New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Chris Schwartz's new article

Posts

Chris Schwartz's new article

#1

Chris Schwartz's new article

Patrick Gibbons

I read with great interest Chris' new article in Pop Wood on tool chests. I agree with about everything he says though we have a few differences. Both the sources I read said to nail the lower batons to the sides and the bottom. This increases the ability of the bottom to withstand the weight of the chest. Chris makes a good point about nailing the bottom to the sides as individual boards making repairs for this part of the box easier. He points out that the bottom is subject to rot in some environments. I don't see most woodworkers functioning in such a wet situation.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#2

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

David Weaver

I'd agree with you. In the days of woodworkers spending their time watching other people do work at conferences, and treating tools as though they shouldn't get a dent, surely boxes won't get wear, tear or water like they would've in days when people actually used them and moved them outside of the shops.

Maybe someone will have a water heater burst and put a boastable watermark on the bottom of a tool box. :b

Most of the tools I've bought used (that are of recent manufacture) still have their primary grinds. If the tools aren't getting used, surely the boxes aren't, either, and in most cases, a plastic stationary rack from home depot would be just as functional.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#3

Chests vs Cabinets

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have read the book and seen the movie. Not to mention the mag and the blog. Still, there are several questions I have about the preference for a chest over a wall cabinet.

My logic (not always good) tells me that a chest is a movable item, and was likely to have been the storage of choice for a carpenter or cabinetmaker who either did not work out of his own dedicated shop, or needed to do some travelling-with-tools. Did those who worked from a dedicated shop in Ye Olde times use a chest or prefer a cabinet?

In the recent PW article Chris answered one of my questions, this being "what do you do with the long planes, such as a 30" jointer?". The answer is that you build a chest long enough to store it. The dimensions of these chests took on a new perspective for me - they are large and too unwieldy for easy transport ... unless you have muscles like Popeye.

Surely not all handtools are stored inside a chest? What do you do with tools such as a mitre box and shooting board ... OK, they can go under the bench. But do you still store your nice LN #51 inside the chest and fit it to the #52 each time? And fit the mitre saw to the box each time? I would prefer a dedicated station for these (not that I have one).

I recall Chris writing that a chest is easier, more efficient, to use. For him, no doubt, and not simply because he has pared down his tool collecton, but because he genuinely finds it to be the case after a decade or so of doing so. I am not doubting his sincerity for one minute here. For myself, I lack the floor space to experiment. Also, I have many tools than I do not wish to part with and - to be frank - it is rather nice to look at some of them as a sort of "working display" while I build in the shop. None of my tools may be termed "garage/shop queens", but there are more than I need. I know I have a little problem :) (But I can stop any time I wish).

Clearly a chest is not in my immediate future, but the topic is interesting as it adds to ones ability to work efficiently.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#4

Re: Chests vs Cabinets

roger lance

Derek..... in the old European system weren't tool chests designed to hold an apprentices limited but growing collection of tools....and give some measure of security from theft....and then to give tool storage/ transport to young craftsmen as they entered their years of working their craft as journeymen??....only after years of journey and toil for recognized masters was a candidate elevated to the position of master of his craft and was, in essence, allowed to settle in a town...village...and put up his shingle as a master craftsman....given the chance to have your own shop, I would think furniture makers switched to tool cabinets and larger tool collections......and began to accept apprentices of their own. I did make a shooting board based on your designs and the Tico Vogt board....but still need to learn how to post a picture....but I'll get something up soon. Lets talk about your pending bench build here as well....theres things about that wagon wheel that I like....that BenchCrafted hardware looks very good.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#5

Re: Chests vs Cabinets

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

..... in the old European system weren't tool chests designed to hold an apprentices limited but growing collection of tools....and give some measure of security from theft....and then to give tool storage/ transport to young craftsmen as they entered their years of working their craft as journeymen??....only after years of journey and toil for recognized masters was a candidate elevated to the position of master of his craft and was, in essence, allowed to settle in a town...village...and put up his shingle as a master craftsman....given the chance to have your own shop, I would think furniture makers switched to tool cabinets and larger tool collections......

Hi Roger

That is my understanding. Are we missing something here? Perhaps Chris will chime in ...

