New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Sharpening medium flatness questionss

Posts

Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#1

Sharpening medium flatness questionss

Bill Tindall

Because this question applies to any material I have separated it from the diamond plate discussion going on below.

1. What does the flatness specification (0.00X") mean?

2. Why is a specification on the order of a few thousandths of an inch for a sharpening surface way more than adequate for sharpening plane irons and chisels to be used in practical woodworking applications?

Question background: Sharpening media flatness is something I have never worried about. Unlike my other ignorances of the fine points of hand tools this detail had never reared its head and bit me.

For stones that wear I can't imagine that the practical woodworker maintains these stones to anything close to a flatness of say 0.005", or even has a means of bringing them to this level of flatness, or measuring this metric. I recall my failed efforts at flatening a plane sole and I would have been delighted if this effort had produced a surface this flat.

It would seem that at best the sharpening surface would only need to be flat, to some specification, over the area in contact with the stone at any one time. If my 12" long cast iron plate was twisted out of plane end to end 1/16" inches I don't see how this twist would unfavorably impact sharpening. Even pressure on the tool would maintain registration of the tool surface to the plate surface over this length. The narrow two bands of the hollow grind on a chisel or plane iron would lay flat and track across this surface just fine, I think. Ditto if the surface was dished 1/16". A hollow in the center would be a problem, but even this unfavorable case might average out to yield an acceptable edge.

To those that have devoted thought to this issue, why do it need a flat abrasive surface, or at least one flat to 0.00X"? How would I achieve it? How would I measure it?

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#2

Why I like flat stones

Steve Elliott

Flatness of a sharpening medium is a minor issue when only the bevel is being worked. In the case of, say, the flat back of a wide chisel a dished coarse stone will remove steel at the edges. When the chisel back is then put on a finer stone, only the center of the back will be polished. A set of stones that all have the same amount of dishing would avoid this problem but after a while the dishing would change. A flat surface is the easiest shape to achieve and maintain. It’s relatively easy to get each stone in a set flat and to maintain that flatness to the necessary degree.

For centuries excellent work was done using techniques to get around these issues, for example what I’ve heard referred to as “the ruler trick but without the ruler.” All of the old laminated blades I’ve seen look like they have had the back of the blade raised a little to help remove the wire edge. Only polishing a narrow band on the back of a chisel is another venerable technique. On the other hand I like having a larger reference surface on the back of a chisel that can be used to guide the blade when squaring out a mortise corner. I like being able to lay the chisel back on my finest stone and know that the edge will touch the stone so that the wire edge will be gone after a couple of light strokes.

I’ve flattened enough waterstones on a granite reference plate covered with fine wet/dry paper to be able to recognize when I’ve reached whatever level of flatness that technique can achieve. I can’t measure it but it’s way better than I can detect using feeler gauges. Since the technique puts the same near-flat shape on all of my stones it doesn’t matter to me just how far it deviates from theoretically perfect flatness.

I’m not advocating for any particular sharpening method here, that’s largely a matter of personal preference, but since your question was about why flatness is important to those of us who like it, I thought I’d present my reasons.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#3

David Barnett

I've talked about this on WC before... *LINK*

David Barnett

but it's been awhile.

Most of this is more germane to machinists than woodworkers, but it has bearing on lapping plates, honing stones and the metrological means to verify them and the surprisingly straightforward methods for making them.

Of course, the easiest way to get a flat lap, say flat to 0.0001" or one tenth in machinist-speak, meaning one ten-thousandth of an inch over it's entire length of say 12" is to buy or make one.

This would suffice for flattening and honing woodworking edge tools, and is realizable for even the untrained DIYer to manage.

Three pieces of equally dimensioned iron plate will yield three equally flat surface plates or laps without requiring an external reference surface, these three plates ground together in a proper sequence being, in effect, the progressively more flat references for one another until the desired flatness is finally produced. This also works for straightedges, by the way.

Of course, if one purchases an inexpensive granite surface plate from a woodworking or industrial supply, that will suffice to flatten a plate to spec without using the more-involved method alluded to in the above paragraph.

