New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Bench questions

Posts

Bench questions

#1

Bench questions

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I am about to build a new bench. My existing bench is 18 years old, has been modified many times over the years to keep pace with my changing approach to woodwork, and is showing its years. It is small - about 4'10" long. It is too wide - about 26". The top has been planed down so many times that the dowels I used to orientate the boards all those years ago are now showing half their thickness. Although the legs are spindly, the bench is really rigid as it is bolted to the wall (the new bench will be placed about 2 ft from the wall). The Record 52 1/2 vises are now hopeless. The front vise racks and the tail vise does not open unless you hold down the release lever while you turn the handle. And it is too dark. The Karri top may look exotic in pictures, but it does not reflect light well.


The bench has been a good friend but I still find it amazing that I managed to do so much work on it. I procrastinated and avoided building another as I generally dislike building shop furniture. Or using good wood that would better be used on furniture for the home. But now it is time for a new bench, a better bench.

I like the simplicity of a Roubo. I thank Chris Schwarz for his research and the information he disseminated. It has been educational.

Since building a Moxon vise (for dovetailing) a year ago I have come to recognise that my face vise needs (for planing edges) would now be best met by a leg vise. I plan to build one with a wooden screw (a most kind gift of Wilbur Pan), while the tail vise is a Benchcrafted wagon vise.

Generally I try and build as much as I can from recycled timber. I find a lot of old Jarrah roof trusses. These are dry and hard. They will be turned into the base.

Today I dug out the rafters that I thought would work best. These are 3"- 3 1/2" x 4"- 4 1/2" and around 80" long. I should be able to get four legs at 3" x 5". I am aiming for a 34" high bench.


Question 1: Your opinion of these dimensions for the legs? What are the dimensions of your benches legs?

The top is to be 4" thick, 21-22" wide and 6 ft long, built from European Oak (which means it likely originated from Eastern Europe). One of the members of my local ww club bought a shipment imported by a failed business, and was selling it at a cheaper price than the local Tasmanian Oak, which lacks its stability and texture. This was jointed and thicknessed for me, and has been "acclimatizing" (aka lying around) for several months. There has been minimal movement.



Two boxes at the top ... BenchCrafted tail vise and woodscrew ...


Question 2: I plan to add rectangular dogholes. How far apart (my thoughts run to about 3"), and how close to the edge of the bench would you recommend (3"?)?

Question 3: For those using the BC end vise, what is the length of the cut out for the vise? How far along the vise do the dog holes start?

My intention is to build a wooden replica of the steel screw leg vise designed by BenchCrafted. The key feature here are the wheel guides.

Question 4: I believe Chris Schwarz has recommended that the screw for the leg vise is 12" below the top of the bench. Jameel Abraham I believe recommends 9" (but uses a steel screw). What would you recommend?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench questions

#2

legs

Bill Tindall

I can't provide any useful information on the rest of your questions but as far as the legs the criteria is no different than any sort of table. The legs need to be thick enough to accommodate mortises sufficient to provide rigidity. 3 x5 will accommodate a mortise more than adequate for the need.

Re: Bench questions

#3

Re: Bench questions

AlanWS

If you use a split top, you will need short stretchers at the tops of the legs to support the top. These, if not carefully thought out, can interfere with a leg vise. If you use the top as part of the structure, as in a windsor chair, or what Schwarz calls a French bench, you have more freedom in the placement of the leg vise.

Re: Bench questions

#4

Re: Bench questions

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Alan

No split top for me.

I do not see an advantage in one, only complications. A split top requires extra stretchers, greater rigidity in the structure (compared o a solid top), and keeping it coplanar is more effort. Simple is best.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench questions

#5

Re: Bench questions

wilbur

Question 1: Your opinion of these dimensions for the legs? What are the dimensions of your benches legs?

Mine are 5" x 5". That may be overkill, but they sure look cool. But you want a beefy leg for the leg vise for sure. It's pretty impressive how much pressure and leverage this thing generates, and I could see bending the leg over time if it isn't thick enough.

Question 4: I believe Chris Schwarz has recommended that the screw for the leg vise is 12" below the top of the bench. Jameel Abraham I believe recommends 9" (but uses a steel screw). What would you recommend?

The plans for the Roubo from Chris Schwarz's first workbench book has the screw at 9" below the top of the bench. That's where I put mine, and it seems to be a good height.

The distance between the top of the bench and the screw puts some limitation on how wide of a board you can clamp with the leg vise by itself, although you can always enlist the aid of a sliding deadman. The distance between the screw and the parallel guide/cantilever affects how much clamping leverage you can exert, with the leverage increasing with distance. Of course, you wind up striking a balance between the two.