For example, there are masses of specialist planes, such as molding planes (the complex shapes, not the basic hollows and rounds) that may be expected to be collected. Or were they considered disposable items? (just joking :) ). It simply would not be convenient to store such in the same chest. So did one then own and use more than one chest?

I did make a shooting board based on your designs and the Tico Vogt board....but still need to learn how to post a picture....but I'll get something up soon. Lets talk about your pending bench build here as well....theres things about that wagon wheel that I like....that BenchCrafted hardware looks very good.

Please post pics of your shooting board (new thread). What did you use of mine and what did you use of Tico? I always expect to learn from the observations of others.

My bench? .. good grief .. Roger, how do you keep track of such things?! My bench is a few projects down the priority list. I need it (my current poor thing is too small - just under 5' - plus I now have flattened the top to its limit over its 18 year life), but the house/family need a few things more. I will likely get to in in late January ... hopefully.

Meanwhile I would be most happy to hear your views on the BC wagon vise (which I have on a shelf).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#6

Re: Chests vs Cabinets

roger lance

Derek....I've had the pleasure of talking with a couple of craftsmen here in the US that were apprenticed in Europe....one as a cabinet maker....the other as a mason....and this apprenticeship system was no joke....both were given over to a master as youngsters (like 10 - 12 years of age) and they then lived with and worked for that master doing as they were directed and having very little contact with their families....they were completely dependent on that master for food, clothes, shelter....and they had to toe the line....daily....so to shorten this part of our talk, it was highly unlikely that a master would allow an apprentice much more than one chest to keep his tools and possessions....there just was not the room for the extravagance of more.....and the journeyman limited himself to one chest due to the practicality of having to transport it from master to master as he worked his journey in his craft....there were some very practical reasons why people had limited tools and a small chest to keep them in....it was not a matter of their choice but what their situation allowed. These were interesting men to talk with....childhoods that are much different than here....both were Dutch/German in background. I do want to get that shooting board up....used your inclined board and running fence....his double adjustable fences and standoff for the plane body....made a square fence, 45 fence, and donkey ear....got a LV BU jack and am looking at your hot dog for the future....think you'll like it....on that bench, I built a somewhat traditional Shaker bench (see posting of pic on 9/15/11 by Moses Yoder of my bench on this forum) which had a very old school tail vise based on a Frank Klauz design....as you know, you can not work on top of this design but you can on top of that wagon wheel and there are definitely times when thats going to be handy....more later.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#7

Shelves win

Bill Tindall

Doesn't seem likely that modern woodworkers have failed to discover this "good idea" of making a tool chest. Stooped over while rummaging in a box on the floor to fetch a chisel may be Period Correct but it doesn't sound handy. Even opening a door or lid to fetch a tool doesn't sound handy, if handy is most important.

I built a bench big enough that tools I will be using continuously (chisels for example) sit on the bench. The rest of the tools are located on open shelves or an under-bench drawer with the distance from bench being inversely proportional to the frequency of the tool's use. From the center of my bench I can reach, with no more than a simple rotation, planes, chisels, marking devices, squares, rulers, saws, scrapers, drill(cordless) and drills, glue, sharpening stuff and other. Everything I need to build except stationary power tools and their accessories is within 5' of the center of my bench on open shelves or in an under-bench drawer.

On the other hand, a tool chest does seem a logical project for those that focus on building stuff for the shop, and those inclined to have a "place for everything and everything in its place". But if the focus is building stuff for the living area a tool chest is not a place I would recommend spending effort for I don't see that it beats shelves for efficacy in building furniture.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#8

I'm in your camp

Ron in Sterling, CT

I have my most often used hand tools stored in drawers under my bench, and other frequently used tools (clamps, etc) hanging on the walls within easy reach (and sight) of the bench. I have a couple of antique tool chests which house my collection, er assortment of vintage tools that I do not use. These chests are in my study, not in my shop. I can't imagine rummaging thru a chest to find the tool I need, regardless of how organized they are. I like my tools readily visible, either in a drawer or hanging on a wall. I have nothing against tool chests, but it is not my cup of sawdust.

Ron

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#9

Tools in plain sight

Steve Elliott

"I like my tools readily visible . . . ."

