New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Vesper at WIA

Posts

Vesper at WIA

#1

Vesper at WIA

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

My good friend Chris Vesper, toolmaker extraordinaire, will be showing his wares at WIA. Look him up and check out his squares. These have an integral tab to aid in holding the square against a board. It is fantastic!


Chris has already received praise from The Schwarz for building the best sliding bevel in the world ..


And he will have a number of the detail marking knives I designed ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Vesper at WIA

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Vesper at WIA

Clint Searl


How is Mr. Vesper's sliding bevel better than my $1.98 jobby? Can a precise angle be dialed in with that little knob on the bottom? IMWTK

Clint

Re: Vesper at WIA

#3

Re: Vesper at WIA

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Clint

The issue is not so much getting the angle, it is keeping the angle.

The mechanism that Chris uses locks the blade very solidly. It takes a lot of grunt to shift it. Accidental dropping of the gauge will not alter the setting at all.

And then of course there are minor issue such as the quality of the fittings and the workmanship (workpersonship?) that go into the build ...

If you tried one, you would not want to use another. Affording one is a separate issue.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Vesper at WIA

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Vesper at WIA

Clint Searl

C'mon, Derek, the vesper model is a display of tool junkie vanity that doesn't transfer an angle any more accurately than my cheapie.

Clint

Re: Vesper at WIA

#6

Clint Searl

Re: Vesper at WIA

Clint Searl

Well, Derek, I guess I've been lucky. My cheapie never lets me down. "Pretty" just ain't worth a hundred times "it plain works."

Clint ;)

BTW, if you dropped your Vesper, wouldn't you reset it just to be sure? :\

Re: Vesper at WIA

#7

Form and function

Bill Tindall

Indeed, in the balance of form and function the form attribute can so exceed the function that the thing in question is no longer a tool, or a chair if we are considering studio furniture. Everybody has there own opinion of where the line is drawn. A long time ago I put anything from Bridge City well across this line.

I suppose there are a multitude of reasons why someone would overemphasize(in my judgement) form over function ranging from ignorance to vanity and a dozen others I can't think of. I try not to be judgmental unless the price for the "form" attempts to be justified by irrelevant function arguments. I avoid Bridge City product descriptions and Organic Food store labels as a means of controlling blood pressure.

Enterprising tool makers have discovered a lucrative market for tools that emphasize form and I admire their marketing savvy for doing so. Providing products for the "rich" may be a more effective economic means of "taxing" them than some alternatives.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#8

Sometimes, you hit the nail on the head

roger lance

Having looked at the beautiful Vesper products, the LV Veritas sliding bevels don't seemed so expensive at $52....I guess thats one of the benefits of having tools for the well-to-do about....it allows the average guy to rationalize buying something that he once thought too costly.....Vesper tools is sorta like Marilyn Monroe, I knew I could never afford her but I sure liked looking at her. At any rate, I hope Mr. Vesper has a very successful time at WIA and his business flourishes.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#9

Re: Form and function - no one correct answer

North of the Border

A lot of woodworkers complain that the trade of making traditional quality furniture is dying because the mass is picking IKEA and Walmart-like furniture over craftsman-made pieces. Furniture -- so called heirloom pieces -- built by skilled craftsmen is not much different from the IKEA stuff in terms of function. A drawer is a drawer whether it's dovetail joints handcut or rabbet joints machined. Same for the fancy cheery hardwood entry door vs the MDF core door. In terms of form, it's, of course, day and night. Can't the same be said of Vesper's products or for that matter, those at Bridge City?

Re: Vesper at WIA

#10

Re: Vesper at WIA

Pam Niedermayer

I think it's ridiculous that no one makes a sliding bevel gauge for less than $20 that holds its setting; but I seldom use sliding bevels for exactly that reason, have to recheck the setting every time I pick one up. That doesn't mean I'd pay such a huge sum as $200 or so for one that works, but it's tempting.

Pam

Re: Vesper at WIA

#11

Re: Form and function

Pam Niedermayer

Providing products for the "rich" may be a more effective economic means of "taxing" them than some alternatives.

Trickle down would be more respected if it actually worked well enough.

