New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Vesper at WIA

Posts

Re: Vesper at WIA

#26

Projection of guilt....another DM.


Re: Vesper at WIA

#27

Ellis Walentine

Re: Denial is a defense mechanism, isn't it?

Ellis Walentine

Roger, cost is indeed an issue, and I don't think Derek is denying it. But it's not an issue for everyone, and some are willing to pay more. Whatever their reason, it's their decision. So, let's keep the discussion on track here. It's about the design of the tools.

Thanks.

Ellis

Re: Vesper at WIA

#28

On design

roger lance

Derek....as I mentioned to Ian below, the design and position of the tightening mechanism is a big issue that Vesper and LV have addressed on their bevel gauges....the issue of the kinds of fittings/handles that come on tools in general is a real issue....it seems manufacturers try to save money in this area to the detriment of the enjoyability/functionality of using their tools....I just tried to improve the handles on my PowerMatic 719A mortiser with some success and every time I use my Craftsman wet/dry vac, I wish someone at Sears would have installed a fitting that allows the hose to rotate instead of making customers fight the thing each and every time they use it....I know this is OT somewhat but the idea that tool makers use good ergonomics and better hardware is valid....the tab on the Vesper is nice and would function when you needed to leave your square in this suspended position which might be infrequent....I do like a square to stand on its own and have enough mass to not easily move from this position....hope these few remarks add to the desired discussion of design.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#29

Sorry, not valuable in money terms...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...but if you use a sliding bevel, this is one of the better commonly available used bevels.

How it works: the end of the rod that sticks out the tail end of the stock is threaded, and tapered at its very end. The threaded part goes through something up just below the pivot, and the taper wedges against a collar or some such, pushing it against the beam. The thumb screw part does break off - my son has one that I picked up and gave him to repair - but, other than that weakness, they're good tools.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#30

Re: Alternative sliding bevel

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I gave $2.00 for mine (more than double what it cost new) and it works well, holding its settings for more than 30 years. I would give the same amount for yours, Bill, but if you can etch your signature and an outline of the Volunteer State on the blade, I would give considerably more.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#31

name recognition

Bill Tindall

I expect my name recognition and TN location would not add but $1 to the price others would be willing to pay

With all the fuss over secure locking I did hope it would be more valuable.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#32

Re: Vesper at WIA

TomD

Actually that design is the General one is it not? It is cheap and rigid, but not fancy, if inset wood so qualifies. I like that for certain applications, but I also like ones that move predictably. So one can move it and it moves smoothly, doesn't shift in normal use but shifts easily otherwise. In that regard I find the LV one both pleasing in it's Pakkawood type splendor, and supremely practical. I also like any old ones one picks up for cheap for those kinds of application where the whole shop needs to be peppered with them to hold various angles in view.

By the way. Krenov required his students to have a small bevel as part of their kit. I do not know what they prefered, but the small LV answered my prayers as far as a small bevel is concerned.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#33

Re: Form and function

TomD

I think you object, Bill, not mostly to form here but ornamentation. I don't see anything extravagent about the form, it is dirivative from what I can make out.

I love you Bill, the thought of getting HB from health food as opposed to the average banger with 5x the daily salt is sweet.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#34

Re: Here you go Pam

TomD

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=32594&cat=1,42936,50298,43508

Re: Vesper at WIA

#35

Re: Manly strength required

TomD

Oops I guess you have one. My all steel general of this pattern is very strong. I don't actually believe the fancy one will survive multiple falls to my concrete deck. But if derek wants to run some video up on Youtube, I will cook some popcorn. The blade should get dinged up pretty quickly if nothing else.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#36

Re: that was a lot of information!

TomD

The thing I hate about the wheels is they are always coming undone on me.

Man, I would have thought a marking knife was the perfect place to learn some hand sharpening chops.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#37

Re: Form and function - no one correct answer

TomD

North of the Border, I agree with you, we should support, one way or another quality tools, and beautiful tools. Too mechanical an approach forgets why we are doing this stuff. That said, beauty is not only in the eye of the beholder, but more generically, by category of holder. Craftsmen should probably appeciate more form is function type stuff, like a lot of japanese tools. There is also the rich buding amateur category.