Thirty years ago the shop I was working in was broken into and many of the hand tools were stolen. I lost two sets of chisels that were mounted on the wall behind my bench. A fellow employee had loaned me an infill rebate plane he had bought in England and by chance I had put it in the tool well of my bench and covered it with a scrap of plywood, just in case. The plane was not taken and its owner told me he wished I’d borrowed all his tools. He lost many of his favorites.

I can understand wanting to display nice tools, but I now keep all my best ones out of sight. I like to group tools for a given purpose together, so I have a box that holds a dovetail saw, marking gauge, layout knife, skew chisel, and so on. The cardboard box is so nondescript it wouldn’t draw attention and it speeds me up to have all the tools together ready for use. It also makes it easier to blow the dust off my work area without endangering anything valuable.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#10

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

TomD

Yeah that is the truth of the mater. In addition to which is that Chris will write another article, and a lot of people will get rid of the old box and build the new one. I have a few tools that are really ground down, but like you I am just as likely for many to get replaced with something else before the blade wears down more than a small amount. When heat treating O1 I just harden the last few inches. Lifetime, even if I power sharpen aggressively.

I did loose a box of planes to a basement flood once. They were in a cardboard box when the water rose. Thereby confirming a life long preference for bronze and wood.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#11

Re: Chests vs Cabinets

TomD

"I have read the book and seen the movie. Not to mention the mag and the blog. Still, there are several questions I have about the preference for a chest over a wall cabinet."

Old houses with infrequent posts, lath, and plaster, damp walls, etc... Do not seem to have spawned a lot of heavy wall fixtures. The kitchen had a pantry, not multiple wall cabinets until later. Many cooks who have used a pantry seem to prefer the "box outside" model. Hard to imagine real conditions back then, not that long ago there were laws taxing things like chimneys and windows. So extrapolating from back then is too tough for me.

"My logic (not always good) tells me that a chest is a movable item, and was likely to have been the storage of choice for a carpenter or cabinetmaker who either did not work out of his own dedicated shop, or needed to do some travelling-with-tools. Did those who worked from a dedicated shop in Ye Olde times use a chest or prefer a cabinet?"

Even in the modern shop, many workers prefer the mechanic's toolbox. That model exists today. When you move on to the next job you roll it out, and somehow get it into your pick-up. It remains popular for a variety of reasons, as in Roubo's day, in part because large shops have multiple benches in a large room. Or multiple car lifts.

"In the recent PW article Chris answered one of my questions, this being "what do you do with the long planes, such as a 30" jointer?". The answer is that you build a chest long enough to store it. The dimensions of these chests took on a new perspective for me - they are large and too unwieldy for easy transport ... unless you have muscles like Popeye."

One would have needed a cart. But that would apply to many household goods. It may also have occurred that they had to go on the road for some jobs.

"Surely not all handtools are stored inside a chest? What do you do with tools such as a mitre box and shooting board ... OK, they can go under the bench. But do you still store your nice LN #51 inside the chest and fit it to the #52 each time? And fit the mitre saw to the box each time? I would prefer a dedicated station for these (not that I have one)."

Those are post Chris tools. In Odate's day, they carried a rather small toolbox, and made many other items at the jobsite for each job. Their planing beams could shoot with the addition of cleats. This is stuff it takes seconds to set up.

"I recall Chris writing that a chest is easier, more efficient, to use. For him, no doubt, and not simply because he has pared down his tool collecton, but because he genuinely finds it to be the case after a decade or so of doing so."

The was also an article in the Mysteries column about that. I remember it being somewhat convincing. But to be real for a moment, Chris is just one guy, a professional communicator and performance artist. He translates what other writers tell us old pros did, for amateur workshops. Very interesting stuff, but none of it has got past my door.

There is this button on my CAD program called "explode". If one draws a figure that is complex, it can't be modified, but it can be exploded into a million dots and then modified. That is modern day woodworking. The traditions have been reduced to dots, and everyone just selects what they want to select.

"I am not doubting his sincerity for one minute here. For myself, I lack the floor space to experiment."

That would be the killer for me. And many shops large or small.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#12

The hazards of hobby magazines

James Watriss

I like Chris just as much as the next guy... and some of you probably are the next guys... But this is getting a bit ridiculous.

