New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Questions on UHMW polyethylene

Posts

Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#1

Questions on UHMW polyethylene

roger lance

I'm preparing to make a shooting board similar to Derek Cohen/Tico Vogt's board and I will use UHMW sheets for the plane bed. I've never worked with this product before and have no familiarity with it. Can it be held down with two sided turners tape (which holds other things extremely secure)?....or is its' slippery nature not glueable/tapeable? Will I have to secure it with screws? I'm also considering making a wooden plane with a LV iron that will be dedicated to shooting (if LN would send me their 51, I'll happily keep it and review it for them :D ....no chance)....any thought on a dedicated wood shooter also welcome. Thanks.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#2

Miracle Fiber W

TomD

I think tape sticks to it well. The piece I found in the shop had some PSA sandpaper mounted on it. I like the stuff, but it isn't all that stiff or straight. Woodworkers can achieve and hold much tighter tolerances with wood. I would probably do something like this:

glue two layers of 3/4" maple together with ample boat epoxy. Glue 1/8" veneer of maple on top of that. Finish the sides and bottom with epoxy. Then I would finish the top with oil and wax. This way you don't have any wood thicker than 3/4", you have the bulk of it encapsulated, so it will hold zero in most reasonable weather you should be building furniture in. Start with decent wood. With wax and oil finish the top should be as slick as UHMW, and it should remain so a long time without maintenance.

Straighter, stiffer, cheaper, weather resistant, woody.

If they can build this out of wood, you can probably make a shooting board:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bQpTkLm6T3U

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#3

Seems overkill

Bill Tindall

If you are building a shooting board to use, that is to say functional only, they are so easy to throw together and they receive so little use that I regard Baltic Birch plywood the ideal material for construction. (By little use, I mean that it is not like the sole of a plane or some such.) If I ever have significant wear on the various ones I have I will simply take a few minutes and make another.

I regard wooden planes ideal for those special purpose applications that benefit from a specialized plane. I just can't see paying the price of a table saw for a LN shooting plane. A Stanley bench plane is just not handy on a shooting board.

I would suggest you build the plane in low angle geometry and if you make all your specialized planes the same width, one expensive iron can be interchanged among them as needed.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#4

On Shooting Boards

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

Thanks for the compliment.

My view about shooting boards - and I have made many! - is that one either makes the most basic design (because it is not a compicated tool and the task involved is equally fundamental), OR one makes a fantastic tool that provides a great deal of pleasure - both from the accurate results and from the quality of the design/workmanship.

At a recent local LN Hand tool Event I made up a bunch of LN design shooting boards for all to use. These are cheapish to build and very versatile: straight edges, mitres, and left-and-right sided for moldings ...



Now the other end of the spectrum is a ramped shooting board. Is this an upgrade? Absolutely YES! I have compared shooting boards and shooting board planes, here ...

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/ShootingPlanesCompared.html

My latest rendition of a shooting board is this design. It has a single fence that changes postion from straight to mitre. The fence can also slide in-and-out to take up wear or angles.



I upgraded the design shortly after the LN Show to include an adjustable running fence for the shooting plane, which was an idea stolen from the Stanley #52 ..


With the combined straight/mitre fence you only need one accessory, a donkey's ear (note the non-slip on the fence) ...


The Main Fence has micro-adjustability over about 1/4" for fine tuning. The Donkey's Ear connects directly to the Main Fence and, thus, uses this micro-adjustability. There are also adjustable feet to ensure perfect alignment.

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/ShootingforPerfection.html

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/RunningFencefortheShootingBoard.html

Also note that I do not use any special materials to increase the running of the plane. A Danish Oil finish plus wax is all that is needed, and less complicated to maintain.

There are a number of articles on my website on shooting plane design. Some are included above. Please feel free to email me any time if you want any information if interested in these designs.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#5

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

Alex Grigoriev

Get adhesive UHMW tape. I use that on my shooting board.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#6

Re: Seems overkill

roger lance

I was also thinking baltic birch as it should take and hold metal inserts better than MDF (which is flatter)....your suggestion to make specialized wood planes that all could share one really good iron is appealing....I even know a guy who has made numerous wood planes and I'll run the idea of a shooter to him (I think a wood plane might lack the mass that is desirable in a shooter)....the price of a LN 51 does slow a fellow up considerably....so I need to get experienced with shooting boards and shooting to really know my priorities here....but thats the fun of making things yourself....you'll know more tomorrow than you know today.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#7

Re: Seems overkill, not

Pam Niedermayer

I typically use two wooden planes as shooters, a Mosaku 54mm and a HNT Gordon try. They both work great, have never failed me. Both are made from very hard woods, Hon Red Oak and desert ironwood respectively; and both have great blades.

