New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Sharpening medium flatness questionss

Posts

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#26

Re: The Japanese way?

TomD

"I really noticed the lack of flatness when preparing new wide chisel backs (faces)."

Which is why the real (?) Japanese method, at least as explained by some, is to lap these surfaces..

The reality is that a lot of folks are still sharpening with Japanese stones. It might be instructive to know the highest level manual of arms for these toolss. I don't know. Here are a few issues:

- Maintaining flatness. My belief is that they spend a lot more time working stones between sharpenings. David mentioned a flattening process every few tools. What I saw back in NH in the 80s was that they sharpened all over the stones. Imagine you are using the chisel to clean the surface of the stone, rather than imagining there is a "shallow end" in the middle that you don't want to leave, for fear of the deep water. When I sharpen I overlap the edges, so that I may have half of a chisel hanging off there. I feel if it is good enough for swords made by living treasures it is good enough for me. One avoids the center of the stone.

- Lapping stones flat. Given that I have never seen a Japanese draftsperson lap a stone; that three general Japanese tool books where published, Odate, Mesiro, and some one printing guy, with no mention of it. I don't thing Van Arsdale shows it in videos. Or in the sword sharpening videos, Etc... I sorta assumed that when the first ceramic laps made it over here a decade or so ago, they were a Kluge for guys in the west. I assumed the same thing when Shapton came out. The stones must be lapped in manufacture, and various processes that involve rubbing stones, or using concrete speak to this. But at the same time. If I was buying stones for 10K I would be loath to punch a hole in the center, then grind a few hundred bucks of stone off. Every few chisels. Don't know what is the real method here. I was amused that when the ceramic laps first hit our shores they had to be returned for lack of flatness, a sure sign of tourist tools.

- Lapping the backs of tools on a steel plate. These laps were part of the early Japanese tool landing, these kits have been dropped by the likes of LV, and just recently replaced with diamonds for other reasons. Gives fabulous results, was very labour intensive and messy when done with SC. I don't know how long this has been in the process, is it post industrial, or have carpenters alway done something of the sort, say back in the 1720s as Bill mentioned. The whole Japanese tool scene is supposed to have change post 1876, as legend has it, which would be well into the machine age.

Anyway, there are lots of folks going on craft tours to Japan, and there are lots of people using the stones. I would be curious to know what the real method of use includes.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#27

Re: The Japanese way?

TomD

"Eventually stones wear from use. If they wore evenly there would be no problem, but they tend to wear most in the center; eventually a stone becomes so dished that it is impossible to hone a straight edge on it."

The obvious reason being that people only sharpen in the center. Why exactly?

"The easiest and fastest way to flatten any bench stone is to use a coarse diamond bench stone. If you can afford one, it is a wonderful luxury."

I didn't follow this particular advice, but I did buy stones of the type recommended at my local Local Value seller, and the result was on several occasions that the stones stopped working relatively fast. So yeah it is a luxury like most tool abuse. I don't know if they are making diamond stones yet that have a bond that is harder than most abrasives... Diamond is harder, vitrius stuff, metal, and plastic are not. I would also say it is a heck of a lot not faster than doing the same job on concrete.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#28

Re: The Japanese way?

Schtoo

TomD wrote;

"Anyway, there are lots of folks going on craft tours to Japan, and there are lots of people using the stones. I would be curious to know what the real method of use includes."

I could write it all out, but I don't think anyone pays me any particular attention here, so I'll not bother to spend my valuable time writing it all out.

Stu.

(I'll give you a hint, I don't need to take a craft tour to Japan...)

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#29

Returning to the beginning.....LV plates

Bill Tindall

Some dissatisfaction was expressed over the tolerance of the LV plates. The specification in question is 0.005". What I have learned so far is that this specification is meaningless as stated. Never-the-less we can make some assumptions about this specification and see how significant such a deviation could be.

In all cases we will assume grinding on a 2 x 2" tool surface which we desire to stay or become flat. The question is how unflat will it be after grinding on this plate?

