New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Cutting gauges.....

Posts

Cutting gauges.....

#1

Cutting gauges.....

roger lance

Having recently gotten around to checking out a cutting gauge I had from a well known English maker, I found its quality to be very low. I also realized that I'd like a second gauge when making hand cut dovetails on drawers. So, I decided to make my own which resulted in these....


I used some hardware from LV....05H1005 brass thumbscrew....07P1553 cutting blade. Note the blade is tapered at about 7* so the kerf in the beam is also tapered to receive this blade....between the snugness of the kerf and a little tap on the top of the blade to wedge it, it is very well held. This has been a good simple project that saved a few dollars and resulted in a superior functioning tool over my Sheffield investment. Hope tool making does not turn into a slippery slope. :D

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#2

Re: Cutting gauges.....

Rob Lee

Excellent work, and an elegant design!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#3

Re: Cutting gauges.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

Those are excellent!

Indeed, they are very close to the design I have been planning. The important elements are a top screw position for one-handed tightening of the fence, an oval fence for greater registration, and a true cutting blade rather than a rod filed to a blade (since these will have a rounded back, which does not cut as cleanly). What I would like is a cut-out at the top of the fence for better grip.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#4

Re: Cutting gauges.....

roger lance

Derek....I'd be interested to see your cut out....I just attempted to photo my grip on the gauge which was an interesting experience (taking a photo left handed)....


I can see where some relief under my thump area would be more comfortable. I would also appreciate no "hairy beast" references or other such commentary. Thank you. :)

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#5

Re: Cutting gauges.....

TomD

I bought one of those knobs also, to retrofit on one of my gages where the hardware has worn out over the years. The knob will go on the side under your palm, rather than the top, though there is some risk it may interfere with the fence making contact with the work, however, it should be possible to get it to stop feathered the right way.

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#6

Re: Cutting gauges.....

George in Springtime Lowell, Mich.

Roger,

How did you cut the slot for your blade????

Work safe

George

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#7

And....

Bill Tindall

How about a description of the whole process, at least the non obvious parts? For example, sticking a piece of brass to a piece of wood is not obvious.

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#8

Re: Cutting gauges.....

roger lance

George....first I ripped a 7* pass on the beam stock on the table saw....then cut the slot kerf in the main piece on the band saw....then glued the two pieces back together....and cut the width of the beam to final dimension....and glued the fence together to tightly fit the beam....Note the threaded insert in the top piece of the unglued second fence....this receives the screw rod from the brass thumbscrew.....


hope this is understandable.....I live in Grand Rapids, we might know each other :)

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#9

Re: Cutting gauges.....

Pam Niedermayer

That's the "wrong" way to hold this gauge. You actually should place it in your upward facing palm, scissor hold the beam with your first and middle fingers, place your thumb on the top of the gauge on the opposite side of the screw, then pull the gauge toward you.

Here's a photo of a Kinshiro gauge. He's the master imo.


Pam

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#10

Re: And....

roger lance

Bill....the attaching of the brass strip to the beam is definitely experimental for me....thought I'd use epoxy but was persuaded to use a glue that bonds to both metal and wood....if this fails (so far, so good), the brass strip is thick and I'll drill and attach it with brass screws.

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#11

Re: Cutting gauges.....

roger lance

Pam....I'd like to see a photo of that grip....thanks.

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#13

Re: Cutting gauges.....

roger lance

Pam....this is somewhat like what you've described except still palm down....


Re: Cutting gauges.....

#14

Re: Fitting the blade

TomD

On the japanese ones they just drill a hole at the fatter blade edge, then they must use something like a fret saw to open it up. I've done that, and I don't remember it being a hassle. On the Japanese ones, the blade is tapered, and the wedging action needs to be mostly along the length of the beam or it will split.

Also, on the Japanese ones, the blade normally is a lot closer to the end of the beam. That may not be an issue, but if it is, it can be nearer than seen here.

Further. The one I have that adjusts best, has a metal pressure plate the screw bears on. That plate has a wide footing on the beam which is just oak. That makes a very smoothly micro adjustable, slide. Can't think of anything that would work better. would like to believe the wedges worked better, they have at times in other applications, but this simple metal on wood design is the best I have used.

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#15

Re: Cutting gauges.....

TomD

That is how I hold it, though maybe a little less clenched. Not sure how that is palm up though. I looked at a ton of Japanese videos, and couldn't find an example.

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#16

Re: Roger.....

George in almost Spring Lowell, Mich.