Pam

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#8

Re: On Shooting Boards

roger lance

Derek....I've been to your site many times and have read numerous reviews several times including your reviews on shooting boards and shooting planes....when I happened upon Tico Vogt's shooting board there were a number of things about it that seemed familiar :)....I am challenged to make a ramped board and really like the adjustable fence idea from the 52...will that fence work well with a plane that does not have a long flat side surface to ride against the adjustable fence like a LV BUJ ??....by the way, there is a job opening in Cincinnati, Ohio....they are looking for someone who knows about woodworking....especially hand tools....knows how to write....and knows how to illustrate a presentation with pictures....interested??....probably not, the commute would be tough!!....anyway, thanks so much for all your efforts at illustrating/reviewing hand tools....its a great help to a pilgrim like me.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#9

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

roger lance

Alex....I've found that tape at LV and WoodCraft (up to 3" wide)....the tape is durable in this application?....do you have to replace it much?

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#10

Re: Seems overkill, not

roger lance

Thanks Pam.....I'll look into those planes....seems like I've heard of the Gordon line....maybe my friend, who has a number of wood planes, might have a shooter....I need to invite him out to coffee!!

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#11

craigd

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

craigd

I have the tape on my shooting board and am underwhelmed. It is nice and slick and durable but has wrinkled.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#12

Re: On Shooting Boards

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I am challenged to make a ramped board and really like the adjustable fence idea from the 52...will that fence work well with a plane that does not have a long flat side surface to ride against the adjustable fence like a LV BUJ ??....

Hi Roger

If you are referring to the "carousel" fence I designed, then I would not recommend it. While good in theory, it not at stable as the latest fence (in my post above). I plan to remove it from the website.

With regard the LV LA Jack, as I noted in my article (link also above), once the technique to hold it is grasped (excuse the pun :) ), it is actually nicer to use than the LN #9. So nothing "wrong" with the LV LA Jack. What makes it even easier - in fact, what makes ALL shooting easier - is the running fence. That is one recommendation that must not go overlooked.

Thanks for the compliment again - the skills that Chris Schwarz brought to PW mag, and continues to bring to writing, are very hard to beat. He has the communication skills of a trained journalist - and writes with discipline - as well as the insights into woodworking that make him a great teacher. Plus the energy and vision to make it happen. That is why he has raised the bar and interest in woodworking. Not many of these guys around to fill his shoes.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#13

Re: Seems overkill, not

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Commenting on the planes discussed above ...

For some years I used a HNT Gordon Trying Plane for shooting. This was replaced by a Stanley #62, which was in turn replaced by a LV LA Jack.

The HNT Gordon Trying Plane is a wonderful plane, but it is not as good for end grain as the others, especially the LV LA Jack. The biggest difference is the low cutting angle that the BU planes can obtain. The Gordon planes at 60 degrees, and this requires the blade to be at ultimate sharpness all the time, plus it still leaves a relatively coarse finish.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#14

Re: On Shooting Boards

roger lance

Derek....I guess what I meant was the running fence....the equivalent on the 52 does not adjust....its fixed to perfectly receive the 51....your version of that feature is what I was referencing....where you made it to adjust to fit the plane you were using....so you like the LV BUJ with that running fence??....that may well be the way I'll go....after reading all your reviews of the LV BU planes, I don't think I could go wrong with that group!!

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#15

Re: Seems overkill, not

Pam Niedermayer

Good points, Derek. The Mosaku has a much lower bed angle than the HNT, and I also use the LN LA jack on occasion, but rarely.

Pam

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#16

One answer.....

roger lance

Just returned from the local WoodCraft which carries 4" x 24" sheets of UHMW in thicknesses from 1/8" to 3/4". Performed an experiment with two-sided turners tape. The tape held the UHMW sheet very securely....so thinner sheets of UHMW could be used on a shooting board and should not have some of the issues that UHMW tape has in this application.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#17

You could also try silicone...

John in NM

that stuff seems to stick to everything, especially if you don't want it to :D

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#18

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

Alex Grigoriev

The tape I used is 0.35 mm thick. I applied it after a coat of varnish. I don't know if it will hold better/worse is applied to bare wood. So far it held well to any abuse.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#19

Or urethane

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

which is even better at sticking to everything, though most enthusiastically to clothing and skin, I think.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#20

Re: On editorial jobs

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"...by the way, there is a job opening in Cincinnati, Ohio..."

