New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Dealing with a bendy board

Posts

Dealing with a bendy board

#1

Dealing with a bendy board

wilbur

I've got a 20" x 20" walnut panel glued up that I'm trying to flatten. It's 3/4" thick, cupped slightly (1/32"-1/16" or so) in the middle, and when I run over either side with a jointer plane, I can get full width shavings either across or along the length of the board, since the pressure of planing makes the board flatten out. I can flatten the board pretty easily with hand pressure as well.

I know I can place wedges under the board to resist the flattening from the plane. But the lazy part of me knows that this board is going to be a vertical divider in a case, and will be trapped on either end by two dadoes, which should pull the board flat given my ability to flatten the board just with hand pressure.

So should I stop trying to mill down this board? Or should I keep trying to get the cup out of it?

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#2

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

roger lance

Wilber....from your description, it sounds like you will never get the cup out of it if you continue with the same technique....the same thing would happen if you ran this panel thru a power planer....you'd get it to desired thickness but the cup would remain....personally, if I can reduce/eliminate any stress or fighting between boards before glue up, I'll try to do that as opposed to having forces working to pull/push my panel out of flat (sometimes opposing forces can be mated against each other to produce flat)....your call, doc.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#3

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

Bob Lang

That's not the lazy part of your brain, that's the smart part. Time to move on. What would you gain by continuing vs. what you have now?

Bob Lang

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#4

Stop!

Bill Tindall

You said it all. The panel will be captured and constrained to an acceptable degree of flatness.

Not knowing the panel's application I can only make general comments. In most panel applications a slight curvature will not be noticed. If the panel is so easily bendable that planing flattens it (and by the way machine planing has this same issue) then its propensity to bend will not result in much strain on what ever is restraining it in its application, for example a panel frame. Bottom line: It can be held sufficiently flat with a modestly strong frame.

I don't ever fret about bent or bendable panels because in every application I have experienced something will hold them sufficiently flat. I made a coffee table and the boardr that worked most attractively had a wicked twist at one end. Some of this deflection was cancelled by gluing this pieces next to its mating straight piece but in the end the table top panel bowed up at least an inch on one corner. However, the top was to be attached to the apron of the table which was rigid and flat. I applied the top and over the course of a month slowly pulled the top flat against the frame with table top fasteners. All has been well with the table for some years after. I provide this as an example of an extreme case where a bendy panel (top) was successfully flattened and held flat by some constraining framing.

PS I have never made a perfectly flat panel of any kind. You should see my drawer bottoms! But these thin bottoms slide easily into their mating slots and become flat.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#5

Poor technique

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Your technique is to blame here, Wilbur. As you have noticed, planing cross grain is no help in this situation. What you want to do is place the board with the hollow side up and check for wind with winding sticks. Then plane only the near and far edges (with the grain) checking with a straight edge until the panel is flat on that side. It is foolish to keep removing material from areas that you know are already too low.

It could be that you can get away with not flattening this particular board, but better technique would have avoided this problem entirely.

When you glue up the panel you have to leave enough thickness so you can flatten it. I usually don't remove any material from the thickness of the board until the panel is glued up.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#6

I agree with Bill


Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#7

Expectations

Bill Tindall

Will everyone that has ever kept a 20" wide glued up assembly flat to 1/32" inch please raise your hand. Given the differential shrinkage and expansion of the different grain orientations (radial vs tangential), or surface to surface exposure, or residual stress relief, it is unrealistic to ever expect to achieve this feat.

As far as procedure, the woodworking industry successfully assembles fret-free panels as follows. Skip plane the rough lumber. Prepare rough cut lengths. Straight line rip to get gluable edges. Apply glue and clamp. Finish plane. Assemble panels into whatever. While there are other means to the end one can't fault this successful approach whether it is done with hand tools or machines.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#8

go back to the basics, Wilbur

Larry Williams

Until you've established a true flat reference face there's no reason to try to create a true edge. Machine or hand tools, it's the same. In this case, because you're laminating the reference face might well be the non show faces of the pieces in your panel. Yes, you have to remove a little thickness of the individual pieces but it'll end up giving you more thickness to work with in the long run.

