New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Benches: one change leads to another.

Posts

Benches: one change leads to another.

#1

Benches: one change leads to another.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I was asked why I chose the Benchcraft tail vise.

The choice of tail vise was made on a number of factors, one of which was the space available for the bench. My bench is placed against a rear wall in my garage/shop. The length of the bench is limited by a cabinet, to the left, and a door, to the right. It comes down to the longer the bench, the shorter the tail vise ... or, the longer the tail vise, the shorter the bench.

The Benchcraft tail vise is notable in that the handle remains in one position, that is, does not "screw out" or "screw in" in length. This translates into a short vise, which means I can build a longer bench. The bench size increases from a little under 5' to a little over 6'. This may not sound a lot, but it is a massive change for me.

I was initially planning on building my own version of the Benchcraft wagon vise. However, when Chris Vesper visited with me last year, he mentioned that he had purchased the BC tail vise. When I asked why he had not simply built his own - since he is a top class machinist - he explained that the design of the vise places great stresses on the mechanism (it screws at the side of the captured dog so as to run close to the edge of the bench), and that to accommodate this, the steel work needed to be heavy duty ... and that the BC was built like the proverbial tank. He did not believe he could replicate it. That sold me on the BC for the tail vise.

I hope to get to the bench dogs tomorrow. These will be rectangular, not round, so I have to prepare them before I glue up the bench top. Why rectangular? Simply because I believe that they will hold work more securely than round dogs. They have a broader face and will not twist. Plus, I wonder how many bench (dog) builders realise that the dogs need to incline slightly (I am using 2 degrees) towards the work piece? This is difficult to do if drilling for a round dog. Yes, it is possible to cut and angle a flat upper section of a round dog, but this thins and potentially weakens the dog, making it more susceptible to bending under stress. A rectangular dog is more work, both in planning and build, but it worth it. This does not preclude one from adding holes for bench accessories, such as hold downs.

So today I plan to finish off the legs. Their dimensions are 5" wide and 3 5/8" deep. I have cut the tenons, and what is left is to prepare one for the leg vise and all for the mortices for the adjoining stretchers. While I will not complete the base until after the top is done (as the length of the stretchers is determined by the dimensions of the top since all facing edges will be co-planar), I need to have everything ready to receive the top once it is glued up just so that I can work on the top.

To decide the length of the legs I first had to finalise the height of the bench. The present bench, which I built 18 years ago, was a remnant from a pre-handtool era. Much modified over the years to better deal with the demands of handtools, it still retained that one feature of the powertool user - height. It is 34" high. Too high for comfortable handplaning at my 178cm/5'10".

Chris Schwarz recommends the "pinky test", that is, the height of the bench should be situated where your pinky joins your hand when your arm is held at your side. I did this and the result was a bench height of 30". To test this out I place a double layer of bricks in front of the bench, and planed a board while standing on the bricks ...


Interestingly, this did feel so much better. It moved the focus of strength from my arms and shoulders to my hips and legs (which is what one is taught in karate). So the length of the legs was calculated for a bench top of approximately 4" thickness (it will end up a little under that), and the tenons were cut. Pictures of the legs tomorrow.

One other point: One change begets other changes. With the lowering of the bench, I shall need to build a new Moxon dovetail vise. The whole idea of the Moxon is to raise the work up high. The existing vise was built for a 34" high bench. To work with the same ease, the new Moxon will need to work 4" higher. Hence a new, taller Moxon.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#3

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

wilbur

"Interestingly, this did feel so much better. It moved the focus of strength from my arms and shoulders to my hips and legs (which is what one is taught in karate)."

I remember the first time I saw one of Jim Kingshott's videos, and noted that when he was using a hand plane, that he mainly moved his body and not his arms, especially when planing longer boards. Using your legs for planing is a really good technique, and lowering a bench helps with that a lot.

