New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Diamond sharpening *LINK*

Posts

Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#1

Diamond sharpening *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Looks like Lee Valley is responding to the cries of those who wish someone would provide a ferrous substrate for diamond sharpening.

Let the conversation begin...


...after you look here

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#2

Re: Diamond sharpening, ok here we go...

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Ok, I'll bite,

Steel vs cast iron, good, bad, differences?

0.005" flatness across the plate, good, bad, good enough?

Bob in NJ

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#3

Re: Diamond sharpening, ok here we go...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bob

This is a copy of a reply I made on SMC (and not edited the content):

I did some pre-production testing on these plates. They are steel rather than the traditional cast iron. Comparing the steel plate with my cast iron plates, I actually came to prefer these steel plates. They are good.

What is "good"? They are flat and they take and hold the diamond paste very well.

The way they are used is that one smears a little paste over the plate, about a pea altogether. Spread it out and try and push it into the plate. If your (oil-based) paste is too thick, thin it with a little mineral oil (e.g. baby oil). The aim is to embed the diamond in the paste. This effectively creates a diamond plate. When you run a blade over the plate, the diamonds cut as they partially project. You do not end up wearing the plate as the diamonds are fixed - in comparison to "loose diamonds", which roll around.

The good news is that these plates work fantastically ... with the appropriate grits. I use 40 micron for grinding (e.g. lapping the backs of blades - fantastic for chisels), then 15, 3, and 0.5 microns as a sharpening system. This equates to waterstones of 1000, 3000 and 15000 grit.

Diamond paste is a great medium - possibly the only medium - for PM steels and HSS. Of course it will work well on all steel as well.

I would not rush and get rid of your Norton waterstones just yet. As good as the diamond paste is, it is not without weaknesses.

The issues ..

Firstly, diamond paste can be messy. Not the splashy type messy, but greasy type messy when you are setting it up. Once I have a charged plate I wipe away the residue since what is relevant is the diamond that is embedded in the plate not the paste on top. (I have used taken plates to wood shows when I do a hand tool demonstration, and I get really weird looks when others see me honing a blade on what looks like bare steel).

Secondly, I would be very cautious about using a honing guide on a plate with paste as it can migrate into the wheels and wear the bearings. Further, it will migrate to and contaminate the other plates. I wipe blades down carefully between plates. I only freehand on diamond paste. To use a honing guide on these plates I section off an area with tape for the wheels to run, which s free of paste. This means that the blade will not be able to have much back-and-forth space, but diamonds cut fast and you do not need more.

I think that most should try diamond paste as it can offer so much. However it will never replace waterstones, or even oil stones, if the current regime is already satisfying the user.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#4

Re: Diamond sharpening

Bruce Mack

I just ordered the set. It will join the many stones, plates, and gadgets I already own. Sharpening is a compulsion and Lee Valley has brought new fun to the pursuit.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#5

David Barnett

My take

David Barnett

Personally, I think Lee Valley half-assed this one. I would have much rather they'd offer smooth surfaced cast grey iron. Low-carbon steel is soft enough to capture diamond, but not nearly so effectively as cast iron. Cast iron has the high graphite content and grain structure that best facilitates diamond lapping. Soft steel simply does not. Copper is better. Several other metal and non-metal substrates are better, in fact, but steel will work. I also prefer polished smooth cast iron surfaces rather than 'textured' surface grinder patterns.

Others will differ, and that's fine. Derek prefers these plates, I prefer cast iron, but both will work, which really is the point, so the takeaway is that using diamond on any adequate substrate is versatile, fast and cheap.

One very economical solution (assuming you choose to go with steel) is to buy a 600-grit EZ-lap polycrystalline diamond stone. The steel back could be prepared and used for 1µ diamond paste, which would be all anyone would need to hone chisels and plane blades. You'd have a complete two-sided honing system.

For others who have yet to try diamond and chooses to forego cast iron, I'd say buy one LV plate and a tube of 1µ diamond past. That's all you'd really need as a fine hone. For a medium hone, buy a 600-grit DMT, Norton, or EZ-lap (my preference) diamond stone and you're good to go.

For grinding primary bevels by hand, you could use coarse stones of other abrasives, whether oil or water, scarysharp with coarse abrasive papers, or for power, choose a belt sander for flat grinding bevels - the 1" version Lee Valley sells is fine - or hollow grind with a bench grinder. You can progress straight from coarse grinding to the 600-grit diamond stone to final honing on a plate charged with 1µ diamond paste. That's it. It really is that easy.

