New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Got some more tools from my dad

Posts

Got some more tools from my dad

#1

Michael Donaldson

Got some more tools from my dad

Michael Donaldson

I just got a few more of my dad's tools from my mom and I just want to make sure I know what I have.

The first is a Lie Nielson #3 plane. What is this plane used for?

The second is a Lie Nielson saw that says "Independence 15ppi RIP" on the blade. Is this a dovetail saw? If not, what is it for and what is the difference between thisnsaw and a dovetail saw?

I also got a Japanese dovetail saw and a set of Pfeil carving chisels.

Final question: what is the least expensive way to effectively sharpen these tools?

Thanks.

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

#2

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The #3 is a very nice smoothing plane; the Independence saw is a dovetail saw.

For sharpening your carving tools you will want oilstones. For cheap and effective I would recommend 1) medium India stone, 2) soft Arkansas stone, 3) soft Arkansas slip stone 4 X 2 X 3/8 (or 1/2) X 1/8, and 4) scrap of leather for strop. Alternatively you could get coarse India, fine India , hard Arkansas.

You might dig around at your Mom's place; your Dad could have had some of these sharpening stones.

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

#3

Your dad had great taste in tools !! 


Re: Got some more tools from my dad

#4

Michael Donaldson

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

Michael Donaldson

Thank you for the information. I am going to do some research on how to use and maintain the plane, and I am going to start cutting some dovetails.

And I need to find some good oilstones.

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

#5

If you do not want to sharpen the....

roger lance

Lie-Nielsen dovetail saw....you can send it to Lie-Nielsen and they will sharpen it for you for $15....see their site or call them.

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

Moses Yoder

Woodcraft has oil stones that will work pretty good for your carving tools at a reasonable price. Inspect them if you get them to make sure there are no cracks in them. Lee Valley has a combination oil stone that looks good, haven't tried it, but 2 stones for the price of 1 is hard to beat. The small stone would be large enough for carving. I use kerosene for honing oil, and James Krenov did too. Warren is a good reliable source of info and you might ask him what he uses.

I like water stones for my plane irons and chisels. A carving tool is a much smaller area, and would dig into a water stone, so you need the oild stone for it. A good water stone set, 1000, 4000, and 8000 grit will run you close to $200 but they will last half your lifetime I imagine. To start out cheaper, search the articles section here for scary sharp or sharpening with sandpaper. Another option is to sharpen with diamond paste on a cast iron substrate; lots has been written about that.

If you intend on becoming a woodworking, you will want to learn sharpening. There is a huge difference in satisfaction between using a good sharp tool and using a poor quality dull tool.

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

#7

cheap sharpening

Bill Tindall

The cheapest effective entry to sharpening is likely to be sand paper fastened to something flat like a piece of glass, or rock. (Places that fabricate rock counter tops throw away miles of back splash waste, free for the asking at least at our local places) Or, a 12 x 12 rock floor tile works fine too, or a scrap or Corian. I have an article in the Articles Section of WoodCentral that tells more than you need to know about the topic. For starters you can use the silicon carbide paper readily available anywhere, but it is not the most durable abrasive to use for hard tool steels.

Don't fasten the whole 8 1/2 x 11 sheet to the rock or whatever. For example on a 12 x 12 floor tile glue down 4- 2 1/2" strips of successively smaller grits. This way just one or two tiles constitute your whole sharpening system. Very convenient, works as good as anything and the entry cost is a few dollars.

After you are successful at sharpening and you begin to do a lot of it you will have the experience to graduate to more sophisticated materials that cost a lot more.

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

#8

Michael Donaldson

What a great article

Michael Donaldson

Bill, your article is fantastic. I love this site!

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

#9

Re: cheap sharpening

charlie belden

The sticky backed sand paper on float glass or flat stone is called Scary Sharp (tm).

A guy who went by the name O'Deen introduced it at least ten years ago in the

UseNet newsgroup rec.woodworking - aka The Wreck. Works very well on straight

single bevel tools like bench chisels and plane irons. Not so good on carving or turning

gouges that have curves, sweeps or fingernail grinds.

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

#10

not the first

Bill Tindall

I found a reference to this technique in Fine Woodworking years before its rediscovery. It has likely been used since sheet abrasives were invented. Its re-inventor had a superficial knowledge of abrasives and recommended silicon carbide and a naive progression of grit sizes. Many who followed the trade marked recommendations discovered poor abrasive life, a result of the abrasive choice. Silicon carbide crushes too easily to be used on hard tool steels, especially so in the larger particle sizes. For all these reasons I am more than happy to avoid infringing on the trademark name when describing the technique.

The recommendations in the WC Article are based on conversations with the tech staff at Klingspor and 3M.

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

#11

Time to set the record straight

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I started reading the Wreck back in about '92 and became friends with Paddy O'Deen. Those days were fun and the traffic was vastly lighter than any of the biggie forums today. Paddy (Patrick Olguin) went on to fame (but, alas, no fortune) with Tom Bruce when they started the Oldtools mail list, which functions to this day. I was the 16th person to subscribe to that list. To this day, there are very heavy hitters on that list who don't post anyplace else, and many of the posters are recognizable to most of the posters here. But Pat and Tom really were the first to carve out a haven for us knuckle-draggers.

Scary Sharp, as it became known, was first described on rec.ww by David Opincairne who was an apprentice machinist. Dave even showed up here a few years back. He described the process that the machinists had been using, as Bill T states, probably since the invention of fine grit papers. I don't recall if it was Dave or Pat who penned the name Scary Sharp.

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

#12

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: cheap sharpening

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

My cabinetmaker Father-in-Law showed me that technique back about 1963. He'd been using it for many years before that.

So-called "Scary Sharp" has been around for a looong time. O'Deen may have given it its current name, but her sure didn't invent it!

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

#13

Re: cheap sharpening

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Pat didn't invent scary sharp, nor did he name it. He didn't claim to, either. He does, however, play a very mean trumpet.

Re: Got some more tools from my dad

#14

Re: cheap sharpening

TomD

I think you are correct to say it isn't so good for the class of tools you mention, but I use it a lot for them. I just sharpen side to side, which is not ideal, though the results are still good. I do it because these tools can be hard to handle, and I can bring the paper to them, or to avoid trncjing expensive stones. These days I do reach for the diamonds, for the same kind of thing.