Pam

Re: Vesper at WIA

#12

Re: Form and function

wilbur

Trickle down would be more respected if it actually worked at all.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#13

Re: Form and function

Pam Niedermayer

I think maybe Bridge City and Vesper would say it does work; but basically I agree with you, it doesn't work as touted.

Pam

Re: Vesper at WIA

#14

Re: Vesper at WIA

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)

Hi Clint

does the wing nut on yours ever get in the way ?

can yours be used nut down, or can it only be used nut up?

The Lee Valley version would satisify the first

apart from Chris V where else can you get a sliding bevel which has the locking nut out of the way at the end.

(For me the "local" flea market is not an option as it costs me $25 return just to get to it -- so unless I score a bargin I've blown my dough)

cheers

Ian

Re: Vesper at WIA

#15

Manly strength required

Bill Tindall

(testing your sense of humor this AM) Mine does if I crank down the tightening screw snugly. But, I don't think I have used it more than a few times in many years and that was for house construction. I can't imagine marking dovetails with the clunky thing.

I inherited another smaller all metal affair that has a tightening screw in its leg like the $200 model. I don't know how it works but it locks securely with minimal force.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#16

Re: Manly strength required

Pam Niedermayer

Maybe. I recently bought a 6" Shinwa that gets pretty darn tight, but with much force I can move the arm slowly, pretty handy the way it works actually (stainless steel, btw). However, it won't maintain the setting if dropped like Derek says the Vespa does.

Pam

Re: Vesper at WIA

#17

Re: Vesper at WIA

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Ok Clint, let's put aside tool cost. That was never the issue here. Let's consider tool design. What features would you consider important in ..

1. sliding bevel - e.g. position of screw.

Do you use one?

2. squares - e.g. size, length/thickness of blade and base.

What do you think of the tab that the Vesper square incorporates?

3. Other marking tools in need of re-design? What would you like to see?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Vesper at WIA

#18

Ellis Walentine

I'll be there

Ellis Walentine

I have met Chris Vesper at other shows and have really admired his tools. While I can't really afford tools of this quality, there's no denying the superb machining and attention to detail, and the added dimension of enjoyment that it brings to your work. Plus, I've found it instructive and inspiring to see tools that incorporate all these design solutions, whether or not I need them to accomplish the task at hand. Design innovations become part of our design vocabulary that we can bring to bear on other projects and processes.

Thanks for posting, Derek. I'm looking forward to seeing Chris again in Cincinnati next week. I hope to see more WoodCentral folks there as well.

Ellis

Re: Vesper at WIA

#19

may I answer for Clint......dovetail marker

Bill Tindall


This dovetail marker is an especially functional design. I can't remember who sent this picture to me but I have made one like it and it works so well for the task at hand I wonder why there aren't more available...maybe they are, as I am often the last to know.

I am about to make some more and I will document the process as well as make a case for why they are the tool for the task when I get another made.

I find the marking knife like the one you posted, which is similar to Blue Spruce and others, to be the most function design of those I have tried. Including some sort device to aid sharpening it would be a nice addition. It would be difficult to improve on the functionality of the "wheeled" marking gauges for layout. I regard squares as multitaskers. If they aren't ruled I have no interest in them. I use the controversial angle transfer/marking thing so seldom I have no useful comment to make on it. It was handy when I was installing cedar shingles on the side of a house and I don't recall lack of robustness as a problem. It was not a tool that lay comfortably in the hand.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#20

......dovetail markers ... and more.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I am about to make some more and I will document the process as well as make a case for why they are the tool for the task when I get another made.

Hi Bill

That is indeed a different dovetail gauge. I would be most interested in knowing how it is used. It is not that obvious. Pictures in use would be better than just a description.

And what angle do you prefer to use? For example, I find that 1:7 is my preference in thin 1/4 - 3/8" drawers, while 1:6 looks better in 3/4" thick carcases.

My markers are really simple - just a section of brass angle. Here's a set in 1:8, 1:7, 1:6, and 1:5 (makes it easier to decide which size will look best) ..


Of course I did make one with bling, for a joke .. a dovetailed dovetail marker :) ...


