Re: scrub plane sharpening
TomD
I sharpen by draging sideways over something. This makes sharpening easy, and while one can argue the scratch pattern, it can be corrected as you go along, and I don't really see a problem anyway.
Another option is grinding and buffing, just as easy as a rounded end scraper for turning.
One thing to keep in mind is that with the more severe radiuses, the whole edge is rarely going to be cutting. While I do try to keep the edge sharp across, you really only need the section that will actually cut to be sharp. That takes the pressure off to some extent.
I think the really severe cambers do have a purpose. My main scrub is an ECE and they are in the 1" radius range, at least eyeball measure. They do allow exteme chips to be liberated crossgrain. I find that useful at times. I do think that if one gets the radius to long that one has re-invented the Jack plane.