Another advantage, by using only one diamond paste of a single mesh size, you eliminate any contamination from other diamond compounds in larger mesh sizes, which can and does happen when you are less than fastidious in segregating diamond compounds or loose grit.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#6

Re: My take

Rob Lee

"Half-assed" - really??? That's just a tad presumptuous - no?

You have no idea what material we tested, and what we chose. This isn't any 'ole off-the-shelf-whatever's-in-stock plate steel. Cast iron has different issues - it's not all about bedding.

I understand different preferences - we cater to them.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#7

David Barnett

My take on your take on my take

David Barnett

Sorry Rob, I really didn't intend to get under your skin and meant no malice. You know how I respect and recommend Lee Valley tools and am an enthusiastic long-term customer. What I stated was my opinion, nothing more, nothing less, which is what Bill asked for when he keynoted: "Let the conversation begin"



"You have no idea what material we tested, and what we chose."

No, I do not know your material selection protocol or your reason for choosing your particular surface finish.

"This isn't any 'ole off-the-shelf-whatever's-in-stock plate steel. Cast iron has different issues - it's not all about bedding."

I do know that industrial cast iron laps aren't exactly cheap to produce and that the now-extinct Harris laps were expensive to manufacture and finish, so it'd be natural and reasonable to assume price points, profitability and other economic factors would figure into your decision. To be fair, I never (nor thought) said you picked up whatever steel stock was lying about.

"I understand different preferences - we cater to them, but there's no reason to be dismissive of other peoples preferences or methods of work."



And I said:

"Others will differ, and that's fine. Derek prefers these plates, I prefer cast iron, but both will work, which really is the point, so the takeaway is that using diamond on any adequate substrate is versatile, fast and cheap."

I'm not sure that's entirely dismissive. But sure there are reasons to eschew other's "preferences and methods of work" if you honestly disagree with those choices. Honest disagreement and argument is entirely fair, and I would say not at all inappropriate to an well-run open woodworking forum.

Again, I'm sorry if my diction and tone offended you, but it's my opinion that steel for diamond laps is inferior. Perhaps I'm more narrowly informed by my gem cutting, faceting and polishing background, where, I think you'd find, others would tend to agree with me. How many gem faceters choose steel laps for diamond? Can you name even one commercial faceting lap that is surface ground steel?

Perhaps you could tell us why steel is superior or at least as good as cast iron, and why machinists, lapidaries and solid-state physicists have held otherwise for so many decades? If your explanation is your steel and finish is "good enough", especially at your price point, I could understand that.

If you'd rather I said "fell short of the mark" or "dropped the ball", so be it, but that doesn't change my opinion of your choice to go with steel over cast iron, at a price I personally would be uncomfortable paying - something I didn't say in my original post, you'll note. So I still say there remains a niche, an enterprise opportunity for someone to offer properly finished cast grey iron laps to woodworkers.

Finally, I haven't tried one of your laps, so everyone should take that into account.

""Half-assed" - really??? That's just a tad presumptuous - no?"

Probably. Okay. Probably more than a tad. Yeah.

But for better or worse, that's my half-assed reply.

Kumbaya,

David

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#8

Re: My take of your take on my take

Rob Lee

David -

No sweat - must had too many coffee's. I should have waited a bit longer before replying...

(Everyone knows we *always* try to do things fully-assed.... :D )

Yes - Cast iron is preferable to steel in many ways for lapping - but not for all form factors. These plates are designed for portability, flatness (stability), and to meet a price point too. We already make an iron lap, and have been selling it for many years. I doubt there are many people that would buy 3 at $89 no matter how good a price that is (and it IS good value for what it is....).

Grey cast iron in thin sections is just not a great choice for for a flat and stable lap - particularly in the sizes we have on offer here.

The soft steel we have selected works well as a lap. It's not short of the mark - it's just a different mark entirely.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#9

Re: My take

TomD

"I also prefer polished smooth cast iron surfaces rather than 'textured' surface grinder patterns."

You would love a surface from a shaper, mirror smooth if you want, and no texture. They used to use shapers to prepare welding coupons since they could fail if the surface was textured, rather than due to a flaw in the weld.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#10

Re: My take of your take on my take

david weaver

I have the cast lap. I would love it for diamonds if I could lap the grooves out of it. They are a bit deep to hand lap out, though!

I understand the purpose of the grooves, but it's been in my sharpening bench nether region for years because I can't keep the abrasive on it (it just goes into those grooves and oozes out).

