New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Gone to the dogs.

Posts

Gone to the dogs.

#1

Gone to the dogs.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I was hoping to have finished it all the past weekend, but did not get much workshop time. Too many social events. In all I had about 2 hours, and in that I made the dogs. Now the bench is a working bench.

I will complete the shelf and a few odds-and-ends after this coming weekend, which is the annual Perth LN Hand Tool Event. Chris Vesper is staying over and we are both presenters all weekend.

The old bench has gone to a new home. I offered it to the first person to cart it away. Hopefully it will give them good service for a few more years.

I did take photos of the dog-making procedure and will post them, if anyone is interested.

Here is a picture of the bench with the Jarrah pieces used for the dogs. It may interest some to note the 2 degree angle (facing the tail vise) ..


Here is one of the dogs (they are all identical), with a head dimension of 1" x 1 1/2" x 5" long. They are faced in suede leather.


The dogs all recess flush with the bench top when not in use ..


I really like the ability to raise them to a height that is needed ...


The leg vise runs very smoothly. I am waiting on pieces of suede leather for the inner faces as these are a bit slippery and work pieces can be moved. I tested the grip with a temporary leather insert, and this made a significant difference. Anyone with comments here is very welcome. ..


The bench in its new home ..



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#2

She's a keeper!!....

roger lance

very nice indeed....how do you like the wagon vise??....I should think it would be very smooth as well....the ability to secure stock between dogs will really give you a whole new set of capabilities....if possible, please take some photos of the LN event, I know I'd like to see that....congratulations on the bench completion!!

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Gone to the dogs.

Jack Guzman from Maine

Derek,

Gorgeous bench BTW. I don't like suede around woodworking.It picks up too much. Hard to keep clean. I find the smooth surface of leather grips nicely in my vise jaws.

I like that you have a dog for each hole. It keeps stuff out of the unused holes. I made 4 dogs and I just move them to where they're needed.I get sawdust in the empty holes.

I always enjoy your projects and the finesse you put into finishing them. I'm glad you finally decided to build a bench. And post it here.---Jack

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#4

My only comment ...

Hank Knight

My only comment is WOW, that was quite a build! Efficient, precise, frought with obstacles, all of which were overcome with great speed, aplomb and style, and the end product is gorgeous. Enjoy it.

Hank

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#5

Note quite done yet...

Paul M.

There's one last step in building a new bench. Grab a chisel and make one random gouge somewhere on the top. It's gonna happen soon enough anyways, so it's best to get it over with from the start in a controlled manner. That way, you won't get as mad at yourself the first time an accidental ding happens to this masterpiece.

Excellent work on this bench Derek! It's very well thought out and should last you for a lifetime!

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#6

Or

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

he could just invite a neighborhood teenager over to complete a project on the bench.

Bill, who mentioned the other day, to my older son, that I've preserved the glue lake that he left on the bench from some project or other 25 years ago.

It won't really be complete, either, until the floor is littered with shavings

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#7

Re: Gone to the dogs.

Sgian Dubh

Nice work overall Derek, and it must be a pleasure to be able do your woodworking at a relatively relaxed pace... I sometimes wish I'd had that luxury once in a while because everything I've ever made always seems to have to get done fast. I've watched your progress with this over a few threads and found it interesting.

I have just one significant criticism: your bench seems to be missing a tool well. I've disliked workbenches without this (to me) essential feature somewhere for almost my whole furniture making career, because without one there's nowhere to put your tools where they are relatively safe and hard to knock off. I guess you can tell that happened to me at some point resulting in a broken tool-- I can't recall what tool now. Ever since a tool well has been an essential element of a workbench in my eyes, and far outweighs the minor inconvenience of it being a junk collection point. Slainte.

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#8

The tool well

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have just one significant criticism: your bench seems to be missing a tool well. I've disliked workbenches without this (to me) essential feature somewhere for almost my whole furniture making career, because without one there's nowhere to put your tools where they are relatively safe and hard to knock off.

Hi Richard

I totally agree with you. I am also ahead of you on this.

There will be a tool well ... although I am not sure that this is the correct name for what I plan to build.

