New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Brass backed saw

Posts

Brass backed saw

#1

Brass backed saw

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Hello.

I currently have an Adria DT saw. Like it a lot. I also have a small Dozuki saw that is ok for crosscuts.

I am looking for something I can grab and use for quick clean crosscuts of small pieces like drawer parts and so on.

I'd like to get a small brass backed saw. Something about the size of my Adria, maybe with an open handle.

I've looked at the Adria and LN offerings, but I am wondering if there is a place to buy refurbished old saws that are sharp and ready to use.

I am not interested right now in refurbishing one on my own and learning how to properly sharpen a saw.

I've looked at eBay but not being a hard-core handtool guy, I don't know what is reasonable and what isn't. That's why I am wondering if there is a trusted source of refurbished hand saws.

My dad has an old Disston saw that he said I can have some day. I prefer waiting on that...

Suggestions?

Thanks in advance.

Joe

Re: Brass backed saw

#2

get a new Lee Valley saw

Bill Tindall

They are as cheap as a newly sharpened "antique" and there is no risk that whoever sharpened it did it optimally. I paid $20 for a nice old saw for the task you describe. Then paid $25 to sharpen it and I would up with a saw I don't like because it cuts slow, because it was not sharpened optimally. I wish I have waited an bought the LV.

Re: Brass backed saw

#3

Re: Brass backed saw

David Weaver

Have you tried using your dovetail saw for small crosscuts? It may work better than you think.

I have not seen anyone selling refurbished saws at a price where it makes sense to not just buy a new saw, especially when a lot of the saws that are being refurbished are second line goods with some pitting and/or thick plates.

It does not make sense to me for someone to buy a $20 backsaw that was fixed up by someone and sold for $75 or $80. If you ever decide you don't like something like that, it's still a $20 saw.

If price matters, I would go with what was said above about LV.

If it doesn't, then I would just look around and buy one of the off-the-rack premium brass backed saws.

The most common old saws you'll find are disston 4s and atkins and other such saws that have a similar pattern, and they'll be steel spine saws (which say to me in use and looks that they were designed to be made of inexpensive materials and with as much machine tooling as possible). Vintage brass backed saws more often will come from england, and if you can find one cheaply, it will likely need work or be of a newer vintage and not desirable.

Re: Brass backed saw

#4

Re: Brass backed saw

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Why can't you use your dozuki? If it is a good quality saw it should produce a cut that is every bit as acurate and with a better finish than a back saw.

Robin

Re: Brass backed saw

#5

Re: Brass backed saw

Pam Niedermayer

We always think of ourselves making crosscuts across the top of the board down; but I don't actually do crosscuts that way. I start the cut on the far top corner, then work my way down and across; so I'd suggest that a backed saw is inappropriate, the back will mess with the slot cut earlier. I do understand why anyone would want a stiff saw, though, so go for a slightly thicker blade.

Pam

Re: Brass backed saw

#6

Brass backed saw are ideal for the task referenced

Bill Tindall

What was asked referred to "quick clean crosscuts of small pieces". I always reach for a back saw for this task even considering that I cross cut mostly on my table saw (and a framed saw for anything bigger when the table saw is inconvenient). I may have tried sawing from the top down as you referenced....once.....only to discover that the saw doesn't track well with this approach. No doubt the rules of thumb for how many teeth should be in the work for band saws has an equivalent rule of thumb for hand saws.

I almost never used a "backless" saw any more, eg Diston or Sandvick. If the task is small I reach for the back saw. If the task in intermediate or repetitive the table saw will be used. And, if I am braking down long lumber into cuttings I used a frame saw with very coarse teeth (one of those red wood framed "firewood" cross cut saws with the 4 cutters and a raker pattern). The latter mows through 8/4 lumber with a breeze.

Re: Brass backed saw

#7

What you are aiming for ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I currently have an Adria DT saw. Like it a lot. I also have a small Dozuki saw that is ok for crosscuts.

I am looking for something I can grab and use for quick clean crosscuts of small pieces like drawer parts and so on.

I'd like to get a small brass backed saw. Something about the size of my Adria, maybe with an open handle.

I've looked at the Adria and LN offerings, but I am wondering if there is a place to buy refurbished old saws that are sharp and ready to use.

I am not interested right now in refurbishing one on my own and learning how to properly sharpen a saw.

Hi Joe

First off, you need to narrow down your search to the saw plate size and the teeth configuration. Only then will you know that you are buying the appropriate saw.

