New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

I screwed up.

Posts

I screwed up.

#1

I screwed up.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Oh boy.

Do you get those moments when it dawns on you that you made a really stupid mistake?

This is a doozy but it is repairable. I would like your ideas.

Its the bench (what else?). I have just realised that the dog hole strip is in backwards. Backwards! No, don't ask the question.

If the dogs were vertical, I'd just leave them and use them reversed. But the holes are angled at 2 degrees ... the wrong way.

I have two choices as I see it.

The first is that I saw out the dog hole strip (with a circular saw on a fence - it is the only way to keep the cut straight), make a new dog hole strip and insert that. This is my preference although it is more work.

The second choice is to fill in the existing dog holes with a plug (contrasting Jarrah?), and drill this for a round dog.

Thoughts?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I screwed up.

#2

Re: I screwed up.

Jerry Gibbs

sounds like filling the existing holes and drilling round holes is a lot of work, and if the plug shows at the edges of the round hole, the dog holes will become the focal point of the bench requiring explanation.

Re: I screwed up.

#3

Re: I screwed up.

GolfSteve in Calgary

Man, I empathise. Every book I read said to double check that the holes are sloped the right way.

I would cut off the dog hole strip and make a new one. Kind of depends if this is your "dream bench" or not.

Maybe you should become left handed

Re: I screwed up.

#4

Re: I screwed up.

roger lance

cut it out.....your leading edge is now dovetailed to your cap, so cut this clear.....and make a new dog hole strip....keep the square holes and keep the 2 degree slant.....and when you have made this repair; get to your favorite bar, sit in a quiet place, and spend some money.

Re: I screwed up.

#5

Re: I screwed up.

roger lance

if you have access to a large bandsaw and some big stock supports and a few strong men, then maybe you might be able to free the front and dovetailed cap....otherwise, a powered "skill" saw followed by a handsaw should get you free....whatever you do, don't just plug it and drill round holes....you'll wind up in therapy!!

Re: I screwed up.

#6

Re: I screwed up.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

I think that running it through the bandsaw may be the best way to remove the existing dog hole strip. This will cut the thinnest kerf and I may be able to save the existing strip (reverse as much of it as possible). Of course, balancing 100 kg of bench top is another story!

Thanks.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I screwed up.

#7

Re: I screwed up.

Tony Sade (Charleston, WV)

Derek:

I saw an episode of "This Old House" where Norm *, while cutting a large beam of some kind (maybe for a pergola) fixed the beam in place (temporarily-on stepladders, IIRC) and moved a band saw to make a cut. This approach might be a tad more complicated in your situation, but I don't see why it wouldn't work.

Tony

* I imagine that you know what I'm talking about, but if you don't, ask.

Re: I screwed up.

#8

Make cat holes!

neal in San Jose

When I made my bench, I didn't put dog holes in line with the shoulder vise, only the end vise. I later decided that I really wanted holes there, too. What I did was lay them out and bore most of the waste out. I then used a 2 degree block to guide my chisel when I chiseled them out to rectangular. I then used a slightly undersized dog with coarse sandpaper glued to the sides (a cat!). I then used the cat like a broach, also guiding it with my 2 degree block to bring the holes to finished size. When starting the cat, I usually had to drive it thru with a mallet, and if the sandpaper got scrubbed off, no biggee, I just replaced it.

So, here's my idea. This will only work if you aren't married to a specific size of dog, tho. Make a 2 degree block; use it to guide the chisel and cat to adjust the holes so they slant the correct direction. You will only need sandpaper on two surfaces of the cat; the sides don't need to change.

Re: I screwed up.

#9

Here is my idea

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I'm writing this as I want to go to bed (it's late) and need to keep a record of my plan.

The bandsaw, even my large Hammer, is too unwieldy to make a straight cut. Not to mention maneuvering the heavy top into position and keeping it on track. Too hard.

A circular saw has promise but mine is a dinky 7 1/2" blade (I used to use it to break down sheet goods).

The need is to cut straight and keep the two cuts parallel.

The best tool here is a router. Reject the temptation to save the dog strip. It is not too much effort to make another. Rout out one side and then the other. I can only go to a depth of 2", but that will ensure that the top section is a clean edge and square. I'll flip the top and rout from the reverse side. Then make a new dog hole strip and fit it.

Now I'll go to bed.

Let me know what you think.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I screwed up.

#10

Re: Bummer!

Hank Knight

Bummer! I hate those moments. They start with a sudden, empty, sick feeling in your gut that doesn't go away when you confirm that you have, indeed, screwed up. It sounds to me like your router approach is the best. It will give you a controllable cut and leave a straight edge. Can you save your end cap? I hope so. After all the discussion, it would be a shame to have to re-do that too. I don't think plugging the holes and drilling round ones is a satisfactory solution. The plugs will gall you every time you look at them and remind you that you copped out, settled for an easy fix and ended up with round dogs when you realy wanted square ones.

