Re: Dealing with a bendy board
TomD
"I've got a 20" x 20" walnut panel glued up that I'm trying to flatten. It's 3/4" thick, cupped slightly (1/32"-1/16" or so) in the middle, and when I run over either side with a jointer plane, I can get full width shavings either across or along the length of the board, since the pressure of planing makes the board flatten out. I can flatten the board pretty easily with hand pressure as well.
I know I can place wedges under the board to resist the flattening from the plane. But the lazy part of me knows that this board is going to be a vertical divider in a case, and will be trapped on either end by two dadoes, which should pull the board flat given my ability to flatten the board just with hand pressure.
So should I stop trying to mill down this board? Or should I keep trying to get the cup out of it?"
To give your question a serious response...
I don't think we can tell from this info. There has been a discussion of whether tolerances could be better (obviously in some work), or whether they need to be at some gross level of generality.
You are the only one who know what the tolerances of this piece are. Basically if nothing comes close to it, and you do not have to do violence to get the part into place, and the result is clean, then you have hit the marks. But I don't know the details of your design.
The other question is how much you can stand to loose. 1/32 means a minimum loss of 1/16", and it could be more if there are compound twists. Only you, so far, know what size this piece needs to be, and whether you have already cut the receiving pieces. Also, as far as how to deal with it. I do not know whether you have more grace in thickness or in the panel size. Larry's suggestion would work best if you sawed it apart and started over, That will hit your panel size, but reduce impact on the thickness, etc...
One other method is to scribe a straight line under the arc on both ends, and place the concave side down over a narrow piece of wood. Remove the excess material from the middle, using the line as a guide. Then reposition the part, and do the edges. This is a mark and cut method, as opposed to the dynamic method that hopes to induce conditions in which a re-planing will on this occasion come out right. The strength of marking it is you establish limits, and work to them, which may appeal if you do not have a lot of material to work with.