When these discussions omit the very elementary concepts of starting out by creating a reference face and reference edge at the beginning, I'm left wondering what all those projects I read about end up looking like or even if they ever get finished.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#9

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

roger lance

Since we are talking the basics here....how many times do you typically joint and flatten each board before glue up or use in a project??....for me, its at least twice prior to glue up and one other flattening after....parts are stickered and allowed to sit and acclimate to their new thickness between flattenings....more often than not, they move....this type of approach is not that of a commercial shop whose practices are different than what the average hobbyist needs to follow.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#10

Low Expectations

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There are two issues that Wilbur raised: whether he could actually flatten this board and whether it was important to do so. I mentioned in my previous post that having a flatter board may not be important for this particular case.

My judgement was that Wilbur was interested in the finer points of planing a board. And that with better technique he could have had a flatter board in less time then he spent.

I think that if "industry" standards were what Wilbur was after, he would buy industrial machinery or just buy factory furniture. I have a neighbor who glues up hundreds of panels every single day. He does not brag about the quality.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#11

Re: go back to the basics, Wilbur

TomD

Yeah, job one when it maters it plane a face flat, and then the adjacent edge true and square. This need is why euro machines can have 20" jointers, or more. It is why the euro machine, at least in English is called a planer, and the planer is called a thicknesser. It is why their jointers are paired up with a planer of the same width, etc...

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#12

Re: Expectations

TomD

"Will everyone that has ever kept a 20" wide glued up assembly flat to 1/32" inch please raise your hand."

Huh? I'm sitting at my trestle table, it is cherry and over 20 years old. It is 34 inches wide and out less than 1/32". It appears to be perfect except that there is one board that is less than a 1/64" out. I don't know what it would be diagonal to diagonal, it's covered with stuff, and I think in the summer it may be a little more out than this. But personally I think your standard is way off. It is a trestle table, therefore it sits on two straight edges. A blind person could spot 1/32" against a straight edge. The trestles can't flatten a table that is 1.25" thick.

I just noticed a gap at one of the trestles, it looks enormous, but I can't get a business card in.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#13

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

TomD

Yeah commercial shops outsource to China, use composite panels, or build stuff that does not have tolerances. The 32MM system is a symphony of such techniques.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#14

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

TomD

"I've got a 20" x 20" walnut panel glued up that I'm trying to flatten. It's 3/4" thick, cupped slightly (1/32"-1/16" or so) in the middle, and when I run over either side with a jointer plane, I can get full width shavings either across or along the length of the board, since the pressure of planing makes the board flatten out. I can flatten the board pretty easily with hand pressure as well.

I know I can place wedges under the board to resist the flattening from the plane. But the lazy part of me knows that this board is going to be a vertical divider in a case, and will be trapped on either end by two dadoes, which should pull the board flat given my ability to flatten the board just with hand pressure.

So should I stop trying to mill down this board? Or should I keep trying to get the cup out of it?"

To give your question a serious response...

I don't think we can tell from this info. There has been a discussion of whether tolerances could be better (obviously in some work), or whether they need to be at some gross level of generality.

You are the only one who know what the tolerances of this piece are. Basically if nothing comes close to it, and you do not have to do violence to get the part into place, and the result is clean, then you have hit the marks. But I don't know the details of your design.

The other question is how much you can stand to loose. 1/32 means a minimum loss of 1/16", and it could be more if there are compound twists. Only you, so far, know what size this piece needs to be, and whether you have already cut the receiving pieces. Also, as far as how to deal with it. I do not know whether you have more grace in thickness or in the panel size. Larry's suggestion would work best if you sawed it apart and started over, That will hit your panel size, but reduce impact on the thickness, etc...

One other method is to scribe a straight line under the arc on both ends, and place the concave side down over a narrow piece of wood. Remove the excess material from the middle, using the line as a guide. Then reposition the part, and do the edges. This is a mark and cut method, as opposed to the dynamic method that hopes to induce conditions in which a re-planing will on this occasion come out right. The strength of marking it is you establish limits, and work to them, which may appeal if you do not have a lot of material to work with.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#15

Stephen Shepherd

Go lazy

Stephen Shepherd

Wilbur, all of my rulers are marked in 1/8 inch increments, so that makes it much easier. Lazy is the way to go, few will notice, just don't let any woodworkers with micrometers near your work.