Re: Bench questions

#6

Re: Bench questions

roger lance

Derek....for a Roubo, since the legs pull extra duty with holdfasts and the nut for the leg vise, I'd make them as big as my stock would allow....I see no advantage in trimming away mass on these legs....bigger is better.

for the depth of the leg vise, you know better than anyone what size materials you work with.....I'm sure that that big wooden screw will handle a deeper chop....9" - 12" is a nice range....keep in mind that the distance between screw and the bottom guide/pin is important....sort of a fulcrum effect at the screw, so more distance here is good....so maybe 9ish.

try to keep the dog holes in line as close to the line of the BenchCrafted screw as you can....and have them as close to the edge of the bench as is logical given the requirements of the hardware....obviously, at least one board away (which is what I've got or 1 3/4" from the edge) this has to fit with your hardware and bench top material....for planning close, this is nice and I've seen people who have placed their dogs further away from the edge and if they are reaching and off balance, its hard to plane.

the spacing between dog holes really depends on the travel length of that BC tail vise (which I like - good choice - you will be able to work on top of it)....3" seems a little close but you have to play with this some to know....with the way that BC vise adjusts should be so easy to move it.....see how the holes fall for the length of the bench and other components (legs, planning stop?,etc)....hope you have access to a radial arm saw for cutting the square dog holes (a RAS makes it easy).....remember to slant the dog holes toward each other between 2-4 degrees (the top holes toward the tail vise and vise-versa).

Re: Bench questions

#7

Do you plan to mount your Moxon in the leg vise?


Re: Bench questions

#8

Re: Bench questions

TomD

I know like everyone else you have space issues, but a 6 foot bench with an inset vise strikes me as too small on a furniture module basis. There is a certain basic length required and it isn't 5 feet, useable. Particularly for someone making all the stuff you do. But presumably that dimension is fixed. My bench is just over 8 feet, and I have never looked back after my 5 footer.

If I had to give up my LV/emmert vise, I would rather give up my bench, The Roubo bench is about as practical as most other technology of the era. Schwart'z work is kinda a step back to the days when people thought the best bench stated with a solid core door. Any flat surface is 80% of it, but I don't believe that if a Roubo were set up next to a Klaus, and there was a pattern makers vice in the vicinity, that the Roubo would see much use. Essentially if one believes in the history of work enough to believe in the Roubo, it tells us that it was superseded during the period of serious hand work.

I used the dimension From Franz Klaus" bench for the doghole layout on my latest. His module is a width of 5 3/8" with the front piece being 2 5/8" wide. From the underside view, the front piece is glued to a piece 1" wide, so I guess that would be the minimum. The doghole is 3/4" inset into the front piece. His holes are set at 88 degrees and his spacing appears to be 6", doesn't seem to be on the plans. I know that was my starting point, but the fact is that a lot of things affect where you end up. These can include:

1) the dimensions of the wood one has on hand; I used 12x maple, and didn't want to cut it all up into small pieces, so that was a factor.

2) The spacing of you vise. Presumably your tail vise will inset from the face a given amount, and that will determine dog inset.

3) The spacing of the dog holes is such that it doesn't hit a part of the base, or leg arrangement.

4) Spacing of the dog works with your tail vise type (spacing around the jaw can be a factor on some layouts, and also the throw of the vice. If the vice is very slow to adjust more dogs can be nicer. Another factor can be the vice sweet spot. There is normally a place where you will do the most work. It can be a combination of where the vice jaw ends, so you aren't working on top of the slot or gap, the position of the legs, and the proximity of the jaw dog. One can end up with annoying effects like great spacing on the area one does not use, long left, but an 8" gap around the jaws at the very area one works most.

I made most of my benches from these kinds of factors, and besides being able to design a yacht from scratch, I winged it enough that I barely escaped. I had to take a small shaving from my stretcher to get one of the dogs to clear, and I was just lucky about the bolts on my face vice.

Good luck! Benches are the most fun.

Re: Bench questions

#9

Benchdogs *LINK*

GolfSteve in Calgary

"try to keep the dog holes in line as close to the line of the BenchCrafted screw as you can....and have them as close to the edge of the bench as is logical given the requirements of the hardware....obviously, at least one board away (which is what I've got or 1 3/4" from the edge) this has to fit with your hardware and bench top material"

I agree totally with the above.

My bench dogs are one board in from the front (about 1.5"). I would recommend spacing them as close together as you can get them. Mine were 5" apart, but I would have prefered 4". Do a full size drawing to ensure the bench dogs don't interfere with the legs or stretchers.

For 65% of my planing tasks, I simply butt the board up against one bench dog and plane away without use of the tail vice.