I find the marking knife like the one you posted, which is similar to Blue Spruce and others, to be the most function design of those I have tried.

Actually, the knife that Dave Jeske (BS) and my design (see Vesper now) are the only two with similarities. Those by, for example, Chester Tool Works (Dave Anderson) and Czeck Edge (Bob Zajicek) are different in design. It is these (subtle to some) features that typify what I was looking to discuss. The BS and Vesper have a similar ergonomic body shape that allows it to mold into the palm. I have not actually held one of Dave's knives so cannot comment on its size relative to the Vesper. I suspect that they are similar. The blade on the Vesper is about 1/2" longer. The bevel angles are the same.

By contrast, the CTW and the CE knives have straight bodies. The bevel angles are different, lower ... which means that the knives must be held at a lower angle to mark. This reduces their effective height when scoring between dovetails.

Including some sort device to aid sharpening it would be a nice addition.

I tend to hone my knives freehand. Dave Jeske has a good video demonstrating this.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=622fDmpM8JA&feature=player_embedded

As it happens, I did come up with a method to use a honing guide to sharpen these itsy-bitsy edges ..

Step One is to cut a 2" length off your garden hose. Slice it down the centre. This will be used to protect the wooden body of the knife and also increase the grip within the guide.


One can make a jig to set the angles, but the simplest way to hone the edge is to (1) place the bevel flat on the media, and (2) ensure that the outer edge is parallel to the honing guide ...


I have designed a proper guide for these knives on paper but have not built a model. If there is interest I will build one and post pictures.

It would be difficult to improve on the functionality of the "wheeled" marking gauges for layout.

I use these as well. However I recognise that it is the rounded blade that I like as it is unidirectional. The downside to the Titemark and LV wheel gauges is that the fences are small and the wheels do not permit much downforce, that is, the lines are shallow. Fior this reason I often prefer a wooden cutting gauge. These are capable of deeper lines.

I regard squares as multitaskers. If they aren't ruled I have no interest in them.

I use Starretts quite often as well, and occasionally also for marking off. In the main I prefer a small square, 4" or 6", for marking joints. What I particularly like about the small Vesper 4" is the slim sides. It is light and beautifully balanced, which makes marking easier. My other favourite is a 6" Starrett double square.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Vesper at WIA

#21

Alternative sliding bevel

Bill Tindall


I inherited this tool. I don't recall ever using it. But, only a dainty force is required to lock it in place as evidenced by the frail thumb screw that does the job....somehow.

I hope someone tells me this a Stanley's rarest tool and it is worth at least $200. Include your address to complete the sale.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#22

Denial is a defense mechanism, isn't it?

roger lance

Apparently cost is an issue....but anyone who has made or attempted to sell very high-end products knows that.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#23

that was a lot of information!

Bill Tindall

I would be most interested in knowing how it is used. .....stay tuned.

And what angle do you prefer to use? ...an issue still not settled

The BS and Vesper have a similar ergonomic body shape that allows it to mold into the palm. ...Exactly

As it happens, I did come up with a method to use a honing guide to sharpen these itsy-bitsy edges .......Thanks for that one!

I have designed a proper guide for these knives on paper but have not built a model. If there is interest I will build one and post pictures......Yes do build one and send it to me with a one way ticket for evaluation.

The downside to the Titemark and LV wheel gauges is.... the lines are shallow.....keep them sharp and this is not a problem, at lest for me.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#24

Re: Vesper at WIA

roger lance

Ian....for me the issue of dropping your gauge and the setting not changing is really not as important as the locking mechanism getting in the way. If you are habitually dropping your tools, there may be other issues that should be addressed. I have the Crown brand sliding bevel gauge and as Bill said, "a little manly tightening" and some normal care in handling will keep the setting....but, there is a high probability that the tightening mechanism will be in the way....resulting in a reconfiguration of the tool....reset up....etc etc. Thus, the attraction to the Vesper or LV.

Re: Vesper at WIA

#25

Deflection Roger .. Deflection

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Cost is only an issue when you want to make it the issue. Here I was hoping that we could instead discuss something we all could contribute to, such as design.

Regards from Perth

Derek