New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

planing diversity

Posts

Re: planing diversity

#26

Re: the benefit of these discussions......

TomD

I agree with you Wilbur, though there are ROSs and there are ROSs. Some of them will really move wood while others are barely better than the 1/4 sheet oscilating sanders. Then there are abrassive belt sanders. Locally there is a 15 inch chinese open ended unit for about 2K. That would do up to 30inches. These things are fairly popular with the guitar crowd, and Grizzly has some pretty nice ones for dearer budgets. All well within a Hotley.

Guitars are another interesting examples. While people have been doing it for centuries. The parts are so thin it really is the easier way to shove them into something. And Bill's concerns about tear out, on a piece of wood that could easily be a grand, are well founded. The reverse is say a bench top. Too big and heavy to carry to a machine. And while I would use a belt sander if I had to, it is easier to hold tolerance with a plane. With a plane, you can tell by feel and eye whether you are within a few thou over the whole surface.

I think the problem in this line of discusion is making any categorical statements. The fun thing about the internet is all discusions are up against the Internet Workshop that like Norm Abram's shop, contains every known tool, and unlike NAs shop, every know skill. At home it is a lot more limited.

Re: planing diversity

#27

Re: the benefit of these discussions......

wilbur

"I think the problem in this line of discusion is making any categorical statements."

That sound you hear is Tom's hammer hitting a nail squarely on its head.

"And Bill's concerns about tear out, on a piece of wood that could easily be a grand, are well founded."

Boy, if a panel of "typical domestic hardwood" is $1,000, I need to be more careful with my cherry and walnut cutoffs. ;)

Re: planing diversity

#28

I think Tom was referring to guitar wood

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Tom said: "And Bill's concerns about tear out, on a piece of wood that could easily be a grand, are well founded."

Wilbur said: "Boy, if a panel of 'typical domestic hardwood' is $1,000, I need to be more careful with my cherry and walnut cutoffs. ;)"

I think Tom was referring to guitar wood, which can get a wee bit expensive.

Re: planing diversity

#29

Re: the benefit of these discussions......

TomD

Some day... And I will be rich.

Nah, but that lutherie wood is some expensive, and that is without calculating the legal cost.

Re: planing diversity

#30

Re: I do use...

TomD

I have a pink Diamondwood plane is you want stable. Not too sure what made me buy that colour, maybe the picture was different.

Re: planing diversity

#31

Re: I think Tom was referring to guitar wood

wilbur

Sure, but as far as I can tell, Bill was not referring to guitar woods. The phrase he used was "a panel of typical domestic hardwood".

Re: planing diversity

#32

two quotes that expain so much

Larry Williams

"I don't find it essential to do anything to the back of blades during sharpening...."

"...I think it will serve the Forum participants best to know that planing a panel of typical domestic hardwood is slow and difficult, if not impossible, for the average woodworking..."

I'm at a loss for where to start and I don't want to write a book. Traditional hand tool woodworking is a system of skills, techniques and tools that allow the average person a lot of success. Unfortunately today's woodworker is generally self-taught and finds their path obscured gimmicks designed to play on self-doubt and offer ways to buy or tinker one's way out of learning basic skills.

Removing the wear on the flat face of single bevel tools is critical, sharpening literature as far back as it goes stresses the importance of flat a sharpening/honing medium. This is important for dependable, repeatable and efficient sharpening. One doesn't need flat honing surfaces to work on the bevel but all the gimmicks out there seem to be aimed at the bevel.

The fact that only one person has stepped up to challenge the second comment, and he's into the different system of Japanese tools, stands as a testament to how pervasive all these gimmicks have become. One of my fears is that the second statement may be accurate and that all the gimmicks are killing the woodworking system they exploit.

Re: planing diversity

#33

Re: two quotes that expain so much

David Weaver

Larry, nobody stepped in on the comment because people are not looking to create conflict.

I think you're over-imagining the universality than there are large groups of people spending a significant amount of time in the shop and who do not clean the wear off of both sides of a bevel when they do work.

When someone has given up on using hand tools, there's no real reason to get into an argument about whether or not they remove the wear from the side opposite the bevel on a plane iron.

In fact, if any of my tools are an indication, people do a better job of being aware of cleaning up the side opposite the bevel with each sharpening than they were in the past, as the back sides of my iron have been pretty nasty, some looking like they been ignored, and others rounded over excessively, presumably by stropping, but maybe by poor sharpening technique.