I'm simply trying to illustrate that production and testing of flatness is not so esoteric as one might initially imagine. In fact, if one were to need hardened steel flats as standards, one can be had or purchased flat to 10 millionths of an inch per inch. So making or measuring or maintaining 0.001" of flatness is really no big deal. It was sort of a hobby with me to flatten laps and plane soles with a machinist's scraper during long cold New England winters. OCD, cabin fever, whatever you wish to call it, but my stones and hones and plane soles are flat.

My iron laps are all scraped to better than 0.001" and what's more, it was easy and even fun doing it.

For those of you who find this hard to believe, and for those who would even like to try it, there's a 539-page out-of-print book that is apparently still available online, was discussed and linked to on WC, but for the life of me I can't locate it in the archives.

Its title is Machine Tool Reconditioning and Applications of Hand Scraping, but I'll leave it to anyone motivated enough to find and read it to search for it. Alternatively, Lindsay Publications often republishes books on scraping flat surfaces, bearings, machine tool ways, and so on, with a few other surprises, as well. Also, such scraping and flattening procedures are found on metalworking forums and in online books on machine shop practice.

I just want to reiterate that 0.001" over a honing stone or lap is easy enough to achieve and maintain, so I find little excuse for having to endure less precision in manufactured and marketed abrasive products.


Scraping not your thing? Try embalming at home!

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#4

David Barnett

Oh hell, what Steve said

David Barnett

You beat me too it, haha. Make your own. It's cheap! It's fun!

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#5

craigd

... and wrote the book about it *LINK*

craigd

How to create flat, a how to by Joseph Withworth, a name old British car lovers love.


Miscellaneous Papers on Mechanical Subjects

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#6

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

TomD

Your question 1) is a fair one. And it seems to normally mean a thou over the whole surface, where the X is a one, or over some dimension, where that dimension is specified.

Getting things accurate to a thou over a foot, or whatever is fairly easy, even a wooden hand plane can do that, and normally without looking. But getting into the area of the tens is conceptually possible but in practice unlikely, and it is unlikely that one could measure it. Surface plates come in different grades, and need constant checking and maintenance. As do the other tools that go with them, holding truly fine specs. is not as easy as it sounds. It is easy to take readings, or go through steps, but they may or not reflect actual results.

If one accepts that the thou range is reasonable, then I see no reason to sidestep it. It may not be necessary but it does not harm anything either. given that is the case, it is reasonable that advertisers mention it to reassure buyer or to coral them with the thought that they couldn't just make their own version of whatever.

Here is a typical rant from my fixture maker Don Ferris:

"The reason machine shop guys may scoff at your flatness requirements is because they know the deal when it comes to flatness. You'll see a lot of folks, frankly, that have no real experience or understanding of metrology throwing .001's around like so many f-bombs. In most cases, it's not really their fault, they're just repeating what someone else has said. It's kind of like that myth that steel frames "go soft" with age. It has no basis in reality but if enough "experts" repeat it as truth, it gets accepted that way by folks who don't spend the time to investigate it. I see it all the time; folks just have no respect for the number. I've seen guys claim that something is within a .001 and they're measuring it with a dial caliper that has an accuracy of .005" when new and before it'd been used for a few years and dropped countless times, the slide never adjusted for wear, and calibration never checked.

The central issue is that even big dumb things like surface plates wear with use (which is why you have to get them calibrated annually) and in most shops, they get used hard. Just because it was claimed to be within a thou say 5, 10, 20, 50 years ago has no bearing on what it's like today unless it has been regularly inspected, documented, and maintained. As my Dad always said (and now I say it all the time), "the only thing you know about old equipment is that it's old."

This is the truth: you're not going to get a used cast or steel table 3' feet across, let alone 5', that will be within .001" unless it's new or near new and has been scraped and not just ground. The reality is that a freshly Blanchard ground alignment table is good for about .003-.005" across the width of the table. You can ask them to hold better, but on a big item it's going to cost you and that still doesn't account for how the table is made, the temperature fluctuations in your shop, whether the table top is bolted/welded to legs or floats on a stand (latter is much better for maintaining flatness), etc., etc., etc."

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#7

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

TomD

Here is Rob's take on specs. From the Canadian forum, if it's Ok to post it here...:

a couple of comments on tolerances below:

1) Tolerances are not a target - they are the gate that acceptable products must pass through. Think of them as a passing grade... when you take a test, you're always shooting for 100%, not just a pass. Parts too, range from pass to 100%.