Sorry for your problem. It's still going ro be a beautiful bench, even if it takes a little longer to finish. My advice is to be patient and do the right thing.

Hank

Re: I screwed up.

#11

Re: Here is my idea

Jerry Murrey

My first reply. I believe I would consider a slightly wide dog as the solution - chisel the current 2 degree taper to be straight and chisel a 2 degree taper on the opposite side. I suspect the dogs would be less than a 1/4" wider.

Re: I screwed up.

#12

Re: I screwed up.

Jerry Gibbs

You could insert dummy dogs, painted orange, in the new strip before installation, to be sure of the orientation. :D

Re: I screwed up.

#13

Re: Better idea

TomD

We have all been there. I mentioned here not long ago making trestle table ends and inserting the middle piece that carried an offcenter mortise upside down on one end.

I gather that sawing this piece out would ruin the dovetail ends, etc... I seem to recall you went with square holes. I would flip it over, mark it out, and use a large hacksaw frame to score in kerfs so that the 2 degree angled face is now angled 2 in the direction of the vise. You would chisel this out, and use a float to make this cut. Several hacksaw blades make a float, there are some power options also. You now have a slot that is the right size as the top, but oversize at the bottom, and lacking a lip for the dog. The properly sized wedge epoxied in from the bottom will form both face angle and dog ledge, and not be visible from the top.

If you scratch the top in making these cuts, you can always inlay a fresh strip over the dog holes, for the few minutes it would take. Dovetail key it into the ends to add that extra grip everyone has been suggesting is needed. :)

Re: I screwed up.

#14

Re: Better idea

TomD

"You now have a slot that is the right size as the top, but oversize at the bottom, and lacking a lip for the dog. The properly sized wedge epoxied in from the bottom will form both face angle and dog ledge, and not be visible from the top."

You now have a square hole that is the right size at the top, but oversize at the bottom, and lacking a lip for the dog. The properly sized wedge epoxied in from the bottom will form both face angle and dog ledge, and not be visible from the top. With dummy dogs in place that can be held for gluing by just driving it in.

Re: I screwed up.

#15

Or a 16" Makita?

Pam Niedermayer

Tom, your fix sounds like the best fix in place so far, very clever.

Derek, my stomach turns for you (literally, way too empathetic in my old age); but if you decide to saw out the strip, please consider begging, borrowing, or stealing a 16" Makita circular saw. Now the spinning blades strike fear into the hearts of men and women everywhere; but they do cut. I'd recommend taking both kerfs from the dog strip itself.

I'd also recommend finding a professional timber frame builder to bring his saw over and cut it for you.

Pam

Re: I screwed up.

#16

Those moments...

John in NM

Oh yeah, at least one on every project :D

If it's really going to bug you, go with the replacement option. About a quarter of the time I do that on the doozies...

The rest of the time I learn to live with the work around. In this case I would probably carefully re-chop the dog holes plumb or angled the other way and make bigger dogs to fit (if I understand you right). This is assuming, of course, that you will be using shop made dogs.

Re: I screwed up.

#17

Re: More

TomD

Thanks. Hard to visualize for some maybe (not you), but it will not leave a visible flaw, or require rebuilding. The only real issue is how flat one can pare the new face, but it is basically the thickness of a plane, so it should be possible. In fact, if one really wants to get jiggy with it, one could make a plane that would fit in like a dog, that would not be hard. It is these kinds of mistakes that really up one's game. I once had to remove a lake of epoxy and core from a classical guitar. Pretty normal tone adjustment think for a prototype. But the materials were not fun, and the underlying soundboard was 2mm thick cedar. Gained a lot of confidence in chisel use.

Actually I just thought up a really cool alternative to making a plane that would cost about a buck and take a few minutes to make. Basically just make a piece of wood with a handle on the back of it, that is the dimensions of a dog. The side that is going to contact the face would have a diagonal hacksaw blade mounted in it, so that as it trues up the new face as it is passed through. It works because the dog hole captures the tool and keep the cutter presentation consistent.

Re: I screwed up.

#18

Re: Here is my idea......

George in snowy Lowell, Mich.

Chisel the proper 2* angle in the dog holes and then glue in a 2* wedge to fill in the OOOPs.

No one will see it and we are they only ones that know about it.

Work Safe,

George

Re: I screwed up.

#19

Re: More

Pam Niedermayer

Yeah, or if you make the dog plane a bit smaller than the final size, you could attach a cheek float and have at it.

Pam

Re: I screwed up.

#20

Re: I screwed up.

