New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Diamond sharpening *LINK*

Posts

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#26

Re: Re: My take of your take on my take

Rob Lee

David -

Good obervations. The surface of the plates is finished to RMS 63 or better. The finish will also "wear-in" with use, but it's quite a fine surface to begin with - the photos are a bit deceptive, making the grind marks look more pronounced than they are.

At RMS 63, the grooves are still deeper than 1 micron, yet the laps work effectively, even with .1 micron grit. One might intuit that the grit "rolls" to the bottom of a groove and stays there - this does not appear to be the case. It seems to bed everwhere.

I'll load up some photos and 3-D surface plots in a few minutes, once I get them on our server, and you can see that finished surfaces - we shot ground cast iron in addition to the chosen steel.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#28

Re: Yet further afield

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Wow! That must have been hogging off at 1/8" or more.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#29

Focusing on the less significant metrics

Bill Tindall

Absent in this discussion is any quantitative comparison, or even opinion, on the two most important attributes for a substrate for diamond paste. Flatness and scratch depth resulting from inexpensive Blanchard grinding of cast iron is sufficient as demonstrated by many years experience in several shops. It would be reasonable to presume the same would be true for a steel plate. It is not these comparisons that I consider important.

What is of critical importance is how securely the loose diamond particles embed in the substrate. If they don't embed, and roll around, the substrate will wear. Consider that glass has been sold as a substrate which is an especially flawed choice. So that fact that something is sold doesn't mean it is best or even adequate.

As important as embedding, the particles embedded must stick up enough to be effective. Soft substrates waste diamonds when the diamonds become uselessly buried in the substrate.

From all I could gather when researching this approach for abrading abrasion resistant steel, cast iron is the optimum substrate. If someone proposes a new substrate then the question of how it compares to the traditionally used cast iron with regard to these factors should be anticipated, and answered, or the questions will linger.

A less obvious criteria will quickly become so with jigless, free-hand sharpening. If the tool sucks flat on the substrate and glides smoothly across it even an inexperienced sharpener can enjoy the benefits of quick and easy jig-free sharpening. Tools suck into flat registration and slide smoothly on cast iron lubed with ample WD 40. Many substrates fail in this regard.

Using loose diamonds in sharpening has some substantial advantages which I have reported previously. There are also some things one needs to know and use to become satisfied with the technique. A successful technique practiced in a flawed manner may not lead to a satisfactory result. I am going to suggest to those willing to try loose diamonds (diamond paste) that these factors are important- substrate, diamond particle size, plate charging procedure and amount, plate contamination, lubrication. When I have given someone a plate the plate comes with extensive discussion of these factors. Successfully practiced the procedure is quick, easy, cheap and not messy. If your results vary then you may not be using the optimum technique.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#30

David Barnett

Thanks for your answer, & a couple more questions

David Barnett

I can well-believe there will be some sharpening taking place even though the 1-micron diamond particles are below the the trench line, sort of like brave little soldiers exposing themselves to take quick shots at the enemy. However, if the diamond is bedding on the exposed surfaces, the higher lines left by machining, how do the plates wear down in an even manner if the diamonds are well-bedded and doing their job? I'm trying to imagine this from a diamond crystal's point of view, of course, the way gem cutters are taught to analyse things.

Also, when the machining scratches do wear down to where the rank and file diamond particles are more exposed, will the resulting wear be even enough edge-to-edge across the entire steel plate that any localized recesses caused by uneven wear might significantly affect the overall flatness of the plate further affecting uneven bevel grinding results from such dishing? (Sorry, for that strenously worded sentence, but I hope you'll understand it nevertheless.)

And another thing, diamond compounds/pastes have a range of diamond particle sizes, not just one homogenous particle size. Of course, it's the larger outliers that one hopes are few enough and easily fractured to harmlessness. I do appreciate that you are offering monocrystalline diamond in your compounds, which may be a better match than my favored polycrystallines. At any rate, cast iron usually has advantages here, IMO.

Lastly, although you address cross-contamination in your instructions, a very real and likely-to-be-encountered problem especially for beginners with only cursory training, you show sharpening using a plate-riding sharpening jig but fail to mention that such a jig would be a major cross-contaminator when used on more than one stone with more than one diamond mesh size -- obviously, three jigs for three stones would solve this. :) Even the hardened steel bevels and backs of hand tool blades perpetuate cross-contamination with less than consistent and solid technique to control this.

