New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Progress and question

Posts

Progress and question

#1

Progress and question

Todd Nebel

I finished my two drawers over the weekend... before reading the informative thread on proper drawer back construction. Nice timing guys ;) Now I'm sure when I close one drawer the other will be pushed open. Suggestions?


I went with one drawer larger than the other. They are dry fitted for now until I get the top built and screwed on. Then I will glue up the drawers and let them cure in place (... a tip I recently read).

The top will be 19" x 34". The widest board I can finish is 8 3/4". So, I will need three boards to make up the top. I will let the figure of the boards dictate my decision, but I got thinking is there a precedence here? Would you make each board the same width or go with the largest in the middle and two equally wide ones on the sides?

Thanks,

Todd

Re: Progress and question

#2

Re: Progress and question

roger lance

Todd....its looking good....what figure!!....I just finished installing drawer stops on my four drawer nightstand using Bill Tindall's method from your earlier post....when it comes to tops (or panels), I've been taught to use an odd number of boards in the glue up (ie 3,5,7,etc) and I would try to make them approximately the same size letting that figure be what attracts attention as opposed to a differential in board width (it will be interesting to see if this thinking is supported or not). As to one drawer pushing the other back when you close the drawers, shouldn't enough air escape the open bottom so this doesn't happen??

Re: Progress and question

#3

thoughts

Bill Tindall

Take a spoke shave and shave a bit off the back. A 1/16" will not be noticed. The idea of lowering the back is not universally subscribed to in American Period furniture. However, a bit of clearance is desirable.

I think it a mistake to prepare a drawer and not glue it as soon as possible to keep it from going astray. It is unclear why you are waiting on some other step.

Two boards for the top would be ideal. Not clear why the 8 3/4 limit. But if you must use three then do what ever looks good with the grain pattern you have to work with.

Re: Progress and question

#5

where's the pictures?

Bill Tindall

Notice how much more traffic this site is getting since people have started posting about making stuff.

Re: Progress and question

#6

Re: thoughts

Todd Nebel

Hi Bill,

I've had no formal training other than shop class in high school many years ago. I learn by doing, reading and asking questions. Which is all to say I read it's proper to build the drawers after attaching the top since the top can cause stress on the base and cause some minor racking. I jumped the gun and built the drawers before the top. So now I figure the drawers could sit dry fitted until I get the top on. Then I can do the final fitting and glue them up. Do you think the drawers can suffer waiting a couple days? The dovetails are pretty tight.

The 8 3/4" limit is due to the stock on hand. That's the widest board I have.

Todd

Re: Progress and question

#7

Re: Progress and question

Todd Nebel

Thanks Roger. Go figure, I was concentrating so much on the top of the drawer I didn't think about the bottom being open, doh!

Re: Progress and question

#8

I agree with Bill Tindall

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Organize the boards for your top so that the grain patterns are happiest together. If you're lucky, and do it right, the fact that it's a glue up will be less visible with good grain matching than you could achieve with any arbitrary rule.

That's a nice looking piece of furniture.

Re: Progress and question

#9

Re: Progress and question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Todd, the two options you suggest for the top, narrow-wide-narrow, or three equal pieces are common 20th century solutions. In the 18th and early 19th centuries it was more common to have a narrow board on one edge. Like a wide board with a narrow board, or two wides and a narrow at one side. I would go some thing like 8 1/2, 8 1/2, 2, but you may not be used to this look. I think you get the best effect from the widest boards possible, but in any case the most important thing is how well you match the boards.

Re: Progress and question

#10

drawers before top?

Bill Tindall

Regarding the issue of drawers before top.....

I have never encountered an experienced cabinet maker that worried about this issue of the top installation altering drawer fit. It would be a frail construction that deflected upon installing a top, and yours is certainly not frail. Nor is it clear how a twisted drawer opening could be accommodated easier before the drawer was assembled. I am inclined to reject this piece of "book learning".