Stephen

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#16

Clarifications

wilbur

Up to this point, I haven't had problems planing 15-20" panels flat to 1/32" or less. Usually I can get a board to that degree of flatness pretty easily. For whatever reason, this particular panel is the first time that I ran across a glue up that gave me this particular issue of having a cup in it, but also being able to be pushed flat.

If there was a technique/process error, I think it was in the glue up itself. Or it was these particular pieces of lumber. Or (most likely) it was that I didn't give myself enough room when milling these boards down before the glue up. These boards came from a thicker piece of walnut that I resawed before gluing up, and the resulting boards were thinner than what I usually would have started with. That's the last time I make that mistake. Instead of trying to eke two boards out of the walnut I started with, I should have gone for one thicker board and one thinner board, and saved the thinner board for when I needed 1/2" stock. And guess what — I need 1/2" stock for this project as well. :\

To truly flatten this particular panel would leave me with a panel that would be thinner than I want, which is why I asked. I really have not had to deal with this situation up to now.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#17

Boy, did you come in looking for trouble... : )

James Watriss

First things first, to all of you brutal perfectionists. I love you all, and you make valid points, but the joinery we use was designed to enable us to work with a material that moves with the seasons... and to keep it from moving in undesirable ways. This isn't machining, here, it's woodworking. Some woods are more stable than others. Not everything can be quarter-sawn, pattern grade stock. Up here in Boston I have a beautiful 6-board cherry blanket chest. Every winter, the 18" wide, single-board lid cups, even with the applied battens, and the front opens up by 1/4". Every summer it flattens back out again. Wood moves. 1/32" of an inch over 20"? the wood might move more than that by tomorrow. So I wouldn't sweat it.

Please note, I'm not disputing the need to establish reference surfaces, I'm making observations on the nature of our chosen medium.

Wilbur, if you clamp the panel between some cauls to keep it reference-flat while you cut your joinery, and keep it that way during assembly, it should stabilize in situ, and be fine. I see no difference between this, and letting a perfectly flattened board react later, post-assembly. As long as it's trapped in a dado or a groove, it's not going anywhere.

If you need to keep the panel flat to cut a sliding dovetail, or something like that, clamp it flat between a pair of cauls. That will hold your reference surface for you.

Or, you can follow the advice of Tage Frid, who came from a traditional European system of apprenticeship: Moisten the concave side, and hit it with a hot iron. The steam should expand that side, and flatten out the board for you. Obviously, you shouldn't do this with a garden hose, do it in increments.

For those of you who cry foul, that the moisture will possibly warp the board, you're right: Moisture and wood do interact with each other. See the beginning of this entry.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#18

Re: go back to the basics, Wilbur

wilbur

I learned (and appreciate!) the benefits of paying attention to reference faces and edges a while back. Some of that I learned from you! The first case that I ever made that really went together well was because I paid attention to reference faces and edges. And I did keep track of the reference face and edges for these particular boards before glue up.

As I mentioned elsewhere, if there was a technical problem, it was probably with the glue up itself. And starting with boards that were too thin for what I wanted.

Luckily, since this is a vertical divider, I only have to worry about a show edge. :D

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#19

Re: Expectations

wilbur

I agree that the process of roughly milling, cross cut, establishing an edge, gluing, and final milling is the way to go for glue ups. Having said that, I can plane a panel to less than 1/32" pretty easily in most cases.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#20

Re: Clarifications

James Watriss

Don't beat yourself up too much... this is a rough crowd.

Resawing boards is not a mistake to regret, and one bad experience is NOT reason to never do something again. Like anything else, it's a skill that's worth learning. And learning new things means going through learning curves. In the end, it's worth learning about. You're reducing waste, which is a good thing. Back in school, they made us mill 3/8" drawer stock from 4/4 lumber... incredibly wasteful!