Is there a chance that the ground stock may come as a polished option in the future for an extra ten bucks or whatever? What's always bugged me with mild steel and tool steel is that it's a lot of work to do the surface to a more polished state and keep it flat, but when they're fresh with grinding marks, and the diamond grit is small, somehow it gives me the feeling like i'm dragging a galvanized bucket across my front teeth.

And I'm assuming it's doing something to the edge, but that could be hokey jedi mind tricks i'm performing on myself (presumably you guys looked at the results off a polished plate and a rotary ground plate under a microscope).

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#11

Re: My take on What's New

TomD

As one who follows the "What's New" section avidly, I also noticed the dual shaft clamp added. Did you consider making the double beam gage double ended, with a blade width offset so one end would mark the outside and the other end automatically mark the inside (tenon, mortise). I know that if you add too many blades and fences you run the risk of running into the province of April 1, but I actually think such a thing would be useful.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#12

David Barnett

Re: Re: My take of your take on my take

David Barnett

Hey, you were being totally fair! You introduce something you're proud of, that represents real effort and investment, and some overbearing loudmouth with no skin in the game tromps all over your nasturtiums.

Anyway, makes total sense to me, Rob. Yeah, I'd opt for iron, but there are such things as viability and feasibility. Cheaper beats most criteria as long as adequacy is preserved, however, and most souls will be happy with ready availability at a reasonable price. I get that. And anyway, steel sure as hell beats most of the bonehead substrate alternatives I've seen (and tried).

I do wonder about the texture for 1μ and smaller, but as I recall, Bill Tindall had his plates Blanchard ground and only uses 1μ in his everyday sharpening regimen.

It really is all about having fun and getting great results quickly, and most will never care one way or the other if they get those results from steel or iron.

Monday evening I spent an hour teaching a house guest to sharpen knives, a few handyman, gardening and household tools. He'd never been able to sharpen anything at all. One hour later and you can see his eyes scanning for stuff to sharpen. Anything. Pointed him to LV on his iPad. Now he's telling me he always wanted to learn to carve, and make stuff, and on and on.

Diamond is definitely the future. Another thing I've been doing is charging 1x42" belts with diamond paste. Yikes!

Lately, I've been releasing my inner curmudgeon and have been purposely prickly bordering on the insulting (no! really?). I'm not an emoticon kinda guy, so people might not know I'm almost always laughing and having fun. Sometimes I forget people can't tell this, but that's never stopped me.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#13

Re: My take of your take on my take

TomD

Polished might or not mean flat. Shaper is where it is at. I have a shaper video up, but it is not doing a polished cut, you can see what is left of a previous polished cut, while it beavers away. That is also aluminum, so the cutter geometry would have to be altered, but that's no biggie. There are lots of these things around, someone in your neighborhood probably has a bigun.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3lx_2uBIp0c&context=C4cb326cADvjVQa1PpcFM94tyKIRBi2r_vmWcm3S4gZhcFEPHc0QI=

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#14

David Barnett

Ah... the shaper

David Barnett

The most graceful, relentless beast among machine tools. When I was a child growing up in St. Louis, our school took field trips to various area factories. I remember my fascination with a behemoth shaper at the railroad yards. For some reason, the sheer power and ease that it shaved metal beat even the flashier lathes and mills. I was told shapers kind of fell out of fashion for awhile but are making a comeback as old ones are being brought back to life. I saw a YouTube video where a shaper cuts a dead flat and almost finished surface and looked like it was hogging off metal when it did it. Amazing.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#15

Re: Ah... the shaper

TomD

I ran into a guy who's dad ran a shaper when he was an apprentice, and it was so large there was a seat on the head, and the guy who turned the downfeed knob actually rode the thing.

One can get a pretty nice shaper for about the price of a 51 without the table.

LV sells the Bull of the Woods series of machinist cartoons. There is a machine in there that has a table that spins like a record player, and there is a gantry over the top of it that holds the tool. The guy operating that had to walk with the wheel as it turns. Or so it seems. Looks like suicide.

Here is a nice southing shaper video:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oZFFYIvTLiE

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#16

Re: Re: My take of your take on my take

TomD

The economic aspect that interests me is why steel is cheaper than iron in the first place. I don't really care, the world is what it is, but it remains a useful material, and it is not that easy to get for any of the many things for which it excels. Sewer pipe aside.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#17

Blanchard Grinding and 1 micron

Steve Elliott

Dave Barnett wrote:

"I do wonder about the texture for 1μ and smaller, but as I recall, Bill Tindall had his plates Blanchard ground and only uses 1μ in his everyday sharpening regimen."