Drawer sides are typically thin and thin stuff seems to be inclined to move about more than thick stuff. For this reason, once I get drawer parts made I press on to get the drawer glued up and the parts fixed in place. Actually, I think this is good advice for any parts of furniture. From what I see in professional shops this seems to be typical practice. Certainly in my case the top is the last thing I deal with before finishing.

As far as how to assemble the top, I can anticipate that it will be tricky coming up with the best arrangement for the curly grain. I would approach the task by laying out the possible candidates on a table or floor and moving them around adjacent to one another until the most pleasing arrangement presented itself. I find it beneficial to mask off the cutting I propose to use with brown paper so that I can focus on what the grain in the candidate piece will look like.

Re: Progress and question

#11

I agree

Bill Tindall

I have lots of tops consisting of two wide boards (as wide as I could find) and a narrow strip filling out the required width (placed to the back if it is a chest of drawers, for example). However, I have never faced doing this kind of assembly with curly wood. In my cases the wide boards had rift or quartered grain on the edge and the narrow piece of similar rift or quartered stock just continued this easy to match grain on to the required width.

In your case you not only have to join in a pleasing way the growth ring grain, but also the curls running perpendicular to the long grain pattern.

It appears that you are a patient person and you will come up with an acceptably good arrangement. Bottom line: forget the "rules" do what looks best.

Re: Progress and question

#12

Looking great Todd...

John in NM

Going to be a very nice table!

I'd agree with Bill, don't wait on the drawer glue up. If the top changes the shape that much, there is something seriously wrong with the top!

I've not heard of the practice of letting drawers dry in place. By all means try it if you like the idea, but it sounds awful fussy to me compared to building everything to square. If you're shooting for a really tight fit, I suspect fitting will be necessary regardless of where the drawer dries.

As to the top, I don't think I'd worry much about making three equal boards or anything like that. I usually lay them out so the grain looks best to me, and don't sweat the symmetry, but that's just me. I'm sure someone else out on the internet will tell you the opposite. At the end of the day, do what looks good to you and ignore all of us who argue the minutia.

Re: Progress and question

#13

Re: Progress and question

roger lance

Todd....well, we are getting some discussion (lets get some more)....the idea behind using an odd number of boards to make a top or panel (I believe) was to give symmetry to the piece with a board centered in the panel....your approach to having one large board in the center and a smaller board on each side of the center board is symmetrical....if you have an especially highly figured board with a very interesting figure pattern, it might be criminal to not completely feature it by cutting it down....I assume that you will be getting all three pieces from the same board, so there will be some "scrap" which would be valuable and you might want to give some thought to the best manner of conserving this scrap for future use....I also took three pieces from a board for the top to the nightstand but the rough dimensioning revealed some flaws (knots) that were not evident prior to this planing and these flaws were removed by reducing the widths of the pieces....you are very fortunate to have a board with such figure and also free from flaw....as your top will be seen, do what is most attractive....as to whether these ideas are "rules" or not, I don't know for sure....but I hope the ideas were helpful.

Re: Progress and question

#14

In Summary...

Todd Nebel

1. No need to wait on the top before gluing up the drawers. I'm sure now that what I read in the past on the order in which to build a small table with a drawer was most likely offered as a best practice and not anything more.

2. Appearance ultimately wins out when deciding on the number and width of table top boards. Some folks like a symmetrical look (me included), some follow lessons taught, and others strive for period correctness. It's going to be tricky finding a pleasing look with grain and curl to attend with.

3. Everyone likes my figure, I mean the woods figure.

Thanks everyone!

Re: Progress and question

#15

gluing drawers in place fussy?

Bill Tindall

What could be easier? Apply glue, bash drawer together, wipe off excess glue, slip drawer in place and center it with thin wedges while at the same time keeping front perfectly aligned with drawer blades. The end. It all takes about a minute. Not insignificant, the drawer is off the bench and out of the way so that dovetailing the next drawer is not impeded.

Re: Progress and question

#16

Not fussy, common and standard practise

Andrew F in Australia

Hi John,

Not fussy. I used to be paid to make things square, but 'square' is a difference of 1/16" on the diagonals.

Drying a drawer in place means it fits the opening.

