New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

planing diversity

Posts

planing diversity

#1

planing diversity

Bill Tindall

Someone asked rhetorically, during one of the frequent discussions on metal, whether I had the stamina of Godzilla, or some such, because I apparently never needed, or looked forward to, a break when planing to sharpen the blade. This curious question has stuck in my mind whilst finishing up the French Footed bow front(now at last only lacking hardware to complete). I have come to realize that my planing is worlds apart from the questioner.

I never have occasion, or desire, to plane large surfaces. My planing involves removing bits of wood here and there in the course of fitting pieces. Most recently it was a hump in the top framing that was not letting the top lay flat, before that some additional tapering of a drawer top that was binding, and before that shooting a whisker off the end of a piece that was to be fit between two others, etc.

I never plane more than a minute or two at a time. As a consequence I never need to sharpen during a planing session and for the most part the plane is always more or less dull when it is pressed into service, or set aside. I am driven to sharpen when the plane won't do some task at hand, and this obstacle usually arrives unexpectedly because I typically have no idea what condition the blade is in when I reach for the plane. Hence, sharpening is an annoying, unexpected interruption in the task of getting something made. A metal, or coating, that would lessen these annoyances would clearly be desirable. Others, using a plane for similar tasks, would be similarly disposed.

Ditto for paring chisels. The only continuum of feedback I have on dulling is when dovetailing. In this case the session is usually sufficiently long that the favored chisel for the task will need to be sharpened "in route". I don't find these sharpening interruptions nearly as annoying because they are not unanticipated and indeed they provide a welcome break.

Re: planing diversity

#2

Taking a break for sharpening

Steve Elliott

Most of my woodworking has been done in professional shops where use of hand tools was kept to a minimum for economic reasons. Early in my career I found that planes do some things better than any type of sander, as long as they don't cause tearout. I also learned that many shop owners don't like to see planes being used, and consider sharpening done on the clock to be a waste of shop time. For decades I've done all my sharpening at home on my own time and have looked for blades that would stay sharp a good long time.

I'm now in my 60s and do work as a hobby, which is a completely different thing. I don't have a $150,000 computer-controlled widebelt sander but I can get an excellent surface with an old plane that cost a few hundred dollars. Of course it's not as fast. And sharpening itself has become an area of interest for me, another hobby related to woodworking.

Re: planing diversity

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: Taking a break for sharpening

Moses Yoder

If I really enjoyed sharpening, I would use a 1982 Stanley iron on all my planes. Instead, my favorite planes have Hock irons on them. Imagine that.

Re: planing diversity

#4

Re: planing diversity

TomD

Actually, I think the occasional planer, not to mention the total incompetant, wants edge durability even moreso. As others have said, one likes the break, and one can also get into a flow of planing sharpening etc... Try some scything, one resharpens every few minutes. I think what really sucks is when you reach for a plane to do two seconds of work and get all sucked into a tear down and sharpening.

I did once end up with a plane in hand, away from the shop and resharpening tools, and did 7 months of work on the same sharpening. It did get kinda rank by the end, but I appreciated the edge durability of the Japanese blade on that occasion. The plane needed a complete rebuild at the end of that abuse.

Re: planing diversity

#5

Re: planing diversity

wilbur

Why not make honing your plane blade at the end of the day part of your routine? That way each time you pick up the plane at the beginning of the next day, it will be sharp and ready to go. For the amount of planing that you describe, a high quality O-1 steel blade will keep an edge until the end of the day.

As far as when to sharpen, I once heard a great presentation on carving. The demonstrator said that you should resharpen your tool before you think you need to. Another saying that speaks to the same point is, "The more you sharpen, the less you'll sharpen." The idea is that frequent honings ultimately take less time than waiting for the tool to dull and having to start from the coarser grit in your sharpening routine of choice.

Re: planing diversity

#6

Re: planing diversity

Frank D. in Montreal

Hi Bill

I'm not sure it's so much planing differently than planing less, or not at all (such as for stock prep or smoothing). I can see how someone could use machines to increase efficiency (although I've been frustrated by machines when they couldn't do an adequate job on thin, long, or figured stock), but I think that taking off machine marks with a sander does an inferior job to smoothing planes, and using a smoother saves time on one-offs. In any case, I find it curious that someone driving innovation in plane blades actually does little planing (logically you'd think that someone who does a ton of planing pushes for better blades). I'm not so sure you do less chiseling than most people, however, so your interest in more durable plane blades could just spring from your interest in steel and edge retention. It does remind me of those Swiss planes that have disposble cutting edges (kind of like razor blades); the avoidance of sharpening is marketed to people who only use planes for a limited number of tasks.

