Re: Chests vs Cabinets
TomD
"I have read the book and seen the movie. Not to mention the mag and the blog. Still, there are several questions I have about the preference for a chest over a wall cabinet."
Old houses with infrequent posts, lath, and plaster, damp walls, etc... Do not seem to have spawned a lot of heavy wall fixtures. The kitchen had a pantry, not multiple wall cabinets until later. Many cooks who have used a pantry seem to prefer the "box outside" model. Hard to imagine real conditions back then, not that long ago there were laws taxing things like chimneys and windows. So extrapolating from back then is too tough for me.
"My logic (not always good) tells me that a chest is a movable item, and was likely to have been the storage of choice for a carpenter or cabinetmaker who either did not work out of his own dedicated shop, or needed to do some travelling-with-tools. Did those who worked from a dedicated shop in Ye Olde times use a chest or prefer a cabinet?"
Even in the modern shop, many workers prefer the mechanic's toolbox. That model exists today. When you move on to the next job you roll it out, and somehow get it into your pick-up. It remains popular for a variety of reasons, as in Roubo's day, in part because large shops have multiple benches in a large room. Or multiple car lifts.
"In the recent PW article Chris answered one of my questions, this being "what do you do with the long planes, such as a 30" jointer?". The answer is that you build a chest long enough to store it. The dimensions of these chests took on a new perspective for me - they are large and too unwieldy for easy transport ... unless you have muscles like Popeye."
One would have needed a cart. But that would apply to many household goods. It may also have occurred that they had to go on the road for some jobs.
"Surely not all handtools are stored inside a chest? What do you do with tools such as a mitre box and shooting board ... OK, they can go under the bench. But do you still store your nice LN #51 inside the chest and fit it to the #52 each time? And fit the mitre saw to the box each time? I would prefer a dedicated station for these (not that I have one)."
Those are post Chris tools. In Odate's day, they carried a rather small toolbox, and made many other items at the jobsite for each job. Their planing beams could shoot with the addition of cleats. This is stuff it takes seconds to set up.
"I recall Chris writing that a chest is easier, more efficient, to use. For him, no doubt, and not simply because he has pared down his tool collecton, but because he genuinely finds it to be the case after a decade or so of doing so."
The was also an article in the Mysteries column about that. I remember it being somewhat convincing. But to be real for a moment, Chris is just one guy, a professional communicator and performance artist. He translates what other writers tell us old pros did, for amateur workshops. Very interesting stuff, but none of it has got past my door.
There is this button on my CAD program called "explode". If one draws a figure that is complex, it can't be modified, but it can be exploded into a million dots and then modified. That is modern day woodworking. The traditions have been reduced to dots, and everyone just selects what they want to select.
"I am not doubting his sincerity for one minute here. For myself, I lack the floor space to experiment."
That would be the killer for me. And many shops large or small.