For the other 65% of my planing needs (I know, bad math), I use a planing stop located about 4" in from the front. Frank Klausz shows the planing stop in his bench building articles, but does not talk about it very much. I'd like to have a second planing stop located about 8" in from the front so that you could plane a wider board against the planing stops without the board twisting like it does when there is only a single stop near the front of the bench.

For the othe 1% of my planing tasks I trap the board between two bench dogs using the tail vice. I hardly ever use the tail vice bench dog when planing a board.

When I built my bench, I used the following criteria to layout my dogholes:

1. A doghole should not be located over one of the bases to avoid interference.

2. The first doghole should be located close to the tail vice face (I used a 1” gap

between the tail vice face and the first doghole). Locating the first doghole close

to the tail vice face allows short pieces (as short as 2”) to be held in the tail vice.

3. Spacing of the remaining dogholes should be fairly close together. I aimed for a 4” spacing, but ended up with a 5” spacing to meet all of these criteria.

4. Dogholes, except for the last one, should be equally spaced for pleasing visual appearance. My doghole spacing was different on the bench body than it was on the tail vice (3-3/64” spacing)

5. Dogholes in the tail vice should not interfere with installation of the tail

vice hardware. The tail vice is screwed into the doghole strip, so I located the

dogholes so that there was no interference with these screws.

6. Frank Klausz locates the last doghole directly up against the endcap.

I didn’t like that, so I offset my last doghole about 1” from the endcap.

I don’t know which way is better or if it matters at all.

A very long write-up about building my bench, including my ponderings on why I built things a certain way, is located here:


My workbench building writeup (long and boring)

Re: Bench questions

#10

Re: bench thickness

GolfSteve in Calgary

Hi Derek, I recall when building my bench that I wished I had built the dog-hole strip section of the bench 5" thick instead of 4" think so that I had more flexibility in vertical positioning of the tail vice hardware....with a 4" thick bench, the tail vice handle sometimes sticks up above the surface of my bench which can be annoying.

The benchcrafted tail vice wheel is, I believe, 5" in diameter, so if the tail vice hardware is centered on your proposed 4" bench depth, you will have 0.5" of wheel sticking up above the bench surface. This can interfere with some operations.

Re: Bench questions

#11

Congratulations Steve....that's a beautiful bench

roger lance

and maybe the most well documented bench build I've ever seen....I really like the carved name/date on the shoulder vise....a great touch....beautiful!!

Re: Bench questions

#12

Re: Bench questions

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Mine are 5" x 5". That may be overkill, but they sure look cool. But you want a beefy leg for the leg vise for sure. It's pretty impressive how much pressure and leverage this thing generates, and I could see bending the leg over time if it isn't thick enough.

Wilbur, today I prepared the legs. Gad, 5"x5" legs would be gigantic! The 3"x5" I built feel massive. My old bench has spindly legs that are 2" x 2". I build drawers with skinny sides that require slips. I am not used to such proportions!

More on this later.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench questions

#13

Re: Bench questions

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

9" - 12" is a nice range... maybe 9ish.

I plan on 9".

try to keep the dog holes in line as close to the line of the BenchCrafted screw as you can....

This only occurred to me later, as obvious as it is! Duh!

the spacing between dog holes really depends on the travel length of that BC tail vise (which I like - good choice - you will be able to work on top of it)....3" seems a little close but you have to play with this some to know....

3" appears to be the consensus among users of the BC.

....hope you have access to a radial arm saw for cutting the square dog holes (a RAS makes it easy).....remember to slant the dog holes toward each other between 2-4 degrees (the top holes toward the tail vise and vise-versa).

The design includes a 2 degree slant.

No RAS (what is that? Just kidding :) ).

Many thanks Roger.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench questions

#14

Re: Benchdogs

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Steve

Your bench is beautiful. I will be a very happy chappie if mine comes out as well.

Your write is hugely helpful. There is much detail there to go through. No doubt I will return to this later.

Thanks again.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench questions

#15

Re: Bench questions

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I know like everyone else you have space issues, but a 6 foot bench with an inset vise strikes me as too small on a furniture module basis. There is a certain basic length required and it isn't 5 feet, useable. Particularly for someone making all the stuff you do. But presumably that dimension is fixed. My bench is just over 8 feet, and I have never looked back after my 5 footer.

Hi Tom

This is an issue that I have been mulling over for some time.

I do plan to try and push the bench top to 6'6", but that is as large as I can go. The problem is not just limited room for the bench, but also limited space around the bench to move.

