Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Dovetail standards

Posts

Dovetail standards

#1

Dovetail standards

Bill Tindall

Preamble: This discussion is targeted to persons that have yet to dovetail a drawer, or who are still unsettled on their approach to drawers. It is not meant to be in any way a criticism of someone else's approach.

Ian, buried in a post below, details his drawer dovetail philosophy which is similar to mine. This alternative view of the dovetailing universe could use more exposure for the benefit of "beginners". To that end, I have taught several dovetail classes and I find that students are often concerned that their efforts won't measure up to the point that they haven't used dovetails, or if they do, they avoid showing their dovetailed furniture.

Dovetails are the best way to construct many common projects, for example case work and drawers. Hence, it is not helpful to dissuade "apprentices" from using this joint. Yet, that is exactly what happens with the current fixation on flauntable dovetails, even in hidden places. Dovetails used to be a sign of quality construction. Now it seems, a perfect dovetail has become the entry fee for peer acceptance.

The dovetail joint has great strength and a far less than perfect dovetail will hold a case or drawer together just fine. In most cases the joint is hidden or at least seldom exposed. So here is my advice:

1. Go to antique stores and see what quality of dovetail is adequate to hold something together for 200 years. Let that be your standard, not the Cosman dovetail executed by someone that makes hundreds of these joints each year for the purpose of flaunting them.

2. Force yourself to use dovetails every chance you have. If they hold the piece together the joint was successfully executed.

3. Show others how you have successfully held something together with a less than flauntable dovetail so that they may be encouraged to try it. Your less than perfect dovetail may have more positive impact on promoting this useful joint than Cosman.

Re: Dovetail standards

#2

Indeed

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

One of the furniture pieces in my parents' house, when we cleaned it out and distributed stuff, was an old chest of drawers - age uncertain - on which the dovetails looked to have been piecework by very small beavers. There were gaps big enough to insert a marking knife blade in, but the drawers were holding together just fine.

Re: Dovetail standards

#3

Re: Dovetail standards

John Pappas

Bill made some very good comments. May I add an additional point for those that have not tried dovetails before. "It ain't as hard as it looks."

Re: Dovetail standards

#4

Re: Dovetail standards

Patrick Gibbons

I'm working on a carcase which I dovetailed together about two weeks ago. My dovetails are pathetic looking but they are holding, and I believe, they will hold for quite some time. They will be hidden so no one will ever know. I believe that in a few years from now my dovetails will be much better. But how does one get to that stage unless they start off? So this case is at the beginning of my dovetail stage. I believe Bill has stated the only standards I can work with. You gotta crawl before you can walk.

Re: Dovetail standards

#5

Re: Dovetail standards

rob cosman

"for the purpose of flaunting them" - Bill, please explain how travelling 33 weeks a year to teach folks how to cut dovetails ( http://robcosman.com/student_gallery.htm the evidence) is "flaunting"? I consider your comments a "shot across my bow" unless I have misunderstood.

Rob Cosman

Re: Dovetail standards

#7

Pleased you have come to visit

Bill Tindall

Our common goal is to get more people to use dovetails. I believe there are two challenges to implementing this goal, one physical and the other mental.

However one wants to analyze the details, a perfect dovetail joint is not trivial to execute. A mechanical engineer analyzing the task of fitting dovetails on a drawer side could conclude it was impossible with the implements commonly used. The tolerance of a proper fit is but a few thousandths of an inch across several dovetail elements in a typical joint and these tolerances are to be achieved with what would appear to be crude tools for the task- hand saw and chisel. However, as evidenced by antiques, a dovetailed joint far from perfect is functionally equivalent to one that is visually perfect, that flauntable dovetail. That's the physical challenge, acceptable tolerances with hand tools

As I said, dovetails used to be a sign of quality construction. Now it seems, a visually perfect dovetail has become the entry fee for peer acceptance, and/or a parlor trick to impress an audience. This is the mental challenge. It takes both exceptional inherent skill and considerable practice to reliably achieve visually perfect dovetails. Some persons that have this skill and experience flaunt it which led me to coin the term "flauntable dovetails". Such a standard, and flaunting the standard, is not going to further the cause of people learning and using this joint. (note: I am not accusing you of flaunting your flauntable dovetails as I have no experience to suggest you do )

I think your approach to dovetails is as easy as any, if not the easiest approach, to learn. I recommend buying your video to anyone willing to listen. When I teach a class I use your basic approach. However, because I am teaching for free, my student's expectations are lower and I can get away with things you may not be able to. I begin with a drawer from a 200 year old family antique. The drawer is still sound and without any repair. The baselines are over sawed here and there and the fit is not perfect everywhere. I tell students that this drawer is the standard to strive for. It held together for 200 years and shows no sign of failing. And, it is a standard that most anyone can achieve using a good saw, your approach and minimal practice.

