New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

Posts

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#26

Real world experience

Steve Elliott

"I will bow to your real world experience . . . ."

For the record I should mention that most of my experience has been with using smoothing planes to refine surfaces produced using power equipment, mainly planers and wide belt sanders. These are nominally flat surfaces with ripples or scratches I want to remove. I use the smoothing plane until the visible flaws are gone from the surface.

An interesting comparison between planes and sanders is to take a sanded surface and plane it with a very finely set plane. I did this with a piece of maple that had gone through a well-adjusted wide belt sander. (This was a model that had two belts, coarse and fine. I don’t remember the grits.) At first the plane didn't seem to take anything off, just a few wisps of wood fibers. Then it started taking off lacy bits that weren't really a shaving. Finally, after taking off most of the scratches from the sander, the plane produced a full-width shaving. The surface of the wood got smoother and shinier and it was possible to watch the deepest scratches fade and disappear. There were also marks perpendicular to the grain that resulted from the joint in the sanding belt coming around at regular intervals.

Ironically, after I remove all the flaws from a surface I always sand it with a very fine grit to give the finishing department a "canvas" that will take stains in the way they expect.

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#27

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LO

Rob Lee

Hi Guillaume -

1) The blade wears from both sides... that's a fact

2) What people call a wear bevel is a distinct plane of wear on the face of the blade that faces the wood. The plane of wear is wider at lower relief angles - which people interpret to mean the blade wears more... this is not strictly accurate, though it is noticeable faster.

3) What matters for cut performance of the blade is what occurs at the edge of the blade(or in front of it, in the case of material deformation), not back of the edge ... what occurs after passing the cutting edge is irrelevant... unless you're talking about the plane body burnishing a surface.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#28

Edge Wear *LINK*

Steve Elliott

Rob is right about this. I’m pretty sure his research department has done some careful work looking at wear on edges and how it progresses.

On point 2, (“What people call a wear bevel is a distinct plane of wear on the face of the blade that faces the wood. The plane of wear is wider at lower relief angles - which people interpret to mean the blade wears more... this is not strictly accurate, though it is noticeable faster.”) I’ve found that the shaving both polishes the surface of the blade and wears it away. Even after a relatively small amount of planing the part of the blade that faces forward will look shinier, and the width of the shiny area depends on the thickness of the shaving being taken. Seeing this relatively wide area of shininess doesn’t mean the blade is no longer sharp enough.

On the back of the cutting edge a worn area develops that widens as the blade becomes dull. The width of this wear is a much better indicator of blade condition. This wear surface slides along the surface that has just been cut and presses down due to negative clearance. As this wear increases the plane doesn’t want to stay in the cut.

I did some microscope work with a rabbet plane to see what a worn edge looks like from the side. The results are available at the link below.


Blade Wear Profiles

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#29

Re: Edge Wear

Pam Niedermayer

When you guys talk about the "width" of the worn area, you refer to the distance from the edge, right? Not the distance across the blade.

Pam

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#30

Edge Wear, Wear Bevels and Back Bevels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Pam

The wear edge is measured from the front edge.

If you lay the blade flat on a (say) waterstone and moved it back-and-forth, the waterstone would abrade the entire back of the blade. The "Ruler Trick", typically using a steel rule about 1mm high, raises the blade by 2/3 of one degree, and so the resulting back bevel formed is very shallow and gentle, but also "long". The typical BU plane bed is 12 degrees, and the resulting wear bevel (another back bevel) is shorter but at a higher angle. The danger of this, as Larry is quick to point out, is that the clearance angle is lowered, which will affect the plane working efficiently.

The information in Leonard Lee's book indicates that 7 degrees clearance is needed, and that it is possible to get away with a little less depending on the wood type. The 12 degrees on the current crop of BU planes is sufficient to keep them out of the danger zone.

As Rob as noted, a blade wears on both sides of the bevel. The question is not whether there is wear, but whether the wear at the back of the blade (in this case for a BU plane) is incursive and intrusive.

Recently I began using the Ruler Trick when I hone a BU blade. For years I did not bother as I was unaffected by the wear at the back of the blade. I simply stropped it. This appeared to be sufficient in practice to maintain a sharp edge.

The fact is I do not expect a long lasting blade in a BU smoother as the wood I work is very abrasive, and the bevel angles I use are high. High bevel angles may strengthen an edge, but they also reduce the size of the window for "working sharp".