It is so often written now, not just on these forums, but everywhere, that you need to polish both sides of the bevel that I don't think very many people could not be aware of it not being optional for sharp tools. Whether or not people get lazy and don't do it, I don't know, but it surely isn't an unknown or a challenged fact.

Re: planing diversity

#34

Removing wear from the back of the blade

Steve Elliott

The complete quote reads, "I don't find it essential to do anything to the back of blades during sharpening. The diamond abrasive sequence I use grinds the initial burr away. I have seen it get ever thinner and then float away across the cast iron plate."

Removing the entire worn edge is essential and is done mostly by working on the bevel. The issue under discussion was whether a good sharp edge could be achieved by working only on the bevel, without turning the blade over to remove the wire edge. I've tried this recently and know it can be done, though my usual technique works both sides.

Re: planing diversity

#35

Re: two quotes that expain so much

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Larry, I think a lot of us rolled our eyes at the two statements you quoted. I thought I had made a pretty strong statement in this thread on Tuesday.

I have chided Bill in the past for trying to solve problems that a skilled worker does not experience and also for using more effort trying to avoid developing skills than promoting skills. And Bill is not alone in promoting gimmicks over skills.

Re: planing diversity

#36

Re: two quotes that expain so much

David Weaver

I remember when I put my infill smoother together - mostly from scratch.

I intentionally set it up with a mouth about 3-4 thousandths of an inch.

Several people accused me of resorting to gimmicks instead of skill.

Nobody wanted to recognize that I put the plane together with no power tools other than a cordless drill and some sanders (I did use a "bought" iron and lever cap, though).

Some of the things that get touted here are gimmickry - like the titanium nitride coating. Some other things that people like to use (like steel that holds an edge a long time) are accused of being gimmickry, and are nothing of the sort.

Re: planing diversity

#37

Re: Removing wear from the back of the blade

Larry Williams

Steve,

I'm not saying one can't remove the wear from the flat face of a plane iron by working only on the bevel. Because that wear is longer, streaming back from the cutting edge, than it is deep into the face; I see approaching sharpening this way as an inefficient, labor intensive way to waste steel. I do admire Bill's tenacity to stick with it, most would have gone back to their biscuit joiners and pocket screws long ago.

Re: planing diversity

#38

Re: Removing wear from the back of the blade

David Weaver

There must be some wear left.

You can definitely get a sharp feeling without a wire edge without necessarily cleaning the opposite face from the bevel (be it a back bevel or a lapped flat area), but the surface resulting won't be flat if there is any wear left, and you won't be able to get the absolutely waxy look on end grain or the perfect glassy look on face grain.

I have a couple of framing chisels that someone bellied. I use them only to hog things. They are so bellied that I don't feel like lapping all of the belly out at the end (i'm not meaning the type of belly that's on some long chisels per design, but a drastic step on the last half inch of the chisel's length). I have been honing only the bevel, and they are "good enough", as in they will still shave hair, stick on your fingernail, remove end grain, whatever - but they will not leave the quality of pared surface that a tool that's had both sides lapped will do.

I'm convinced a plane iron that does not have the face opposite of the bevel will also not last as long, because in my experience, any iron that has any unevenness along the bevel edge lasts less long in use.

Re: planing diversity

#39

Bevel vs. blade back

Steve Elliott

Larry,

"I'm not saying one can't remove the wear from the flat face of a plane iron by working only on the bevel. Because that wear is longer, streaming back from the cutting edge, than it is deep into the face; I see approaching sharpening this way as an inefficient, labor intensive way to waste steel."

I hope we're talking about the same thing here. I sharpen by removing enough steel from the bevel to eliminate the worn edge. This means going back behind the curve of the wear surface to where the back is flat. If less steel is removed, working the back of the blade won't remove a wire edge.

My preferred method for getting a very sharp edge quickly is to work the bevel until the worn edge is gone and then apply a very narrow microbevel to the blade back, just a couple of degrees with a width of maybe .010".

Re: planing diversity

#40

We're all on the same page then..

David Weaver

... when the back bevel is added in, same thing as lapping a flat iron, and maybe a near necessity for speed when a tougher steel is used.