Case 1. The 8 x 3" plate is planar but it is twisted out of plane by 0.005" corner to corner. The 2 x 2 tool surface will become a twisted plane with a deflection of 0.0016" corner to corner, or 40 microns. I can not think of any woodworking operation where this deflection would be significant. However, if this deflection was ground into the tool on a coarse plant and then the tool moved to a perfectly flat plate with 1 micron diamond, 0.0016" or 40 microns of material would need to be removed from the corners to perfectly register the tool against the 1 micron plate.

Case 2 The 8 x 3' plate is planar but bowed end to end with a deflection of 0.005" in its middle and the bow approximating an arc of a circle. In this case the tool would also be bowed with a deflection from a perfect flatness of 0.0006" or 15 microns. Damned if I can hand hone to these dimensions.

Case 3 The plate is cupped across its short 3" axis. In this case the tool being ground would become convex and out of plane by 0.0016" or 40 micron.

Now what in fact happens when this theoretical 2 x 2" tool surface slides about the plate depends on how it slides about the plate. In some schemes for moving the tool about the plate the unflatness of the plate will more or less average, thereby further reducing the calculated out of flatness reported above. In other cases the out of fatness will be in an irrelevant orientation to how the tool is used.

I leave it to the reader whether to fret whether the LV plates are flat enough for your work. Of much greater concern to me are the attributes previously enumerated- how well do the particles embed and how easily does the tool slide on this steel.

I free-hand grind on a fixed EZY-Lap fixed diamond plate of unknown to me some flatness followed by a free-hand grinding on a Blanchard ground (similar to the LV plate I presume) cast iron plate. I have seen no evidence of plate unflatness problems with this arrangement. Softer synthetic or natural stones may become substantially less flat than what I am using and this unflatness can become significant, as other have pointed out.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#30

I recommend settling...

Bill Tindall

....for the results from cheap Blanchard grinding because it is good enough. I am confident that folks building stuff will have bigger fish to fry than worrying about diamond plate flatness.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#31

Re: Flatness is easily had, so why settle for less

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I certainly don't see a flat stone as the most desirable. If you can manage your stone, the stone imparts a natural camber to the iron. This saves time because you don't flatten the stone before use and you have the camber without using some Mickey Mouse method to create and maintain it. Some people buy a convex plate to give the stone some curvature, but I think it is easier to learn to manage the wear on the stone.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#32

Re: The Japanese way?

Pam Niedermayer

I don't know whether it is/was the Japanese way, but notice that they do use the stone shards to great effect. Also, they sell very expensive stones that are decidedly unflat, not just dished, but with great gaping ledges and cracks, etc.; and these stones are often very expensive (I've seen $20k selling prices). I'll also comment that Jay van Arsdale in his Japanese Handplanes dvd uses a huge, very flat polishing stone which probably would cost a small fortune today, maybe when he bought it, too.

I have about 10 natural waterstones, several from LV which arrived flat, and several from Japan which did not, din't even approach flat. None of them were what I'd call cheap, but I've never paid much more than $100 for any of them.

I'm miserly about using up these stones, partly because once I integrate a particular stone into the sharpening process for particular blades, I haven't a clue as to how to replace them. It's not like I could name these stones, except for the LV ones which would cost a lot to replace. And partly because I don't have as much money as I did when I bought them, partly thanks to the cost of the stones. :)

So, I try to use the entire surface of the LV stones before flattening them. With the non-LV stones, I never flatten them. Instead I start working with whatever flat I can find with small chisel bevels and kind of create a spreading flat that will accommodate larger bevels, and so on. It takes a little time, but this is not unsatisfying.

With the man made stones, like the Shaptons and Sigma Pro ceramics, I use Atoma and iWood diamond plates right after each sharpening session. Easy peasy.

Pam, who's been driven to join the verbosity of this thread :)

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#33

Re: The Japanese way?

Pam Niedermayer

Impressive, Stu, but you did sell me a set of three stones and a chisel or two; so I don't see how your time here is wasted. Also, seems to me you could have saved even more time if that's your goal.

Pam

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#34

Touche...