Is the Ruler Trick making any difference to the longevity of the edge? I do not know at this stage. It does not hurt the edge, but it is an extra step, and I prefer to keep things simple (not have extra steps). I know Steve has done some sterling work researching wear bevels, etc. However I do not recall, but think, that this has only been on BD planes. Steve?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#31

Re: Edge Wear

Steve Elliott

Yes, the width of the wear surface is measured from the cutting edge. For a blade used for smoothing, the wear on the back of the blade is only about a thousandth of an inch wide when the blade needs rehoning. The wear on the front is approximately the thickness of the shaving divided by the sine of the cutting angle, which means that this shiny area is wider at low cutting angles, as Rob said.

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#32

No bevel-up study yet

Steve Elliott

Derek,

The images of a worn edge profile in the link I posted were from a bevel-up rabbet plane bedded at something like 20 degrees (I forget right now). I haven't done any controlled work on low-angle bevel-up configurations. It's one of many things I'd like to look into, though.

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#33

Re: Difficult woods

Warren in Lancaster, PA

David, all of your arguments are flawed except the one that a single iron takes less time to place back in the plane.

You talk about looking at "old woodies" with ineffective cap irons. Well, you can't take a plane that was used by a carpenter in 1890 and a farmer in 1930 and expect to see the kind of refinement that was used to plane the highly figured woods in Federal furniture in 1795. Even if one finds a 200 year old plane, it is likely that some handyman has used it in the meantime.

You say "single thin iron without the support of the second iron would not work as well". Perhaps you did not know that 18th century irons, both single and double were thin; thick irons are a 19th century development. I think it was Peter Ross (blacksmith) who told me he thought that 18th century workers could handle a thin iron and that thick irons were a sign of declining skill.

You talk of "old texts", but they sound like 100 year old material, not 200 year old material. If you have 18th century texts that bear upon this subject they would be worth quoting.

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#34

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LO

Guillaume Dery

Thanks for the explanation Rob.

I read too quickly/misunderstood Derek. I was understanding that people were talking about the introduction of a wear bevel on the back face from wear which I couldn't understand/ hadn't seen. This makes more sense now.

Just reading up on the wear profiles now. Fascinating. Even though I only noticed wear on the leading face up to now, I find it isn't so...

So much more still to learn!

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#35

Re: Difficult woods

David Weaver

Warren, all I'd ever need to know about double irons is in the pictures in Leonard Lee's sharpening book.

Peter Ross thought, or Peter Ross knew? I have some planes that are early 19th century that have thin irons (they are single iron planes). I don't find them that difficult to use. However, I don't see a lot of virtue in "skill" using a thin iron if it doesn't translate to a better finish on wood than a thicker iron. Could very well have been a cost to keep the irons thin in the earliest planes, or an effort to decrease the time early cabinetmakers would need to spend on stones.

Sometimes you go overboard accusing people of being "wrong" or "flawed", and follow it up by support things that a lot of people "think" might be true. So far you've shown an advertisement, and I've referred to writing that was part of an early 1800s advertising describing the virtue of ejecting chips. Perhaps you could quote the copious materials describing exactly what the second iron does that must've existed 200 years ago. You wouldn't need to quote a blacksmith who "thinks" that he knows a reason for something.

The fact that plenty of people who know well the development of planes don't agree with you straight away is proof enough that you don't have a definite 1 to 0 view of everything, but sometimes you come across as though you're running around with blinders on inside a bubble.

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#36

plus..

David Weaver

I think the thick iron does more to benefit the planemaker than it does the cabinetmaker. It should be obvious why that would be the case.

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#37

Re: plus..

Pam Niedermayer

I don't see that statement as obvious at all, David. I much prefer the surfaces left by the thick Japanese irons than those left by thin irons. Now I don't pretend to know why that's so, but it's definitely the case.

Pam

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#38

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LO

Brian Greene

What are the practical realities for sharpening given that as soon as the edge hits the wood it starts to degrade? Note that a) I sharpen for speed and performance not theoretical perfection; and, b) I don't know all that I need to know about wear bevels, clearance angles and such.

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#39

Re: plus..

David Weaver

On a western plane, a thick iron allows the planemaker to be a little more fast and loose with what they're doing bedding the iron and fitting the wedge, and still get a plane that doesn't chatter.

If a planemaker is using a single iron 1/8th inch plane, the iron has to be bedded just about perfectly to not chatter on a heavier cut.

The skill of the plane user to keep and use a 1/8th iron plane vs. a 3/16th thickness iron in a plane is not really much of a difference, but the difference in the quality of the planemaker's work is significant - especially on irons that would've been hand forged.

I would imagine the planemaker appreciated the thick irons more.