Re: planing diversity

#41

Exactly so

Steve Elliott

For speed and ultimate sharpness I find the small microbevel to be very helpful. I think of it as similar to the back of a Japanese plane iron, which has only a small perimeter that gets honed, although not at an angle.

I recently prepared some plane blades for a chopping test in which a flat back was necessary. I was able to get the edges sharp but only with a great deal more effort, and these were blades that already had flat backs.

While I've suggested that a good sharp edge can be done by working the bevel only, the very sharpest edges still need the other side honed too. And for ridiculously sharp edges I've found that the back bevel method beats a flat back, no matter how hard I try.

Re: planing diversity

#42

Re: two quotes that expain so much

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I can imagine trying to remove all wear by sharpening only the bevel, and it's not a pretty sight. These discussions about micro bevels and very short back sharpening ("only need to touch up the last inch") mostly make me wonder why the manufacturers bother making flat blades. However, I'm very tired of arguing about it. I give the backs of my blades, the full backs, a swipe or two to remove any waste left over from bevel sharpening. The backs are flat. The bevels, with a couple of exceptions, are flat, NOT hollow ground. That's it. There's nothing that anyone can say that will change my behavior.

As to hand planing panels, I do, with a very light sanding pass from time to time if needed on the edges.

Pam

Re: planing diversity

#43

That's a lot of unnecessary work

Larry Williams

You're the one with very fine measuring capability, maybe there's a way to measure what I'm talking about. The depth of the wear bevel into the steel is incredibly shallow, probably quite a bit less than 1/10th the length of the wear bevel.

Here's a photo of the wear bevel of an iron Don was getting ready to sharpen a few months ago. I'm sure it only took three or four passes of the flat face over a medium (maybe fine, I'm not sure what he's using) to remove the wear and the same amount over a translucent Arkansas to uniformly remove the abrasive signatures of the India. The bevel is even easier.


I can't say how much it would take to remove the wear by working only on the bevel but I wouldn't want to waste the time or steel every time I sharpen. BTW, if your irons or chisels show the signatures of any more than the last stone you used, you need to flatten the iron, chisel or stones with a lot more care.

Re: planing diversity

#44

to add a little more

Larry Williams

Thinking while walking dogs, I remembered this photo.

Unless you badly damage an edge, grinding is only to manage the size of the honed bevel. I keep it pretty small so it only takes a stroke or two to raise a wire edge. This is my smooth plane iron after after grinding and ready to hone. I normally get several sharpenings between grinding.


Sorry for the glare, it makes the honed bevel look larger than it is. It's about a 32nd of an inch wide.

Re: planing diversity

#45

Re: I think Tom was referring to guitar wood

TomD

"Sure, but as far as I can tell, Bill was not referring to guitar woods. The phrase he used was "a panel of typical domestic hardwood". "

I hear that. The part I was agreeing with (partly just to be agreeable, must tweak the medicine...) is just the idea that there is a pro mentality that just equates, sanding with not loosing pieces, and cutting with loosing pieces. I actually inserted a pragraph in the original "draft" about my experiences "competing" with an Oregon Myrtlewood turner to meet his needs by cutting not scraping his bowls. Without going into the details, and I am a great believer in a variety of techniques, I could not have convinced him. And the killer was that the cutting could leave him with just a slight bit more micro-tear-out that would require even more sanding than his high speed scraping technique. So for a guy who TURNS WOOD FOR A LIVING, it doesn't take much to direct the technique away from hobbie methods, but it isn't because those methods are worse. Just think of one thing. He always turns the same most-profitable bowl, and he gets his wood supplied in dried slized blocks. I cut my own wood, or get mostly green wood, and release the bowl in the tree, and do not necesarilly stick to a script. So his method is completely repetitive, his only variable is that the wood has variations that he seeks to limit by choosing a method that works best for that. It is such a different world, that it would be surprising if it did yield to similar techniques. He was very good at what he did.

Re: planing diversity

#46

Another letter in the same magazine

wilbur

Just got my issue of Popular Woodworking Magazine this weekend. (For some reason, issues take longer to get to the Garden State.) Also in the letters column, another reader wrote in to ask about problems he had with persistent scratches while sanding his project. So it would seem that sanding is not necessarily the panacea that it's made out to be.