I built my bench using the pinky joint rule, and I think it could stand to go down another inch. This is probably because I'm using wooden planes for the most part, which means that my hands are a little higher in relation to the board I'm planing than when I'm using Stanley/Lie-Nielsen type planes.

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#5

Gift it to your son or....

roger lance

convert it to a piece for your office or family room....would make a bar....or great storage for your more exotic collectable tools/planes....

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#6

Bench height

david charlesworth

I find this bench height question very interesting. My favorite height is 40 inches and I used to be 6'1" tall.

The recipe I came up with, some time ago, was about 4 1/2 inches below the average height of underside of elbows when forearms are held horizontal. People tend to be lopsided ! In fact Jim Kingshott said that cabinetmaking made people lopsided. (and deaf in one ear. machine shop side.)

I can see that wooden plane users might like a couple of inches lower, but if we think of making tasks more height seems generally preferable. Sawing, and horizontal chisel paring both need height and I like to sit on a stool for chopping..

I try to plane almost exclusively with my legs and my right elbow fixed to my ribcage. How else are we to manage long stuff? If a plane is sharp it does not need much downward pressure.

Over the years many students have felt my benches were a bit high when they arrived, but none when they left.

The picture of John Hoffman planing on page 21 of the Lost Art Press reprint of Robert Warings splendid book "The Essential Woodworker" will demonstrate why I disagree whith Chris Schwarz about bench height.

Best wishes,

David

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#7

Bench Height question

Bill Tindall

I do very little surface planing so this is a question from this perspective(ie. ignorance)......

Why would one design a bench for optimum planing height?

An answer that would end further discussion would be because optimum planing height is also optimum for all the other stuff done at a bench. But a bench as low as was suggested for optimum planing would not be ideal for the way I use a bench for other tasks. In my case the pinky criteria would put my bench at 29" and leave me stooping for all other bench tasks. I have never seen a bench this low.

So why not design a bench optimum for some other. or the other, important tasks? Or more globally, what is the optimum height criteria for a multitasking bench?

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#8

Re: Bench height

wilbur

First of all, I'm really glad to see that you're fit enough to write posts on woodworking again, David.

I think that what a lower bench top height gives you in terms of planing is not so much mechanical advantage, but it automatically encourages good form. I agree that best practice for planing is to minimize arm movement and maximize the use of leg and body muscles. And it is true that if you pay attention to your form that you could do this at a wide variety of bench heights. To take a ridiculous example, you could hold your arms firmly against your body and walk a plane down a bench top that is at chin height. So the fact that you have good technique when planing is, to my mind, not so much a result of your bench height, but a result of good technique on your part.

For the rest of use mere mortals, :D if the bench height is higher up, there's more temptation to use your arms more when planing, because it is possible to do so from an anatomic standpoint. If the plane is low, there's only so much back and forth motion that your arms can do. If the plane is higher, your arm swing increases, and so people tend to use their arms more when planing.

Of course, everything is a compromise when it comes to a workbench, and so if you do a lot of detail work, or work with powered equipment (routers, sanders, etc.) it may be better for the bench to be higher up. From what I've seen of luthiers and carvers, their benches are higher than the "pinky knuckle" rule, which makes sense since they don't use bench planes to the same degree as a person making furniture.

The Platonic ideal would be a series of benches, one for planing, one for sawing, one for chiseling, one for carving, and so on. Very few people would have the space for such a set up.

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#9

Re: Bench Height question

wilbur

If you want to see a 29" high bench, come up to NJ and visit my shop sometime. :D

I think the reason that planing operations takes precedence when it comes to bench height is that for other operations, like sawing or chiseling, the optimum bench height is higher than it is for planing, and it is relatively easy to raise the workpiece on a platform, or to sit down to do these operations. If the workbench is higher, it is really difficult to lower the bench to optimize it for using a plane.

I would also say that for me chiseling and sawing tasks are a lot less height dependent than planing tasks.

