New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Dovetail standards

Posts

Re: Dovetail standards

#26

New Hampshire Furniture Masters Association

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

I remember reading an article (I think it was in Woodwork) about the standards of the association. One candidate submitted a piece that was "kosher" by the standard of antique furniture. The piece was rejected ("deferred" was the word used) because of, among other things, gaps in the joints (not just dovetails). The candidate re-submitted the piece unchanged, arguing that this was the way it was done in the past. The evaluation committee then stuck business cards in the joint gaps...

The standard for the association regarding craftsmanship is, not what was done centuries ago, but rather the best that can be done today. 200 years ago it was understandable to leave the insides of cabinets rough, at that anything not in view, as it was done all by hand. Nowadays, it's not that big a deal of planing the inside of a cabinet when the bulk of the work can be done by machines, so the argument doesn't hold as well. The association demands that no shortcuts be taken.

Is this elitist? I guess. Is that level of craftsmanship necessary? Not for functional pieces, but this is not what we are talking about here. Does this limit the market? You bet! Few people are willing to pay for this level of craftsmanship, therefore there are few craftsmen who can make a living at it.

I strive to attain that level of craftsmanship. I'm not there by any means, not even close. But I'll keep working at it. I don't do this for a living, so I can afford to...

Cheers,

DC

Re: Dovetail standards

#27

Re: Here's what I think ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Rob writes, "let's strive for perfection". I would like to stress something in this regard.

Somehow we need to find a way, on the one hand, of recognising that this is a destination - perhaps achievable, perhaps not. And on the other hand we need to support the efforts of all by recognising that we all make errors and the journey is rarely a smooth path for even accomplished woodworkers.

Over the past year or so I have posted many of my experiences that chronicle not only my successes but also my failures. I have been concerned that many woodworkers are intimidated by the expected apparent ease with which joints are cut and furniture is built. My posts are intended to draw out the reality here, such as (currently) the time it takes to build a drawer.

I have learned a lot from the exchanges of ideas, the critiques and the information supplied here. These are good topics. And I believe that they will encourage many along a path to do the best work they can.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dovetail standards

#28

Indeedy yes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My wife and I got involved in a community choir last year. After 40+ years of believing I couldn't sing, I've discovered I can. I won't be invited to Carnegie any time soon, but I can hit the pitch, swing with the rhythm, and convey the emotion (the main elements of "carry a tune"). I'm striving to get better, but in the meantime, I'm getting out there and singing. I'm better for it, and people aren't rushing for the exits when I get up, so they're at least not much worse for it. I'm glad I didn't wait until my singing was "gap-free," but I am determined that it will improve as I practice more.

I note that Bill Tindall was specific in his initial post that he was addressing beginners and people who hadn't cut dovetails. Rob Cosman makes the argument that he can teach people (even people in their 50s and 60s!*) the art of high quality dovetails; but not everyone can afford one of his classes. Imperfection is probably unavoidable for most of us.

I used to say at work (human resources) that our goal was zero errors, and that we'd never reach that goal; that we should acknowledge our mistakes and accept that they happened, then figure out how not to make them again; but get our work done, because there was always more work than hours to do it in.

I'm not arguing that we should accept mediocrity, nor do I think Bill Tindall was. I am arguing - and I think Bill T. was, too - that we should do our best, work hard at raising the bar for that best, but not wait for perfection to get work out the door.

-----------

*I was amused by this, after my initial flash of irritation. My fine motor skills, my understanding of standards and quality, and my grasp of how to work wood, are better now in my 60s than they were when I was 20 or even 30. The only thing that gets in the way now is middle-aged vision and close focusing (well, and the neverending list of non-shop projects), something that I can accommodate as needed with magnification (haven't found a cure for the to-do list problem yet). Rob Cosman, I urge you to save your post somewhere you can find it on your 60th birthday and ask yourself then what you think of your younger self's statement :D .

Re: Dovetail standards

#29

I agree with Rob!!!


Re: Dovetail standards

#30

Re: Indeedy yes

rob cosman

No sweat Bill, 60 is only ten years away, I am sure i will be able to read that thread right here in 2021! As for not being able to afford my instruction, I have multiple free youtube videos, I have a membership site that teaches the process for $20 a month, my dvds are only $30 and my book on the topic is $25. I dare say all or any of this is within the reach of most folks.

Cheers

Rob

Re: Dovetail standards

#31

Re: Indeedy yes

Pam Niedermayer

And my parting shot: How nice to know how many ways we can give you more money, Rob. Now probably you'll complain in email that you have to make a living, therefore, Bill should shut me up. Have at it. You guys are pretty much in league anyhow, members of the ungentlemanly club of crass commercialism.