The main arguments against the traditional tool well are that it (a) gets filled with shavings and tools get lost inside, (b) the tool well restricts the use of clamps (which is a reason, no doubt, behind the design of a "split top bench", and (c) the well is never deep enough to keep the tools out of the way of planing, etc.

With a wide bench, generally placed against a wall, there is some room for tools at the far end. I have always dislikes doing this, which eventuated after I removed the tool well on the old bench (it disintegrated from age).

What I have planned is a tool well that will attach to the wall at bench height. The bench is about 12" or so away from the wall, so there is space for a well, and this will not restrict the use of clamps across the bench, and on each side. The bench is 21" wide, so there is no difficulty reaching across. Essentially, it will be a long, low dovetailed box for planes, etc. At the end there will also be a few slots to hold chisels that are in use.

Any thoughts?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#9

Re: Gone to the dogs.

TomD

Awesome, but the brick wall has to go, not feeling it...

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#10

Re: The tool well

wilbur

Actually, that's exactly what I wound up doing, more or less. My workbench used to be right up against the wall. I moved it about 10" out, and then attached a strip of wood on the wall, and a second strip of wood onto the back side of the bench top, creating two ledgers that I could rest a 1 x 10 pine board on that is set about 1 inch below the surface of the bench or so. This created a good area for storage and to serve as a tool well of sorts, although it is considerably shallower than traditional tool wells.

Since it's just a pine board on ledgers, and has no sides on it, it's easy to keep clean. I can just sweep dust and shavings off the ends with a brush, or quickly pop the whole board out altogether.

Quick and dirty Japanese workbenches out in the field often consisted of a pair of sawhorses, putting a thick beam like a 4x12 on them to serve as a planing beam, and a 2 x 12 behind it as a place to store tools.

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#11

Re: The tool well

Bruce, a MN Galoot

this is the only time I'm grateful for unfinished walls in my shop/garage. There is a tool well on my bench, and the back side of it is 2Xsomething that is strong enough to clamp against. The bench is up against the studs and the empty bays allow the clamps to fit in.

I'm slightly ambivalent about the tool well. About 75% of the time I think it's a good thing. Then I have to clean it out, and at the time it's not so good. I really does stop stuff from rolling off the bench to the back, though. Plus, there is a perforated rack that holds frequently used screwdrivers, scratch awls, files and rasps.

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#12

Re: The tool well

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

One of the workbench books had a trap doorish part at one end of the tool well that removed for sweeping shavings out. Of course, this then puts them behind the bench...maybe no more convenient.

I've also seen pics of ramps on the ends of the tool well to facilitate sweeping shavings up and out.

But a shop vac is probably best, if you get all those Berg chisels out first so they don't get vacuumed up; they'd make a heck of a clatter going through the hose.

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#13

The Bergs have a place of honor in the rack

Bruce, a MN Galoot

above the bench and the tool tray has ramps at both ends. But, the most fun is to set the shop vac to blow and the tool tray is clean as a whistle in no time at all! This is best done on a windy day with the garage doors open. ;)

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#14

Re: The tool well

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

I have cogitated on the floor design for the tool well. In the end I decided to make it rampless. It is a simpler solution to use my Fein shopvac and suck out dust. Sweeping it out simply means I have another job to do (cleaning the shop floor)!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#15

Re: She's a keeper!!....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

very nice indeed....how do you like the wagon vise??....I should think it would be very smooth as well....the ability to secure stock between dogs will really give you a whole new set of capabilities....if possible, please take some photos of the LN event, I know I'd like to see that....congratulations on the bench completion!!

Thanks Roger.

The wagon vise looks to change my work methods on the bench. The ability of hold small, thin boards, such as drawer sides - securely - will make my life so much easier. No more will they take off over the end of the bench in an oppositional manner! :D

I'll post pics of the LN event after it is complete.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#16

Leather

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Jack.

the reason I decided on suede leather is really because it was recommended by Jameel. My own experience is of using chamois leather on the Moxon, since I had it, but it is too thin (?) for long-term use. It does, however, grip very well.