As I mentioned above, the mix of tasks that you do in your workshop will determine what's good for you. But for furniture making using primarily hand tools, the pinky knuckle rule seems to be a pretty good one. If you are using powered equipment, or do something else like carving or inlay, you might want a different bench height.

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#10

Re: Bench height

Pam Niedermayer

It probably also matters whether one is pulling or pushing planes.

As far as different heights for different tasks, I agree, and think the move to Moxon vises for dovetailing and bench-on-bench arrangements are great solutions.

Pam

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#11

Re: Bench Height question

Pam Niedermayer

Maybe because planing puts more muscle stress on all the wrong places if you've got the height wrong?

Pam

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#12

Arm Movement

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think minimizing arm movement is a poor way to plane. It makes my shoulder hurt just thinking about it. Nicholson (1812) wrote about a Jack plane:

thrust the plane forward in the direction of the fibres of the wood and length of the plane, until you have extended the stroke the whole stretch of your arms; Of course if you want to take long strokes you have to walk along, but still end with the arms extended.

And if you watch Odate, he starts the stroke with his arms fully extended and ends with his arms at his side, whether he is taking short quick strokes or walking along the beam. I think you want everything fluid: legs, hips, shoulders, elbow etc.

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#13

Spot on

Bill Tindall

Disclaimer: I never have planed for more than minutes at a time.

But I have/do done other furniture building tasks for hours at a time at my bench. I arrived at its optimum height by trial . For curiosity I measured its height by David's metric and hit it within my ability to measure my irregular anatomy.

The moral of this story would seem to be that there is not one metric for bench height, and as Wilbur pointed out, what is best will depend on what one does on the bench, as well as personal preference. That said, I have never seen anyone building furniture on a bench as low as the pinky metric. Persons building a bench for the first time that have not established their bench height by experience might be advise to make the legs plenty long so as to enable adjustment as desired.

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#14

Re: Arm Movement

wilbur

"Minimizing" was probably not the best word choice. What I was trying to get across is that planing uses leg muscles to a greater extent than probably what most people realize. I've certainly found that to be true for both Japanese and western planes.

As far as Odate's technique, he does start with arms extended and finishes with the plane close to his body. I do the same thing. What doesn't come across in pictures and/or video is that the legs and body are really doing most of the work. I do agree that keeping everything fluid is important as well.

Just out of curiosity, Warren, how tall is your bench in relation to your arms?

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#15

Re: Bench Height question

Hank Knight

Bill,

I couldn't agree with your proposition more. I'm short: 5"5" high (tall?-maybe not). My bench is 34" high. Actually, it's adjustable, but 34" is my ideal multitasking height. I do a fair amount of hand planing, but I don't dimension stock with hand planes or do any of the other labor intensive hand plane work. For me it's an easy trade-off - optimum hand planing height or optimum height for evertything else. Everything else won out and I've never regretted my decision. I'm sure if I were planing at my bench several hours a day, I might have a different attitude; but as it is, what planing I do on my 34" high bench gives me no problem. I think I would be much more uncomfortable doing all the other tasks I do at a bench built for handplaning than I am handplaning at my multitasking bench height. In point of fact, given the kind of handplaning I do, I'm not uncomfortable at all doing it on a 34" high bench.

My $.02.

Hank

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#17

Re: Bench Height question

Guillaume Dery

Bill, I believe that the accepted multitasking (hand and power tool operations) bench height is around 34" for average height individuals (say 5'10"). Like everything else, it's a game of compromises and trade-offs.

Going by the pinky rule for handplaning (and yes, a lower bench really does make a nice difference) my ideal bench height comes in at around 32". However, for sawing joints and doing paring, I like my work high (my eyes aren't what they used to be and my back hates bending), probably around 38 to 40". This is where a Moxon vise or a bench, on bench come in. Of course, I rely on sawbenches for crosscutting and ripping and they are at knee height (around 22"). Mind you, try as I might I can't seem to adopt proper body position at the sawbenches. If I actually put my knee on the board, I lock my foot behind the other knee and look like a drunken crane. However, most of the time, I just plant a foot on the board. Bad form, I know but it works for me.