John Ruskin wrote about the Greeks, and their classical architecture, and their obsession with perfection. All of the lines in their buildings were clean and unblemished. Their sculpture was similarly so. And, Ruskin writes, this is the sign of a culture that is so afraid to make mistakes that they will only develop their skills so far: The pursuit of perfection kept the craftsmen from reaching the limits of their abilities, because they were limited to making only that which they could do perfectly, every time. And, he writes, the essence of Christian morality is that it's forgiving... of others, and of the self. Only someone who is willing to forgive himself for his own growing pains can ever reach his (or her) full potential.

A friend of mine was restoring an antique side table a number of years ago. The front legs were reeded, 12 reeds, going around the leg. The back legs were reeded, too... but each only had 11. He contacted Brock Jobe at Winterthur about it, and Jobs told him that the legs were very likely authentic, and it was simply a case of a cabinetmaker's error, that was made to look as good as possible. My friend only noticed the discrepancy when he took a really close look.

I don't think 1/32" across a 20" wide panel that's going to be trapped in dadoes is a glaring mistake. Coming in here, and asking this crowd about it, that might have been a mistake. :)

Do NOT begrudge yourself the opportunity to grow and learn.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#21

Excellent Post

Steve Elliott

James, thanks for putting things in perspective. The original question was, "So should I stop trying to mill down this board?" The answer is yes. Wood movement due to seasonal moisture change is the reason.

One of my general rules is to focus time and energy where it will do the most good. Getting one part of a project to a high level of accuracy often means that other parts will be shortchanged. Knowing the value of "plenty good enough" doesn't mean you're not working on improving skills, it means you have good judgment.

Now please, nobody tell me I'm spending too much time and energy on planes and sharpening--it's a hobby in itself.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#22

More Clarifications

Bill Tindall

There are at least three reasons a panel may not remain flat as enumerated earlier.

1. Uniform moisture absorption into a panel with various grain types- flat, rift, quartered. Each of these grain orientations respond quantitatively different in size to moisture gain or loss. The result can be a wavy or cupped panel.

2. Differential moisture gain or loss on one side vs the other resulting in cupping.

3. Captured stress in the lumber, either from growth or drying. A nearly immediate cupping is most likely a result of this factor. It shows up most commonly in resawing or when planing a significant amount of material off one or both sides of a board. It shows up readily when machine planing on a big machine when a pass through the planer removes a lot of thickness. I suspect your panel is cupping from relief of captured stress. If it was severe enough to worry about there is no cure other than plasticizing the lumber with heat and steam, something I have done on a small scale with a steam iron.

Even if a stress-free panel is made flat, an uncaptured or unrestrained panel will still likely experience factors one or two and not remain so over time. But if the panel doesn't stress its constraints (frame, batten, etc) it matters not whether it is cupped some or wants to cup some over time.

One would expect considerable inclination for door panels to cup in cabinetry or architectural doors. Every humidity change in the room will result in a difference in moisture content of the panel between its inside and outside surface. But, as you have shown, panels flex easily so the panel frame holds all in control and there is no concern. However, get one side wet with a water leak or some such and the door will likely severely cup and break.

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#23

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

Pam Niedermayer

I'm interested in why you chose a 3/4" thickness for the panel. I don't intend to pile on here, but I think that a bit thick for a panel in general. So why? Do you plan to make it raised?

Pam

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#24

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

wilbur

The whole project is a TV stand -- basically a low case about 60" long, 20" high, 20" deep. It's divided into three compartments, each about 20" x 20", so three square compartments side by side. There will be an additional shelf in each compartment, which will hold stereo equipment, DVD player, etc. The TV sits on top. This particular panel that was giving me fits is going to be one of the vertical dividers. So that's why the 3/4" thickness.

Since it's a vertical divider, if it's less than 3/4", I think it won't compromise the strength of the structure by much.

What thickness would you shoot for?

Re: Dealing with a bendy board

#25

another possibility

Bill Tindall

If the board was resawed and book matched and there was even a small moisture gradient across the thickness of the original board, a cup will develop across the panel as the pieces equilibrate to uniform moisture content. In such a case the cup will be there forever.