The two crosscut saws I recently built are the specifications you are are after. One was a carcase saw (11" long plate, +/- 2 1/4" under the brass back, and 14 ppi crosscut), the other was a smaller joinery saw (9" long plate, 1 1/2" under the brass back, and 16 ppi crosscut). The carcase saw is for crosscutting boards with widths of 3" and greater, while the joinery saw is for narrower widths, plus more delicate cuts such as the dovetail ends of a tail board or small tenon shoulders. There are pictures of my saws in a thread below.

The absulte Best Bang for the Buck in a new joinery saw is the Veritas Small Crosscut (16 tpi and 9 1/4" long plate) ... http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=64007&cat=1,42884,64007

Veritas also have a 11" long and 14 tpi crosscut carcase saw here: http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=66066&cat=1,42884

At under $70 each they are a steal in a new saw with this quality. Please note that I have used neither, but do have and use the Veritas dovetail saws, which are superb. I cannot imagine that the others would be less than this. Veritas also stock the Wenzloff saws, of which the types you are seeking are available. However the prices for these are at least double the Veritas and more than you indicate you wish to spend.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Brass backed saw

#8

Re: Brass backed saw

Patrick Gibbons

Two other options are to buy kits from Wenzloff or Tools for Working Wood. There's a lot of pride in putting a tool together, even from a kit. And it would be a beautiful and sweet-cutting saw.

Re: Brass backed saw

#9

Re: What you are aiming for ...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Thanks all for taking the time to offer suggestions. Again, I'm not a hard core hand tool guy so I'm not sure what to get. I do know enough to know that a saw isn't just a saw... there are so many different types and different configurations and different intended uses.

I guess the carcass saw fits the bill.

I'll take a good/better look at the Veritas offerings.

I've considered the LN or Adria type higher end saws, but thought maybe, for less money, an old 'antique' saw would be okay. Seems like, from Bill and others comments, it isn't the best/most logical choice.

The Veritas saws seem like a good route to go. Guess I would have to decide 11" or 9-1/4" saw. 14 vs. 16tpi.

Thanks again, I appreciate the help.

Joe

Re: Brass backed saw

#10

that's easy

Bill Tindall

Get the longer saw with less teeth for handy sawing of small stuff. The extra weight makes it cut faster. If you intend to use the saw for small stuff where it seems silly to start the 3HP motor on a table saw then you want the saw to get on with the task, or you will find yourself reaching for the table saw switch. . My saw stays within reach of the bench, if not on it. Anything fractional inches to a few inches gets sawed with it unless there are repetitive cuts to make where the table saw would make sense.


For breaking down long lengths of lumber into cuttings this firewood saw works great. The blade is easy to sharpen, no complicated angles to deal with. It breezes through 8/4 stock. As in the picture, I bridge the 12' lumber between two bench vises and saw away. With a bit of practice I can track a line as well as with a traditional hand saw. The blade needs to be a 4-cutter plus raker style to cut quickly. A large triangular file is used to sharpen the blade.

Re: Brass backed saw

#11

Re: Brass backed saw are ideal for the task refere

Pam Niedermayer

I almost never used a "backless" saw any more, eg Diston or Sandvick. If the task is small I reach for the back saw. If the task in intermediate or repetitive the table saw will be used. And, if I am braking down long lumber into cuttings I used a frame saw with very coarse teeth (one of those red wood framed "firewood" cross cut saws with the 4 cutters and a raker pattern). The latter mows through 8/4 lumber with a breeze.

Just a note to suggest that while I believe all of this, your frame saw is NOT a back saw. Right?

Pam

Re: Brass backed saw

#13

In my case

Bill Tindall

For how I wound up using a small saw for cutting small stuff (ie. a handy saw to keep at hand on or near the bench to supplement my table saw) I would have been money ahead had I bought the LV saw rather than the old back saw route I took. I tried the LV dovetail saw at a show and it felt as good and cut as good as the LN saw costing twice as much. I have not used the larger LV saw; only presuming it is as good.

Keep in mind that I worship the concept of multitasking tools so I am inclined to own a tool that does a lot of tasks acceptably. Also, I keep on hand a Zona saw for the occasion that a very fine cut is needed, for example a very small molding or dowel. And I use a table saw when I find it more convenient or productive.

Re: Brass backed saw

#14

Is this a left handed or right handed saw?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Just kidding.

I just ordered the Crosscut Carcass Saw, 14tpi.

I told my wife I blame Bill....

Thanks all for the replies.

Joe

Re: Brass backed saw

#15

After you've had your new LV saw awhile

roger lance

how about a little report of what you think of it??

Re: Brass backed saw

#16

Re: After you've had your new LV saw awhile

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Will do, but keep in mind I'm not a committed hand tool guy.

In fact, looking at the picture of this saw, I don't see a switch or power cord. Hope it come with instructions so I know how to turn it on...

:)