One of the biggest reasons for wanting the Benchcraft endvise is that the space saving: the handle does not wind out from the bench as others do. The handle of other makes/types, when fully retracted, would extend into the doorway (which is positioned immediately behind the end of the bench) - I am that tight for space. Use of the BC means that the bench, per se, can be 6" longer than if I used another end vise.

While I take your point that the effective bench length is reduced with an insert vise, I could also argue that (1) there is a longer bench for when I use a bench stop, and (2) the end vise is a bonus for me as I have really managed without one all these years.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench questions

#16

Re: bench thickness

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The benchcrafted tail vice wheel is, I believe, 5" in diameter, so if the tail vice hardware is centered on your proposed 4" bench depth, you will have 0.5" of wheel sticking up above the bench surface. This can interfere with some operations.

Hi Steve

Thanks for the heads up. I will test this out ... however, the BC end vise is designed specifically for a 4" thick bench top. Instead of the screw being centred, I assume that it is offset so that the wheel does not extend above the bench top. I will check the plans.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench questions

#17

Building the legs - issue with stock

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I began preparing the stock for the legs this afternoon, in other words, finding boards in my wood pile for laminating into the desired 5" x 3" size.

As I showed earlier, I have a number of rough sawn rafters approximately 3" x 4". Once jointed it became evident that only 2 legs could be created from two boards, and that the other 2 legs would require laminating 3 boards.

The two-board laminations are joined edge-to-edge. They are not my concern. It is the three-board laminations that I need advise about. These are not only joined edge-to-edge but include a face board to increase the thickness.

The two boards in question are the first and second on the right ..




Opinions? Will this work, or do I need to find other boards?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bench questions

#18

Re: Building the legs - issue with stock

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Since modern glues generally make a bond as strong as the wood, why not? Having said that, were I building it, I'd avoid a mortise on which an edge of the hole landed on glueline. It's hard for me to believe that a long straight line like that would not be more prone to separation than the wood grain.

But this is speculative on my part.

Re: Bench questions

#19

Re: Building the legs - issue with stock

roger lance

Derek....personally, I would not risk it....you can't even do that for a simple kitchen cutting board....get some other stock and sleep well....JMO.

Re: Bench questions

#21

Re: Building the legs - issue with stock

wilbur

I'd find another set of boards to make your legs. You wouldn't do this sort of glue up for a cabriole leg for a table, would you? So why would you do it for a workbench leg?

I ran into an almost identical situation when making my workbench legs. I was looking at doing a bit of a wacky glue up because of the size and width of the boards that I had. My friend from my woodworking club, who has had a ton of experience woodworking professionally told me to just find suitable sized wood and do it right. He put it something like this:

"What are you talking about, $25 of wood or so? You're going to blow away that amount of money on waste the next time you make a piece of furniture with any sort of decent quality wood. This is your workbench, which you will use EVERY SINGLE TIME YOU STEP INTO YOUR SHOP. Take the time to do it right. It will be worth it."

I did do just that, and I haven't regretted it one bit.

Re: Bench questions

#22

Re: Bench questions

wilbur

Yes, 5"x5" legs are gigantic. They are still very cool. :D

Re: Bench questions

#23

gut feeling

Bill Tindall

I would not have glued the thiner piece on only one side. I would have either glued a piece on both sides or preferably glued up the leg like a butcher block. That said, I can offer no technical reason for my concern unless this species has a large radial to tangential shrinkage ratio. It does look strange but then it is a bench.

But....

Is this wood that hard to find in the sizes you need? I was led to believe that this is not a rare wood where you live. I generally set the bar for frugal but I would find some spare change to buy some wood more ideally suited for the task at hand.

Re: Bench questions

#24

PS

Bill Tindall

Again, I have no experience with this species. But in general I don't like laminating with thick pieces as a result of unfavorable experiences. If I was making up a lamination 4" thick I would do it from 4-1" thick boards, not 2-2" pieces. 2" stuff is very strong and if one of the two pieces decides to become unstable it will be strong enough to distort or fracture the leg. More, thinner pieces tend to cancel out stresses. However, if this species is especially stable and the pieces are dry and the grain not running about, then what you did will be fine.

Re: Bench questions

#25

Re: PS

TomD

That is all true, one should not laminate with pieces thicker than 3/4" as a general rules. But that said large pieces can also be just fine. My first bench was built from Tage Frid's plans. The guy who sold me my turning wood told me he could get me the Beech I needed. But some of the pieces were very large, and most of them from the base to the top were laminated, which was a disappointment. 26 years later none of it has shown any tendency to separate. Worst case there can be raised surfaces at joints. In my shop the variations in temp can be quite severe, but humidity is normally not too bad. Obviously starting with quality wood will help a lot.