Sometimes it's hard for me to see the other side
David Barnett
So Derek, thank you for taking the time to write and explain your experience with the Lee Valley plates.
"I recall that my first thought was that the plates still retained their machine marks, yet the scratches were extremely fine and I could not feel them when running a narrow blade across the surface."
As Rob pointed out, the catalog photograph of the grouped plates exaggerates the surfaces and the machining marks, and I do not doubt the truth of that whatsoever. Your experience confirms this. I should state here that texture can be a designed-in exploitable feature in some types of laps, and that not all laps are intended to be highly smooth (they should be flat, though). I was questioning whether or not machining marks should be considered a positive "feature" of these plates, or at least whether or not they didn't compromise functionality of the plates.
"Whether the cast iron took more or less time was insignificant. Yes, no doubt it is possible that someone could measure a difference but frankly it would be academic and of little concern to a user."
I'd agree that the time and effort it takes to charge a plate for honing woodworking tools may not be a factor with no appreciable differences that would make a difference, at least not for most folks. I personally charge metal plates and laps by pressing the diamond into the substrate with a hardened steel or ceramic roller bearing, or more typically, a half-boule of synthetic corundum (ruby/sapphire), which improves bedding, presentation and longevity of diamond particles. This is a long-standing practice of gem faceters and solid-state materials lab specimen preparers alike.
"Similarly, I found it difficult to separate the two mediums with regards how well they held the diamonds captive. They lasted a similar period of time."
Again, I don't doubt your experience, but would add that other charging methods may yield extended abrasive performance. This may be insignificant and a non-issue to woodworkers given the low cost of diamond and the ease of getting adequate results from such a simple and straightforward charging method.
"Whether the steel plates were flat enough was never a concern since they removed scratches evenly and at the same rate as the cast iron plates."
This is where I have the greatest problem and doubts. Steve Elliott replied:
"Dave, your concerns about the .005" flatness spec for the Lee Valley plate are reasonable."
Later adding:
"A stone that was out by .001” would be way too much for me."
I say "me too". Notice neither Steve nor I are talking about laps that are usually held to far tighter tolerances, but honing "stones" for everyday sharpening and flattening. 0.005" seems way outside usability for me and I would presume for most other serious or knowledgeable woodworkers. Back to Derek:
"What I came to like about the steel plates was the feedback they provided. This is likely a consequence of the machine marks."
I'll have to say this may fall into how each of us perceives things individually with differences in expectations and perhaps semantics, as well. I find the feedback from charged cast iron gives consistent, sensitive feedback, and not so subtle as to fall beneath the threshold of easy detectability and repeatability. I have a hard time imagining this to be the same phenomenon of which you speak and experience. To be fair, I haven't tried the LV plates so cannot support my position beyond supposition.
"I must emphasise that the machining looked greater than it felt. The plates feel smooth."
Your repeating this observation accords with Steve Elliott's experiences with Blanchard-ground plate surfaces, so I accept this as entirely valid.
"However, the cast iron plates do feel smoother, more slippery when honing."
This, however, I don't quite grasp. Bill Tindall says:
"If the tool sucks flat on the substrate and glides smoothly across it even an inexperienced sharpener can enjoy the benefits of quick and easy jig-free sharpening. Tools suck into flat registration and slide smoothly on cast iron lubed with ample WD 40. Many substrates fail in this regard."
This is my experience exactly, which also matches the extensive writings of lapidarists and specialists in preparing metallographic specimens for research and quality control testing. But maybe I'm not understanding your observations or how you've explained them. And I'm not saying there's any shortcoming in your descriptive abilities -- just that I don't get it. Derek again:
"I liked the very slight apparent resistance the steel plates had. Now this may be due to the grain of the steel rather than the machine marks. I don't know. I just preferred this effect."
Personal preferences are entirely valid and unchallengeable, so I respectfully accept that.
"For that matter, none of the other mediums were any flatter than my best effort. Where does the average Joe find decent plates? Such a simple tool, and so difficult to make."
I suppose that's my main frustration with these plates as described. Heirarchically, I prefer continuously-cast grey iron over copper, zinc, tin, perspex, corian, steel, and glass (which I generally do not find useful). I do not prefer iron it over BATT alloy on rotary laps, but that's another story. So yes, I do favor Meehanite iron to steel, but can accept that steel can be used to adequate effect, which I did state early on. I also questioned that the machined surfaces on these steel plates might detract from their effectivenes, but you, Rob, and Steve have convinced me to reconsider my prejudices. But as to flatness, I remain wholly unconvinced and cannot accept there is an easy end-user workaround for 0.005" total deviation on an 8"x3" honing plate.
"So where does the average Joe find decent plates?"
Well, this is what I thought, I'd hoped Lee Valley had successfully addressed. I'll admit I was also hoping and expecting that Lee Valley or some other enterprising entity would produce flat, polished and affordable cast iron lapping/honing plates, and so remain disappointed but guardedly hopeful. As I've said before, I do appreciate the challenge of doing so, of bringing such tools to market under current market constraints, and sincerely am sorry I have to consider these stones short of that mark. I also hope, quite sincerely, a workaround for the flatness issues can be found that won't too adversely affect affordability. And if anyone can solve these problems and improve a product, I'd bet it will be Lee Valley.