Also, in fairness to BCT, they have quite a lot of practical tools. With the jointmaker they recently made a cheap version to meet demand. Guess they just didn't have a great practical idea before. They do have a lot of fucntional tools, but they can tend to be single use only, too restricted, but sometimes the underlying principle is clever.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#38

Thank you, well said 


Re: Vesper at WIA

#39

The balance is very subjective....

John in NM

To tell you the truth, I used to be much more on the function side, being a bit of a cheapskate.

But we've just moved my shop out of a dark, dingy, basement and into a much smaller, unfinished, yet reasonable building. Whenever I had to go work in the basement, I couldn't wait to leave. It was just plain depressing. The new building is a place I like to be, even though its a mess, unplastered, and with no door just yet. I fully expect to get far more work done with a cheerful place to work.

If buying fancy pretty tools cheers people up, I have no problem with it or those who produce the tools. My cheap gene may not let me buy them too, but I do like looking at them, just like I looking at furniture that is far above my abilities to make. Even if the tools are never used much, I'd say the world is a better place for their having been enjoyed as art or engineering alone. Some of the people who buy fancy tools have no interest in art, and those tools may be the only thing they collect that give them a definable sense of pleasure. To me, that alone justifies the making and selling of the tool.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#40

Re: Here you go Pam

Pam Niedermayer

Thanks, Tom, I've had that small version for $46 in my cart for some months now, actually it's gone in and out of my cart for years. Oh, well. :)

Pam

Re: Vesper at WIA

#41

I guess I'm a naughty boy

:(

Re: Vesper at WIA

#42

Clint Searl

Re: Vesper at WIA

Clint Searl

Ok Clint, let's put aside tool cost. That was never the issue here. Derek, cost is an issue; the price premium for the Vesper tool will pay for a lot of nails to complete my joinery. Let's consider tool design. What features would you consider important in ..

1. sliding bevel - e.g. position of screw. The wingnut at the pivot point is logically and mechanically perfect. The mechanism on the Vesper is an extraneous affectation detracting from the inherent elegance of the tool's simplicity.

Do you use one? Yes

2. squares - e.g. size, length/thickness of blade and base. My 45 year old Craftsman tri-square is just as accurate as my Starrett, both of which are more useful than a fixed square.

What do you think of the tab that the Vesper square incorporates? Cute but superfluous.

3. Other marking tools in need of re-design? What would you like to see? I'd rather direct my creativity to designing furniture than to tools. Centuries of craftsmen have invented all the tools I'll ever need.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#43

I'll disagree with you on one point, Clint

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I own a Stanley No. 18 sliding bevel (and a Craftsman knockoff). This bevel uses the same approach as the Vesper bevel, with a long bolt acting against a wedge in the head of the stock (handle). I do find it much more convenient in use, as I can cram the bevel into a corner and reach the tightening mechanism easily.

Also, the winged handle on the bevel does not overhang the side of the stock, a problem with some bevels with wing nuts at the pivot point, as it can be hard to tighten the bevel when the nut binds on the work being measured.

And, I do find that it results in a much firmer "hold" on the angle. Yes, to respond to a question someone (Pam?) asked in another post in this thread, if I drop it on the floor, I'll recheck the angle. But I don't have to treat it like an eggshell from a chicken that's not getting enough calcium, afraid that a slight touch on the bench will knock the angle off (OK, I'm exaggerating there; but I do find wing-nut bevels more delicate).

I should mention that most of my woodworking for the last fifteen years has been architectural, with the angles that I've had to take off frequently being in awkward spots measured while I'm standing on a ladder and reaching up or over; this has no doubt influenced my judgment as to the benefits of this design.

I do think there's a place for high-end tools, just as there is for high-end cars. I'm unlikely ever to enjoy the benefits of either, having made decisions in my life that meant my income would never be high enough to afford them; but I can appreciate them when they do the job well.