Keeping the suede leather clean? It is dark brown. Actually, I am not fussed about "clean". I am more concerned about "grip". Is there a difference in the types of surface treatment?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#17

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Leather

Jack Guzman from Maine

Derek,

My point was that the smooth leather surface grips quite well.I would think that the fuzzy surface of suede would grip less well. Try this test. With a piece of leather in your hand pick up a blank of planed wood both rough side out and the opposite.My dislike of suede stems from my LN chisel roll. I kept it under my bench on a shelf. I can't get the little wood chips out of the surface so I just abandoned it and keep the chisels in a wall rack.---Jack

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#18

Seeing the bigger picture

Bob Hackett

I personally think many people limit themselves by not thinking in terms of how something like a bench or other tools can be made most efficient/effective by allowing them to interact with the entire shop.

As an example; a tool tray may be an effective place to store tools but only while working at the bench. When you move away from the bench then the tools contained in that tray need to be transferred to something else so they can go somewhere else.

For me the answer has been totes or tool holders like racks. With racks or tool holders you can readily see when a tool is missing because the space it took up is empty until you replace it. A tote or rack can be moved anywhere, even to a friend`s shop. If you plan it right you can even find a way to hang a tote or rack off at least 3 sides of your bench and that makes your tools far more accessible that any built in tray ever thought about being. Whatever system you use to hang your rack or tote off the bench can also be used to place a ledger/cleat anywhere in the shop you may work and those tools will still be organized and handy when you need them. When you`re not working in that area then there is less stuff hanging off the walls and taking up space.

Now that tool storage cabinet you`ve been putting off making just got way easier to plan and make. It just became a simple box with a series of cleats (easily moved I might add) to hang racks from and the bottom is now a shelf to hold one or more totes.

Think about things like tool storage as an integrated part of how your entire shop functions rather than isolated spaces and you`ll be less self limiting. You`ll also spend far less time hunting for misplaced tools as well.

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#19

Re: Gone to the dogs.

Todd Nebel

One of the nicest working benches I've ever seen. Congrats!

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#20

Ellis Walentine

An essential bench

Ellis Walentine

Here's a bench that consists of a plank and two sawhorses. The holdfast consists of a knee swung up onto the work.

Ellis

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#22

Re: An essential bench

roger lance

the quality of the work produced under such limited conditions also grounds me....


a coffee table purchased in Vietnam in 1971 as I was leaving the place....there are also 2 end tables that picture scenes of ancient wars and the peaceful scenes of the Oriental garden in the coffee table....war & peace....this set was made elsewhere....not in Vietnam....

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#23

Re: An essential bench

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'll bet the chisels that carved those pieces weren't ordered from the latest woodworking catalog, either.

Posts such as yours definitely keep me humble.

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#24

Re: The tool well

roger lance

Derek....a response to the three criticisms of tool trays/wells:....a.) a tool tray is not designed to be a long term storage solution for your hand tools....just as you would not store your hand tools on your shop floor, do not leave them in your tool tray indefinitely and then complain about clutter....clean the thing out at the end of the day....b.) one way that a tool tray does allow clamping even when the bench is up against a wall....


and c.) my tray is only 2 3/8" deep (which I consider shallow), but I could lay a LN 51 on its side (2 1/8" dimension of the base would now be in up right position) and work right over it....what more do you want??.....if any one would like to voluntarily send me their 51 for this experiment, I'd gladly accept.

Re: Gone to the dogs.

#25

Re: An essential bench

TomD

Great picture Ellis, (one legged stance) looks serious. As far as I can deduce though, Japanese Cabinetmakers did not work that way. Swensson was profiled working like that, and he picked it up from Imai, who is a timberframer. In the lexacon of early influences we still don't have a reference who is a cabinetmaker. We have Imai school and Odate school, both of whom where jobsite guys. These days there are craft tour over there, so if anyone knows...

This has paralleled itself on the western side to some extent. Both of the big early names on that side, Underhill, and Abrams, are both carpenters from the house side. Now we have the enormous popularity of Roubo's bench which while it wasn't jobsite expedient, was not a cabinetmaker's bench either. There is something in the water where the not for real benches are more appealing. It's a bit like those schools in art or fashion that from time to time idealize human forms that, were are at least told, could not deliver a baby. Though having delivered a baby myself (finally a sport were you get credit for just showing up unprepared), I have always been skeptical of that claim also.