New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

scrub plane sharpening

Posts

scrub plane sharpening

#1

scrub plane sharpening

Eric in Los Gatos

I just recently happened upon and came to own a Stanley 40. It was in pretty fair condition and, being a scrub plane, looked like it would be a good worker. Japaning is a very nice. The blade a bit rusty. So I've cleaned it up and prepped the back (front?) side of the blade. I've been to the Schwarz School of Sharpening so I'm OK with putting a bit of a radius on my bench planes but I still use a guide. The question is how to deal with the relatively severe curve of the scrub plane blade. My jigs won't help and I'm OK with trying it by hand but wondered if their are any tips I should be aware of. Any advice would be appreciated.

Thanks,

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#2

Re: scrub plane sharpening

bugbear

A side clamping style jig, with a narrow roller, allows enough movement to sharpen a scrub plane blade, if you prefer using a jig.

Indeed, some people cite the lack of side-to-side control as a fault in this style of guide...

BugBear

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: scrub plane sharpening

Moses Yoder

I think a lot of scrub planes have about a 3" radius on the iron, which in my opinion is pretty useless. I think I put a 9" radius on my scrub plane iron and I really like it. It still makes a radius furrow when you push it across a board, but it removes about 3/4" width of wood instead of 3/8" in the center of the iron. I use a Lee Valley honing guide to hone mine, and yes the angle ends up not being consistent across the iron but it works.

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#4

Re: scrub plane sharpening

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Some people will clamp an iron with a radius like this in a vise, or hold it in one hand, and use a small stone on the iron. Watch your fingers if you do.

As Moses points out, perfection is not required here. This is a rough work tool, and it will work even if the camber isn't the same all the way across the iron.

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#5

Re: scrub plane sharpening

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Eric

The Veritas Honing Guide ...


... will work with the cambered roller ..


Before the cambered roller was available, I came up with a novel method using the Veritas Guide ... use it upside down, and run the top screw on a scraper blade so as not to damage your waterstones, etc.


My preference these days is simply to hollow grind the blade (3" radius) and then freehand hone with a side sharpening method.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#6

Re: scrub plane sharpening

roger lance

Eric...check YouTube for/or Lie-Nielsen instructional videos on sharpening a scrub iron....I know its out there.

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#7

Re: scrub plane sharpening

Eric in Los Gatos

Great input as usual. I think I now 4-5 techniques to choose from. I have both of the guides and the inherent weirdness of turning my Veritas jig upside down seems like fun to me.

I do wonder about the radius. My initial reaction on looking at the stock radius was that it was REALLY small. Seems like 4/5th's of the blade never touches wood. Moses idea makes an awful lot of sense to me but I can't help thinking there was some sound thinking that went into the 3 in number. I think I'll try the stock radius first since it's there and maybe work my way up.

Thanks all once again.

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#8

Radius

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Some of it may depend on the uses to which you're putting the plane. My understanding of Stanley's intent in producing it was to serve carpenters who had to hollow out (there's a term for it, which I could have told you yesterday or even earlier this morning, but which is now hiding in the recesses of my sputtering brain) the back sides of casing, baseboard, etc., to accommodate lumpy trim and plaster. A fairly sharp radius makes sense there. I've stayed with what I think is the factory radius, more or less, and it's served me well; but everyone's mileage varies.

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#9

don't over think this sharpening

Bill Tindall

I am likely the least expert on fine planing to be found but I do frequently use a Stanley #5 with a scrub iron in it to hog off unneeded wood. It is not clear to me why a pedigreed scrub plane is better than any cheap plane with a cambered blade. For me a scrub plane is one step refined from an ax or draw knife. I don't find that it makes much difference how it is sharpened, it removes wood. I free hand hollow grind the blade on a grinding wheel putting some more or less symmetrical radius on it, stroke it a bit on some stone and have at it. Unlike most of my planing attempts this scrub plane always works successfully to remove wood, quickly. And it doesn't have to be very sharp to do so.

Maybe if used in a more refined way more critical sharpening would be necessary. But, if the need is to remove wood quick don't over think the blade requirements to do so.

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#11

that's the idea

Bill Tindall

"Seems like 4/5th's of the blade never touches wood."

I don't know how you are supposed to use these things but for my work(quick rough stock removal) I want the edge to bite into the wood, pick up a shaving and plow across the surface with a minimum of pushing force, even with a dull blade. Shaving thickness is measured in fractions of an inch, not thousandths. For the bites I am taking I couldn't push the plane with a full width shaving. Given that this plane is for roughing, which leads to fast dulling, a small deeply scalloped cut can be made with an exceptionally dull edge. The surfaces I generate look about like what I see on the bottoms of Period furniture drawers and case backs so my technique is not far off what a country cabinet maker would have used to knock out affordable furniture.

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#12

I think the term may have been "backing"

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

but am not sure.

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#13

LN scrub plane sharpening vid here

North of the Border

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lAq3hgSRVKM

Deneb gives very clear instructions on how to clean up/sharpen a scrub plane blade. I tried the free hand method (don't have the small sharpening jig) with someone's plane and it worked reasonably well. The nice thing about sharpening the scrub plane free hand is --for me-- I can't really tell a big difference between it and using my Veritas sharpening jig.