Re: planing diversity

#7

I lead you to a letter in recent Popular W.

Bill Tindall

The letter writer asked how to plane panels that were laid up from pieces in the most attractive way, which led to grain reversals, which led to tear out in his hands. The bottom line answer was to sand them. Indeed, this is where I have arrived. I bought a LN 4 1/2 high angle frog with the hope that it would lead to successful panel planing. It didn't and it sits idle. I have come to the conclusion that it is not practical to plane the panels I lay up. The results are too unreliable. My experience is exactly that of the letter writer, supported by the PW editor that answered the letter and further supported by the fact that I see some means of panel sanding in most of the professional shops I visit.

I think people that plane a lot simply like to plane a lot and they may even like to sharpen. No doubt picking projects and materials that are compatible with hand surfacing will lead to success, but I can't be limited by these constraints. The exception is drawer sides. I know that I will be planing these to precisely fit the case. Therefore, I carefully choose the lumber and orientation in the drawer. If I occasionally get a bit of tear on a drawer side it doesn't bother me. This same tear on a table top would(does) leave me scurrying for the air driven RO sander.

.....I have been thinking about the possibility of a carbide, segmented helical plane iron..........

Re: planing diversity

#8

I have the issue in front of me (August 2011)

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

And Mr. Schwarz suggests falling to sandpaper as a fourth and last option (first three being higher angle of attack, card scraper then cabinet scraper, in that order).

I am disappointed by CS' response, because he missed out on two factors that are most important in preventing tearout: sharp blade and (really) thin shavings. Novices might not pick on the importance of shaving thickness, and they might not know what sharp really means.

The letter writer quotes that he uses an "incredibly sharp iron". I have no idea as to what "incredibly sharp" means to him. It would help greatly if the writer described his sharpening regimen so we can have a better idea of what "incredibly sharp" means to him. Gut feeling tells me that this is the first area to investigate.

Then, provided the sharpness test is passed, one has to remember that, the thicker the shaving the more probable tearout will occur. Smoothing a panel is supposed to involve taking out the rougher spots and bring a uniform, smooth surface. We aren't taking 1/32" shavings here, just skimming off the surface. I remember CS in a previous PW article, where he reduced shaving thickness down to a "fuzz" for really gnarly woods if needed. The rule of thumb is to take as thick a shaving that will not create tearout, in order to finish the job faster. Methinks the writer is not following that rule.

Frankly Bill, and I hesitate to mention it , but even though I'm not a fan of LN tools in general, with a LN 4 1/2 equipped with a high angle frog you should be able to plane just about anything out there. Give it another try...

DC

Re: planing diversity

#9

Re: I lead you to a letter in recent Popular W.

TomD

"The letter writer asked how to plane panels that were laid up from pieces in the most attractive way, which led to grain reversals, which led to tear out in his hands."

This obviously begs the question how much effort he was willing to spend finding the best wood. A lot of woodworkers don't really put much effort into it at all, and do not budget much money, or restrict themselves much as regards design. The classic bookmatch is a natural grain reversal situation though.

"The bottom line answer was to sand them."

There isn't anything really wrong with sanding anyway. As we have said here many times there are few projects that people do that can be achieved only by hand planing. There are some but it is rare. Production is an economic environment, and similar but very different rules apply in my home shop.

Sanding is uneconomic for me because it leaves a huge mess in my shop. I don't have the time to clean up after sanding. I do a lot of work where sanding is the only way, but I save it for summer when I can do it outside. Small shop economics are not the same as big shop. Would I be willing to deal with a tiny tear out? I would if it allowed me to work how I wished, but in a big shop wrecking even one panel might be too much. Equally, they want to hire idiots to push stuff.

"I think people that plane a lot simply like to plane a lot and they may even like to sharpen. No doubt picking projects and materials that are compatible with hand surfacing will lead to success, but I can't be limited by these constraints."

I think it depends on how you view the constraints. The cool thing about hand tools is they lead back to the greatest furniture ever built. When I started out I had a few tragic experiences hand planing veneer surfaced particle board. I don't do that any more, but the hand tools can lead to places where at least no power tools have been designed to go, though I always assume they might very well could be. I don't have a problem only having time doing great and interesting work and am glad to leave stuff I wouldn't touch to others. You can always helicopter to the top of Everest, Bazooka your deer, or use dynamite for trout. But I am going to stick with boots, bows, and flyrods.