I have an old style tool chest, something I found on ebay or craigslist or something. It's nice enough. I don't use it, it's up in the loft. I mostly use a tool chest that I built at North Bennet, and the big storage setup that came with the monstrous bench that I bought when I set up shop. When I find something that's not working for me, I tweak it to make my arrangement work better for me. But just because Chris has a book out, is not a reason to rebuild my shop.

I give Chris his due for researching and working with old methods. He applied it to workbenches. He's applied it now to tool chests. And he's chasing the thread further with his new imprint. I think he's providing a wonderful resource for anyone who's GETTING STARTED, because it's all proof positive that you don't need to install a new service panel to get into woodworking. It's possible to do good work with simple setups and without having to take out a massive loan.

But it seems to me that another one of teh Shwahtz' foci is on systems that work... so you can use them productively to do something other than swimming laps around the kiddie pool.

I'm generally more concerned with putting together my next project, whatever it is, than with going back to basics every time the trends change. If you have something that works for you... use it.

I'm in a cranky mood. So... time for more coffee for me.

Happy Cyber Monday.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#13

Depends on woodworking motivation

Bill Tindall

For a long time I did my woodworking in isolation and incorrectly presumed everyone did woodworking for the same purpose, to make something useful for around the house or to sell. It has been hard for me to accept that there could be other motivations under the umbrella of woodworking. With so many things I want to make it is baffling to see others spending their woodworking time on activities that don't support my goal of making more furniture(loosely defined).

However, the motivation of some woodworkers seems to be to build elegant stuff that never leaves the shop-presentation grade work benches, shop cabinetry, refined jigs of primary woods, etc. While for me a tool chest represents a piece of furniture that won't get built, for others it would seem to be something else they could build for the shop to satisfy their woodworking desires. The latest in tool chests is an example, to be followed soon by an updated bench, no doubt.

It remains baffling to me why Chris would use his considerable skills to build something I consider utilitarian like a bench or tool chest when he could be using these skills to make a table or desk. But. for whatever reason. that is the way it is and his efforts at building stuff for the shop clearly have an audience.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#14

Re: Depends on woodworking motivation

Patrick Gibbons

I started researching tool chests two years ago. Before Chris or BC. I started building one and made a major mistake that makes me have to start over again. It was, and still is, my opinion that a tool chest will give my shop some much needed organization. I do not have wall space and don't know how all you others have so much. A tool chest is close by, easy to use, not difficult, and will hold all the things I can't find now. I believe I'll be able to build my other projects faster with it than without it.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#15

Well said Bill

roninkokomo

We are all different, and we go to the shop for different reasons. I know a few guys for whom the shop is the project. They will spend weeks building a chisel rack... and be happy as a clam.

More power to 'em. It is their time and shop.

I am 66 and can't afford that use of my time anymore. I have too many nice pieces of furniture to build.

ron

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#16

Agree with Bill

Jim in Fenton, MI

I'm currently working on a tool cabinet but I'm not obsessing about it. It will be well built with solid wood and hand cut dovetails but it is what it is; something to hold my tools. It's a project to try to make myself more efficient but it's certainly nothing I'm going to hang my hat on. Next up is a Queen Anne footstool and then an ES345 guitar and maybe a grandfathers clock after that. At 57, I have so much I want to make and times a wasting. Work benches, sharpening stations, et. al are like a good chef spending time making his/her cutting board....

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#17

Re: Chests vs Cabinets

Gary Roberts

Derek... I believe you've heard this from me already, if so, forgive.

Looking at old photographs, the best possible resource, I'ld say: there is no answer. Workers in permanent shops used both wall cabinets and floor chests. Or just wall cabinets. Workers in the field used floor chests. Some used over the shoulder totes and floor chests. Some used huge floor chests on the job site and carried other stuff. Some loaded everything on a wagon and set up shop at the work site.

I don't think anyone lost any sleep over what was the right or wrong way to do anything. The fancy ones that we see today were, and this is my feeling on it, advertisements for the craftsman to show a prospective customer just how good they were. That's why these fancy chests still look so good.

I have one question. Why did chests and cabinets have small locks? To keep out prying hands. None of these locks were substantial. They were just to stop the busybody from borrowing tools.

Stop obsessing. Go work wood.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#18

Bill....its probably a good thing that....

roger lance

you didn't work with Henry Studley making pianos because you would have criticized him for all that time and effort he spent fiddling on his tool chest :D

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#19

Wall vs Floor??

roninkokomo

I hear you, but I think for most of us wall space is easier to find than floor space??

