We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Estate sale in the neighborhood yesterday. Picked up two socket chisels. One a 1/4" Buck Brothers, the other a 1/2" Marshall-Wells (Northern King model). I'm under the impression that old socket chisels were generally the better quality chisels. At any rate, for a couple dollars each I didn't think I could go wrong.
Your closing line is certainly accurate. eBay prices, or specialty seller prices, would be higher. I'm not familiar with Marshall-King, but Buck Bros are respected chisels.
But, your question: are you asking whether socket chisels were higher quality relative to tanged chisels? If so, while I'm no chisel expert, my impressions:
The main answer is "it depends on the nature of the chisel." Paring chisels are often tanged, for instance (if you don't need to strike the chisel, you don't need the extra strength of a socket), and may be very high quality indeed; or not, depending on the tool.
In general, I think sockets were an indication of a heavier-duty chisel. All else being equal, if you're looking for a general bench chisel that you might bash now and use for paring then, a socket chisel will probably be your friend.
On the other hand, in some of the conversations here, folks have mentioned that they like the balance of a tanged chisel better; and, certainly, carving chisels, which are almost all (or all) tanged chisels, demonstrate that you can get a lot of mileage from a tanged chisel that you bash with a mallet.
Maker probably matters more than handle attachment. I own a Fulton socket chisel that, for some reason, I can't bring myself to get rid of, even though it duplicates sizes I have in better names (since it's a duplicate, I've never actually used it); Fulton tools do not have a very good reputation.
I have tended to buy socket chisels when I come across them in garage sales. For some reason, I've found more old socket than tanged chisels. I do have a couple of nice little Buck Bros. tanged chisels that appear to be designed for small-quarters paring that are in the queue for cleaning up and trying out.
Marshall Wells made the Zenith brand socket chisels and I love those. I don't know what Northern King is, but if it is just a different name on the same chisel, you've not wasted your money.
I don't think that socket chisels are necessarily higher quality, just preferred by different groups. In the 18th century carpenters often used socket chisels while joiners and cabinetmakers usually used tang chisels. Nicholson (1812) wrote that socket chisels were used by carpenters to make mortises, but that joiners used tanged mortise chisels for this purpose.
In the late 19th century socket chisels were often more expensive, possibly a reflection of manufacturing costs as much as quality. There were certainly high quality tang chisels made in this era. Here is something written about Buck Brothers display at the Philadelphia Centennial exhibition in 1876:
I notice that in your article you wrote: The typical way I and most people use bench chisels is by squeezing the blade between fingers and resting my wrist on the workbench to give maximum control when positioning the chisel. Holding the tool by the handle only makes controlling it harder on delicate cuts. It's funny that when we select chisels we are more likely to just hold the chisel by the handle instead of the way the tool is usually used.
This was the subject of some discussion a few weeks back. Would you like to expand on it. You did promise something when you wrote, "But that's another story".
If a chisel is supposed to be used that way, and one was not prying on it, why does it need to be handled at all? Particularly for those who have paring chisels in addition.
Don't know about stuck chisels (maybe you meant struck?); but under no circumstances is a chisel ever held like that, ever. It's an inherently fallible hold, and probably a bit inefficient as you try to aim for a handle end that's wandering around.
Having a slightly different opinion, older chisels are always better especially when laminated. Those should serve you well.
The only drawback I have associated with socket chisels is the damn handles always fall off, or worst still the handle remains in your hand and the chisel hits the floor.
Some minor variant is the way I chisel and it is the way I have seen many others who produce more work than I. Side of hand is on the board, chisel between thumb and forefinger. One can then quickly position the chisel in a scribe line, tap with mallet, then move to an adjacent position. If I recall correctly this is exactly what I think has been demonstrated in various dovetailing videos. And, it is exactly why chisels that are not top heavy are used for these operations. The "blue handles" suck, short Japanese are great, the short tanged ones I made, equivalent great.
If you have a top heavy chisel it is awkward, which is why tall heavy chisels are not ideal for removing dovetail waste and the like. Try it with a short Japanese chisel.
Bill, Would you mind posting some pics of these when you get a chance? Reason I ask... I received a set of Ashley Iles butt chisels recently and love the shorter length, but they aren't too stout... wish they were a tad thicker. Anyway, before I order some metal I'd like to get the shape/size worked out first. Thanks if you can, no worries if no...
When I was learning to chop hinge mortises, say 45+ years ago, that is just exactly the grip my dad taught me. I started out holding the handle of the chisel, watching where the hammer was striking. Dad made me learn to KNOW where the hammer was going without looking at it, so I could pay attention to where the business end of the chisel was and what it was doing.
I learned that lesson and do it just that way to this day without a problem at all.
I'll send information direct to your email tomorrow some time. If you search I have posted details of construction various times but I could probably make the chicels quicker than I could find the information. .
I think that photo is of a new super-low stealth grip. His hand is resting on the table, and while Klaus does hold and rest is sure isn't that low as far as I remember. He uses a pen grip about mid way up the blade, and supports the chisel off the lower three fingers. Not the same thing at all.
Dovetails aren't the be all and end all. I think the limitation of the pen grip shows up with folks who are really working the chisel. This isn't necesarry in light work like small dovetails, but when the power comes into play it is nice to have the dexterity to follow the line, etc... with a handle grip. That isn't going to magically appear if one has always held a chisel as if it were a pen.
This has been my experiance as well. I have a much easier time fiting a tanged handle and having it stay on than I do in fiting a socket handle. I have even gone to the trouble of drying the handle for a couple of days in the oven before final shaping on a socket handle and it still managed to come loose a few years later.
As partial as I am to tanged chisels I find brands to be a more reliable indicator of quality than type of handle. My go to chisel is a 1" Erik Anton Berg which is a socket handled chisel. it is easy to sharpen yet it really holds an edge well. I have some other highly respected vintage brands(stilleto, barton, ward & payne, buck bros, greenlee) and the Berg beats them all hands down as far as toughness and edge retension.