New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Chris Schwartz's new article

Posts

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#26

Just human nature...

John in NM

The curse of self awareness is that we crave definable answers to everything, and inherently desire that there only be one correct answer.

I understand completely the desire to continue to build and refine ever better tool storage, or jigs, or furniture. The desire to improve the world around you is another human trait, and for most of us satisfying that desire is more important than the money we spend on the project.

As far as I know, floor chests filled a specific need - secure storage of personal tools in an unsecure workplace, and relatively easy portability to a new workplace when necessary. Most cabinet shops I've been to over the last 20 years, the bulk of the tools were owned by the shop, not the cabinet makers, making the huge tool chest a bit of a legacy (one which many of us enjoy as much as furniture :D )

I admire pieces like the Studley chest in the same way I admire a pair of Vise Grips. Both are very effective for what they're designed to do, I sure wish I was smart enough to come up with a design like either one :D

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#27

One thing that is kind of interesting about....

roger lance

the Studley tool chest is that although numerous preservationists and researchers from the Smithsonian and other institutions have studied this chest and Henry Studley extensively, they have not been able to identify a piano or other furniture-type piece that they can establish as Studley's work....and they have sparred no effort in this search. What survives of Studley is this collection of tools and that chest....and I don't believe that anyone here who makes prototypes believes for a moment that Studley made his chest on his first effort....there had to have been many other incarnations of that chest over the years....changes made to accommodate new tools....changes made to solve storage problems....that chest was evolving....there was no perfect solution for tool storage that Studley went to immediately....no mail order plan that Studley bought and then made the chest and then went on to making other things....furthermore, Studley must have enjoyed the process of designing the ultimate in tool storage....the challenge must have given him pleasure (and some grief also)....but mostly pleasure....satisfaction at meeting his challenge....at solving his puzzle....and that maybe the real lesson here....do woodworking in a way that is satisfying to you....there is no one and only way to do things....even though there are people with a great amount of experience and skill, the way they do things is not the absolute and only way....thank them for their opinion and insight and then be on with your work....which will evolve and change too over time.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#28

Re: there is a difference.....and more on chests

Gary Roberts

'Manic' was not meant as a nasty comment, more of a lightening of the entire debate. Your reasoning is the perfect answer to the conundrum that is not a conundrum. You do whatever you need to do. We're a product of the everything in it's place society, the neat as a pin workshop with every tool in it's own french fitted spot. I've worked with machinists who are very much like that and all power to them. It's just not me.

You may decide at some point to build a chest, or buy an old one, or something else. Why worry about it at all is my point? Many people, not all people, are busy trying to define the ultimate whatever when there is no ultimate whatever, either traditional (whatever traditional means, what century are we talking about?) or modern.

We're boxing ourselves into a corner of our own making. Knock down those walls I say! Sorry, I got carried away.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#29

My shop mantra, alas...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

is "A place for everything, and everything out of place."

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#30

Jesper, Denmark

Re: there is a difference.....and more on chests

Jesper, Denmark

My grandfather was a cabinet maker in Copenhagen - pre 1900. He died long before my time, but stories remain about the shop and organisation. It was a five year apprentice time, where the apprentice lived with the family.

The very first thing the apprentice did (after learning to sweep the shop) was to build his own tool chest and complete set of tools, molding planes etc. These tools would follow the cabinetmaker throughout his life, and would therefore have to fit in a chest, so they could follow him from one workplace to the next.