Schtoo

You're right, I could have kept quiet and saved that time too, which probably wouldn't have been such a bad idea all things considered...

From what I've seen and been told of folks who sharpen here in Japan, flat stones are not undesirable, but the blade being sharpened, more often than not, eliminates the need for extremely flat sharpening devices.

And the number of diamond plates I've seen scattered around where folks who sharpen stuff for a living can't be ignored. Yes, it's very possible to work the stone flat (and I do it myself), there's still a need/want for flattening devices. Usually these are diamond plates now, but in the past they were kanaban (flat steel plates) with loose abrasive, sand or chipped off bits of coarse stone or a particularly hard, coarse stone specifically for the purpose.

The little nagura stone, a small conditioning stone, is also helpful to smooth things out.

It's a combination of flat sharpening stuff, the design of the blades themselves, the stones and the person doing the sharpening. I could quite honestly and easily get by without flattening any stone I own, simply working it flat with use.

But a few seconds with a diamond plate makes sure of it. And I'm not the only one in this small, island nation that will take the easy, simple and uncomplicated way out to get this job done, especially with synthetic stones.

There's always more than one way to skin a cat, and one of the very surprising things is that here, most folks are usually more than willing to find out how someone else skins theirs.

I used to think it was a case of a thousand years of tradition unhindered by progress, until I realized it was more like a thousand years of progress building upon tradition. Sometimes the progress isn't apparent though, which makes it difficult to spot.

Stu.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#35

David Barnett

Returning to the beginning, having not moved much *LINK*

David Barnett

"Some dissatisfaction was expressed over the tolerance of the LV plates. The specification in question is 0.005". What I have learned so far is that this specification is meaningless as stated."

Well, I can't say I've come to that same conclusion.

"I leave it to the reader whether to fret whether the LV plates are flat enough for your work."

Fair enough.

"Of much greater concern to me are the attributes previously enumerated- how well do the particles embed and how easily does the tool slide on this steel."


I, too, believe how particles are bedded and presented on a lap is important, and for sharpening I would also agree the ease of tool movement across a charged surface is a benefit. However, I was talking more about flattening (an integral step in sharpening) the back of a chisel or plane blade and here is where we differ.

I want to say early on, so I'll do it here, that while your three cases are well-written and thought out, they don't represent one real-world phenomenon that machinists and toolmakers invariably encounter; that bringing a product to the same precision as the manufacturing tool, in this case a lapping plate, used to produce that tool is pretty hard to accomplish. It helps if the reference tooling is accurate to a higher degree than the material being lapped, ground, or so on -- at least one more place to the right of the decimal point is preferable if feasable.

I can understand that you and probably most others who've participated or followed this discussion may think I'm somewhere between persnickety and obsessively whacked out of my gourd, but I find I'm not alone in my respect for highly flat honing and lapping surface tolerances.

Chris Schwartz reviewed the DMT Dia-Flate Plate last year (2011), and had this to say:

"The grit cuts fast and leaves a nice surface. And the thing is flat. DMT certifies it as flatter than .0005" across its surface. That is way flatter than anyone needs."

Now that's flatter than the 0.001" I'll accept and that Steve Elliott prefers not to accept ("A stone that was out by .001” would be way too much for me."), and although I'm not quite sure it's way flatter than anyone needs, it's flatter than most metal bonded diamond plates, and that's a fact. So i remain not quite sure that my expectation of ±0.001" for a lapping plate (again, Rob refers to these as hones, although established usage defines the process of employing hard loose grit on a softer substrate as lapping), nomenclature aside, is unreasonable, at least it's not to DMT. Cheap? Not so much.

At any rate, if there are those content with steel instead of cast iron at ±.005" deviation from flat, or who might regard the Lee Valley offering as an affordable "kit" plate that they can improve, refine, fine tune to greater flatness, I say go for it.

Nothing anyone has said here sways or compels me to believe that less flatness is desirable, acceptable, or even overlookable, though.

