New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Diamond sharpening *LINK*

Posts

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#51

David Barnett

Apparently Canadians aren't nearly so fussy... *LINK*

David Barnett

...picky, finicky, argumentative and cantankerous as their lower-48 counterparts. Both Rob and Derek had a far more agreeable time of things on the Hand Tools forum of Canadian Woodworking & Home Improvement.

All I can offer at this point is mea culpa, guys!


Thoughts on new Lee Valley sharpening package

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#52

David Barnett

No shame. Different strokes, horses for courses


Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#53

Re: Focusing on the less significant metrics

Bill White

Whoa!!! No mud slinging here. Just time/results question.

Bill

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#54

Re: Focusing on the less significant metrics

david weaver

Well, we are in agreement about quick.

I can't think of much quicker than two stones and a grinder, or straight off the grinder only one stone.

I don't think, though, that any of the masters at any point did their fine work with marginally sharp tools, though.

And I can't think of a good reason why a new woodworker wouldn't want to take advantage of sharpness if it can be done quickly.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#55

WC is different

Bill Tindall

When I am directed to another Forum on some topic being discussed here I usually find that the depth of the technical expertise and hence the technical depth of the discussion is greater here on WC. The other Forums may be nice places to chat but WC is the place to go for in depth expertise on a topic.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#56

Re: Focusing on the less significant metrics

Charles

David, I don't doubt that techniques and implements may have been lost to history.

My basic method of honing has been a settled issue for many years. I'm not revisiting it, even if something is represented as the sharpening equivalent of the Second Coming of Jesus Christ. Which it often is. Which is what I hate the most.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#57

Re: Higher levels of woodworking precision...

Charles

I've been using a mortise chisel to chop bulk dovetail waste for practically as long as I can remember. I'm not claiming that this makes me the woodworking equivalent of Will Neptune. I'm not. But using a beater chisel, or a strong chisel like a mortise chisel, for chopping bulk material while reserving the edge of a finely ground paring chisel for final cleanup certainly shouldn't be viewed as groundbreaking technique. At least I hope it isn't. That's pretty common sense stuff I think. Who wouldn't get tired of folding the edge of a paring chisel ground at 15*. It took me about two seconds to figure that out and I'm as dense as they come. 'Course most of you guys seem to put 30*+ secondaries on everything. Which is the essence of ludicrous.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#58

David Barnett

The Art of Generalization

David Barnett

"'Course most of you guys seem to put 30*+ secondaries on everything. Which is the essence of ludicrous."

We do? On everything? Most of us? :)

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#59

Re: The Art of Generalization

Charles

Yup.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#60

Re: Focusing on the less significant metrics

Pam Niedermayer

It may well be the answer if you're using tools made of more exotic steel, such as HSS, A2, PM, etc. If you're not, if you're using the O1/W1 our ancestors used, you don't need diamond sharpening methods.

Pam

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#61

Re: The Art of Generalization

Pam Niedermayer

Well, that's just not fair. How about all those visitors who never chip in to the threads recommending steep angled bevels? I'd say that's most of us. I know it includes me, who just got tired of debating the issue.

Pam

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#62

Re: Focusing on the less significant metrics

Charles

No doubt you're right. Moving to these new steels requires different media. I don't think oilstones would be very effective. At that point, assuming you didn't want to get rid of your oilstone setup, then you have to get a new series of media (from coarse to fine) to handle the "new" steel. Seems a little overwrought to me but I'm a Simpleton - every chisel I own will fill fit in my shop apron. I have enough trouble wielding the meager inventory I do own with any aplomb. Owning more would just accentuate my ineptitude and lighten my wallet unnecessarily.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#63

Re: The Art of Generalization

Charles

Well, it was an obvious generalization to an extent. I think most woodworkers' chisel inventory tends to obtuse end of the spectrum - especially the relative newcomer who is still a little scared of sharpening or who have not figured out a routine for quick hones to keep more thinly ground chisels going during the day.

I can't stand trying to power obtuse wedges through wood. It makes no sense.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#64

Re: Focusing on the less significant metrics

Pam Niedermayer

Charles, I did not, repeat NOT, suggest that you should buy more tools; nor did I recommend which steel they should be made of. Claro? I simply explained why you and several others, including me, don't need to worry about this at this point in time.

I may later this year when, as planned, I start trying to make some chisels from CPM; and even then I seriously hope my waterstones will work, but I don't expect them to.

Pam

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#65

Re: The Art of Generalization

David Weaver

Who are the people on here who use secondary bevels of 30+?

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#66

Re: The Art of Generalization

Charles

Too numerous to mention. Search for yourself.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#67

Re: Focusing on the less significant metrics

Charles

I definitely didn't mean to imply that you did. I was just agreeing with you more or less by example.

Thanks.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#68

With plates jigs are unnecessary even for novices

Bill Tindall

One of the most significant advantages of loose diamonds on cast iron (and perhaps on the LV steel?) is the ease with which the bevel of a tool can be kept securely registered against the plate surface during sharpening. I have not failed to quickly teach a novice to sharpen this way on cast iron with out a jig.

The physics, for those inclined, is just like gluing two surfaces together with the lubricant acting as the "glue" . Except in this case the "glue" has no shear strength and the friction of tool on plate is minimal. This situation enables the tool bevel to suck into registration and stay there while moving the tool about the plate to abrade it. If I was selling plates this would be the advantage, along with cost and speed, that I would emphasize.

I would find that taking up a substantial part of what I consider an already too short plate with a jig an unacceptable limitation. Anyone making their own plates should make them 12" long.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#69

Re: Patent applied for

TomD

I think the deal here is the same as one I recommended a long time ago for sharpening on sandpaper. We need a version of the LV jig that works side to side. Or best might be one that works in all directions (how about magnetic flotation?) I sharpen freehand whenever possible, but there can be cases where it is faster not to, and it is also probably necessary for race tool use. You can easily get a good working edge freehand, but can you work your way through all steps of stones up to say 30K without good optics and/or a jig. And they can also speed up some repairs, and then some people just prefer jigs. A side to side jig would allow one to use sandpaper for sharpening, one could maybe use it on a belt sander, or flat wheel, and it would allow one to use all of a plate by riding an uncoated side, or riding a plate set next to the charged plate (opportunity to sell a fourth plate!).

My patent attorney/brother in law is conveniently located in Ottawa, at least until the divorce comes through...

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#70

Re: With plates jigs are unnecessary even for novi

Pam Niedermayer

Does it matter in which orientation you place blade and plate? Side to side (blade bevel aligned with the longest plate part)? Or forward and/or back?

Pam

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#71

Re: With plates jigs are unnecessary even for novi

TomD

Are you talking about my thing, or their thing? I think you could have a point with reach on some cuts.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#72

Re: With plates jigs are unnecessary even for novi

Pam Niedermayer

I responded to Bill's message about diamonds, metal plates, and sucking; but I suppose it could be a question for you, too, except you were talking side to side on sandpaper with a jig. :)

Pam