Thanks to Rob Lee/An Informal Plane review (LONG)
Guillaume Dery
Last week was a special meeting for the Handplane Special Interest Group (operating under the umbrella of the Ottawa Woodworkers Association). Turns out that Robin, in an assumed fit of insanity, actually entrusted one of the Lee Valley staffers who is also part of our group with a selection of planes from his own collection. Not only were we allowed to drool at these planes, the combined value of which is more than some people make in a year, Rob actually let us play with them!!!
Prior to arriving at our humble meeting, all of the plane irons received some loving attention from LV’s resident sharpening guru (among other skillsets), Brian. Brian respected blade geometry (grind angles and cambers) but boy did he hone them. Once Brian is done with an iron, forget shaving a patch of arm hair to test for sharp, you can actually split the hair lengthwise. All this to say that the playing field was level between all of the planes.
Ok, so what did we have to play with?
From Rob’s private stash:
• Marcou bevel up smoother in brass
• Sauer and Steiner Infill panel plane
• Holtey Special edition smoother
• Bridge City adjustable pitch smoother
• Bridge City block plane (a weird transformer looking thing which looked somewhat like an alien probe destined for unmentionable parts of your anatomy…)
Now Rob had requested that we not play with the Bridge City toys… errr…. tools… so we just admired them and only played with the first three items on the list.
From our own group:
• 2 shop-made wooden planes, one smoother sized and one jackplane sized.
• A multitude of Stanley/bailey smoothers
• LV bevel-up smoothers
What an opportunity! After the reverential oohs and aahs and the obligatory photo op, we got down to business. To test these planes’ mettle, we broke out some gnarly cherry with lots of tearout and a soft knot, some maple (birds eye and normal) and, at the end, a board of wenge (really nasty stuff to plane!).
Rather than a narrative, let me just give the rankings in 3 categories before giving some general observations.
Aesthetics/Design
Plane Score Notes
Marcou 8/10
The mass of this plane has to be seen to be believed. The lever cap alone weighs over a pound. Workmanship is flawless. My only two quibbles would be as follows:
• The mouth adjustment screws, although they function perfectly well detract from the overall appeal and are not the most elegant solution.
• The tote although extremely comfortable and well executed, is not the ideal shape for me.
Overall, a gorgeous plane which is well designed and easy to adjust. Low score probably reflects the lack of aesthetic appeal that the bevel up variety holds for me.
Sauer 10/10
Perhaps it is just my fondness for infill planes but this plane is drop dead gorgeous, the workmanship is flawless and the tote fit my hand like a glove. I wouldn’t change a thing on it.
Holtey 9/10
One can easily understand why these planes are considered the pinnacle of the planemaker’s art. Again, flawless workmanship and an overall gorgeous plane. Only reason it didn’t get a 10 is that it isn’t an infill and although different strokes for different folks, I cannot say that I am a fan of the look of the brass cones (flawlessly executed). Other minor quibble is that there was a bit of play in the rear tote.
Bridge City 8/10
Another flawlessly executed plane. However, the adjustment is too complicated/fussy, probably due to the variable pitch (gimmicky to me). The infill on adjustment screws is a gorgeous detail and they have probably the loveliest knobs in town. The tote however was a turn-off for me.
Woodies 5/10
Function over form. This is as basic as a plane can get with nothing to get in the way. Adjustments with a hammer (my preferred method at any rate). Stock is chosen for stability and usability, not appearance. Interesting note, one of the woodies had textured areas in the side for grip and tactile registration as well as a more raked back which tended to direct planing force down and forward. I intend to incorporate this on my upcoming woodie build. Highly recommended.
Stanley/Bailey 7/10
The old ways are often the best ways. No substantial improvements have been made to this form since mr. Bailey himself. Personally, I am a fan of black, brass and rosewood. Looks good, works good. Lateral adjusters are however, finicky beasts. I ignore them and reach for the plane hammer.
Veritas 7/10
A prime example of function dictating form and innovation. Certainly not the prettiest planes around but they do have a certain charm. I am however, not a fan of the totes although I realize that their shape is dictated by economy of manufacturing and function. From a design perspective, these planes go up to a 9/10. Norris adjusters are tight, work well and the mouth adjustment is ingenious. The designers have spent a lot of time and it shows. One should also note that when mass manufacturing at a certain price point, some compromises must be reached.
Functionality
Plane Score Notes
Marcou 10/10
The mass of this plane helps in use. Full width sub-thou shavings can be achieved easily and with little effort. Once started, the mass of this plane is like a freight train, you are just pulled along for the ride. Your only job is to steer. However, keep the wax handy for the sole, this is a lot of plane to move. Tearout, zero.
This plane demonstrates the value of a bevel up for dealing with gnarly wood. Bedded at 20 degrees and with the blade ground to achieve a functional planing angle of 50 degrees, it laughs at figure, knots and reversing grain. As a practical experiment, it left a glossy finish going against the grain in gnarly cherry. Having a few blades around lets you plane at a conventional angle for tame woods and softwoods.
Sauer N/A
Unfortunately, the mouth was so tight that it was difficult to achieve anything other than dust and intermittent shavings at best. However it feels like it would be a flawless performer if the mouth was opened just a titch. I was also discouraged from opening up the mouth as a favour to Rob.
