finish, then perhaps you might want to try green chromium oxide on MDF.

Actually, if you want a finer edge .... the finest edge! ... treat yourself to the diamond film that LV is selling. It is cheap enough. Use the 0.5 and 0.1 micron films after your stones. You only need a couple of swipes. It is amazing.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#23

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

roger lance

Eliot....common sense has no place in these discussions. :D .

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#24

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

david weaver

Why the excitement about the stones? I guess because it's gotten away from just having a sharp edge to wanting to feel nice about how we get there and removing metal at nascar pace even with the finest grits. And when we have money burning a hole in our pockets, all of us like to try things. If you're thinking about spending $300 and I tell you to spend $10 for chromium oxide because you already have a good basic system, you're going to feel like you haven't executed a move that's going to yield the results you want.

I can tell from shaving that the finest stuff I've come across that leaves a smooth comfortable edge is 0.5 micron chromium oxide powder (which is basically a pure pigment). There are diamond grits that are smaller, but on MDF, they are functionally no sharper. On a harder surface, they are sharper, but on your last stone, hardness doesn't have to be there, and it may be a hindrance if you use too much pressure.

As far as polish goes, if you have good eyes and you do truly have a uniform polish all the way to the edge, and at the edge, the edge itself will be sharper than an unpolished edges, though at grits less fine than the finest grits, there is some room for discussion because particles rolling around leave a matte finish without uniform scratches. When you are talking about the 1 micron finish level, a uniform bright polish will definitely be sharper after stropping.

In all of the past discussion about absolutely sharpness, where natural japanese stones have mystery powers or whatever, in reality most of them are more coarse than something like a sigma power 13k, and considerably so. It only takes shaving with a razor sharpened on one of each, and examining the scratches to see coarse scratches from relatively inexpensive natural stones (under $300), as coarse as, say, a 4000 stone with some finer scratches mixed in.

For the finest natural stones, like antique japanese barber hones and new ozuku stones that are graded for razors, they will impart a bright polish and be more comfortable to shave with than an artificial stone. A matte edge just will not be as sharp no matter what you read on the internet, but because the natural stones don't cut as fast or as deep as synthetic stones, anything of the razor grit size is incredibly slow on a woodworking tool.

There is a famous professional razor sharpener on one of the razor sites that said something along the lines of having never seen a hone (natural or otherwise) that isn't improved upon on a razor edge by following the treatement with chromium oxide.

I wouldn't be surprised if the edge off of an ultrafine spyderco that's been worn in is at least as fine as anything we're talking about in terms of synthetics. It imparts a very bright polish.

The best test you can do for yourself in your own ship is to take a test piece of nice planing wood and see how thin you can plane it with different sharpening mediums. With something like the shapton 15k or the SP 13k and no strop, you should be able to get shavings off of something that planes nicely in the .0002-.0003 range. If you're at that point with the sypderco, you really have nothing to gain, and I'm sure a lot of people working wood never approach a shaving like that in day to day work because you just don't need to go that far to get a bright surface with no tearout.

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

#25

Re: Two Stone Sharpening....

david weaver

I have a piece for razors, but I haven't affixed it yet. My concern against a coarser chromium oxide (not LV's, but a pure pigment that is a softer cutting comfortable edge making version) is that I will need to affix the diamond to something fairly hard to protect it from getting sliced by anything.

The best edge I've gotten bar none has been chromium oxide on balsa, because the balsa is hard enough to keep geometry in place, but it does not force the CrOxide deep into the razors edge like an abrasive on a hard surface does. I know that 0.25 is regarded as giving an edge that is actually improved by properly used chromium oxide 0.5 micron on balsa or hard leather (which is true in my experience, a tube of diamond graded 0.1-0.25 does not make an edge as nice). I'm assuming that the diamonds if they are on a hard surface will actually also do the same thing, dig just as deep as the chromium oxide.

On a hard surface, it would be no contest, though, the diamonds would be finer.

I have some fairly expensive razor hones from europe and japan, including an antique asagi stone that came from a barber shop (that is incredibly fine, to the point that it's hard to tell if it's cutting at all), but they are all a full notch away from chromium oxide on balsa, which is disappointing to my wallet!

We are way into esoteric land now!