Pam

Re: Dovetail standards

#32

The babe in the tee shirt!?!

Bill Tindall

"I pooped today"

Not only did I learn a new useful word but the babe in the tee shirt was entertaining. I probably won't put the shirt on my Christmas list.

Re: Dovetail standards

#33

Well the consequences of that will be.....

Bill Tindall

After your visually perfect dovetail got passed around our last club meeting I suspect there will be a diminished inclination for lesser mortals to bring in their work to show. We get little enough stuff posted on the Hand Tool Forum anyway and it may be this new standard of perfection could dissuade some in the future. It will be a brave soul that would post a less than perfect dovetail no matter the design, carving, finish or other attributes.

Re: Dovetail standards

#34

Re: Societal issue?

joel moskowitz

"...but at $3200 for the table I expected at least gap-free DTs... .."

For $3200 for the table I would expect at least dovetails with filled gaps.

Re: Dovetail standards

#35

Re: Well the consequences of that will be.....

rob cosman

Sidney Crosby is the best hockey player on the planet, but I dont see all the younger wannabees selling their gear because they will never be that good! I must be missing the joke on this.

Rob

Re: Dovetail standards

#36

I found the idea that children should

roger lance

not keep score in their athletic games because someone would lose and maybe have their feelings hurt and be ruined for life to be completely preposterous (and that is one of the nicer words that describe this type of thinking).

Re: Dovetail standards

#37

Re: I found the idea that children should

rob cosman

Can you imagine what it will be like when these poor kids get to the real world?

Rob

Re: Dovetail standards

#38

Re: Indeedy yes

TomD

"but not wait for perfection to get work out the door."

Perfection is not a static thing, as one might think it should be. Standards are constantly inflating. Which means that for now we can probably get away with a little less perfection than we will be called upon to provide in the future... But wherever it stands, it can be questionable whether imperfect work should go out of the door. Certainly in some other fields like guitars, knives, etc... There is no way on earth you want to send a second rate product out there. It will hang out there and define your standards for the rest of your career, quite possibly. And that was before the great gossipy internet became available.

If I learned one thing from trying to play the guitar, it may well be that you have to actually do something to a final performable standard. I went ahead practicing pieces until I got them 95% right (to be incredibly charitable), and then moved onto the next, harder, thing. Now that I look back on it, I realize I should have found the simplest one note piece and perfected it before I moved on. But that is the problem with woodworking, most people are tied up in delivering projects. Much of the audience, like family members who want a desk to write on, want the stuff done, and wouldn't know good from bad to save their lives. So the incentive is to finish stuff. But why is it acceptable for adults to put on the equivalent of a school concert performance of a 5 year old, when it comes to woodworking. Most of us would not sit still to hear our adult friends' recital at that level, why is it acceptable in woodworking.

Re: Dovetail standards

#39

Re: Pleased you have come to visit

TomD

"However, as evidenced by antiques"

Are we sure? Can we know that something that held together for 200 years is therefore without a doubt strong enough. Maybe it was so ugly nobody used it. How do we know that there just weren't 20 times more rough stuff that lasted to the modern day because it was owned by poor people who couldn't afford to replace it. Not sure this line of reasoning is sound. When it comes to badly cut DTs they are just as likely to come out tight as loose, and tight can break before one gets the piece together.

Can you give me the latest update one the tails and pins war. Has someone won. I always start from the premise that a competent woodworker would be able to proceed from either point Imagine one was called upon to make a repair from the starting point of either pins and tails being the unbroken part. Despite Frid calling tails first Mickey Mouse, I am pretty sure who could do it either way. But I don't really see a convincing argument for either. But I don't read the mags any more, etc... so I may have missed the news.

Re: Dovetail standards

#40

Re: Dovetail standards

Normp

Not sure if this is simply an argument of utilitarian vs. fine, narrow pin dovetails. I'm in the camp of striving for perfection and not settling for mediocrity.

The example of a hi-end piece of furniture I would say demands flawless dovetails, or close to flawless.

I always challenge myself to make better work, tighter joints, more accurate work. The curve can be initially frustrating but once the techniques and skills are mastered ... the time was obviously well spent. I think this is the mindset we should instill in novice woodworkers.

I guess I'm saying that we ( experienced and novice) woodworkers should strive to produce better work, because inevitably the effort of creating better joinery is similar to the effort in producing mediocre joinery when the skiils are attained. We've just raised the bar in the quality of work we produce.

Then we have the aesthtics of fine dovetails vs. plain, equally spaced fat dovetails. Having developed the skills to create fine, accurate dovetails also lends itself well to becoming more creative with dovetail work.

Norman