I also like the thick japanese irons, and in the days of powered grinders for western irons, I'd rather have a thick iron, too. If it's (in mathematical terms) a dominant strategy, then twaddling with something thin to "prove your skill" seems like a waste of time. But I don't believe that a comment from a contemporary blacksmith that is what they think might be the case (a blacksmith, not a planemaker or a cabinetmaker) isn't much proof, anyway.

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#40

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LO

philip marcou

I thank Gillaume for this thread and Derek for alerting me to it. And Rob Lee for "showing' my plane.

I am still reading through all the replies so right now I feel the need to tell everyone that I have a brand new web site here: www.marcouplanes.com which is very comprehensive . Undoubtedly, on checking it out, you will want to know who has produced this master piece-unfortunately this is a highly classified secret, on a "need to know only " basis (;).

Incidentally, the plane that Rob has is a very early version, and it is possible that the current versions have the same working characteristics but may have improved appearance and ergonomics. Even though I am a follower of the "If it ain't broke don't fix it " doctrine I still have the urge to "fiddle"..... Anyhow, if you look at the new site you will see that different knob styles, strange knurls, exotic unobtainium timbers and fine screw pitches, not to mention the finest dove tails in history, are alive and well....

Best regards,

Philip Marcou

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#41

Re: plus..

Pam Niedermayer

But I don't believe that a comment from a contemporary blacksmith that is what they think might be the case (a blacksmith, not a planemaker or a cabinetmaker) isn't much proof, anyway.

Of course it's not proof; but then this is not a presidential debate (debasement?) in which they go for the jugular and lie as a matter of course to get more votes/money. Seems to me you and Warren are surmising, making some intelligent guesses, having a chat; and you've come up with different answers. I've enjoyed it so far.

Pam

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#42

That's a really nice shop.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'd be tempted to say that if I had machines like yours I could produce work approaching the quality of your work. The truth is, if I had machines fabulously better than what you do, I couldn't begin to produce the masterpieces you have made. That miter plane on the opening shot is unbelievable.

Just WOW!

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#43

over simplification

Larry Williams

"...The information in Leonard Lee's book indicates that 7 degrees clearance is needed, and that it is possible to get away with a little less depending on the wood type..."

That's not what the book says or, at least, the way I read it. If it did say that, it wouldn't be accurate. There are just too many variables. Dealing with this in theory is very different from the real World and I deal with clearance angles all the time. This reminds me of talking to my accountant who knows that a $100 bill equals 200 rolls of pennies. In actually dealing with them one soon figures out they're very different.

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#44

Re: That's a really nice shop.

philip marcou

Thanks Bruce.

Everything except for the milling machine and a few small tools were moved to NZ from Zimbabwe, some eight years ago. Since I still haven't got rid of the sense of "temporary existence" here I still haven't made proper cabinets etc for everything and the hundreds of small engineering tools used for planemaking tend to crowd out all spaces. It would be nice to have an EXACT place for every small tool-they tend to run and hide when they know they are being looked for :D

Re the opening page with the M12 mitre plane: the plan is to post a new picture there every time a new plane is completed-so the next picture to be seen there is an S50A (bevel down smoother 50° Adjustable mouth), coming soon.

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#45

Quote of the week

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"It would be nice to have an EXACT place for every small tool-they tend to run and hide when they know they are being looked for."

Huh! Tool laziness and/or mischievousness. That explains it!

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#46

Thick irons

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I am sorry I mentioned the blacksmith. About 15 years ago he showed me some thin 18th irons he had made and offered his explanation. I don't have any idea why people switched to thick irons in the 19th century. I don't see any connection between double irons and thick irons; the use of double irons preceded the thick irons by more than a generation and later the thick irons were used for both double iron and single iron planes.

Frankly I think that any serious craftsman has to learn to make adjustments himself to the plane's bed, the wedge, the sole, et cetera. What do you do when an iron is worn out, David? Do you refit another iron or just throw the whole plane away? So I don't buy the argument that the planemakers wanted to incorporate a double iron to save time on fitting. Making a cap iron is a lot more rigamarole than doing a nice job on fitting the iron.

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#47

Re: That's a really nice shop.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

btw, is that big old bandsaw a Crescent?

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#48

Re: Thick irons

TomD

One of the overall flaws in a lot of these threads is the idea that "they" of the past:

1) did things just one way. Back then there were lots of reasons for having different ways. Commercial segmentations; inflexible task master; geographic separation.

2) whatever way they did stuff, was probably right, or based on evidence and scientific method due to various reasons: Like they were full time and desperately practical. Had centuries to work stuff out. And mostly because we can't easily think out of our own heads. Etc...