Bill had his plates surface ground, it was me who went with Blanchard grinding. Now that I've used a plate for a number of years, mostly with 1 micron, it is almost smooth and has a softer feel than a plate direct from the Blanchard grinder.

I've tried diamond on a kanaban plate (mild steel, I believe) and liked cast iron better but the difference wasn't that great. I'd take the smooth steel plate over the grooved cast iron plate any day for final honing.

At first I thought the flatness spec was not good enough for blade backs, but after thinking it over I realized there's a way to take advantage of a not-quite-flat plate. For the coarsest abrasive I'd use the convex side of the plate, which would put a tiny amount of hollow on the blade back. Progressing to a flatter plate and a finer abrasive, the edges would be the first areas to get the desired fine polish. The middle of the back doesn't matter.

I'm glad Lee Valley is offering these plates.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#19

setting the record straight

Bill Tindall

The first plates I made nearly 10 years ago, and reported here, were surface ground cast iron. The larger batch that followed were Blanchard ground because it was cheaper and adequate. At the time it was not difficult to find sources of inexpensive continuously cast, cast iron bar stock ideal for plates. Slice, grind and done. This plate making occurred many years ago when the idea was dismissed by most. My early surface ground plates have become contaminated, something I consider one must take into account in developing a strategy for using loose diamond. The problem is discussed more than 50 years ago in a machinist handbook. (There isn't anything here I invented,)

For the past many years I have been using a single Blanchard ground plate(to avoid carry-over contamination) and it is adequate for my sharpening. On numerous occasions I have described what I found efficient and effective. I found it interesting that Will Neptune uses an identical strategy except he finishes with a black ARK stone and I use a black piece of cast iron.

I have not used a Lee Valley plate so I have no idea how it compares to the material preferred for diamond grinding for the past 400 years. I asked the companies selling diamond for metal polishing what to use and went with that recommendation without any further evaluation. Since, I have evaluated a great many materials and they all fall short in one critical area. Everything else I have tried is more grabby than steel sliding on cast iron and, hence, free hand control suffers.

I don't understand the angst over plate flatness. Given the rate at which traditional water stones wear away it would not take a stringent flatness specification to achieve the flatness of a slightly used water stone. Nor do I see any practical need for such flatness given the tiny amount of the plate occupied at any instant by the stuff being sharpened.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#20

Question, Rob...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Grey cast iron in thin sections is just not a great choice for for a flat and stable lap

What thickness is needed to make a stable lap? Can you elaborate a bit?

Thnx,

DC

Go Habs go... Golfing :(

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#21

Re: Yet further afield

TomD

Wow, some nice stuff there! Here is a pretty bigun:

http://www.practicalmachinist.com/vb/attachments/f19/49475d1332979291-huge-shapers-shaper.jpg

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#22

Re: Question, Rob...

TomD

Maybe 3/4" There is no magic number since it depends on everything. My cast iron surface plate depends mostly on ribbing. If you wanted to stiffen up something thin, like an old plane body, just casting in some epoxy would get er done. Needs to be decent stuff though, since some of the cheaper stuff is fairly flexible. With the right approach one might be able to dump the metal, the rusting, the weight and the cold.

Here is a base for a CNC machine made out of epoxy granite.

http://forums.reprap.org/file.php?148,file=531,filename=cncrouteruj1.jpg

http://www.cnczone.com/forums/epoxy_granite/30155-epoxy-granite_machine_bases_polymer_concrete.html

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#23

Re: Yet further afield

TomD

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xFcMdi88wWU&feature=channel

Skip to about 3:00

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#24

Thickness of Cast Iron Plate

Steve Elliott

I've been using a plate that is 5/16 x 2-1/2 x 8" and haven't seen any change in surface flatness except for the tiny amount due to wear from the diamond. I've been a little concerned that the relatively thin cast iron might break if dropped the way a gray cast iron plane body would, but any oil- or waterstone would likely break if that happened, too.

My first plate was from Harris Tools and it was both wider and thicker than I like. I've tried a 2-1/4" wide plate and it was a little too narrow for me, but with a 3" width there is always one side of the plate that isn't being used, which contributes to dishing of the middle of the plate.

One thing I like about the new Lee Valley steel plates is that I could use a hacksaw to make one narrower.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#25

Re: Question, Rob...

Rob Lee

Hi Denis -

Tough to guess - but if I had to, I'd want something like an inch of thickness per foot of length. Doesn't have to be solid - it can be webbed.

Cheers -

Rob

(who also forgot to wish you a "Happy Leafs Elimination Day" )