The singular advantage of sanding
Bill Tindall
I never mastered the belt sander. Screwed up more surfaces with it than I care to remember. Pad sanders are uselessly slow. Don't know about electric ROS as I never used one. When in doubt I look to professional shops for the reliable path. They all use air driven random orbital sanders so that is what I bought. Quality paper is a must to avoid visible scratches. I found it a way to quickly remove wood where wood needed to be removed and it didn't take long to learn to use it. Cost was less than a used Bedrock #5. Faced with hundreds of linear feet of trim, as well as doors etc. to sand for last house it was a satisfying purchase.
That said, it is but one means to the end, a surface ready for stain and finish. It is not necessary to get a table top granite-reference-plate level. Typically I start with scraping, and scrap where scraping is needed to remove "bulk" wood such as edge joints and grain tear from thickness planer. Then I proceed to the air driven sander with 120 grit if I can get by with this size, or 100 grit, and remove the machining marks from thickness planer over the entire surface. Then I hand sand 120, 180 and maybe 220 depending on the wood. I can not get the perfection in the surface I want without finishing with hand sanding.
My procedure may not be quicker than planing, but if it isn't then hundreds of cabinet shops are missing a cost saving idea. What it definitly is, is more reliable.
I have two problems trying to hand plane a surface. First, the plane often won't cut the place on the surface where I need it to cut, presumably because the offending surface is lower than the rest of the panel, I guess. It would seem that the only solution would be to plane the whole surface down to this level, which leads to the other problem.
I don't find hand planing reliable and this shortcoming trumps all else. I lay up panels for best looks. As a result the grain in a typical panel has many reversals. I have never been able to avoid tear out in these situations. And fatally, the tear out occurs unexpectedly. All seems to be going well and damn, a divot is removed. It is the equivalent of catches with a skew. After a few one can conclude screw the skew. These unexpected and fatal events don't occur with hand sanding. (they certainly did with belt sanding which is why I eschew it too).
Some claim that planing a panel is reliable(divot free) in their hands. Maybe some day I will see this claim demonstrated on furniture similar to what I make. The only data I have is the observation that much of the antique furniture I see made from walnut and cherry has the same divots I create in the areas of grain reversal.
I don't have a problem planing drawer sides for fitting. I Lay these up anticipating planing so the grain is oriented favorably. And, if I get an unexpected divot I don't care in a drawer side.
BTW, I was doing some wear testing on the TiN blade and after 100 meters of planing now I see what you mean about looking forward to a restful sharpening break.