It's not Lee Valley's responsibility to thoroughly train the purchaser, of course, but I could imagine beginners using more than just one stone with one diamond mesh becoming discouraged with ensuing results leading to incorrectly-based assumptions. They might quickly conclude that diamond is not for them, which in this case, might be an accurate assumption, but they might also wrongly conclude that diamond is inferior or does not work at all, and nobody wants that. Just speculating, here, but wonder if addressing this issue in more detail might be helpful. You guys are pretty experienced in these matters, having the best customer service in this regard bar none. I may be over-thinking this, of course, although it did give me pause so thought I'd mention it.

Thanks also for the photos and the effort in posting them, although I'm not exactly sure how I'd interpret them. I hope Steve Elliot will weigh in here. I do know that what I assume to be 63 RMA looks different than 25 RMA under my microscope. The plots are truly interesting. What a great way to show surface characteristics and distribuition features.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#31

I have a question, Bill

les winter

I am using a cast iron plate with 1 micron paste. Works as advertised. My chisels and plane irons are A2. If I come off the waterstones with a burr, the bur will scratch the plate. Is this normal? The scratches can just catch a fingernail.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#32

Lapping Plate Surface Quality

Steve Elliott

I've used a Harris Tools lapping plate that was surface ground and plates I had Blanchard ground at a machine shop where I requested their "lowest cost option" when asked what sort of surface quality spec I needed.

Both plates worked with 1 micron diamond right from the start. The Blanchard ground plate has worn in considerably over the years, meaning that it is shinier and shows fewer scratches from the grinding. It has not dished to any significant degree. The worn-in plate has less of the harsh feel that diamond lapping can have compared to the softer waterstones.

I'd guess that the flatness of my Blanchard ground plate was considerably worse than the surface quality of the Lee Valley plates but the cutting edges it produced were straight right from the start and I didn't notice any problems with low spots on the plate that didn't cut. I use the plate primarily for putting a microbevel on the bevel side and a narrow back bevel on plane blades, not for lapping or polishing the blade back. Lack of flatness of the plate might be a bigger problem when polishing larger surfaces like the back of a blade.

I'm considering buying a Lee Valley plate so I can just try it out and see how I like it, which is my ultimate test.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#33

David Barnett

Let me ask you this, Steve

David Barnett

I, too, started with the Harris plates, but mine came astoundingly flat and smooth. I do recall that some who bought them later had both flatness and surface issues, though. I mostly used the smooth Harris plate for sharpening with 1μ and set the grooved diaper-patterned plate aside for flattening.

I'm glad your surface grinder marks did not detract for 1μ sharpening/polishing success, which bodes well for Lee Valley's new plates, at least on the surfacing issue, and am also glad your wear was even enough to not adversely affect your bevels.

"Lack of flatness of the plate might be a bigger problem when polishing larger surfaces like the back of a blade."

Even if there is some plate uneveness, this may average out in use if figure eight and other distribution strategies are employed, much like telescope mirror and lens grinders used to work with pitch laps, but I'm bending a lot to positively preface the rest of what I have to say (and had pretty much decided to let it rest until your reply, which puzzles me, especially as you know I respect your observations and integrity). Let me walk you through my thinking.

Tolerances for edge tool steels may be less demanding than for what I also use my laps to do, to put the final polish on heat-sensitive gems, such as some garnets, to avoid cracking or shattering. Anything greater than 0.00025" will produce visibly unsatisfactory results. I would've thought that across a 2" tool back or bevel, Lee Valley's stated flatness of 0.005" over 8" would make produce a noticeable and only marginally usable flatness on the back and cutting edge. Even so, let's think about this in relation to flattening a 2" plane blade back.

I have never kept a stone that was outside 0.0015" flatness over it's length, having experienced the trouble this causes on broad tools. Some ceramic stones have stated 0.002" but egregiously exceeded this specification and were unusable for broad edged tools such as plane blades and chisels. Worse, some of these stones displayed twist, which really amplified the problems. I just really have to wonder whether 0.005" over the length of a lapping plate will perform to the needs of woodworkers.

