New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Cutting gauges.....

Posts

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#26

One last modification (I hope)....

roger lance

Derek....there was one last possible source of a round brass knurled knob that would potentially work....


and low and behold!!....I think I have addressed the design concerns you expressed as well as I can....so on to other things....the brass strip for gauge #2 is on order from the local hardware and is suppose to be at the store tomorrow....looking forward to seeing your gauges.... :D . Thank you!

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#27

Re: One last modification (I hope)....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Nice Roger!

Where did you get them?

And tell us about the difference(s) in using the new shape compared to the old.

I hope mine turn out as nice as yours.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#28

Re: One last modification (I hope)....

roger lance

Derek....Surprisingly, these round brass knurled knobs came from the old Crown gauges ??!! Who would have thought that those knobs would be anything other than metric but they are 1/4"-20....and I replaced those knobs on the Crowns with the thumbscrews. The change in shape of the fence....especially the lowering of the top that fits under the butt of the hand....has made a tremendous improvement in comfort....and the shortening of the left side of the fence allows using your index finger to grab on that new surface and get a very secure grip. All in all, I'm very pleased with these gauges and am looking forward to making some dovetails with them....I know I'll have a special connection to these tools.

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#29

Re: Talking design ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Dear Derek,

I think you should have a close look at the pin in your Colin Clenton gauge.

It is ground freehand and not filed as the HSS would be too hard.

I have always considered them to be a toolmaker's work of art. The side opposite the flat has been sinificantly relieved, so that the cutting area is thin. This has also produced a crescent shaped edge which tends to ride smoothly on coarse grained timber.

It was a shame I could not persuade him to put the pin in at an angle, so that the cutting edge could be seen, but what the heck!

best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Hi David

Colen is a real free spirit - a gentleman who is very approachable and laid back in manner ... but he has very definite ideas and does voice them.

One of my fond memories is a Perth Woodshow I attended some years ago. Colen had shown an interest in one of my marking knives, and I had dropped off a couple with Terry Gordon, who always shares a booth with him, as Colen had gone walkabout. I returned later to find Colen staring at one of the knives. He grabbed me - did not look up to recognise it was me (I was just a passerby) - and said with passion .. "This is how you design a marking knife!". I could have kissed him.

I have a bunch of his squares as well as this particular cutting gauge. His work is first rate, as you know. Yet I do find some faults with the design of the gauge, as mentioned elsewhere.

So to the blade. I took some photos of it, as well as a similar one I made for a panel gauge I built.

Here is Colen's blade. As may be seen, it is a HSS rod that has been ground flat on the face ...


Here is a close up to show that the back is rounder than flat ..


The front profile is round, along the lines of a wheel gauge (but smaller) ...


Here is the blade I made. It is not nearly as nicely done (I freehanded it on a grinder to shape, then lapped it to finish) ...


I tried for a slimmer profile with a rounded tip ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#30

The photos, finally

Pam Niedermayer

Here you go. I decided to show a gauge I got with a bunch of planes just because it's wedged. There's no blade yet.


Pam

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#31

Returning to the original post.....

Bill Tindall

The stated use of the tool being made was for laying out drawers. It appeared that what was made and the discussions that followed was a detailed discussion of cutting gauges. As I understand it cutting gauges serve a different purpose than "marking gauges" that are used for layout and ,hence, the two have different designs.

Compare of the pictures posted to Will Neptune's marking gauge and contrast the differences.


The double taper knife enables this marking device to mark by pulling or pushing, one-handed. There are times when pushing and pulling are essential, such as marking between two reference points, and one handed is handy.

The thin and narrow knife enables deep penetration when that is desirable such as establishing a reference plane to pare or plane to.

The narrow beam enables good visibility, handy, if not essential, for some marking operations.

I would find the devices pictured inconvenient for typical layout, such as drawers.

