New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Questions on UHMW polyethylene

Posts

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#26

I am an ABD

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

In my case I, quit, after having done all the course work and comprehensives (economics).

Dissertation, like Gary said, is quite an undertaking. At the time I had started working, and for the first time in my life money was good. Plus my director, one of the top econometricians in the world, had plans for me that I didn't find attractive enough...

ABD should be a sign of someone quitting, not failing. It is the very rare occurence where a candidate fails the thesis defence, if only because it makes the thesis director look quite bad (they tend not to like that...).

My understanding (that's what I was told a long time ago) is that in the US people who fail their Ph.D. get a masters degree as a consolation price if certain requirements are met... Is it the case?

DC

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#27

No offense taken.  No problem here.


Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#28

Me, too...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

and in my case I quit my program simply because the job market virtually vanished 30 years ago. I didn't want a teaching position, and the rest of the market ceased to exist. I had successfully defended my master's thesis the year before, and my adviser had already approved my dissertation topic. Since I had my MA, I just moved on.

However, I had friends who were in masters bypass tracks and when they didn't finish, they had nothing to show for 5 years of work.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#29

In reply

Gary Smyth

Where I was a student, after acceptance, a Masters degree was awarded and separate before acceptance to a doctoral program. At that time a Masters required an additional 30 credits post graduate with an acceptable grade point average, with a thesis but no written comprehensives or orals. After completion of that, to be accepted as a doctoral candidate took a review of past work, standardized test results, and an interview. An additional 30 credits plus the rest finished the requirements.

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#30

Re: In reply

Jerry Nicholson

When I got my Masters in Physics almost 50 years ago, the thesis, written comprehensives, and orals were all requirements. Attendance at the graduation ceremony was also a requirement then. The orals committee was a bunch of sadists who delighted in torturing the candidate. I knew one guy who had a panic attack and almost fainted during his orals. Then he had to do it all over again. The head of the Physics Department actually came to my rescue when a mathematician started asking me some stuff so obscure that nobody understood what he was trying to get at.

Jerry

Re: Questions on UHMW polyethylene

#31

Re: In reply

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

Your experience pretty much matches what happens/happened in Canada, at least in the social sciences fields.

DC