I guess what I am saying is that I prefer a lower benchand too accesorize it to work higher. This way, I can do most tasks at their optimum heights (for me) rather than accepting a generic compromise and tradeoffs.

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#18

Re: Arm Movement

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Wilbur, my bench is nearly an inch lower than my wrist bone. As others have said the height is a compromise. Sometimes we are planing stuff that is 1/16 inch thick and sometimes we are planing a 6X6. Sometimes mortising a 1 inch stile, sometimes a 4 inch stile. Probably we can get used to a pretty wide range. We can't have an ideal height unless we have a very limited set of tasks.

Nicholson suggests 32 is an average height and ten or twelve feet for length. My bench at 90 inches is barely adequate for making mouldings.

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#19

Re: Bench height

bugbear

The Platonic ideal would be a series of benches, one for planing, one for sawing, one for chiseling, one for carving, and so on. Very few people would have the space for such a set up.

The much derided Workmate has two heights - sawing and "the rest".

The Workmate is by far the best bench for when you can't have a bench...

BugBear

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#20

sawing on an "adjustable" bench

Bill Tindall


My bench has a two height feature provided by the vices. I have the typical metal quick release vice on each end of the bench. To break down long boards I drop them onto the vices which lowers the working surface 4" to a comfortable saw buck height. Once the lumber is in manageable pieces the rest of the sawing is on a table saw.

BTW, the saw shown is hands down the best tool for cross cutting rough lumber to size. The saws are cheap to buy, easy to sharpen and they cut quick and true. I have two others tuned for green and dry firewood (more and less set).

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#21

Re: Bench height

TomD

I agree with Pam that Japanese is different, as are all the different height western planes, and preferences for different height wood stock. Handle types may also mater.

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#22

Re: Workmate

TomD

I think the best bench for when you don't have a bench is some large chunks of wood propped up, etc... My dad has a WM and it comes in handy. But they seem to shine more with power tools where there is less heavy leaning into stuff.

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#23

Re: Bench Height question

TomD

"Why would one design a bench for optimum planing height?"

I don't know for a fact they did that in the old days, or that one sees it that much today. DC's point was reflected in the Landis book. Landis was at one point engaged in bench manufacture, and made benches in accordance with Michael Fortunes ideas which worked out to a rather stall bench.

But I can think of several reasons for making them planing height. One is that planing in a real hand tools setting is the biggest part of the job by far. One sees descriptions in old texts that describe cabinetmaking as an activity where a person makes their living from their planes. Also it may be the physically heaviest work done at the bench. Mortising also need a lower bench, and dovetails are one case where there can be some extension to the workpiece to meet the maker.

Another thing is that one can raise a bench up from planing height, but cutting it off is more destructive. One can imagine a world (not sure it existed) where one made all benches small, and the young apprentices did the hard slog. As you got older and did the finer work you simply block up your bench, as Krenov did. This also suits mass market benches that are sized for the smallest user.

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#24

Bench

Kevin Adams

Hi Warren,

I presume you made your bench. Is it your original one or have you updated it over the years? Is it a particular style, e.g. Nicholson, or your own "hybrid" design? Do you use vises? What wood did you use? Anything you would change today except maybe the length?

Thanks for your input on so many things over the years, I have learned a ton from you!

Kevin

Re: Benches: one change leads to another.

#25

Why not have a portable panel that....

roger lance

once placed on the floor would raise the worker up relative to the bench....a panel about 4" thick or more that would be strong enough to walk on....but could also be used for other purposes like placing on saw horses to make a portable bench or assembly table....a 34" regular duty bench would become a 30" plane bench....just a 2x4 frame with cross bracing and a 3/4" plywood skin 5' - 6' long and 24" - 30" wide....or just stand it up in a corner to get it out of the way....could even put some of those unpopular levelers on it to make it stable with those uneven shop floors.... :D