I've said before that my background may have conditioned me to be far more comfortable (and not so mystified) with higher realizable and absolutely necessary tolerances for lapping and laps, which again may seem too demanding for most woodworking hand tool users and sharpeners, so even with my lowered standards for woodworking tool sharpening (which includes lapping backs flat), I'll accept others can have differing personal standards that satisfy them. I wouldn't be happy with steel at 0.005" deviation, but if others think it's just fine, they're certainly entitled to their opinion.


Chris flattens his Norton flattening stone

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#36

Re: The Japanese way?

TomD

"I could write it all out, but I don't think anyone pays me any particular attention here, so I'll not bother to spend my valuable time writing it all out. "

Why should you escape so easily, It's the internet, nobody pays anyone much attention. :)

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#37

Re: Touche...

Pam Niedermayer

But a few seconds with a diamond plate makes sure of it. And I'm not the only one in this small, island nation that will take the easy, simple and uncomplicated way out to get this job done, especially with synthetic stones.

I agree completely. It's been a revelation to me to so thoroughly separate sharpening and flattening, and that's due to you, Dave Barnette, and TomD, for which I thank you.

Pam

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#38

Re: Touche...

Schtoo

I don't think I had that much of a hand in it.

But I am glad that what I sent seems to be working well. It's all I can do. ;)

Back to writing up some product descriptions. At the moment it's a bit of a mouthful...

Laminated powder metal/matrix high speed steel chisels. :D

(I don't know what kind of a cat they're supposed to be for skinning. Probably a really big, angry one...)

Stu.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#39

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

Brian Greene

I 've only glanced through some of the comments on this thread. I'm sure lots of good stuff has been said. As a cabinetmaker, sharpening teacher and someone who does a large amount of sharpening, I have a couple of simple points to make about the importance of regularly lapping water stones to maintain flatness.

One, an unlapped stone, or irregularly lapped stone is inconsistent. You don't know what you have because it's constantly changing. This has significant consequences for the user because the tools will reflect the condition of the stones and you will not be able to make minute corrections.

Two, the opposite of one, stones that are lapped regularly (every 5-10 minutes of use or better) are very consistent. You know what you have. The feedback is consistent as are the results. I regularly produce identical or nearly identical results, time after time, very quickly because I don't have to think about what the stones are doing much less worry about accomodating it.

Three, lapping is easy and takes less that a minute every time I sharpen, or more often if I have a lot of blades to do. Drywall screen on granite or plate glass is reliable and relatively inexpensive. It's more durable than sandpaper, less messy than powders, cheaper than diamonds and more reliable than the Norton-thing-that-doesn't-work-anyway. How flat? Flat enough to make pencil marks go away and produce a clean stone.

Cheers ... when in doubt, lap.

Brian in Ottawa

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#40

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners and esoteric info

david weaver

Sometimes when we have threads like this, the commentary becomes so esoteric and for lack of a better way to put it, maximin, that I just can't even read it.

There seems to be a movement because of magazine articles and beginners instructors (not to mention the machinists and lab workers who were already present in the crowd) such that whatever is described must not work that well because it wouldn't work for a beginner after a day.

I have trouble believing warren needs to have mechanically flattened stones, he shaves with what he sharpens.

I also feel like if I had to worry about as much as some of you guys worry about sharpening, instead of doing some of it by feel and observed results, I probably would just sit around and see if I could learn to carve pinheads or something else less tedious instead.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#41

Re: Sorry Brian....

david weaver

...I didn't intend for that to be a reply to your post, I thought I had posted it in response to the original post. No direct response to your post intended.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#42

Re: Thanks for that

Brian Greene

Thanks David. I agreed with what you said 100%. Some of this stuff strays so far into the weeds it makes my head hurt. I can't read it all and usually don't.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#43

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

Pam Niedermayer

I regularly produce identical or nearly identical results, time after time, very quickly because I don't have to think about what the stones are doing much less worry about accomodating it.

I'll admit right off that we probably have different objectives, given that you're trying to teach sharpening and I'm not; but still, every time I hear/read "without thinking" I think about running away as fast as I can. There is a place for thinking in sharpening. There is a place for accommodating the stone, or at least some stones. There is a place for being attuned to everything that happens as each event can tell you a lot about your tool, the steel, the stone, etc.