Our paths haven't crossed that I'm aware.

I have to ask....Are you a hand model? I don't see any scars or cuts or scabs from previous blood donations to projects.

I always end my posts with "Work safe" but I don't seem to take my advice.....

Work safe,

George

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#17

Re: Cutting gauges.....

Pam Niedermayer

Rotate the gauge 90° so that the screw is further from your hand and unclench. I've got the camera battery charging up, so should be able to make a photo tomorrow.

Pam

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#18

Talking design ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

While I think that your gauges are excellent - I really mean that. I could happily live with them - there are features I would change in my ideal gauge.

Firstly, I like a gauge with a true knife. This gets can cut a finer line compared to a steel rod that is flattened on the front, since its rear remains rounded and thick. Ideally a V end allows for being used in either direction.

Secondly, the knob needs to be on the top, where it is easy to adjust while holding the gauge in one hand (and the other left for the work piece). It also needs to be a round knob, not a thumbscrew (which may be easier to grip but is not as easy to adjust with fingertips).

Thirdly, the hand needs to wrap around the front so that the grip is firm as you pull the gauge backwards/towards yourself. This requires that the profile of the fence is lower under the heel of the hand, and that there is a grip area for the fingers.

Like Pam, I think the Kinshiro rocks. It incorporates all these features. One is below, alongside a Colen Clenton. The CC looks amazing but, in my opinion, gets the design elements wrong (side knob, which ensures the gauge can only be worked using two hands, and which is non-knurled and so slippery - and a rod-turned-blade).

Both are comfortable to hold and a pleasure to use (the CCs faults notwithstanding).



Here are images of my non-model hand holding these gauges ...





For comparison, here is a Tite-Mark ...

Gripped more delicately, with a round cutter (=wide), and thus able to effect less downforce.



Hopefully I will get a chance this weekend to built a couple of gauges. I am inspired by yours.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#19

Re: Talking design ...

roger lance

Derek....I looked about to find a round brass knurled fitting but had no luck locating anything suitable (perhaps LV will have an offering in future)....the knife blade I used from LV seems to be cutting well and I have a friend who does metal work so maybe in future I might make a blade or two with his help....I see how the shortened side of the Kinshiro fence can be used in gripping the gauge (modification of my fence is always a possibility)....looking forward to seeing your gauges.

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#21

Re: Talking design ...

TomD

I'm happier with the Knob not on the top. I want it where it is least in the way when used, not least in the way when adjusting. With the right drag, I just set the knob a little open, and the beam will adjust stay put, could even be used without tightening, though I mostly do. Part of the reason I like the knob on the horizontal plane, is it seems to be more scure on the beam since it is tightening the beam against the drag direction, and in the case of the beams I prefer, holding it against a curved surface where it stabilizes nicely. Doubtless there are other arrangement that work well also, but I wouldn't put them ahead of a clearly workable system.

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=50263&cat=1,42936

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#22

Re: Talking design ...

TomD

It should be easy to make a little blade for a gage. A propane torch would be enough for the heat treating. If you are in search of quality knives, I have used these ones:

http://www.japanwoodworker.com/dept.asp?s=JapanWoodworker&dept_id=12996

The Blade I have used the most is crazy cheap though, it is hard to tell if it was even hardened, works great so far. I've had it about 30 years, and it still has some life left in it. O1 would be a clear upgrade.

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#23

Fence design modification made....

roger lance

Derek & Pam....borrowing from Kinshiro, I made the following modification to fence #2....


also, hopefully this photo will show the glue line in the end of the beam that creates the 7* wedge in the blade slot....

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#24

Re: Talking design ...

david charlesworth

Dear Derek,

I think you should have a close look at the pin in your Colin Clenton gauge.

It is ground freehand and not filed as the HSS would be too hard.

I have always considered them to be a toolmaker's work of art. The side opposite the flat has been sinificantly relieved, so that the cutting area is thin. This has also produced a crescent shaped edge which tends to ride smoothly on coarse grained timber.

It was a shame I could not persuade him to put the pin in at an angle, so that the cutting edge could be seen, but what the heck!

best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Cutting gauges.....

#25

Re: Fence design modification made....

roger lance

Pam....the increased slope on top of the gauge (Kinshiro-ish) makes this a more comfortable grip....


I like the alteration to the fence....Kinshiro gave me some direction....there is still good registration of the gauge with the work....there is another way to grip the gauge with the shortened left side of the fence....and the increased slope and rounding of the top of the fence is more comfortable.