Sounds less fussy to me than building things individually then having to shape them to fit.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Progress and question

#17

Fitting drawers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

What could be easier? Apply glue, bash drawer together, wipe off excess glue, slip drawer in place and center it with thin wedges while at the same time keeping front perfectly aligned with drawer blades. The end. It all takes about a minute. Not insignificant, the drawer is off the bench and out of the way so that dovetailing the next drawer is not impeded.

This is the theory and the strategy one aims for. It does not always work out as planned for me. Perhaps others are more successful.

In the example I posted a little while ago, the first step was to fit the drawer front. I kept the tolerance very tight.

The front became the template for the drawer back since the housing for the drawer was as square as I coiuld make it - in other words, the front and back dimensions should be the same.

The strategy was to complete the dovetails, wack it together, and insert in the drawer housing to dry. As it happened I could not do this. The drawer sides were a fraction of a mm wider than planned (here-and-there - no doubt due to a combination of the hand finished thicknessing and the movement of the boards themselves), which meant that they needed a little planing/tuning. I did not want to plane the boards while the glue was wet. So I used a jig to maintain the squareness (see post), and planed it to fit once dry.

Back up strategies are always needed.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Progress and question

#18

Re: Fitting drawers

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Derek,

I've had the odd occasion where they haven't fitted. Have broken the drawer apart while the glue's wet and then re-fitted it.

The aim is to make sure that three of four parts fit properly first, (sides and back, with the front being just proud of opening.)

Dry-fit drawer before gluing up to ensure that it fits is a strategy I use to ensure that things work.

Cheers,

Andrew F

Re: Progress and question

#19

One other option

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Todd,

Noticed that you just said the widest board you can finish is 8.something inches wide a/c machinery considerations.

You could hand-finish it from two planks if possible. Matching would be easier.

Cheers,

Andrew F

Re: Progress and question

#21

Perhaps I will try it.

John in NM

Never occurred to me to fit drawers any other way than I do, but then it was never a process I've needed to do efficiently, and thus never looked for improvement.

I do seem to have committed the very grave internet error of being outside a recent discussion and then having the gall to comment unfavorably on it in another discussion. Such complicated times.

I deleted my last reply after some thought and coming to the decision that it was playing into some of the more superior, haughty, and at times downright nasty answers I've been seeing recently around here. A common reaction for most of us, but no more excusable for all that.

Re: Progress and question

#22

Hopefully not on my account, John

Andrew F in Australia

Hi John,

You said:

-------------------------------------------------------------

I do seem to have committed the very grave internet error of being outside a recent discussion and then having the gall to comment unfavorably on it in another discussion. Such complicated times.

I deleted my last reply after some thought and coming to the decision that it was playing into some of the more superior, haughty, and at times downright nasty answers I've been seeing recently around here. A common reaction for most of us, but no more excusable for all that.

----------------------------------------------------------------

Hopefully not on my account, please. I've got no interest in playing politics or any desire to be haughty or nasty.

If there's anything that has offended you, or anyone else, I apologise.

It's a genuine email address above - feel free to contact me in private if you wish to discuss.

Cheers,

ANdrew

(who stopped participating in a lot of internet forums for the same reason.)

Re: Progress and question

#23

Re: Perhaps I will try it.

Pam Niedermayer

John, I honestly have no idea what you're talking about here, so I'll have to ask you and everyone else somehow offended to be specific, please. It's just not fair to complain in ambiguity.

Pam

Re: Progress and question

#24

No, not at all...

John in NM

Any criticisms were intended more in general terms, not specific to your post - they just happened to be in the reply to you as some explanation for replacing my previous reply.

Re: Progress and question

#25

Not complaining, not offended...

John in NM

I merely felt my first reply to Andrew could be construed as a cut, though minor, and thought it reasonable to explain why I changed it.

As I just stated above, any responses I'm criticizing are not necessarily in this thread or even the Hand Tools side of the forum. Its more a matter of observing that some of the responses I've recently seen incline myself, and probably others, to be sharper in responses than one really should do. If the last three things I read before writing a reply are all kind of negative, I've noticed that my reply picks up that tone as well.