What troubles me is that many people would now days to ashamed to show a fellow woodworker this drawer, had they made it. To hell with the design of the piece, the carving, molding, or the rest of the visible parts. The critics open a drawer and search of a gap in a dovetail. A tool mark on a molding or carving is a sign of quality hand craft work. But a tiny gap in a dovetail, oh my! Better patch it least someone notice.

Bottom line: We agree on the physical aspects of dovetailing. Tails first is much easier to learn. I don't know if we agree that flaunting dovetails discourages use of the joint or showing examples of less than flauntable joints encourages use, because I have not heard your views on the topic.

If the unintended "shot across your bow" gets you to participate here, I'm delighted. This Forum is where the deeper technical discussions on a multitude of topics take place. Join in on the current drawer discussion or post some of your work.

Re: Dovetail standards

#8

Societal issue?

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

Rob can defend himself, but I certainly can understand his reaction.

Rob is selling dovetailing instruction (among other things, BTW his DT saw is excellent). In order to sell his courses at a high enough price to make a living he has to be able to demonstrate that he can make perfect DTs, among other things. Otherwise, who would be willing to pay big bucks for his instruction? Not me! It's not an issue of flaunting but rather a necessary business practice.

Correct me if I'm wrong Bill, but you seem to suggest that because the average Joe woodworker does not produce perfect DTs, the ones who do should keep them from view, lest it might discourage some people... Why? I want to see them! I want to see what the best looks like! Sure, less than perfect DTs can hold and has held furniture together for centuries, but are we striving for "good enough"? If there is only a small minority of hobbyist woodworkers who can master the dovetail, so be it...

When I dovetailed 14 drawers for my tool cabinet, my goal was to make them as well as possible AND as quickly as I could. Can't get better if one doesn't push himself IMO. The result was mixed, some joints being gappy while others were perfect. But we're talking utilitarian stuff here, and these drawers will hold together for a long time. So I have no problem showing them to people, although I obviously prefer showing the better ones ;)

I am of the type to scrutinize others' workmanship, trying to keep things in context. A few years ago Rosewood Studio had a conference where student and alumni work was on display for sale. I remember looking at a "telephone table", a tall, narrow and shallow table suited to put a phone on. The table had a drawer, so of course I looked at it. The dovetails had a few gaps on each side of the drawer. I'm sure that the drawer will hold together for centuries, but at $3200 for the table I expected at least gap-free DTs...

I think what we have here is an instance of the instant gratification society where people think that they can master anything without investing the required effort, and when that doesn't work out, strive to blame someone or something for their lack of success, anything but themselves...

The fact remains that there is a certain skill set required to cut DTs, and not everyone has it. But with sufficient practice (amount which will vary for each person) most people can cut decent DTs. But the practice has to be there...

You are right in saying that we don't need flauntable DTs everywhere, still, the more of them I see the better... And you're also right that we might put too much focus on DTs, to the detriment of design, etc. It's up to us hobbyists to steer the ship back on its course...

Cheers,

DC

Re: Dovetail standards

#9

Unfortunate

roninkokomo

I understand and support Bill's thesis here. I do think his terminology regarding Brother Cosman was unfortunate.

A major issue in this discussion is that we have come to expect "instant results" Professional woodworkers do not get "instant results". For hobby woodworkers the expectation is ludicrous.. I think Frank Klausz said this " I almost guarantee that your fiftieth dovetail joint will be a lot better than your first one.

Actually it is a lot more difficult to make a great mortise and tenon joint than it is to make a great dovetail joint.

Ron a Kokomo Galoot

Re: Dovetail standards

#10

Re: Dovetail standards

Pam Niedermayer

I agree completely, and have long held that which dovetail saw one uses isn't of any importance because the cuts are trivial. What's important is to get in there and try making some, get over that "fear." :)

Pam

Re: Dovetail standards

#11

Thanks for dropping in - question

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Rob,

THanks for dropping in.

I had briefly skimmed the initial post a couple of days ago.

Just a quick question (I'm a trade cabinetmaker and, while out of practise now, could cut a dovetail as quickly as you show on the internet when I was on a run. It'd take about 5-8 minutes now.)

If I recall correctly, you run a small rebate of about 1/32 or so on the inside of the dovetail to aid alignment when marking out. Is this done via router? Does it provide any other benefits in the joinery?

Cheers,

Andrew F

Re: Dovetail standards

#12

You provided a perfect illustration of my problem

Bill Tindall

You have illustrated the point I am trying to make better than I have. To wit-

"The table had a drawer, so of course I looked at it. The dovetails had a few gaps on each side of the drawer. I'm sure that the drawer will hold together for centuries, but at $3200 for the table I expected at least gap-free DTs..."