2) Flatness tolerances - when objects are machined and ground, they undergo tremendous forces. Metal parts can flex, magnetic chucks and tables can hold a slightly curved piece flat, and tools can wear from the start of an operation to another. Even expansion of metal parts due to heating can cause deviation. Holding a part can also flex it - it will flex back upon release - after machining or grinding. All of these things can work to take a part out of tolerance. However - when a surface is out of tolerance, it's rarely a very localised defect (like a ridge, or a bump) - it's usually a very gradual change over a larger distance.

3) Location of variation - where a part has variability can be more important that what they variability is. Does the variation occur where it will affect performance? Is the tolerance on a functional aspect, or a cosmetic aspect? Looking at lapping plates, is a plate out of tolerance within .010 of the edge really defective? (answer is yes - because it's out of tolerance, but practically it makes no difference).

4) Tolerances are measured at a point in time. We all know wood moves... metal can too, and does - especially if it wears. Metals in solid form are in a state of equilibrium, but there may still be internal stresses that express themselves over time. Grey iron castings do this - especially if you change the surafce. Think of it as a block of ice with embedded stretched elastic bands frozen in it...stable, until you shave the surface, causing a band to snap (it's just an analogy - not a model!). Sudden shocks, changes in temperature can also cause movement.

There's a lot more to tolerances - but this should give you a bit more insight into how they apply, and are used...

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#8

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

JDK

So how flat does a reference surface need to be to ensure woodworking edge tools are properly sharpened?

You know, without the angels-on-the-head-of-a-pin drama.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#9

David Barnett

I'm not so sure its entirely fair...

David Barnett

...to drag Rob's post from another forum to this one without his consent, but I'll express and reiterate my concerns from this different framework. If Rob or the list moms would prefer I remove this unsolicited (by Rob) reply, I'll respectfully absterse it from this discussion. I'm not criticizing you, Tom, for posting this -- it's an interesting opinion Rob offers. I'm just not sure of forum etiquette and protocol in this case.

This is all interesting material and I'm in agreement with most of it. I'm even sympathetic to the considerable challenges of making affordable diamond honing plates. Where I still have reservations involves the final maximum allowable deviation from flat, especially regarding flattening the backs of broad edge tools. I'm willing to accept my shortcoming in understanding the factors and explanations for how 0.005" maximum flatness deviation can be overcome by production or end-user technique and will endeavor to keep an open mind.

"1) Tolerances are not a target - they are the gate that acceptable products must pass through. Think of them as a passing grade... when you take a test, you're always shooting for 100%, not just a pass. Parts too, range from pass to 100%."

This sounds all right at first until you realize that setting the passing grade of 0.005" for overall flatness sets the bar pretty low, at least too low for me. I understand the concepts involved but am not so sure I understand why we should expect lowered standards from 0.001" or even 0.002" all the way down to 0.005" to accomodate production challenges to achieve an attractive price point.

It reminds me that beginning musicians need well-made instruments to learn upon, and that poorer made instruments can discourage and defeat beginners before they've had a fair chance to experience an adequate instrument and learning experience. If 0.001" earns an 'A', and 0.002" gets a 'B', it doesn't speak well for 0.005", at least not to me.

"2) Flatness tolerances - when objects are machined and ground, they undergo tremendous forces. Metal parts can flex, magnetic chucks and tables can hold a slightly curved piece flat, and tools can wear from the start of an operation to another. Even expansion of metal parts due to heating can cause deviation. Holding a part can also flex it - it will flex back upon release - after machining or grinding. All of these things can work to take a part out of tolerance. However - when a surface is out of tolerance, it's rarely a very localised defect (like a ridge, or a bump) - it's usually a very gradual change over a larger distance."

Although there's nothing here I would disagree with -- every bit of it is true -- it addresses only production challenges and difficulties that need to be overcome in machining a flat honing plate for use with diamond. In other words, none of these obstacles should be left unresolved in the final product, nor can they serve as excuses for lack of final flatness.

"3) Location of variation - where a part has variability can be more important that what they variability is. Does the variation occur where it will affect performance? Is the tolerance on a functional aspect, or a cosmetic aspect? Looking at lapping plates, is a plate out of tolerance within .010 of the edge really defective? (answer is yes - because it's out of tolerance, but practically it makes no difference)."