Re: planing diversity

#47

Re: Another letter in the same magazine

TomD

Sanding is not without skill. And knowledge also helps, stuff like not letting the sander run down on the surface, and a few hundred other things. Making very high quality finishes, the piano, guitar, etc... is normally a difficult trade to learn. Sanding, like planing, is not always relied on because it is easy, normally because it is the only way. Something like buffing a guitar or knife has some rather high risk associated with it, and nobody would do it if there was a practical alternative.

Re: planing diversity

#48

The singular advantage of sanding

Bill Tindall

I never mastered the belt sander. Screwed up more surfaces with it than I care to remember. Pad sanders are uselessly slow. Don't know about electric ROS as I never used one. When in doubt I look to professional shops for the reliable path. They all use air driven random orbital sanders so that is what I bought. Quality paper is a must to avoid visible scratches. I found it a way to quickly remove wood where wood needed to be removed and it didn't take long to learn to use it. Cost was less than a used Bedrock #5. Faced with hundreds of linear feet of trim, as well as doors etc. to sand for last house it was a satisfying purchase.

That said, it is but one means to the end, a surface ready for stain and finish. It is not necessary to get a table top granite-reference-plate level. Typically I start with scraping, and scrap where scraping is needed to remove "bulk" wood such as edge joints and grain tear from thickness planer. Then I proceed to the air driven sander with 120 grit if I can get by with this size, or 100 grit, and remove the machining marks from thickness planer over the entire surface. Then I hand sand 120, 180 and maybe 220 depending on the wood. I can not get the perfection in the surface I want without finishing with hand sanding.

My procedure may not be quicker than planing, but if it isn't then hundreds of cabinet shops are missing a cost saving idea. What it definitly is, is more reliable.

I have two problems trying to hand plane a surface. First, the plane often won't cut the place on the surface where I need it to cut, presumably because the offending surface is lower than the rest of the panel, I guess. It would seem that the only solution would be to plane the whole surface down to this level, which leads to the other problem.

I don't find hand planing reliable and this shortcoming trumps all else. I lay up panels for best looks. As a result the grain in a typical panel has many reversals. I have never been able to avoid tear out in these situations. And fatally, the tear out occurs unexpectedly. All seems to be going well and damn, a divot is removed. It is the equivalent of catches with a skew. After a few one can conclude screw the skew. These unexpected and fatal events don't occur with hand sanding. (they certainly did with belt sanding which is why I eschew it too).

Some claim that planing a panel is reliable(divot free) in their hands. Maybe some day I will see this claim demonstrated on furniture similar to what I make. The only data I have is the observation that much of the antique furniture I see made from walnut and cherry has the same divots I create in the areas of grain reversal.

I don't have a problem planing drawer sides for fitting. I Lay these up anticipating planing so the grain is oriented favorably. And, if I get an unexpected divot I don't care in a drawer side.

BTW, I was doing some wear testing on the TiN blade and after 100 meters of planing now I see what you mean about looking forward to a restful sharpening break.

Re: planing diversity

#49

Re: two quotes that expain so much

Steve Altman

Hi,

I know this thread was about stropping, but I'm trying to understand what's now being discussed.

I know there's a lot of people who believe that the first thing to do with a plane blade, or chisel, is to make the flat side perfectly flat. Some people go to a high grit (>8000) when doing so, so that the flat side is "polished" and mirror-like. After that, the notion is that you don't have to work this polished side much. For instance, if one were using a sharpening sequence like 1000, 4000, 8000 you would work the bevel side on each stone and then, only on the 8000 grit, work the flat side, too, in order to remove the wire edge that still existed.

Other people feel that it's important to work the flat side on each grit. So the sequence would be working the bevel and flat side on 1000, then again, bevel and flat on the 4000, and once again bevel and flat on the 8000.

Is that the distinction that's being made here? Or something like it?

Thanks for any replies.

Re: planing diversity

#50

Fine honing on the blade back

Steve Elliott

The intent of my stropping test was to find out if stropping on plain (uncharged) leather improved an already sharp edge. My conclusion was that it didn't.

As for working on the back of the blade, I flatten the backs of my blades when I first get them, taking them all the way up to 8,000 grit. After that I do as little as I can to them so I won't start to lose that flatness. Usually I just finish off on my finest stone to remove any wire edge that might be there. Going back to coarser grits just increases the amount of work I have to do.