Pinnacle spokeshave
Joe Shelton
Has anyone tried the new Pinnacle spokeshave Woodcraft is now advertising?
I've seen nothing but photos, but am interested in it.
Joe
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Pinnacle spokeshave
Joe Shelton
Has anyone tried the new Pinnacle spokeshave Woodcraft is now advertising?
I've seen nothing but photos, but am interested in it.
Joe
no....but
Bill Tindall
I bought the set from Lee Valley and just love these tools. I do a fair amount of spoke shaving and these a joy to use. Easy to adjust, comfy in the hand, durable steel in the blade. What more could be desired? Something about tools designed by people that do woodworking results in an exceptional product.
I have other spoke shaves including some I have made but the LV are the ones I reach for when the need arises.
Re: no....but
TomD
+1. Though the one they originally made in bronze for Boggs was even nicer, but the Boggsish ones are still really pro.
Wow !!....that's a great tool endorsement...
roger lance
from you Bill....those spokeshaves were on my list....but now, I feel much more assured about them....I think Brian Boggs has spokeshaves thru Lie Nielsen but for more money than the LV offerings.
Re: Wow !!....that's a great tool endorsement...
TomD
The first Boggs one I know of was an LV collaboration. Then when they came out with the set at LN, LV also had their own product, that is simlar, but has their usual spin of new features. They are beefier than the first one they did for Boggs, which has it's points. LV also has that very cool one with the planar blade. I don't like the handles as much as some others, but it is a very neat tool. And on top of that they have a nice carrying case. I put all these shaves in there, and then wrap the roll around my drawknife, when I am travelling. They also have that Magnum shave, but I haven't tried it out yet. Certainly the go-to people for shaves.
For once everything hit the market at the perfect time for me as My Kuntz shave had just snapped on me.
Re: Wow !!....that's a great tool endorsement...
Pam Niedermayer
Is the one with the planer blade their super large version?
Also, have you tried one of the Japanese style spokeshaves?
Pam
Japanese style?
Jack Guzman from Maine
Pam,
Do you have a link to info on Japanese style spokeshaves? This is the first I heard of such an item.---Jack
Re: Japanese style?
wilbur
They are essentially a regular Japanese plane, with a very wide and short body. Japan Woodworker sells some, as does Hida Tool and other places.
http://www.japanwoodworker.com/dept.asp?s=JapanWoodworker&dept_id=12942
Re: Wow !!....that's a great tool endorsement...
TomD
Yeah I have one. The one I have is a straight and flat one, and I have it set-up for a fine shaving. Which is the short way of saying I don't use it much. I do a lot of spoke shaving type work with spoke shaves (rounds), as in making paddles, tillers, and chair parts, and general edges, so I like all the contours. I assume those are out there in Japanese form, but I haven't got them.
My very first woodworking project was a paddle, and I bought metal spokeshaves from Lee Valley. Just wore one of those out. I later replaced those with some records from LV with Hock blades, and now LV has their own shaves. It wasn't probably till about 2 years later, around '79 or '80, that I went all Japanese on my tools. All my cabinet tools started out Japanese, but my boatbuilding tools and greenwood tools have been western.
As you know Pam, but for others, the Japanese spokeshave have the wedge crossgrain, which is different.
Re: Japanese style?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
HNT Gordon does something similar, Technically speaking, it is of Malaysian influence, but looks a close cousin to Japanese spokeshaves ..

These are really excellent for interlocked grain. I completed a review a few years ago: http://inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/THE%20HNT%20GORDON%20SPOKESHAVES.html
Link to HNT Gordon: http://www.hntgordon.com.au/prodflatspokeshave.htm
Terry Gordon has a new design out, also of Malaysian influence (I have a couple of Malasian versions) designed for tight curves ...

http://www.hntgordon.com.au/prodsmallcurvedspokeshave.htm
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Japanese style?
TomD
I would call that at best a distant cousin. There are two parts to the Japanese one. There are two parts to every part on that thing. 
Re: Wow !!....that's a great tool endorsement...
Pam Niedermayer
I brought it up because you praised the LV shave with planer blade, and I wondered how they compared. I haven't ever used either, but am thinking about making a couple or three for various tasks.
A wedge? Where? I know of no wooden wedges in Japan Tool Land.
Thanks,
Pam
Re: Japanese style?
Pam Niedermayer
Thanks, Derek, valuable reviews; but my tasks right now involve chair seat shaping for which the handles would get in the way. That's also true of the Japanese style, but I can make them without handles. Of course, I could cut off the HNT handles, but that would make me cringe given their cost.
The most valuable were Terry's insights about how the shaves behave in use and how he designed them to overcome some of that behavior. Very interesting.
Pam
Re: Wedges
TomD
Or rather, they all have wedges, they are just not separate from the blade. 
Re: Low angle VS. Japanese
TomD
The blade angle on the LV low angle is really low, might be like 25 degrees, or whatever the bevel angle is. The Japanese shave could probably be made as low as 30, though the one I have is probably 40. So for endgrain, the low angles are pretty much in a class of its own. The LV attachment for The Low angle is really clever and would make an interesting plane if adapted to that.
Re: Low angle VS. Japanese
Pam Niedermayer
I'll have to dig mine out of storage and play with it more seriously.
Thanks,
Pam
agree on Boggs shaves