My flatness expectations for lapping plates seem reasonable for such tools. I would expect better than 0.001" corner to corner should be the maximum deviation for sharpening and flattening woodworking tools, and far tighter for other machine shop tasks that don't concern us here. I've heard of old-timers who claimed they could sharpen on a deep-dished Arkansas stone, but I remain somewhat dubious. Perhaps 0.005", or .13mm, is a mistype.

As an example, the Shapton Diamond Glass Lapping Plate claims a flatness of ± 5μ, which is 0.000196850 inches. The 220-grit Norton Diamond Stone conservatively states flatness of ± 0.002", or 50.8μ over its 11 -1/2" x 2 1/2". Lee Valley's 0.005" comes to a whopping 127μ, however, so added to the varying and undulating depth of its machined finish, it just seems 1μ, or 3μ, or even 6μ diamond crystals would have to jump like fleas to bite the back of a plane blade on each polishing pass.

So what am I missing here? Why does this apparently work so well for Derek who lavishes considerable praise on these plates? What's the deal? Delusion? Magic?

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#34

Dealing with The burr

Bill Tindall

What you observed has been observed by myself. I don't remember the details any more but my plate has some impressive scratches from a burr that dragged across the plate in some forgotten fashion. The steel in our tools is more than hard enough to mill shavings from soft cast iron.

There was a time that I thought a hard ARK stone was a useless artifact from the past. I have a tiny one given to me 40 years ago. It is ideal for breaking this burr off. But then so would any hard surface.

Usually though I am just lazy and I just start grinding away on the bevel and at least on my 3V tools the burr just melts away.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#35

Re: Thanks for your answer, & a couple more questi *LINK*

Rob Lee

Hi David -

You must type a heck of a lot faster than I do....that's a lot of ground to cover.

Firstly - you'll note that we call these honing plates.... I'm guilty of using the word "lap" as much as anyone else - but these are strictly designed and promoted for honing. As mentioned - we also make an iron lap (and call is a "lap"). Flatness for sharpening woodworking tools in a non-issue at these tolerances.

Yes - there's a honing guide shown there - but the "tech" info also says to leave a few inches clear of diamond for the wheel.

"Tip: If you will be using a honing guide, charge only the top two-thirds of the plate to provide an abrasive-free area for the roller. This precaution will reduce unnecessary wear on the brass roller." (instruction link attached)

Photos and plots - I just pulled the few I could find with a cursory search of some public (here) drives... they're really meant for interest, and to show that we really do look at this stuff...

Wear - generally, lapping requires that the bedding material be softer than the material being lapped (sharpened, in this case). My understanding is that differences in particle sizes result in either fracture, or deeper bedding in the base substrate (these can be used with SiC, and not just diamond). Some grit (in either case) ends up rolling around, and wear of both surfaces occurs. I'd have to think that it would take an awful lot of sharpening to produce significant wear .... that's certainly what we see in our power lapping processes. Once the diamond is bedded, the wear of the substrate should diminish significantly, as the blade being sharpened slides across the diamond studded surface.

Cross contamination - haven't really found this to be a problem, with only reasonable attempts to keep the roller clean. Of course a brass roller is likely to pick up abrasive...and it can get transferred. Same goes for just about any friable medium (waterstones) or even sandpaper based kits.... loose grit happens all of the time...

I've used the same honing guide (the original) for more than 20 years, and don't have any wear issues. We see wear happening if swarf gets between the roller and the axle, and the roller starts to stick. keep it clean, flushed ro wiped after use, an a bit of light oil once in awhile....

I don't think you're overthinking this at all - but you certainly do have an atypical depth of experience in this area, and know the right questions to ask. Many of the questions you ask would not occur to most woodworkers.

Really - it just works, gives the results we expect it to, and that it was designed for...!

Cheers -

Rob


Honing plate Instructions

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#36

Half an answer

Steve Elliott

Dave, your concerns about the .005" flatness spec for the Lee Valley plate are reasonable. In an earlier post I suggested using the convex side of such a plate with a coarse grit to produce a slightly concave back so that finer grit on a flat plate would polish the edges, which are what matter. I've used that technique with a 5 x 24" Blanchard ground plate and it has been effective for initial back flattening of PM steel blades.