Bill Tindall

Personally, I would do what Tom suggested if I wanted an acceptable fix. But to make it perfect I would see if someone had a 12 or 14" saw in a cabinet shop. These industrial scale saws would be up to the task of ripping out the offending piece, even on such a heavy top. The tops of these saws are huge and the fences robust. If you could get it to the shop and back the actual sawing would be trivial.

I do not recommend trying to saw it with a portable saw. The blades on these saws are not designed to be buried in oak for 5 minutes. When I tried to saw the ends of my bench square with a portable saw the saw blade got hot, and warped, and the result was not what I hoped for.

The router route is not without difficulty. There will be a substantial load on the bit and if it is not razor sharp heat will be an issue. I would not risk anything less that a 1/2" shank, 1/2" bit.

Re: I screwed up.

#21

Ellis Walentine

Two options

Ellis Walentine

...as I see it. Either rout it out as you suggest and replace the routed section, or take Tom's advice and chisel the backs of the slot and glue wedges in the sides facing the tail vise. Both will entail a fair amount of work. Personally, I'd probably take the challenge of the chisel-and-wedge solution, though chiseling and floating that much jarrah would not be terribly appealing to me.

I suppose you could make custom wooden dogs for the existing holes, with shanks that slant one way and faces that slant toward the tail vise. What a conversation piece those would make.

Ellis

Re: I screwed up.

#22

Re: More

Pam Niedermayer

On second thought, you could cut a segment of an Atoma lapping sheet and glue that to the dog plane.

Pam

Re: I screwed up.

#23

A philosophical moment ....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks to all that have responded so far ... and please do not let this post stop further ideas coming. All are helpful - even if outlandish they can spur a creative moment.

Firstly, after my initial realisation of the cock up I made (something that is not unusual in my spatially challenged life), my frustration remained mainly for the precious time it would use to make the repair. Repairs do not phase me that much. I think that they are part of woodworking and life. Evaluate, plan, do. This is an opportunity to do something interesting, to be creative. I want to be reminded one day of a success, not of a failure.

It strikes me that few are willing to start again. Cut out the dog hole strip and re-make it. Perhaps there is a simple fix, and I appear determined to do it the long and hard way, but modifications as repairs are rarely satisfying. Far better to have the Real Thing.

Reshaping the dogholes is not practical. It is not just that they slope at 2 degees on both sides of the shaft, but that the head of the dog faces the wrong direction. Even if you turn this around, the support for the dog hole head is now absent. I don't want patches.

In the repair I plan the dog hole strip only gets removed as far as the last dog hole. There is no need to touch the side board or the area for the tail vise, and the latter includes leaving the dovetail well alone.

The tool of choice is a power router with a fence running along the outside edge of the bench. I have a 1/2" bit to run in a large Elu router, and plan to take very shallow cuts (although I find the Oak so easy to work after Jarrah).

The advantage of a router is that I can create a perfectly vertical, smooth and parallel set of grooves. I can work the top first, which is the show side, to a depth of 2". Then flip the top over (flip is a relative term for something that weighs 100 Kg!), and make the identical cuts on the other side. I will work short lengths once I get to the underside, clamping each section carefully to prevent any movement of the top. This is not to avoid binding, as with a saw blade, but the inadvertant routing into the sides of the dog strip, which will affect its parallelism.

The alternative is to rout the top section, as described, and then use a hand panel saw to remove the remainder of the waste, with the sidewalls now able to act as a guide for the blade. Your thoughts on this are welcomed.

I have managed to order another length of Oak. This means that there is a good chance that the repair will leave the bench top better than before! The existing dog hole strip is made up of several joined sections. Now I can replace it with one long, continuous piece. An ill wind and all that ..

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I screwed up.

#24

Re: A philosophical moment ....

TomD

"Reshaping the dogholes is not practical. It is not just that they slope at 2 degees on both sides of the shaft, but that the head of the dog faces the wrong direction. Even if you turn this around, the support for the dog hole head is now absent. I don't want patches."

I think you will be better off with a complete repair, since then the object is pure, same as the idea of finishing the inside or back of a piece. But if you did the repair suggested you would end up with the underside the of the dog supported.

Normally when I want to use a boggy, dusty tool like a router to make a precise cut, I just freehand it close, with whatever, then use the router to trim the last few mms.

Re: I screwed up.

#25

Re: A philosophical moment ....

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you use the router (or, as it's pronounced in parts of the States, routah*), you can get pattern bits with the bearing on top that will allow you to put the fence aside once you get to a certain depth. This may speed things up a bit, and will certainly reduce the need to be obsessively aware of keeping the fence against the work to avoid oopsies on the sidewalls.

Not that, as a hand tool guy, I know anything about these. I've just heard...yeah.

*This parenthetical bit refers to the New Yankee Workshop, an American cultural experience that may/may not translate well. Kind of like vegemite, but without the aftertaste.