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#32

Re: Returning to the original post.....

roger lance

It is my understanding that Cutting gauges (knife gauge) are intended for cross-grain marking like for dovetails on drawers....Marking gauges (pin gauge) are intended for with-the-grain marking like laying out mortise sides.

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#33

Re: Returning to the original post.....

Pam Niedermayer

I happily use my Kinshiro for all marking, measuring (that is, Not), and cutting tasks. It's never clumsy, the inner blade can be retracted, the L shaped knives cut like you'd want, it handles very wide needs, and I really like it.

Pam

PS Roger, I like the mods you made to yours

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#34

Re: Returning to the original post.....

Bill Tindall

No doubt somebody does, but I have never seen a furniture maker pick up a different device for marking what ever needed marking. For example Will said he had used the device pictured for 30 years and he marked every joint he demonstrated with it- cabinets, tables and chair joinery.

But the "proof is in the pudding". If the cutting gauge works handily that is all that counts. You now have an alternative to keep in the back of your mind if it doesn't. Personally, I use two of the "wheel" style marking devices. Their only shortcoming is they don't mark sufficiently deep unless they are kept sharp and more significant, the friction fit style is hard to precisely adjust(the two knurled adjuster style is easy to adjust). I intend to make a Neptune style to try. He adjusted it like one would adjust a wooden plane, by tapping the bream, again one handed. One handed operation is more than handy.

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#35

Re: The photos, finally

Jerry Gibbs

Thanks. Looks like the mark is on the underside of the board if you are looking down. Pam, I have always wondered if you are related to Scott and Rob? Jerry

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#36

Re: The photos, finally

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Does the curved rabbet help register the work? Make marking easier?

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#37

Re: The photos, finally

Pam Niedermayer

I've been told I'm not related to Scott. Who's Rob?

Pam

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#38

hockey playing brothers


Re: Cutting gauges.....

#39

Re: The photos, finally

Pam Niedermayer

I just received this gauge and haven't had time to set it up, thus I don't know what the curved rebate does. Maybe it's related to being a splitting gauge (wari-keshiki) for kumiko, turning the blade to follow the split. Maybe it's a holding convenience.

You have to hold it fairly tight to cut through 1.5/4" of softwood (one pass on each side of a 3/4" kumiko). Odate shows holding it with his left hand on top of all to press down with enough force.

Pam

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#40

Re: The photos, finally

TomD

Yeah, I think it is a splitting thing. In marking one can keep the fence perfectly aligned, and guide it. I personally find that I some times can pick up a line better when I skew the fence a lot. With the splitting gauge it is used to make one kind of cut, and a fair amount of force is used, so the rebate allows you to get onto that.

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#41

Re: The photos, finally

Pam Niedermayer

I've previously used the Kinshiro mortising gauge for slitting/cutting; but I think I may go buy a blade for this one, give it an honest tryout.

Pam

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#42

Re: The photos, finally

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

Thanks for the picture. It raises a question ..

Your grip is very different to mine. But then your gauge is different from mine in the blade adjustment area (I am referring to the original, not my copies). That is, yours has a wedge and mine a screw.

I wonder if you were taught that hand hold to manage with the wedge as you held it. The grip you use would neutralise any advantage of having an adjustment screw on the top in the case of my gauge.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#43

Re: The photos, finally

Pam Niedermayer

I hold the large Kinshiro the same way. If you try it, I think you'll find your grip much more relaxed and stable, thus easier to make a line.

Pam

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#44

Re: The photos, finally

TomD

One thing is that Japanese gauges have a rectangular beam, with a handward rounded edge, so that the beam will fit between the fingers with relative ease. On gauges with square beams this may not be as comfortable.

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#45

Re: The photos, finally

Pam Niedermayer

That's true, but if the beam is too thick I would simply allow my middle finger to rotate slightly back to accommodate, leaving my index finger in the same place. However, I have no such accommodation to make for the Kinshiro, which is a thicker beam due to the two blades being supported in the beam. I don't know of a gauge with a thicker beam.

Pam