By the time I started using diamond on cast iron I had already polished the backs of all my test blades to a very high degree of flatness using waterstones. I've never wanted to put these polished backs on anything except my finest stone, freshly flattened, because it would degrade the flatness. I just haven't done much work on blade backs using diamond on cast iron so I've tried to refrain from commenting on that as if I were an expert. My use of coarse diamond on the large plate makes the blade back plenty flat enough for adding my standard narrow back bevel. I've used my smaller 1 micron plate on a few backs and it indeed polished the edges first due to the minutely concave back produced on the large plate.

For the record, I use waterstones on my chisels, which are all older carbon steel. I just like the feel of waterstones for them and I can get the stone as flat as I like for use on the chisel back. I'm pretty strict about keeping chisel backs dead flat. A stone that was out by .001” would be way too much for me.

My Harris plate was one of the later ones and I had to do some work on it with waterstones to get it to an acceptable flatness. By the time I was done it was pretty flat and well polished. After a lot of use during my blade tests I found it was dished more than I liked so I re-flattened it. For a while after this the sharpness of the blades I tested dropped, probably because of embedded grit, but before too long the edge sharpness returned to its previous level. I’m mentioning this because even a surface-ground plate probably has some grit in it and will improve with use.

That’s a long answer that still manages to be half-assed about addressing your question but it’s the best I can do without having used a Lee Valley plate.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#37

Re: Question, Rob...

Bruce Mack

Another question for Mr. Lee -

I am not convinced that the finer diamond grits would cause undue wear of the rolling jig bearings, maybe just burnish them.

Have you any comments, having tested, I'm sure, the plates with jigs?

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#38

Re: Dealing with The burr

les winter

thanks, Bill.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#39

Re: Let me ask you this, Steve

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

So what am I missing here? Why does this apparently work so well for Derek who lavishes considerable praise on these plates? What's the deal? Delusion? Magic?

Hi Dave

I don't have or use testing equipment, so I cannot offer technical information. My tests are real world, that is, using the tools and making comparisons with reference tools. Some of this is subjective, obviously, but some is also objective insofar numbers can be compared. For example, the number of strokes required to remove scratches.

Keep in mind that I looked at these plates some while ago now....

I recall that my first thought was that the plates still retained their machine marks, yet the scratches were extremely fine and I could not feel them when running a narrow blade across the surface. My reference plates were the cast iron ex-Stanley bench planes I converted into honing plates ( http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/Castironhoningplatesfordiamondpaste.html )

Loading the two mediums with diamond appeared to be much of a muchness. Whether the cast iron took more or less time was insignificant. Yes, no doubt it is possible that someone could measure a difference but frankly it would be academic and of little concern to a user.

Similarly, I found it difficult to separate the two mediums with regards how well they held the diamonds captive. They lasted a similar period of time.

Whether the steel plates were flat enough was never a concern since they removed scratches evenly and at the same rate as the cast iron plates.

What I came to like about the steel plates was the feedback they provided. This is likely a consequence of the machine marks. I must emphasise that the machining looked greater than it felt. The plates feel smooth. However, the cast iron plates do feel smoother, more slippery when honing. I liked the very slight apparent resistance the steel plates had. Now this may be due to the grain of the steel rather than the machine marks. I don't know. I just preferred this effect.

Overall, these are good plates. I have used all sorts of mediums in the past, from different hardwoods to plastic, steel plate, cast iron and glass. I went as far as making cast iron plates from old planes. These are as flat as I can get them. For that matter, none of the other mediums were any flatter than my best effort. Where does the average Joe find decent plates? Such a simple tool, and so difficult to make.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#40

The wire edge

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Les

Every medium I use creates a wire edge. If it did not do so I would be concerned.

I think that part of the skill of sharpening is to create the smallest wire edge you can. The final edge does not care how large the wire is, just that the bevel was honed across the full side.

What is the smallest wire edge you can feel after three or four strokes that go across the bevel? Can you feel the wire off a 5000 grit stone, off a 12000 grit stone? I regularly meet beginners who cannot feel a fresh 1000 grit wire.

I tend to wipe the wire off on the final polishing stone after each successive grit. The wire edge is my feedback how I am doing. Sometimes, however, I just keep going through the grits, and the wire edge gets honed smaller and smaller, and finally disappears on its own. Generally this is when I use a honing guide, since it can be difficult to wipe away the wire when the blade projection is small, such as on high angles. Most of the time I freehand, and then watch the wire.