Pam

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#44

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

Brian Greene

Pam, You are right. Picky, but right. Instead of saying I don't think about the stones, I should have said, very accurately, I don't waste my time wondering whether my stones are flat and all the grief that will cause because I know they are flat; very flat; always.

More to your point, when I'm sharpening I'm very accutely focused on what I'm doing and very aware of what is happening.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#45

David Barnett

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners and esoteric info

David Barnett

Fun discussion and totally interesting to see how others think and approach precision.

"...for lack of a better way to put it, maximin..."

I think there's a better, less esoteric way to put it, but I get your usage and it is a fun word.

No-one here is suggesting that to sharpen, or even sharpen well, we must approach unreasonable limits of precision. In fact, Bill Tindall argues well for the converse. And yes, there are certainly diminished returns when we get below 0.001" into "tenths", but it's not a bad thing to consider or to shoot for, nor is it really all that difficult, unrealistic and unrealizable to some of us.

What may seem odd to some of us is resistance to easily-realized greater precision that for those same few of us is a difference, granted a tiny difference, that genuinely makes a difference. For a few of us, such as myself and Steve Elliott ("A stone that was out by .001” would be way too much for me."), who prefer and expect better than .001" tolerance, .005" might seem downright obscene for certain work. And by the way, some of us who like flat, and I mean really flat, actually do sharpen and use our tools day-to-day without requiring anti-psychotics or seratonin reuptake inhibitors. :)

"There seems to be a movement because of magazine articles and beginners instructors (not to mention the machinists and lab workers who were already present in the crowd) such that whatever is described must not work that well because it wouldn't work for a beginner after a day."

None of the above really resonates with me. I'm unfamiliar with such expectations for beginners. I can say, however, that while I can sharpen a tool on damned near anything these days, and quickly so, as a beginner I could not. I think beginners deserve good sharpening tools from the start and while they are new to the game, need to take sufficient time to get satisfactory results. Speed comes with practice and experience, of course. Yes, I've taught people in a day and even an hour the principles of sharpening, but it doesn't happen all at once for them..

So while I can sympathize with those who are skeptical of our need for or even the realizable existence of such tolerances, and am only too happy to recognize that others have differing requirements, I don't think that makes the rest of us wrong in expecting more from a tool intended to improve tolerances and performance of another tool. Doesn't seem esoteric to to those used to and who appreciate tighter tolerances and ensuing results, and while other may not think tighter tolerances actually improve performance, I'll just have to differ. Not up to me to judge for them but by the same token, not up to them to judge for me. There's really no need for either side to be intolerant of another's tolerance for tolerances.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#46

David Barnett

That's what keeps me coming back

David Barnett

"More to your point, when I'm sharpening I'm very accutely focused on what I'm doing and very aware of what is happening."

I find sharpening entirely fun and even relaxing. Like scraping surfaces flat, it's such a satisfying process.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#47

David Barnett

Good point, Pam

David Barnett

It's thinking, all right. A different sort of thinking, perhaps, more akin to the kind of thinking and constant little decisions that one makes as one refines a shape. I relate it to sinking and raising metal from flat into something with volume; a vessel. So satisfying. Same with prepping for finishing and even finishing itself, which I find equally satisfying.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#48

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

Pam Niedermayer

Yeah, picky. Well, some of your students may be watching. :)

Pam

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#49

Re: Beginners vs. Non-Beginners and esoteric info

david weaver

I like flat just as much as the next guy.

I really like stones, I have *gobs* of them, and I'd love to have 100 more just to play with (but I think I am at my numerical limit now).

But once I find something that is quick and precise, that's about where I tune out talking about specs. I trust my hands and my eyes after that.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#50

Re: Good point, Pam

Pam Niedermayer

I also love finishing, my first major woodworking effort starting when I was 13 or so (after shelf building and boat carving, but these were play comparably) with a Sears guitar. Now I concentrate on making finish free pieces. Funny, hadn't thought about things that way before.

Pam