There are different to think about localization. In one view, the anomaly is small in relation to the total surface area of the substrate, either as a pit or a protrusion, a pit being preferable for honing purposes. If the bump is anywhere near the middle, this demands correction. If at a corner, say, one could presumably avoid it with considerable ease. The bump could also be corrected (flattened) with considerable ease, although this shouldn't be left for the purchaser to have to do on his or her own. It's similar to anvils that have a localized bump where it's out of the way of where things get flattened. In some cases, the bump even gets used as a feature. Prominences and dishes involving broader percentages of total surface are can be more complicated and deleterious.

Unlike anvils, with hones, however, these issues are genereally undesireable. If a higher ridge occurs along an edge, this can dig into and scratch the back of a blade during flattening. It can also raise the angle creating a long angled surface on the tool back where flatness is desired. But even if the aberration is gradual, concave or otherwise, what may not too badly interfere with bevel sharpening, is apt to cause flattening problems, especially on wider blades in 2" widths or greater. Having experienced such problem stones which were out of flatness well below the Lee Valley allowance of 0.005", I'd have to consider anything above 0.001" to 0.002" unusably aberrant and in need of correction.

Furthermore, I'd say the above offered example, where Rob postulates an out-of-tolerance 0.010" deviation, saying "practically it makes no difference", isn't something I can so easily rationalize into agreement. In my opinion, this is not so.

Lastly, under Rob's point 4), he explains:

"Metals in solid form are in a state of equilibrium, but there may still be internal stresses that express themselves over time. Grey iron castings do this - especially if you change the surafce. Think of it as a block of ice with embedded stretched elastic bands frozen in it...stable, until you shave the surface, causing a band to snap (it's just an analogy - not a model!)."

Rob's right, metals move and cast iron benefits from letting in season and settle so the casting stresses can sort themselves out. Some Chinese woodworking machines could do with more homogenous iron and better casting schedules to minimize jointer bed torquing and tablesaws that depart considerably from flatness, although this occurs less now than before more stringent quality and production inspection was implented.

Now Bill Tindall and I avoid much of this distortion by using continually cast grey iron plate, such as Meehanite, which is far more stable when it cools, is more homogenous in its grain structure and settles in a very controlled manner owing to its composition, method of manufacture and manufactured shape. What I'm trying to convey is that iron isn't always just iron. There are broad differences not only in composition but in realization of final product. So thinking of cast iron "as a block of ice with embedded stretched elastic bands frozen in it...stable, until you shave the surface, causing a band to snap" isn't nearly so applicable here. And as Rob said, "it's just an analogy - not a model!"

And as Rob also says, "Sudden shocks, changes in temperature can also cause movement." Couldn't be more true, and applicable both in the case of plain cast iron and continuously cast iron. Machinists and metrologist must deal with this constantly. What's more, it's generally more true for iron than for mild steel, which can be more stable and relaxed that cast irons.

So while I'm obviously still resistant to sharpening plates being called flat with an accepted tolerance of 0.005", I welcome efforts to convince me otherwise. Won't likely be easy and probably unlikely, but I'm willing to listen.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#10

David Barnett

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

David Barnett

I really think flat to 0.001" to be fair and realizable for a commercially-made hone or sharpening stone, which seems to be the stated industry standard for most honing products. Better than 0.001" if you're using a surface plate is realizable, but 0.001" across the entire surface plate's length is sufficient for most flattening and beveling, both sharpening processes being integral to produce a sharp arris.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#11

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

wilbur

First of all, there seems to be an underlying assumption that maintaining flatness on your sharpening medium is hard and tedious. In fact, it's quite easy to maintain flatness. Here's a video showing how I do this with waterstones and a diamond plate. It's about 30 seconds of time.

http://giantcypress.net/post/668546073/japanese-tools-are-traditionally-sharpened-with

I don't know exactly how flat my waterstone is, but after doing this I can't get a 0.001" feeler gauge under a straightedge placed on the surface of the waterstone.

For me, the reason for flatness in your sharpening medium is for efficiency. Sharpening regimens often are a series of steps: 15/6/1 micron diamond paste, soft Arkansas/translucent Arkansas/strop with green compound, 1000/4000/8000 grit waterstones, and so on. To move most efficiently from one stage to the next means having the same profile on each stage of your sharpening method of choice, and the easiest way of keeping the same profile is to make all of them flat.