You did what we all do. What might have been a creative design, an artful choice of materials, and finely crafted carving, molding, surfaces, and finish were all devalued because an internal joint was not up to the standards we have come to expect of this joint. We value the evidence of hand craftsmanship in the parts of furniture we see yet demand hidden dovetails to be of machine perfection.

How did we get to this point? I think it is wrong.

Re: Dovetail standards

#13

Re: You provided a perfect illustration of my prob

rob cosman

I dont think it is wrong, I had the good fortune of spending time around some of the worlds best craftsman, Alan Peters being the one I think was the best. His work was flawless, inside, outside and underside. His dovetails were perfect and if they were not he would start over. This is what I shoot for and this is what I teach. There is a point where you can be satisfied but always trying to improve is not a bad thing. I agree with Denis, at a certain price point or level we should expect near perfection everywhere. No one has to agree, there are opinions.

rob

Re: Dovetail standards

#14

Re: Thanks for dropping in - question

rob cosman

Nope, just for alignment. But the way it does that makes it well worth the time. I saw more student improvement from that tip than any other.

rob

Re: Dovetail standards

#15

Re: Dovetail standards

rob cosman

How can the cuts be trivial? If you do it right, the saw cuts are the one and only thing needing to be done. Saw the tails, trace to the pins, saw the pins and assemble the joint. Poor saw cuts means extra work paring or a bad glue joint. Explain?

ROb

Re: Dovetail standards

#16

Ta, Rob.  Appreciate the response.


Re: Dovetail standards

#17

I agree as well...

John in NM

I find dovetails a lot of fun to make, even when not perfect (I doubt I've ever made anything perfect!) a functional joint can really give you a sense of accomplishment. It's a real shame to see people stressing over something so simple and fun, just because others may be able to do it better for one reason or another.

Re: Dovetail standards

#18

Re: Dovetail standards

wilbur

I think what Pam is referring to by "trivial" is that sawing to the line, where dovetails are concerned, should not be that hard of a task. It is important to do it correctly, of course, and it is important to lay out the lines accurately as well. But the fact is that for most dovetails you only have to hit a line for 3/4" or so with your cut. This is easier than making an accurate crosscut on a 9" wide board.

Over the weekend I made some dovetails using a western dovetail saw. The saw was an issue for me because I only use Japanese saws, and I had a hard time starting the saw and cutting smoothly with it. Nonetheless, the dovetails I made were tight (except for one area where I didn't clean out the waste at the baseline well, but this was not a sawing issue). I was really slow making them, because of the saw issue, but they were tight nonetheless. To me, this shows that the actual sawing part of a dovetail joint really isn't that hard.

Re: Dovetail standards

#19

Re: Dovetail standards

Pam Niedermayer

Note that when the occasion arises for me to say that, it's to relative beginners who are asking about the tools, saws, not how to use them; so the advice they really need at that point is to get moving, don't worry about a special tool, learn to use the one you have.

That said, the actual cut is trivial. Zip, zip, zip, and I'm done (that's 3 or 4 strokes for a 3/4" board). I cut my first dovetails 30 years ago, and they turned out perfectly. I also realized that since the complementary side was laid out based on the first side, there was no reason to formally lay out that first side. At that point I became a tails first Frank Klausz, long before I'd even heard of him. It's just not a difficult thing to do, and I've done it with all sorts of saws including a 26" Tyzack, even though I religiously use a kataba rip these days.

I'll also note that Mark Grable, saw metate extraordinaire, advises using much larger saws than called for by the job to learn how to use saws with grace and speed and accuracy.

Pam

Re: Dovetail standards

#20

Well, all right, way to go, Wilbur.


Re: Dovetail standards

#21

The economic consequences

Bill Tindall

From the antiques I have studied it would appear that at least some, if not many, Period cabinet makers either were unable to make visually perfect dovetails or they couldn't make a living devoting attention to visual perfection in the interior of cabinetry. Given the number of modern cabinet makers turning to teaching rather than making stuff to sell , and the lack of success of many students when they hit the market place, it may be the current market can't, or won't, afford this degree of refinement either. Hence, I continue to think it is wrong to promote this standard in interior joinery.

Re: Dovetail standards

#22

Re: Dovetail standards

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

Ian, buried in a post below, details his drawer dovetail philosophy which is similar to mine. This alternative view of the dovetailing universe could use more exposure for the benefit of "beginners".

Bill

I've responded to your query from that earlier post

You're welcome to reuse the diagrams I've posted here.

regards from Sydney

Re: Dovetail standards

#23

Here's what I think ... *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

One may refer to the high end Cabinetmakers of Olde as epitomising all that defined excellence in their era, and that some lavished attention on their dovetails, while the priority of others was different.

