Re: Two Stone Sharpening....
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Derek, David, & Stu et al....based on our recent talk of Shaptons and Sigmas, how does the following two stones look for a sharpening system??:
1) Sigma Power ceramic 1200 (Select II) since the Shapton Pro 1000 has become hard to find in the USA. This stone will easily handle O1 and A2 and other more exotic metals that I might acquire in the future.
2) Shapton Pro 15000 (cream stone) - this stone is sometimes referred to as a 12000 but always cream color (yellow).
I still have a King 6000 for an intermediate stone if needed....and I'm open to suggestions of any great intermediate stone....I'm just not aware of one that has emerged from the pack.
Hi Roger
Both David and Stu are far more knowledgable in this area, but I will give you the benefit of my experience to date.
As I understand, the Select II 1200 will replace the 1000. I have the 1200. Stu sent this to me to test out. I had no need at the time of another 1000-range stone as I was happy with the Pro Shapton 1000. I am still happy with the Shapton (as it cuts well), but the Select II 1200 is better overall. The Sigma has to be the hardest stone I have ever used! Flattening it on a extra coarse diamond stone took three times as long (at least!) as the Shapton 1000. It holds its flatness very well, as one might expect.
Both the Shapton and the Sigma will raised a wire edge very quickly on the toughest steel you can throw at it (yesterday I threw a 10V chisel at it, and it did not blink).
The Pro Shapton 12000 is a good stone for O1 but only just gets by on A2. The Sigma II is in another class altogether. The reason I was after Sigmas was to work more efficiently on the more abrasion-resistant steels, such as M2 (HSS), M4, and other PM steels. The Shapton was really not getting these sharp at this level, even with the Pro 5000 as an intermediate grit (I think that this stone is a dog on anything other than O1).
Yesterday I sharpened a hard A2 smoother blade from LV (which was always a struggle on the Shaptons, so had put it aside). This was from the woodie range, not the BU range of blades. The Sigmas (1200/6000/10000 or 13000 - the 1200/13000 is a new-to-the-market double stone that Stu sent me. I purchased the 6000/10000 separates) handled this blade in a way that I could not believe possible. It was effortless, and the result was a really sharp blade that performed at the highest level (I was smoothing some interlocked Jacaranda).
I also had the opportunity to hone 3V, M4, and 10V chisels. The 3V and M4 were like sharpening A2 on the Shaptons. Absolutely hair-popping sharp in a couple of minutes. Keep in mind that I am running through the full compliment of Sigmas at this stage, even though they are hollow ground, rather than reducing the number - still getting to know the stones. My recall is trying the same on the Pro Shaptons was never this good. While the 1000 was able to create a wire edge in a couple of strokes, the 5000 and 12000 did not improve the edge much after that.
I have given away my King stones below the 8000 Gold. They really bring very little, if anything, to the table. They dish rapidly - which is deliberate since they need to expose fresh grit all the time. While I do not get that anal about flatness when freehanding the bevels, I certainly am when honing the back of blades. Honing a microbevel on the back of the bevel because the stone is hollowed ... and then having to lap the blade flat again ... well that is more work than I want. I am not interested in King stones.
The downside to the Sigma II is that they all need a little soaking. Actually I am not sure that this is really a downside since, according to Stu, the Shaptons also benefit from soaking, even if it is just a few minutes. The thing about a sintered Sigma versus other stones is that they are unaffected by water. Consequently, you can leave them lying in a shallow Tupperware container (as I am) without danger of damaging them. So no time is lost to soaking.
Just a comment on 2-stone systems. I think it is a mistake to aim for this. Sure, you can hone a microbevel on most steels using just two stones. However you will need a third stone as the microbevel gets larger, and indeed there are some bevels that benefit from being left flat. It takes less time to hone a hard steel using an intermediary grit since you are not spending extra - unnecessary - time on a higher grit to do the work of a lower grit. Get a third stone.
Regards from Perth
Derek