Picky is ok!
Sharpening medium flatness questionss
Posts
Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss
#52
That works
David Barnett
"But once I find something that is quick and precise, that's about where I tune out talking about specs. I trust my hands and my eyes after that."
Entirely sane and well said.
Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss
#53Re: The Japanese way?
TomD
Thanks for the detailed response Pam, I think we do a lot of things the same, though I thing you are a little more deeply into authentic stones than I am.
Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss
#54Re: The Japanese way?
Pam Niedermayer
I only started trying to work with natural stones because I was so disappointed with the Shaptons, probably only with partial justification.
Pam
Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss
#55Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners and esoteric info
Bob Hackett
"There's really no need for either side to be intolerant of another's tolerance for tolerances."
A classic line if there ever was one.
Sound the vuvuzelas and lay the laurel wreath upon the hero`s head! 
Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss
#56I disagree, intolerance results in progress
Bill Tindall
Continuing my campaign of making, making stuff simpler.........I presume there are persons who are yet undecided, or inexperienced, about how to sharpen or what materials are necessary to be successful in sharpening sufficient to make stuff.
If someone advocates a woodworking operation, specification, requirement, etc. useful for making stuff, say sharpening, that is unnecessarily complicated or exacting it is a useful exercise to respectfully challenge what is being advocated. Ideally the challenge will be backed by data. Ideally the result will be data that the Undecided can use to come to a conclusion that is best for them.
In the Will Neptune class I recently took Will challenged several established woodworking procedures with alternatives he believed to be faster, more reliable and/or easier to execute. And he had a lot to say about tolerances. It could be said that he was intolerant of the alternative way of doing things, but not necessarily intolerant of the people advocating them.
Take the case at hand, the tolerances of the LV plates. I think a Blanchard ground plate is adequate in terms of scratches and flatness for sharpening for typical "building stuff" applications. I have nearly 10 years experience using Blanchard ground plates for this application. I think it may have been helpful to the Undecided to challenge an alternative opinion that the LV plates fell short in these attributes/tolerances.
The bottom line is that it is useful to be vocally intolerant of things, procedures, theories, etc. so long as the critic remains tolerant of the person advocating an alternative opinion. Intolerance of what is "known" is how science has successfully worked and advanced since it was invented. There is a wonderfully written discussion of this thought in John Tyndall's 1850's book where he reported on his adventures studying glaciers, studies that led to upending the prevailing notions of how glaciers worked.
Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss
#57
There you go, being tolerant of intolerance
David Barnett
To which I agree fully. That was more tongue-in-cheek wordplay than anything else, and my derision of conflict-avoiding sappiness ("Can't we all just get along?"). Mea culpa.
Aside from intolerance being just fine, even laudable in your well-reasoned conceptual framework -- I mean shouldn't we be intolerant of lawlessness or senseless mayhem or crime? -- I also applaud and embrace discrimination and even (God forbid) prejudice as useful and desirable traits, traits that have kept me alive, in fact. And before anyone gets all knee-jerky, I'm not advocating indiscriminate application of either.
So it's fair to say I'm often intolerant, discriminatory, highly critical, argumentative and most definitely prejudicial, and that's a good thing, as Martha would say, when it's appropriate to the issue at hand.
You know what I mean.
Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss
#58Reminds me of David Charlesworth
Frank D. in Montreal
and, to pick just one example, his advocacy of the ruler trick. I've heard criticism of his techniques and claims that he doesn't know what he's doing (although admittedly those were some time ago, when his influential first two books came out), but no one has taught me more about how to be efficient and accurate in woodworking, regardless of established practices.
Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss
#59It's why I never fail to read your posts
Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss
#60Results always trump theory
Bob Hackett
If it works for you and is repeatable then what else do you need to know?
There is much to be said for sticking with something till you understand it as completely as you can before throwing more variables into the mix.
I am reminded of a story about searching for water. If you dig a few feet ,hit nothing and then move on there`s a good chance you`ll do a lot of digging and never hit water. On the other hand if you stay in one spot, and dig, even just a little a little each day, sooner or later you`ll get water.
As far as tolerances go, I see nothing wrong with starting off with as accurate a reference point as possible. If nothing else it helps reduce accumulated error.
Sure there are ways to work around most anything and I`m sure many of us are capable of getting entirely acceptable results with even badly dished stones. We understand the hows and whys of what we`re working with and that in depth understanding allows us the flexibility we need to adjust to less than optimal conditions.
Without that in depth understanding there can be a lot of tail chasing. We may not have enough understanding to be sure which of the variables or loose tolerances we`ve exposed ourselves to were the ones responsible for our less than stellar results.
Some of the people I`ve worked with have observed my techniques and thought I was absolutely insane to attempt to sharpen any number of things the way I do. All that doubt vanished once they put the edge to work.
I usually would smile and say something like; "Just because you are incapable of doing it that way and getting results doesn`t mean I am incapable as well".