Of course nobody would say any of this flat out, but it is kinda built in. So if someone says they used thin irons, maybe that maker was the betamax of his time. Or lived in a part of the world with relatively worse access to steel. Krenov thought thin irons were best in his early book, but those weren't the irons Ron Hock built, all the while building thin irons for other planes.

Also modern commentators (myself totally included), often don't really know the technical aspect anyway. One interesting aspect of Japanese practice is that they quench in a quenchant that ought to shatter the steel. They ought to oil quench. But the composite works OK. Go back further and some sword styles used this process to induce the characteristic curve of some japanese swords. Basically a large scale version of the bimetal thermometer. The traditional approach to their blades in theory comes out of a distribution of swordmaking practices into other crafts (though I have never really found the proof this happened, or how wide the dilution effect was). I don't know whether they made planes the way they did because they made swords that way, or whether it was to make planing "difficult hardwoods easier" When the idea of difficult wood is kinda counter to their tradition anyway. Technical arguments are mostly just justifications for stuff one has already made one's mind up about, at least for now.

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#49

Re: Thick irons

TomD

"I don't have any idea why people switched to thick irons in the 19th century."

Bessemer got his patent in 1855. Could that have had an effect?

"So I don't buy the argument that the planemakers wanted to incorporate a double iron to save time on fitting. Making a cap iron is a lot more rigamarole than doing a nice job on fitting the iron."

And the wedge is more work also. One needs efficient screw cutting tech. They could have cut back on the unnecessary ornamentation on the planes if they just wanted a cheap product.

I subscribe to the idea that the tools normally follow the wood. Some people plane easy woods, others are making casework for royalty. There is probably nobody in modern recreational woodworking who has the slightest idea about the latter. Yet it was your high end at one time. And it was unrecognizable compared to what we see today. I started dropping my chip breakers back in the 80s. It's easy with Japanese planes, in fact dropping them is a whimp-out on the set-up. But I don't have time pressure to prepare very nasty veneer, I work almost exclusively in reasonably nice hardwoods like maple, cherry and walnut. Not burl veneer. I'm not completely willing to accept that chip breakers were a big mistake.

There is a lot of interest in Race planes today. Planes that can finish difficult woods completely by hand planing. I'm not all that sure that was the idea back in the day. I think they needed to not loose more than score a home run. Planing was defensive. Get stuff fast to the place where they could scrape or sand it, but always move forward, no tear-out that would destroy a piece or require starting over. Just a guess.

Re: Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)

#50

Re: Thick irons

David Weaver

Thin and thick iron is not the same as double iron and single iron.

I saw an entry in an english encyclopedia from 1824 that mentioned that a design for a thick single iron "with two bevels" had been submitted and pitched as the solution for working wood that a double iron plane can't handle.

Whether a craftsman fits a thin or thick iron to a plane makes little difference. I don't remember how long it took me to properly bed an iron the last time I did it, half an hour? For a craftsman, it doesn't matter if it takes an extra hour to bed a thin iron properly, if you can bed a thick iron, you can bed a thin iron well enough to get acceptable performance from a plane.

From the perspective of a planemaker, if it costs little or no difference to get the iron from butcher or whoever 1 1/2 times as thick as it was a decade ago, a less finished plane can be sent out.

I will believe that the thick plane iron was not demanded by the planemaker as a way to make planes more cheaply when I see it somewhere in the records of a company like chapin or someone that the skill of users was declining and thus a thicker iron was demanded.

I have conceded plenty of times that a second iron does work well if someone wants to play with one, but I just don't think that for a competent sharpener and user, that it's any real improvement over something like an infill plane with a managed mouth opening.

There have been times where I didn't use a 55 degree infill plane because I wasn't satisfied with the finish it left (on a hardwood). I can count exactly zero times in the last 3 years where I needed to use a second iron to get an acceptable finish. In fact, I can't even think of any time I used a "normal" wood (quartersawn hardwods, curly soft maple...) that I couldn't plane it with a japanese plane with an 8/10 bu iron, which is my first option if I don't like the finish my favorite infill plane leaves.

I just do not think as highly of a double iron as you do, and I think if everyone else was as hardcore as you are about it, certainly there'd be a lot more describing how spectacular it is compared to single iron planes, instead of some improvement to reward you for screwing around with it.

FTR - if I have a plane with a beat iron, then I bed another iron. You know as well as I do that bedding an iron is a time issue, not a talent issue. Any cabinetmaker would be able to do it in their sleep.