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#14

Ellis Walentine

Other aspects

Ellis Walentine

Bill, I hear your reality check about a hogging tool versus a finishing one, but there are a couple other dimensions to a scrub plane that may or may not matter to the user. One is the quality of the finished surface. If you're doing preliminary flattening on a twisted board and you'll be finishing up with a sharp bench plane, the quality of the scrub-planed surface doesn't matter at all, so a dull plane will be adequate, at least regarding the quality of the surface it leaves, which is likely to be pretty torn-out, depending on the wood. But, even in that case, there is the non-trivial matter of the amount of effort you need to invest to remove that wood, especially if you are using the plane to potential and hogging a fairly wide shaving. In that case, a sharp edge will make a world of difference.

Absent from this discussion thus far, though, is the possibility that someone would be using their scrub plane as a finish tool, perhaps purposefully planing refined scallops on a drawer bottom, for example. In a case like that, someone might want a much gentler radius and a much sharper edge.

Ellis

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#15

be careful of that technique

Larry Williams

Rigidly locking a cutting edge vertically, like shown in that video is a little dangerous. A moment's inattention can result in a serious cut. I used to use a similar method for sharpening molding plane irons in workshops and a couple close calls plus one emergency room visit by a student changed how I have people do this.

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#16

Re: That method carries

North of the Border

the same degree of risk of cuts as many other free hand sharpening methods. I agree care should be exercised when sharpening a chisel or an iron free hand. Inattention is indeed a major source of cuts and injuries.

This gentleman uses a locking approach to sharpen his chisels and again, one should be attentive when working with sharp edges:

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/woodworking-blogs/chris-schwarz-blog/a-dance-to-keep-your-stones-flat

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#17

Clumsy

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Deneb says the rounded edge "is not like a traditional plane iron". I don't know what tradition he is talking about. I never heard anybody suggest it was a new idea when Moxon discussed "a convex arch" for a fore plane in the 17th century. The whole presentation seems awfully clumsy. Nicholson (1812) suggests sharpening a convex iron with a "to and fro" motion on a flat rub stone and a Turkey stone.

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#18

Re: LN scrub plane sharpening video

roger lance

This is the instructional video I was referring to above....I, for one, am very grateful to LN for their series of instructional videos....they help to de-mistify a number of tools and procedures including scraper planes, saw sharpening, router plane, scrub plane, etc....if someone feels that they can do better, please make a video, put it on YouTube....I'd like to watch it.

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#19

moved post to proper location

Larry Williams

see "disagree" above

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#20

disagree

Larry Williams

You have the blade rigidly clamped in a vertical position and you're moving your hands and arms around the cutting edge. It's very easy to be distracted and lose track of where that cutting edge is. I used to have people in workshops refine the profile of unhardened molding plane irons in a similar manner. I learned my lesson and don't do that anymore. There's just a lot of unnecessary risk. Here's an image from the video:


img

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#21

Re: LN scrub plane sharpening vid here

David Weaver

Far easier to just use the method he uses with a side clamping jig, but do it freehand. Back and forth across the stone is slow, no reason to not just pull the iron length of the stone and roll the edge as you go.

It is not a small enough iron to consider locking it in the vise and running a stone into the edge. Reminds me of people who lash a stone into the edge of a drawknife.

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#22

Re: disagree  - Larry, Now I understand

North of the Border

you were referring to that part of the sharpening. I never tried it because if need be, I grind the edge. I only follow the part that Deneb showed for locking and sharpening the scrub plane iron on the waterstones. Like any other free hand sharpening methods, it takes some practice to get the result you want, or as Deneb said, to get the chips flying afterwards.

It's hard to find two woodworkers to agree on what's sharp, let alone how to make an edge sharp. Tage Frid used the back of a chisel to burnish the card scraper, something Chris Schwarz would label as stupid if modern woodworkers do that (because scrapers these days are harder than those Tage Frid was familiar with).

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#23

Re: LN scrub plane sharpening vid here

North of the Border

"Back and forth across the stone is slow, no reason to not just pull the iron length of the stone and roll the edge as you go. "

I believe Deneb demonstrated this method as an alternative to benefit those - myself included - who don't have such a clamp jig. I agree it may be slower (but not a lot, because there's no time spent on clamping the iron to the jig).

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#24

See Popular W.  #192  page 42

Bill Tindall

The picture shows what I think a scrub plane typically is used for as well as what I believe to be a typical profile of the result. If the goal is something more refined a different plane may be more appropriate.

Re: scrub plane sharpening

#25

Re: LN scrub plane sharpening vid here

David Weaver

I don't use a clamp jig for that, either. Pull it the length of the stone freehand, it's not difficult. It's actually a lot easier to do than sliding the iron side to side. I can't imagine fooling with a side clamp jig for that (and I'm not against using a side clamp jig - especially on a smoother iron, but in this case it is an understatement to say that it gets in the way).

If one would want to slide the iron side to side the way deneb shows freehand, might as well at least turn the stone 90 degrees so you can do that in the long direction of the stone rather than the finicky short sideways strokes across the width of the stone.