All this is by-the-by since we are now in a different era with different standards. What may not have been high end features of furniture in the past are today prized by some as a mark of excellence. But why single out the dovetail? I expect discerning buyers to demand excellence in all areas of design and construction. Some woodworkers will strive towards this. This is what Rob was referring to, and I agree.

The reality, however, is probably closer to this: most furniture buyers could not tell a dovetail from a doovalacky. My family can because I bore them to tears on the subject. My friends do not care. They do not open drawers in furniture stores. Only woodworkers do this.

Regards from Perth

Derek


doovalacky

Re: Dovetail standards

#24

Re: The economic consequences

rob cosman

Bill, it doesnt take me any longer to make a great dovetail than it does to make a sloppy one. I have always taught that if you have to saw one side of the tail, how much longer would it take to stop the cut right on the scribe line instead of stopping 1/16 before or blowing by it by the same amount. This makes chopping between the tails faster because the corners are now finished and you dont have to come back and "carve" them. It takes no extra time to saw perpendicular across the end of the tail board instead of crooked, getting those cut less than perpendicular is the mail cause of future gaps. When sawing for the 1/2 pins I teach students to split the marking gauge line rather than saw "safe" and have to come back with a chisel to get rid of the extra material. It takes no extra time to trace the tails to the pins accurately than it would to not do so. The vertical pin cuts are easy once you have mastered the vertical cut. Keep the work piece standing plumb and use a pistol grip saw, this way it registers in your hand and in very little time gravity will have you making plumb cuts without looking at the line. In fact you will not even have to draw vertical lines on the face of the pin board, more time savings. Zip that waste out with a thin blade in a fret saw and you are only a few chisel chops away from finishing the pin board. Since you followed my rule "inspect what you expect" along the process there is no need for a test fit which would only waste more time and we all know the joint really fits just once anyway.

Now if I can teach part-time hobby woodworkers in thier 50's and 60's to be able to do this I think there were many, many furniture makers from the past that could do it as well. Should we take as an standard the few who for whatever reason didnt care, and hold them up as a standard? I think not! Go to my site and look on the student gallery page. There are multiple examples of perfect dovetails and in many cases first time joints. I cant stand this mediocracy being promoted by instructors! Check out the work of Ed Looney, Gary Zimmel, Gary Benson, Duncan Robertson, Tim Harmon, John Zurhak, Tim Cripe, Kyle Seleski, Barry Chatwin, Mike Cope, Fulton Smyl, Steve Odut, Mike Smrek, Dean Sinnott, Bruce Gilespie, Craig Clifton. Dont recognize any of these? No wonder, they do it for fun a few weekends a month but they cut gap free dovetails none the less! In case the point was not made the list could go on.

For those reading this thread you have the choice of settling or pushing yourself to do better. Dont be persuaded that you shouldnt do it because some bad examples have survived from the past from "professinoal craftsman", I see bad examples in todays work. Alan Peters made it a point to never leave a stray tool mark anywhere on his work. He also demanded that from his shop. He ran a successful business from the early 1960's up to the late 90's.

If you want to talk about why the demise of the craft I beg to differ that it has anything to do with the Craftsman! When we have a large part of the under 40 generation that are unaware boards come from trees and worse still - they dont care to find out! When shop classes were removed from public schools 40ish years ago it began the rapid decay of woodworking professionally and recreationally. Consider 50 years ago, at least in Canada, every male that went thru public school had to take a shop class somewhere along the line. May not have enjoyed it but at least by the time he hit adulthood he had seen a hammer before and if a nail needed pounding he had a "chance". Today the vast majority have never seen a woodworking tool nevermind instruction (good or bad) on how to use it. 50 years ago the only competition the ww hobby had was the garden and the golf course. Not so today. All of this factors into a market that cares not about how it was made nor how long it will last. Attention spans are short, financing terms are painless and plentiful and when they grow tired of the look or color......hello landfill (or kids apartment). Dont fool yourself into thinking there is a market for "heirloom quality" furniture, wrong generation. Now I am not stupid enough to pretend this negative view represents 100% of the population, but the percentage has changed enough in the past 50 years to make it very difficult if not near impossible for the maker of custom free standing furniture to survive. Out of confidentiality I will not disclose the name for you would all recognize it, but one of the most noted craftsman today, in business for a very long time, makes less than most fast food restaurant managers. The best hobby, but a tough way to make a living!

Now get out in that shop and dont stop till it's perfect!!!

Cheers

Rob Cosman

Re: Dovetail standards

#25

Re: Here's what I think ...

rob cosman

Amen Derek, so since it is only woodworkers that care, lest impress the heck out of them with perfection! No more gaps, no more gaps, no more gaps, no more gaps, no more Bill! ( had to :) )