It's true that if you only had a one step sharpening procedure, that you might get away with a 1/16" dish in the middle of your sharpening surface, if the tool was small enough in relation to the size of the surface. So you won't have a problem with a 1/4" chisel. Sharpen a 2" wide plane blade on a non-flat surface, and you'll have issues.

The other issue with the hollow grind and one stone process is that you'll wind up doing more grinding than you need to maintain the "narrow two bands of the hollow grind on a chisel or plane iron". After just a few honings, the narrow bands won't be so narrow any more, and then you'll wind up grinding more often than necessary unless you have another way of sharpening, like one of the three step methods I outlined above.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#12

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

Warren in Lancaster, PA

This morning I put a nice straight edge on my coarse stone and was able to slide a .012 feeler gauge in the gap. I am sure that it has at times been worse. However, this has not prevented me from routinely taking shavings in the .0002 to .0005 range. It made me uneasy to put a straight edge on an abrasive surface; I would not want to do it regularly.

With my black Arkansas stone, I could see light under the straight edge, but could not get a .001 gauge underneath. It has not been flattened in the 35 years I have used it. I think the biggest factor in the equation is experience, not stone flatness.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#13

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

Schtoo

#1, not much. You're missing some details, as you're likely aware already. The 'flatness/straightness' of anything needs to be a given measure (small) over a given length of material (large).

#2, I don't quite understand the question. Sorry.

For me, the numbers don't actually mean anything, but holding oneself to a tight specification means that repeatability is a built in benefit.

It doesn't matter very much how flat the sharpening device is, so long as it gets your tools sharp, and it gets them sharp every single time without having to change anything to maintain the consistency.

Tool is blunt, you sharpen it the same way you always do, it comes out the other end of the process sharp, you get to work making it blunt again.

Usually, I use waterstones. I flatten them often to make sure they're flat and I use the same piece of equipment to flatten them all, so even if they're not 'flat' (they are), at least they're all 'flat' with respect to each other and I don't let them get too far out of 'flat' to further ensure that they're all very close to each other flat-wise.

In essence, I have a single, reliable reference surface by which all other flat things are generated by and referenced against.

This is the thing that a lot of folks miss. Because I only have one 'flat' thing, I only need to ensure it is flat (or close to it) and it makes other things 'flat' according to it. So everything else will be the same kind of 'flat'.

It's that simple. I could spit out all kinds of numbers and tolerances, but none of it is as important as being able to have every bit of gear that touches the blade 'flat' relative to each other.

And that 'flat' is what causes consistent results to just happen. No need to chase them, they just happen and that's all there is to it.

Granted, I'm probably not an expert when it comes to sharpening tools and such, and certainly not good enough to be quoted in magazines and on forums.

Stu.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#14

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

David Weaver

If you get the results you need, I can't see worrying about flatness. Some experience will keep a smart user for jamming the back of a chisel into a hollow on a stone and dubbing the edge.

I figure with a hard stone, you can keep things in check pretty easily. I generally consider a shapton professional stone to be the lower limit of hardness that can hold its shape and give you plenty of flat spots around the edges to find for the back of a chisel or to work with the back of a chisel to keep in check.

The finest stone is the only thing that touches the back of something more often than initial flattening, so it's the only one where I need to be able to find a flat area. The other stones don't get flattened that much sometimes.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#15

I like flat stones too

david charlesworth

Bill,

I use waterstones and have flattened them for years on 240grit wet and dry, on 12 mm float glass.

These days I have some diamond plates, the new DMT and Shapton. I get very slight convexity at the edges, but can not get a 1 thou" shim, into the visible gaps, under a precision straightedge.

I do flatten religiously after two or maybe three tools. Depends what they are. If planing a lot I let the 800grit stone wear a little concave, but never the polishing stone.

With my ruler trick method for plane blades, flatness is still particularly needed for the backs of chisels. If the wire edge does not float away on the stone or the sponge cloth, I am disappointed.

On a complementary subject, I have just flattened an old Stanley 5 1/2, and all light showing is less than 0.001". I was pissed off until I measured....... with a good light source one thou" looks huge !