If the wire is large, it can indeed scratch the surface of a plate. This is why I warned users of the diamond mesh not to use them for edges that are chipped. The mesh will tear. Plates will scratch. Fine scratches do not concern me. Just ignore them. They will not affect the plate at all. If you are concerned about the possibility of a deep scratch from a thick wire, then first use a fine diamond plate (I have a 600 grit), but then you will need to return the back of the blade to the level of the final polish.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#41

Re: Focusing on the less significant metrics

Charles

Lawd, Lawd.... the saying A life so short, the craft so long to learn comes to mind.

All of this for lapping woodworking tools? Really? Talk about holding your mouth right. Phew.

Supply certainly creates its own demand when it comes to anything having to do with sharpening. Just make it. It'll get bought.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#42

Re: Focusing on the less significant metrics

Charles

Bill, I'm going to obtain a pet owl. I'm going to feed it a secret, proprietary diet which will produce the perfect grit in an otherwise, and oft quoted, slick substance (you know - slicker'n owl $h*t). When the owl poops I'm going to harvest it and package it into cute little tins and sell it as a lapping medium for $75/lb.

I might buy two owls come to think of it.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#43

Re: Focusing on the less significant metrics

Bill White

Phewww!

I ain't doin' brain surgery, I'm cuttin' wood.

I can't EVEN conseptualized the infinite degree to which some choose to sharpen cutting tools.

How did the old masters manage?

Bill

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#44

Re: Question, Rob...

Rob Lee

Hi Bruce -

As far as wear to guide wheels on honing jigs go - the issue with diamond is the same one you'd have with any abrasive (silicon carbide, or aluminum oxide).

If the guide is kept clean, there isn't a problem... if grit does get between the roller and the shaft, then wear can occur. Again - this may of may not present a problem...

Most issues I've seen are caused by rollers not rolling freely - and before it's noticed, someone's honed a flat on the wheel.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#45

Re: Focusing on the less significant metrics

Charles

Wish I knew. I do know that all of this 'stuff' isn't the answer.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#46

David Barnett

Sometimes it's hard for me to see the other side

David Barnett

So Derek, thank you for taking the time to write and explain your experience with the Lee Valley plates.

"I recall that my first thought was that the plates still retained their machine marks, yet the scratches were extremely fine and I could not feel them when running a narrow blade across the surface."

As Rob pointed out, the catalog photograph of the grouped plates exaggerates the surfaces and the machining marks, and I do not doubt the truth of that whatsoever. Your experience confirms this. I should state here that texture can be a designed-in exploitable feature in some types of laps, and that not all laps are intended to be highly smooth (they should be flat, though). I was questioning whether or not machining marks should be considered a positive "feature" of these plates, or at least whether or not they didn't compromise functionality of the plates.

"Whether the cast iron took more or less time was insignificant. Yes, no doubt it is possible that someone could measure a difference but frankly it would be academic and of little concern to a user."

I'd agree that the time and effort it takes to charge a plate for honing woodworking tools may not be a factor with no appreciable differences that would make a difference, at least not for most folks. I personally charge metal plates and laps by pressing the diamond into the substrate with a hardened steel or ceramic roller bearing, or more typically, a half-boule of synthetic corundum (ruby/sapphire), which improves bedding, presentation and longevity of diamond particles. This is a long-standing practice of gem faceters and solid-state materials lab specimen preparers alike.

"Similarly, I found it difficult to separate the two mediums with regards how well they held the diamonds captive. They lasted a similar period of time."

Again, I don't doubt your experience, but would add that other charging methods may yield extended abrasive performance. This may be insignificant and a non-issue to woodworkers given the low cost of diamond and the ease of getting adequate results from such a simple and straightforward charging method.

"Whether the steel plates were flat enough was never a concern since they removed scratches evenly and at the same rate as the cast iron plates."

This is where I have the greatest problem and doubts. Steve Elliott replied:

"Dave, your concerns about the .005" flatness spec for the Lee Valley plate are reasonable."

Later adding:

"A stone that was out by .001” would be way too much for me."

I say "me too". Notice neither Steve nor I are talking about laps that are usually held to far tighter tolerances, but honing "stones" for everyday sharpening and flattening. 0.005" seems way outside usability for me and I would presume for most other serious or knowledgeable woodworkers. Back to Derek:

"What I came to like about the steel plates was the feedback they provided. This is likely a consequence of the machine marks."

