Re: The Japanese way?
TomD
"I really noticed the lack of flatness when preparing new wide chisel backs (faces)."
Which is why the real (?) Japanese method, at least as explained by some, is to lap these surfaces..
The reality is that a lot of folks are still sharpening with Japanese stones. It might be instructive to know the highest level manual of arms for these toolss. I don't know. Here are a few issues:
- Maintaining flatness. My belief is that they spend a lot more time working stones between sharpenings. David mentioned a flattening process every few tools. What I saw back in NH in the 80s was that they sharpened all over the stones. Imagine you are using the chisel to clean the surface of the stone, rather than imagining there is a "shallow end" in the middle that you don't want to leave, for fear of the deep water. When I sharpen I overlap the edges, so that I may have half of a chisel hanging off there. I feel if it is good enough for swords made by living treasures it is good enough for me. One avoids the center of the stone.
- Lapping stones flat. Given that I have never seen a Japanese draftsperson lap a stone; that three general Japanese tool books where published, Odate, Mesiro, and some one printing guy, with no mention of it. I don't thing Van Arsdale shows it in videos. Or in the sword sharpening videos, Etc... I sorta assumed that when the first ceramic laps made it over here a decade or so ago, they were a Kluge for guys in the west. I assumed the same thing when Shapton came out. The stones must be lapped in manufacture, and various processes that involve rubbing stones, or using concrete speak to this. But at the same time. If I was buying stones for 10K I would be loath to punch a hole in the center, then grind a few hundred bucks of stone off. Every few chisels. Don't know what is the real method here. I was amused that when the ceramic laps first hit our shores they had to be returned for lack of flatness, a sure sign of tourist tools.
- Lapping the backs of tools on a steel plate. These laps were part of the early Japanese tool landing, these kits have been dropped by the likes of LV, and just recently replaced with diamonds for other reasons. Gives fabulous results, was very labour intensive and messy when done with SC. I don't know how long this has been in the process, is it post industrial, or have carpenters alway done something of the sort, say back in the 1720s as Bill mentioned. The whole Japanese tool scene is supposed to have change post 1876, as legend has it, which would be well into the machine age.
Anyway, there are lots of folks going on craft tours to Japan, and there are lots of people using the stones. I would be curious to know what the real method of use includes.






