Real world experience
Steve Elliott
"I will bow to your real world experience . . . ."
For the record I should mention that most of my experience has been with using smoothing planes to refine surfaces produced using power equipment, mainly planers and wide belt sanders. These are nominally flat surfaces with ripples or scratches I want to remove. I use the smoothing plane until the visible flaws are gone from the surface.
An interesting comparison between planes and sanders is to take a sanded surface and plane it with a very finely set plane. I did this with a piece of maple that had gone through a well-adjusted wide belt sander. (This was a model that had two belts, coarse and fine. I don’t remember the grits.) At first the plane didn't seem to take anything off, just a few wisps of wood fibers. Then it started taking off lacy bits that weren't really a shaving. Finally, after taking off most of the scratches from the sander, the plane produced a full-width shaving. The surface of the wood got smoother and shinier and it was possible to watch the deepest scratches fade and disappear. There were also marks perpendicular to the grain that resulted from the joint in the sanding belt coming around at regular intervals.
Ironically, after I remove all the flaws from a surface I always sand it with a very fine grit to give the finishing department a "canvas" that will take stains in the way they expect.