I'll have to say this may fall into how each of us perceives things individually with differences in expectations and perhaps semantics, as well. I find the feedback from charged cast iron gives consistent, sensitive feedback, and not so subtle as to fall beneath the threshold of easy detectability and repeatability. I have a hard time imagining this to be the same phenomenon of which you speak and experience. To be fair, I haven't tried the LV plates so cannot support my position beyond supposition.

"I must emphasise that the machining looked greater than it felt. The plates feel smooth."

Your repeating this observation accords with Steve Elliott's experiences with Blanchard-ground plate surfaces, so I accept this as entirely valid.

"However, the cast iron plates do feel smoother, more slippery when honing."

This, however, I don't quite grasp. Bill Tindall says:

"If the tool sucks flat on the substrate and glides smoothly across it even an inexperienced sharpener can enjoy the benefits of quick and easy jig-free sharpening. Tools suck into flat registration and slide smoothly on cast iron lubed with ample WD 40. Many substrates fail in this regard."

This is my experience exactly, which also matches the extensive writings of lapidarists and specialists in preparing metallographic specimens for research and quality control testing. But maybe I'm not understanding your observations or how you've explained them. And I'm not saying there's any shortcoming in your descriptive abilities -- just that I don't get it. Derek again:

"I liked the very slight apparent resistance the steel plates had. Now this may be due to the grain of the steel rather than the machine marks. I don't know. I just preferred this effect."

Personal preferences are entirely valid and unchallengeable, so I respectfully accept that.

"For that matter, none of the other mediums were any flatter than my best effort. Where does the average Joe find decent plates? Such a simple tool, and so difficult to make."

I suppose that's my main frustration with these plates as described. Heirarchically, I prefer continuously-cast grey iron over copper, zinc, tin, perspex, corian, steel, and glass (which I generally do not find useful). I do not prefer iron it over BATT alloy on rotary laps, but that's another story. So yes, I do favor Meehanite iron to steel, but can accept that steel can be used to adequate effect, which I did state early on. I also questioned that the machined surfaces on these steel plates might detract from their effectivenes, but you, Rob, and Steve have convinced me to reconsider my prejudices. But as to flatness, I remain wholly unconvinced and cannot accept there is an easy end-user workaround for 0.005" total deviation on an 8"x3" honing plate.

"So where does the average Joe find decent plates?"

Well, this is what I thought, I'd hoped Lee Valley had successfully addressed. I'll admit I was also hoping and expecting that Lee Valley or some other enterprising entity would produce flat, polished and affordable cast iron lapping/honing plates, and so remain disappointed but guardedly hopeful. As I've said before, I do appreciate the challenge of doing so, of bringing such tools to market under current market constraints, and sincerely am sorry I have to consider these stones short of that mark. I also hope, quite sincerely, a workaround for the flatness issues can be found that won't too adversely affect affordability. And if anyone can solve these problems and improve a product, I'd bet it will be Lee Valley.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#47

Re: Focusing on the less significant metrics

david weaver

Have you got documentation of what they used to sharpen 200 years ago (the old masters?). Closest i've seen to it is documentation describing the fine natural stones from all over europe.

I have my doubts that anyone who was a fine craftsman didn't have access to nicer natural stones than we can generally get today. That was certainly true among japanese craftsmen who were working for royalty, they were using better stones than we'll ever see.

Biggest escher (though it's probably more like a 100 year old stone than 200) I have ever seen came out of a cabinetmaker's toolbox (and not from a barber). A stone that back then would've cleaned out the shop revenue for a few days, but now is probably worth over $1500 due to scarcity.

English craftsmen had a whole bunch of stuff available to them in terms of fine stone, stones that are suitable for razors (dragon's tongue hones, and finer versions of welsh slate hones, none of those were particularly expensive, and the ones I've seen are very fine, even the ones that are still cheap are fine).

The only difference I can see between then and now is that you can get something artificial that will work well in a two stone rotation, and not have to find a natural stone to do it.

It's funny that the same mud-slinging goes on with the razor forums, where some folks cast stones at "edge chasers", who look for fine natural stones to sharpen their razors.