Best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#16

It's so easy to have flat stones

GolfSteve in Calgary

It's so easy to have flat stones that I really don't understand the need for all these discussions.

I takes about 10 seconds each sharpening session to flatten my three stones, and there is no way I can fit my thinnest feeler gauge between my straight edge and my stone (I forget if my thinnest feeler is a 1/1000 or a 2/1000 ). I have no idea how that compares to the 5/1000 flatness of the latest LV iron plates, but my stones are very flat and that is a very good thing.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#17

Re: It's so easy to have flat stones

wilbur

Steve is 20 seconds faster than I am. :D

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#18

What would be the result.....

Bill Tindall

....If the sharpening surface was not flat to 0.001". What I am failing to grasp is why flatness on the scale of thousandths of an inch across an 8 or 12" surface is important. I am skeptical that the typical woodworker has sharpening surfaces this flat or knows whether they do or not, in this age or in 1720. How flat is a leather strop, or the piece of MDF or maple that some have used for charging diamond paste? The logical conclusion is that stone flatness on this scale is irrelevant to the making of furniture.

Making stuff is hard enough without introducing unnecessary impediments to the process. If sharpening surfaces don't need to be on the order of 0.001" to fit a drawer with hand plane or pare a tenon with a chisel then the distinction of what can be achieved in stone flatness, and what is necessary to make stuff, needs the clarification of these discussions.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#19

Re: What would be the result.....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you have a stone that is 2X8, the flatness in length is unimportant. Across the width a slight depression in the middle imparts a camber to the blade, which is desirable. If the depression across the width is too great, the camber becomes more than is optimum for a smoother or a jointer. For this reason we concentrate on wearing the edges of the stone as we sharpen.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#20

Re: What would be the result.....

david charlesworth

Bill,

I really noticed the lack of flatness when preparing new wide chisel backs (faces).

When changing from one grit to another, different areas would be worked.

Now I know that some people can sharpen on dished stones, but I prefer flat ones.

David

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#21

fair enough

Bill Tindall

I can visualize the adverse effect on a wide flat surface. I can't on a bevel unless the abrasive surface was severely out of whack.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#22

Read my reply above.

wilbur

"....If the sharpening surface was not flat to 0.001". What I am failing to grasp is why flatness on the scale of thousandths of an inch across an 8 or 12" surface is important."

Again, the benefit of flatness is that it makes your sharpening more efficient, which is something that you say you are interested in accomplishing. If I have a sharpening process that is more than one step, like a series of diamond grits ending in 1 micron diamond paste, then the quickest way to progress through the steps is to have the surfaces of your sharpening medium flat. You could theoretically have three sharpening surfaces that are dished to the same degree, but I fail to see how this is easier to achieve than flattening the surfaces in the first place.

"I am skeptical that the typical woodworker has sharpening surfaces this flat or knows whether they do or not, in this age or in 1720."

Again, the surfaces of my waterstones are in the range of 0.001" after quickly going over them with a diamond plate. I don't consider myself to be particularly skilled, so if I can do it, I'm sure lots of other people can.

"Making stuff is hard enough without introducing unnecessary impediments to the process. If sharpening surfaces don't need to be on the order of 0.001" to fit a drawer with hand plane or pare a tenon with a chisel then the distinction of what can be achieved in stone flatness, and what is necessary to make stuff, needs the clarification of these discussions."

Your underlying assumption, Bill, is that flattening a sharpening surface is hard to do and an unnecessary impediment in the first place. I think that assumption is wrong. If you haven't done so, then watch the video I made and then see if you can still make the case that this 30 second task is either hard to do or an unnecessary impediment. In practice, the 30 seconds it takes for me to do this leads to faster sharpening, and 30 seconds is nowhere near an impediment to woodworking.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#23

David Barnett

Flatness is easily had, so why settle for less?

David Barnett

Which is to say, I agree fully, David.

I've had folks bring chisels and the stones upon which they sharpen them, that they thought, even swore, were flat, and have quickly demonstrated their misperception. I simply must conclude that some get it and some don't, and that a few who don't get it likely never will. Some blamed the chisel, some their stones (often rightfully), their jigs and all of the above.

Accomplishing this demonstation of producing acceptable and effective flatness for both stones and blade backs was easy with a single commercially available (less that $65) 600-grit diamond honing stone with a reasonble flatness of ±0.001". And you can go even cheaper with other methods and materials, of course.

