Re: Dealing with a bendy board
TomD
"First things first, to all of you brutal perfectionists. I love you all, and you make valid points, but the joinery we use was designed to enable us to work with a material that moves with the seasons... and to keep it from moving in undesirable ways."
That is true, but is not the case in point, this is about error in the parts as they come together, which may or not be a problem. That isn't a mater of theory, it comes down to cases, literally. To get the stuff you refer to to work you need to get the parts well made to start with. Building in stress is not a great start. To take as simple example, knowing one's wood, environment, and design, one might conclude that a gap in a cabinet door of 1/16" was a good deal. Would it then be sensible to conclude than in executing that par the tolerance is 1/16"? Obviously not.
"This isn't machining, here, it's woodworking."
Well acutaly it is machining, hand planes are machines, and the tolerances they are capable of is similar to my mills, lathes, and reciprocating shaper. More to the point the tolerances of good woodwork are the same as machine work. There are differences in the two disciplines, general sloppyness is not one of them.
"Some woods are more stable than others. Not everything can be quarter-sawn, pattern grade stock. Up here in Boston I have a beautiful 6-board cherry blanket chest. Every winter, the 18" wide, single-board lid cups, even with the applied battens, and the front opens up by 1/4". Every summer it flattens back out again. Wood moves. 1/32" of an inch over 20"? the wood might move more than that by tomorrow. So I wouldn't sweat it."
Not sure I agree with that. The fact is it probably would not move that much in an unheated enviro. The modern home is not really the standard for traditional woodworking. It blows up musical instruments and antiques. Are you really suggesting tha 1/4" is ok, and did the guy who made this work to that tolerance or is that just the abuse it is managing in it's new quarters? My dad owns a very nice Grand Piano, a Bechstein. Over the 35 years he has had it, he has pampered it with every system of humidification known to man, yet all the veneer on the case has either wrinkled up, or drapped, off. Let's just call it good...
"Wilbur, if you clamp the panel between some cauls to keep it reference-flat while you cut your joinery, and keep it that way during assembly, it should stabilize in situ, and be fine. I see no difference between this, and letting a perfectly flattened board react later, post-assembly. As long as it's trapped in a dado or a groove, it's not going anywhere."
Yeah if it starts out flat, and something goes wrong, you can throw it out on the grass during season, or maybe a damp towel in winter, and get it to come back. Assuming the fault is warping, and asuming that the humidity the board was seasoned to is typical of it's final resting place. Assembling with strees isn't always the same as the way something goes later one. And it is also the case that once something is in a piece, as with this dust panel, it will tend not to move around as much because it's end grain is encased in other boards, and those boards also cloak it.
"Or, you can follow the advice of Tage Frid, who came from a traditional European system of apprenticeship: Moisten the concave side, and hit it with a hot iron. The steam should expand that side, and flatten out the board for you. Obviously, you shouldn't do this with a garden hose, do it in increments."
Apparently his advice wasn't to just hammer it home...
I'm sure one could get away doing stuff as you suggest, I just don't see the harm in high standards, often the last few strokes across the stone are the ones that bring up the edge. Why toss away all the work that went into getting there when one could have a much sharper and longer lasting edge by going only slightly further.