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#20

Re: Chests vs Cabinets

Bob Lang

One of the hazards of reading old stuff about woodworking is to project our current mindset on the past. It's real easy to assume that woodworkers way back when were doing what we do as hobbyists, making one piece of furniture at a time to fill some need we have, either practical or psychological.

A lot of the old literature applies more to interior millwork rather than furniture making. If you need to haul all the necessary tools to a job site for several months, and keep track of them during that time, you have a different set of requirements than if you're staying in one place. If you make your living making stuff out of wood, you have a different frame of mind on nearly everything, such as tools, work flow, what's important and what's not.

Bob Lang

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#21

there is a difference.....and more on chests

Bill Tindall

There is a fundamental difference between not understanding something and being critical of it. I don't understand lots of things(String Theory for example), some of which I try to gain further insight into. But, I am not critical about how anyone spends their time unless you're on my payroll. If someone spends their time dovetailing a tool chest instead of a blanket chest I will remain bewildered, but not critical.

I met someone recently who told me her grandfather, or perhaps great grand father, was a cabinet maker in NY City (1900+/-?). She has his tool chest and some of the furniture he made. He was good. I would have liked to document the inventory in the chest but for whatever reason that was not to be. But I did get to poke into it a bit. The tool chest contained most, if not all, of what one would need to make furniture with hand tools. So I have no reason to doubt that cabinet makers in some sort of situation kept their tools in a tool chest. I have no insight as to the details of what environment the grandfather worked in to answer the question of whether the environment led to the tool chest or whether it was personal work preference.

Personally, I would not have found it convenient to work out of his chest, even if it was elevated to bench height to lessen stooping. While it was complex and ingenious in its layered construction to accommodate his many tools most were not at hand with a simple reach. It was not locked when I saw it nor do I recall if it was lockable.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#22

Re: Chests vs Cabinets

Gary Roberts

Bob, I agree. In looking over photos of, let's call them 'sedentary' workplaces such as patternmakers and furniture shops, I see wall hung cabinets for chisels, saws, hammers and other such tools and on the floor a large chest which I would take is for planes or other such tools. The combination makes sense from usage reasons. These are in shops were some security of tools was necessary. Unfortunately, I don't have a photograph of a lone workers shop with a cabinet or chest that really tells a story. Those that I do have tend to show a hodge podge of tools all over the place, which might be the truth of the matter?

I'm in the process of re organizing all the photographs so who knows, I may turn up something interesting.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#23

Re: there is a difference.....and more on chests

Gary Roberts

You've got it. There is no one answer. People used whatever they were used to, or wanted to use, or were provided with, or had made or who knows what for who knows what reason. I've seen every sort of old chest, cabinet, shelf, etc. in photographs and in person over the years and all it tells me is, there is no answer because there can't be one.

The only answer I am trying to come up with is why is there this mania for there needing to be a definable answer to things like which tool storage is better?

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#24

Re: there is a difference.....and more on chests

Patrick Gibbons

One of the plans I have for a chest includes a stand to elevate the chest. When I build my chest Bill, I'll tell you if it's difficult to access the tools inside. At this stage of the game I'm betting it won't be. Once again, I posit that a bench and a chest should be built at the beginning of things and thus doesn't get in the way of building furniture. Some of us just get things done bass-ackward. I'd have more furniture built up to this point if I'd just done things in the right order to begin with. There's also that little issue about my lack of talent, but that's another matter.

Re: Chris Schwartz's new article

#25

Re: there is a difference.....and more on chests

Patrick Gibbons

Gary I'm not being manic about which tool storage solution is best and I know you mean no harm in the statement. Rather it appears to me that tool chests are not viable in most people's minds. I agree with you that there are always multiple solutions to most problems. In my case, I already have storage on the walls and elsewhere for saws, braces and drawknives and I keep my planes on a shelf below the bench. I want a chest by the bench to hold the other tools I use on every project as well as some special tools that need protection and my joint making planes. I also believe a tool chest will help clarify what tools are a necessity and help cull out space and money wasters. Unfortunately I am far beyond that point as most people are at this stage. That's why I wish I'd built a chest right after my bench.