But when I read the literature that existed 100 years ago intended for barbers, it says in the back to accept nothing other than a fine natural stone, and it mentions coticules, eschers and "superb mystery stones from japan".

If you can get sharper in the same amount of sharpening time or in less time, and for less cost, I can't see a reason why you wouldn't.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#48

David Barnett

Higher levels of woodworking precision... *LINK*

David Barnett

... and tight tolerances can easily mystify woodworkers comfortable working at lower tolerances. What ultimately matters is working appropriate to one's needs, of course.

If you haven't already, read Bill Tindall's experience in Will Neptune's class.

Ian Kirby's claimed benchtop flatness used to illicit guffaws from lesser woodworkers, but he was dead serious, and his bench was dead flat.

And as for sharpening, what might be acceptable for one woodworker might fall far short of utility for another. The difference that makes a difference for some may truly be to subtle for others.


A different approach to dovetail chiseling

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#49

David Barnett

I cover a lot of ground just by standing on it

David Barnett

Yeah, I was used to working under deadlines when preparing briefs, précis, and so on. I got into the habit of writing fast and typing as fast as I could think, but things have slowed considerably over the last decade or so.

"Firstly - you'll note that we call these honing plates.... I'm guilty of using the word "lap" as much as anyone else - but these are strictly designed and promoted for honing."

Point taken.

"As mentioned - we also make an iron lap (and call is a "lap"). Flatness for sharpening woodworking tools in a non-issue at these tolerances."

As far as sharpening goes, that is to say, for bevels and microbevels, I understand where you're coming from. Like Steve Elliott, I'd still prefer a flatter stone but that's another discussion. Thing is, I consider flattening the backs of plane blades and chisels an integral part of sharpening, so would find myself vexed by anything more that say ± 0.002" out of flat. I'm still dubious of your stated 0.005" tolerance.

"Yes - there's a honing guide shown there - but the "tech" info also says to leave a few inches clear of diamond for the wheel."

Now that's entirely my fault that I somehow missed or forgot that. I'd blame it on age or distractions but will own up that I was probably too hasty and careless in my reading, and for that I'm sorry. You deserved better. I'd also read Derek's remark on this and completely forgot about it before putting pen to paper, to use a now arcane expression.

As for wear, your description of the wear process is accurate, although (as you've also alluded) a well-charged substrate reaches a point where wear is maintainably minimal. I have laps that only require infrequent and light charging.

As for cross-contamination, my experience and yours differ. Although I've had minimal contamination issues in my own equipment and practice, I've seen considerable problems in both individual worker's diamond use and more than you might imagine in lab environments. Now much of this surely stems from multiple users, often with less than sufficient training and too-often being in a hurry, but it can be a real problem.

In cases with solitary individuals working in a small shop, the difficulties usually arise from using multiple mesh sizes, unavoidable in many cases, with failure to observe uncomfortable and time-consuming contamination-avoidance protocols. We all get lax when overworked, tired, or distracted. Gem cutters and faceters are mostly who I have experience with in this regard.

But woodworkers who sharpen with diamond have their share of costly and unfortunate experiences, too. Bill Tindall has more than once described his own difficulties which he largely solved by adopting a sound strategy of using a diamond sharpening stone (with bonded grit) followed by only one mesh size of loose or compounded diamond, which I too have adopted in the woodworking shop, although my lapidary, glassworking and goldsmithing venues necessarily remain multi-grit environments.

I wouldn't have concerns about your honing jigs being damaged. I, too, have one of your earliest models and they're built tank tough and have shown no appreciable wear on the many stones I've tried over the years. No worries there. When I do use a jig for honing, that's my go-to.

As for my questions and opinions on diamond sharpening, I try to stay aware of how one field of use affects my thinking in another. Gem faceting and polishing is not sharpening. Steel isn't emerald and although there's crossover in abrasives and techniques, the requirements and goals for both are distinctly different. I suspect I do get a little jumbled at times. I'm also probably more demanding than I need be where steel and diamond contamination is concerned. It's one thing to get a few scratches on the back of chisel -- not exactly a game changer -- whereas it can really ruin your whole day to get just one scratch on the crown of an emerald during final polish.

Re: Diamond sharpening *LINK*

#50

Re: Higher levels of woodworking precision...

Bill White

OK! I concede.

I've got to hone my plane irons with leather and some green rouge.

Shame on me.............

Bill