Derek wouldn't want that job - these wimpy American hardwoods would be no challenge to someone trained on the woods of Oz. He'd feel like he was doing soap carving, and they'd have to be sending ocean containers of jarra over every month.

On the other hand, having a woodworking magazine with an editorial board that included a licensed psychologist, in addition to the editor with an ABD* in Elizabethan literature already on staff, would make for some interesting articles :D

*For those not familiar with academic acronyms, "ABD" stands, officially, for "all but dissertation," but is more commonly understood to mean "all but done."

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#21

Let me take exception.

Gary Smyth

ABD does indeed mean "All But Dissertation". But "All But Done" is inaccurate. The dissertation process is by far the toughest part of the terminal degree. The dissertation is not merely writing a report. It is an exercise in self control and perseverance. First there is finding a topic that not only has never been done before, but meets the approval of each member of the seriously critical doctoral committee, AND will not be completed by someone else (completely unknown) before you have yours signed off and registered at the University of Michigan clearing house after the final defense. It involves an oral presentation of substantial written research under review by peers who are determined by honor, and the pettiest of challenges to defend their life choice by making your work no less than their highest expectations. There is revision after revision, chapter by chapter, from no less than five Ph.D. prima donnas who want you to amend your data to reflect their thoughts. To earn a Ph.D. there is a language requirement at most universities (which thankfully will accept music (playing/writing, not listening) and computer programming as a language). There are time constraints to assemble current information, construct a questionnaire, collect data, get a statistically valid sample, assess the hypothesis, draw conclusions, and state the present, and future, based on your study. Finally, there is the defense where the committee has had the opportunity to review the written work and will pose questions that will cut to the bone if the victim can’t support his/her result based conclusions. At that point it’s swim or forever go under. “All But Done” does not begin to excuse the candidate that does not complete the task.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#22

agree

Bill Tindall

No dissertation usually means flunked out of grad school or simply quit, at least in science and engineering. In some schools and some departments there is so little course work that the dissertation is essentially the only degree requirement. It is kind of like running a race and not crossing the finish line to have an official time posted. Who knows how far you got, and who cares.

I have never heard the term "ABD" in the sciences or engineering. Maybe in the liberal arts someone would admit that they tried for an advanced degree and failed to achieve it but in the sciences most would be embarrassed and hide the fact they had failed to achieve the goal. If in fact one is actively working toward an advanced degree and in the dissertation stage then one modestly states the fact they are working toward a degree, period. No status conferred until finished.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#23

ABD

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Composer Milton Babbitt (1916-2011) was ABD for 46 years. He taught at Princeton from 1938 until 1984. His doctoral thesis was rejected at Princeton in 1946, but it did not seem to bother him. In 1992 a new committee accepted the original thesis with no additional work on his part. Perhaps they thought it would look bad in his obituary that Princeton had rejected him.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#24

I've known several...

John in NM

All fellow geologists :D :D :D

Though I will say it seemed more common to be "all but thesis"...

One even was a registered professional geologist with the fancy little seal and everything, but not even a bachelor's degree. His mere existence seemed to annoy at least one other registered geologist I knew :D

I would imagine though, that this is a quirk of the field of exploration geology, which tends to be extremely cyclical, with salaries matching the boom or bust. In lean times, people tend to go back to school, but when jobs are plenty, the temptation is to go earn some good money for a change.

Come to think of it, my grandfather was a civil engineer with no degree, building hydroelectric projects in the 1920's-1950's.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#25

Didn't mean to offend

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I was teasing, but sure didn't mean to offend. I know, from observation (not from experience; I decided a BA was enough for me), how rugged the dissertation process is. We occasionally hired faculty who were in process on a dissertation, contingent on finishing within a deadline; they usually looked like a cross between raccoons who'd stayed up for a week and deer caught in the Headlights of Doom when they were done. Being new on the tenure track is way more than a full-time job in itself, and combining that with finishing the dissertation is murder.

And political, too. One of our faculty was getting her doctorate from a Midwestern institution, and her committee (or perhaps it was just one member, don't know) got seriously offended by her choice of university for which to work, and proceeded to start gaming her. She finally finished, but we had to extend her deadline twice.

So, again, I sure didn't mean to offend.