Holtey 9/10
Another prime contender for the fluffy shavings society. It also laughs at grain direction and leaves a primo surface.
Being lighter than the Marcou, more effort was expended in use however. One had to bear down more significantly to start the cut and through the cut. I am unsure as to whether this is due to the weight difference or a bevel-up vs. bevel down difference. I would love to try one of his infill planes to remove mass from the equation.
Bridge City N/A
Rob only let us look at these, not play with them
Woodies 7/10
For those who want to spend the time to build one, these little beauties come out above the baileys and just shy of the Vertias. Adjustment is an art (although when mastered, like riding a bicicle, it becomes second nature). The normal planing angle and their light weight make them less than stellar for difficult wood however. Tearout was nothing that a bit of quality time with a scraper would not fix. However, being made entirely of wood, it should be noted that these can prove to be cantankerous beasts as they can move in unpredictable ways when taken out of their environment. This can affect overall plane geometry which may give a user fits to address.
Stanley/Bailey 6/10
These planes are perfectly functional once well fettled. However, they are rather light, there is a fair amount of backlash in the depth adjustment and the lateral adjusters are useless. A marked improvement in quality when the blade and chipbreaker are upgraded to Hock or LV. This pretty well eliminates chatter. The fact remains however that they are bedded at a standard angle which is proven sub-optimal for difficult woods. Unless you are solely doing studio furniture with cantankerous woods, an old Bailey with an upgraded blade and chipbreaker will be perfectly suitable for 90% of your planing tasks. Tearout can be significant with difficult woods.
Veritas 8/10
The first thing to point out is how close this plane came to matching the Holtey and Marcou in performance at a fraction of the price. It is nothing short of outstanding. The Norris type adjuster works very well and the entire plane is well thought out. Mouth adjustment is brilliant. When properly sharpened, this plane leaves a beautiful finish although there can be some tearout in more difficult woods
Affordability
Please note that these prices are my approximations based on conversations and may no longer reflect reality.
Plane Cost Notes
Marcou 2,000
The most reasonably priced premium plane.
Sauer 6,000
Considering what Norris Jointers are fetching, not at all unreasonable.
Holtey 14,000
Price reflects reputation and craftsmanship… and is in British pounds
Bridge City N/A
No longer made.
Woodies 80
Brass or steel rod, solid stable stock and a plane iron. That plus a lot of sweat equity gets you one of these
Stanley/Bailey 150-200
Approximate price includes an old plane and a replacement blade and chipbreaker. Adjust upwards for a Bedrock plane. Significant sweat equity in fettling
Veritas 200
Out of the box, lap iron, sharpen iron and go. Best bang for your buck
Parting Thoughts
Bevel-up vs bevel-down:
Aesthetics aside, in difficult woods, a marked preference arose among the users for the bevel-up smoother by Marcou. The ease of changing planing angle by dropping a new blade in cannot be overstated. Lack of a chipbreaker removes one point of failure and/or frustration. As these have thicker irons, they are less prone to chatter. If the planing angle is the same, the nod goes to the bevel-down. As an interesting aside, the bed of the Marcou is 20 degrees vs 12 degrees for the Veritas. When one shoots for a high planing angle, a higher bed angle is beneficial.
Planing angle:
50 degrees for figured or difficult woods. No questions, enough said. The increase of effort is not significant enough to outweigh the benefits. 45 degrees for normal tasks. Lower for end grain
Mass:
Heavy is good. It keeps the plane from stalling and powers through the difficult cuts. The Marcou was a monster and gave us the best experience. Interestingly enough, no one in the group found the extra weight tiring or a burden however. I thing I will solder some led to my Veritas now

Which plane would I take home?
Cost notwithstanding, if offered my pick of any of these planes to take home as a user. I would pick the Marcou hands down. This is the best performing plane I have ever used, bar none. It feels and performs flawlessly. What is scary is that it is borderline affordable so the temptation is there!
Some thoughts on the Veritas:
Rob, if you are still with me here, playing with these planes as a group led to some consensus. The Veritas plane was surprisingly close to the primo planes in use. Kudos to your design team for producing such a fine plane at such a low price. Here is what we/I would change on it (or introduce at your hinted at primo plane line):
• Introduce more mass, I don’t know how much it would affect your production costs to make a more massive casting or otherwise add weight to the plane but count me in for buying it if you come up with it.
• Increase the bed angle. I am now 100% sold on the bevel-up benefits. However, unless planing end grain, I would rather have a higher bed angle… say 20 degrees?... Not only does this add some mass and stiffen the plane, it makes for more reasonable grinding and sharpening angles for the iron when one wants a ridiculously high attack angle. It is hard to quantify but that 20 degree bed just works better.
Couldn't figure out how to insert pictures so I will save them for later.
Thanks for your patience.
Guillaume in Ottawa

This is stated (not yet proven) to occur more easily on low bed angles. To be blunt, I have yet to experience the incursion of a wear bevel, and I have a lot of time on BU planes. Still, it is an argument of the anti-BU plane brigade, and one that must be taken seriously.







