Dovetail standards
Bill Tindall
Preamble: This discussion is targeted to persons that have yet to dovetail a drawer, or who are still unsettled on their approach to drawers. It is not meant to be in any way a criticism of someone else's approach.
Ian, buried in a post below, details his drawer dovetail philosophy which is similar to mine. This alternative view of the dovetailing universe could use more exposure for the benefit of "beginners". To that end, I have taught several dovetail classes and I find that students are often concerned that their efforts won't measure up to the point that they haven't used dovetails, or if they do, they avoid showing their dovetailed furniture.
Dovetails are the best way to construct many common projects, for example case work and drawers. Hence, it is not helpful to dissuade "apprentices" from using this joint. Yet, that is exactly what happens with the current fixation on flauntable dovetails, even in hidden places. Dovetails used to be a sign of quality construction. Now it seems, a perfect dovetail has become the entry fee for peer acceptance.
The dovetail joint has great strength and a far less than perfect dovetail will hold a case or drawer together just fine. In most cases the joint is hidden or at least seldom exposed. So here is my advice:
1. Go to antique stores and see what quality of dovetail is adequate to hold something together for 200 years. Let that be your standard, not the Cosman dovetail executed by someone that makes hundreds of these joints each year for the purpose of flaunting them.
2. Force yourself to use dovetails every chance you have. If they hold the piece together the joint was successfully executed.
3. Show others how you have successfully held something together with a less than flauntable dovetail so that they may be encouraged to try it. Your less than perfect dovetail may have more positive impact on promoting this useful joint than Cosman.





