New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Bench update: the top is complete!

Posts

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#26

One wrinkle....

John in NM

The rails won't help any because the "nut" portion slides in them. Now if they were rigidly attached to either the front bushing or the theoretical plate that Bob was proposing, they would contribute.

However, I do agree that for all but the most extreme abuse (see my "breaking of my wetzler clamp" for what I call extreme :D ) the cap/bolt arraignment will be fine. I would have no qualms about using it that way personally, even if it is not theoretically as strong as other methods.

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#27

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

TomD

By the way, you can attach all sort of bolt covering by magnet.

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#28

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

Pam Niedermayer

Bench top is gorgeous; but I don't undertand why the end cap extends above the bench body.

Also, I'd like it if you were to stop assuming the motivations people have for saying what they do before they even get a chance to say it. There are more than two reasons for ways to deal with plug holes. For example, I just don't like leaving dust/dirt collectors in the open because they collect dust and dirt. I know men don't understand that (take that! :) ); but my new washing machine is much easier to keep clean than my 30 year old one, because most of the dirt collectors were designed out.

Pam

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#29

Thanks Wilbur

Bob Hackett

The link went a long ways toward clarification of the mechanics of how this beast is supposed to work.

I gotta say that because I have and work in a mixed materials shop I have to build everything to pass the "blacksmith`s test", which essentially means will it stand up to the abuse of a blacksmith putting his body weight behind the operation of it and then maybe helping it along with a 3 pound(or better) hammer.

Having seen a wagon vise used as a horizontal arbor press in another person`s shop that`s what I would be designing one to withstand if I built one. Lags screwed into end grain and wood joinery holding vise components together would not last long in a shop like mine. Even for a metalhead like me those multiple hardware store bolt heads interrupting the surface of end cap are just plain ugly. I`d use polished bronze or stainless at the very least.

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#30

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

TomD

Its the thirty year rule Pam. If it sits in a hole in your bench for 30 years it isn't dust.

I'm not sure this is what you mean, but sometimes I pre-guess answers because of the drection I need an answer in. You know how it is to ask for help on how to refirb a plane and get 100 well meant answers to the effect that LN has a sale, or why would you us one of those old things, etc... Of course whatever one says, people get to answer as they want anyway.

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#31

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

Pam Niedermayer

Yeah, but if your answer is one of the assumed answers but for a very different reason, you tend to feel foolish or disdainful, in which case you may decided not to answer at all or have to write a very long answer to refute the assumption. In some cases, on this forum and others, it's led to disagreements, some rancorous, like the "fear" of grinding thread.

Pam

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#32

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

Hank Knight

I consider a six week build someting of an accomplishment! I was more than a year building my bench - not steady working for a year, but a long time nonetheless.

Hank

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#33

Update on bolts ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I replaced the coach bolts. I was not happy with the idea of relying on end grain to support the threads.

I really do know know why - call it a senior moment - but I drilled out the first underbench bolt hole with a router. Noisy, the smell of wood burning, and s-l-o-w! Ugh!

The light came on, and I switched to a 12" brace with 3/4" bit.


It was amazing how much faster - and effortless - this was. The European Oak is so much softer than Jarrah. Once the hole is to depth, chisel a flat side for the nut.


The bolt hole is slightly oversized (for expansion) and is slightly deeper than the underbench hole for ease of tightening.


Here are the first two holes ...


Handpower rules!


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#34

Re: Update on bolts ...

roger lance

vast improvement over coach bolts....consider a slot in the cap for expansion.....


Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#35

Thanks Pam ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bench top is gorgeous; but I don't undertand why the end cap extends above the bench body.

Hi Pam

Actually, the end cap entends below the bench body.

The Benchcrafted tail vise is designed for a bench with ideally a 4" thickness (or greater). A 4" thick end cap is needed so that the handle/wheel can be attached below the bench top.

Of course not all benches are 4" thick. The Benchcrafted tail vise is still capable of being used on benches with a thickness of even 2". This would require a spacer under the rails of the vise to create sufficient depth, and then a 4" deep end cap for the wheel.

My bench top is 3 1/2" thick, which is why the end cap is a little deeper. I do not imagine that this will create a problem (other than having to off-centre the dovetail on the endcap so that it ended up symmetrical).

Also, I'd like it if you were to stop assuming the motivations people have for saying what they do before they even get a chance to say it. There are more than two reasons for ways to deal with plug holes. For example, I just don't like leaving dust/dirt collectors in the open because they collect dust and dirt. I know men don't understand that (take that! ); but my new washing machine is much easier to keep clean than my 30 year old one, because most of the dirt collectors were designed out.

:)

I plan to plug up the holes at the end of the build with a contrasting wood (my choice is She-Oak ... now that could be interpreted the wrong way! :) ). There will be "accents" of this wood around the bench, such as the garter (which I have yet to make).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#36

Re: Update on bolts ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

I very much doubt that the Jarrah will move much ... certainly not THAT much! :)

The bolts all lie in oversized holes. The bolt hole at the far end is larger still. What movement occurs will be towards the back of the bench.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#37

Re: Update on bolts ...

roger lance

What can I say??.....when I made those slots.....it was over kill....maybe a subconscious attempt to compensate for some repressed need or something :D

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#38

Actually, they look like lag bolts?

John in NM

Names aside though, I have to say I've never found much use for carriage bolts, kinda useless without a bit of metal with a square hole.

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#39

Overkill

wilbur

We're woodworkers. We're all about the overkill. :D

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#40

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

Guillaume Dery

Why not please both the aesthetic side of you and the practical side?

On the one hand, bolt heads are ugly. On the other hand, you need to periodically get at them to adjust.

Nice decorative plates, be they of the black iron or brass variety , pinned in to cover the hole would answer both needs methings. This is nothing new as it has been around for covering bed bolts as long as bed bolts have been around. I have seen some that are a definite visual plus.

Not as pretty as making the hole dissapear but very pretty nonetheless and infinitely more practical.

Just my $0.02 (Canadian, I have no idea what that's worth down under)

Guillaume

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#41

Re: Thanks Pam ..

Pam Niedermayer

OK, understood. This is the part of your photo I was looking at, looks like there's a bit of a step up from bench to end cap; but it could easily be planed to flat.


Anyhow, great looking bench.

Pam

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#42

Re: Thanks Pam ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Ahha ...

Pam, that was the corner that was damaged. About 95% came out, but there is a slight depression in the picture. In reality the bench and end cap are absolutely flush.

I thought you were referring to the underside since I could not see an issue with the topside.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench update: the top is complete!

#43

I see, forgot all about that damaged area.