One authority on sharpening wrote:

"Eventually stones wear from use. If they wore evenly there would be no problem, but they tend to wear most in the center; eventually a stone becomes so dished that it is impossible to hone a straight edge on it.

The easiest and fastest way to flatten any bench stone is to use a coarse diamond bench stone. If you can afford one, it is a wonderful luxury."



He further wrote:

"Traditionally, diamond stones have only been available in only relatively coarse grits (600x or less)... "

Note he considers 600-grit to be the upper limit for coarse diamond, which therefor could serve as a flattening stone for man-made (excepting diamond) abrasive stones and for mined stones such as Arkansas (novaculite), Welsh, Scottish, Turkish, Belgian and other natural stones, as well.

The nice thing is that 600-grit diamond stones are at the low end of medium diamond sharpening, allowing them to serve double duty for flattening other honing stones and for taking a tool straight from the grinder, round or flat, to the 600-grit diamond stone, then on to an iron lap charged with 14,000-grit diamond paste. Fast and entirely economical.

The quotes were from Leonard Lee.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#24

Re: What would be the result.....

TomD

"....If the sharpening surface was not flat to 0.001". What I am failing to grasp is why flatness on the scale of thousandths of an inch across an 8 or 12" surface is important. I am skeptical that the typical woodworker has sharpening surfaces this flat or knows whether they do or not, in this age or in 1720. How flat is a leather strop, or the piece of MDF or maple that some have used for charging diamond paste? The logical conclusion is that stone flatness on this scale is irrelevant to the making of furniture."

Certainly one thou over 8 inches is a working requirement in cabinetmaking. FWW had a good article back towards the beginning that showed how minor errors, that one associates with metal work are at play in woodwork. And woodworking tools easily maintain these thou like tolerances.

No question these tolerances were around in the 1720s, or whenever.

It may be true that not all tools require these tolerances in the stones. My thought though is that it is actually easier to hold to some higher level of accuracy than a lower one. Basically nature likes accuracy. While one does not need maybe a thou flat at times, a thou anything other than flat is way harder to hold. Having stones with dish that is dissimilar, which is probably what you would end up with just letting it ride, is a nightmare, that will hugely increase time to sharpen.

"Making stuff is hard enough without introducing unnecessary impediments to the process. If sharpening surfaces don't need to be on the order of 0.001" to fit a drawer with hand plane or pare a tenon with a chisel then the distinction of what can be achieved in stone flatness, and what is necessary to make stuff, needs the clarification of these discussions."

Commercially machinery is set up to good tolerances, so it would take time to do a bad job. In most stuff there is a speed where perfection is fastest, until you push things over the top then mistakes enter in. The sweet spot is normally a clean "perfect" job. Think of walking, weaving purposelessly will not get you there fastest. A good fast straight line is best. But if you push too hard, you will probably trip. This is what working for piecework wages teaches. When I used to tie flies for dough, I learned that the least number of wraps, perfectly applied was fastest, and made for the best job because weight can really harm some flies, as can bulk.

Since maintaining stones flat is the easiest option, and yields the fastest sharpening, I don't really see where speed or skill are an impediment to this process. One could probably come up with a whole sharpening method that would have no straight lines, though probably some consistent curves would help, and do just fine for most stuff. But that isn't where the craft has been, it could be done. The issue you are raising is whether using a straight line based mode is better when you are careless in method and maintenance, and I don't really see that.

Re: Sharpening medium flatness questionss

#25

Re: What would be the result.....

david charlesworth

Bill,

I totally agree that flatness is not so important for bevel sharpening.

Many years ago I used Soft Arkansas stones which hollowed a little after a year or two.

The trouble was so had the backs of all my chisels and plane blades........

I was curious to try Japanese waterstones when they arrived in this country, I flattened them and immediately discovered that the backs of all my blades were bellied. Wire edges were not floating away on the polishing stone. (I am pretty sure this is why the traditional woodworker was fond of a leather strop. It was finer than his fine stone and deformed to match the bellied back).

Bellies and stiction and brain strain, caused me to come up with the ruler trick.

David, I assume those quotes are from Leonard Lee's great book "Sharpening"?

best wishes,

David