In one of Klaus' videos, he shows panel prep. He planes all over the panel coming at the grain from the correct direction in every case. Then he moves on to scraping. Then he does a very light evening out phase with sandpaper. Sometimes the answer is too simple - plane with the grain. Even if you succeed in planing against the grain you will still need to sand it for an even effect, so sometimes it isn't worth fighting it.

"further supported by the fact that I see some means of panel sanding in most of the professional shops I visit."

It seems like a bit of a stretch to call woodworking in America a profession. Some people have made a good business out of it, but on that basis the greatest lovers are walking our main streets. I also wonder what the long term economics of these shops are. A stroke sander strikes me to be a lot like a lot of heavy machinery that is being sold at scrap prices on Craigslist. Not automated enough to stay in America. These days when This Old House cuts to the guys making their cabinets, it's pretty much all robotic. I don't doubt there is a sander in there somewhere, there just aren't any people, or the people are overseas.

Re: planing diversity

#10

Speed?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

One process modifier is speed. The faster one planes with sharp blades the fewer tearout events occur.

Pam

Re: planing diversity

#11

Re: I lead you to a letter in recent Popular W.

Bob Lang

One think I think was missed in the response was planing technique, in particular the angle of approach. No matter what plane you're using, the likelihood of tearout is greater if you're pushing the plane in the wrong direction in relation to the grain. This will vary with every individual piece of wood, and usually will change at some point along the length of any board.

If you go from right to left and the wood tears, try going from left to right. If a straight on approach isn't working, try coming at the wood from an angle, or skewing the plane in relation to the glue line. One of the good things about planing by hand is you can change direction when you need to, unlike a powered joiner or planer where you're committed to one direction.

When two boards are glued together the situation becomes a lot more complicated, but more often then not there is a way that will work if you aren't locked in to moving in a straight line from a single direction. It takes some thought and experimentation, and often I need to come at one part of the glue line from one angle, stop at the right place and come at the rest of it from another angle. That's part of learning how the tools work, and I try to do everything I can with the tool in hand before moving on to a different tool.

Bob Lang

Re: planing diversity

#12

Re: I lead you to a letter in recent Popular W.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

When I had trouble planing panels with grain reversals, I considered myself a beginner. I don't care if a person is a magazine editor, next year's Cartouche winner, a dilettante or an amateur. If he can't plane a panel all in one direction, he is a beginner in this one small part of woodworking.

Re: planing diversity

#13

Re: I lead you to a letter in recent Popular W.

TomD

The exception to that would be if the alternative was more productive. FK is not a beginer, and makes a living at it. May even use the big Iron Sanding Apprentice for most things. As mentioned, he demonstrated planing with the grain. The problem with fine shavings is that nothing happens fast. So that if you have a fairly large amount of wood to shift in the 1/32"-1/16" range, that is 80 passes at a thou or less. Sometimes just some crossgrain work will get it done, followed up by some fine passes. Whatever, I am not so convinced that the ability to make clear passes in one direction necesarilly means it is the efficient way to get the job done.

There are also a fair number of finishes that prefer to sit on a sanded surfaces, and even some finishing methods, like french polish that end up sanded/abrading in the application of the finish. There are also pieces where different parts get different tools providing the finishing cuts, from scratch awls, to scrapers, to spoke shaves, to carving tools, etc... These surfaces may end up blended with paper. Any time the last touch is with paper you might as well have sanded the whole thing unless there was some reason not to. At the very least one isn't going to baby the surface just to have that glistening look when it is going to be lost.

Re: planing diversity

#14

Re: I lead you to a letter in recent Popular W.

David Weaver

There shouldn't be boards of common woods that can't be planed, as warren says, in one direction, and without tearout.

You might not have quite the shiny surface quality you want at some of the grain reversals, but they should still be tearout free.

I wouldn't stop until you get a plane/setup that gets you to that point.

The rotten (well, it wasn't actually rotten) wood that wilbur sent me was the only board I've ever had that I couldn't plane any direction I felt like planing.

Re: planing diversity

#15

Chalk me up for not liking to sharpen..

David Weaver

..in the middle of a panel or rough board, and I do most of my dimensioning by hand. I also do not find it difficult to sharpen, nor time consuming, but I don't like to stop working.

It may be that an iron will tolerate 15-20 minutes of continuous planing, or about 2500 feet of wood for other-than-smoothing work(that's my guess based on some testing I did previously of high-quality irons).

I don't like to stop to sharpen the iron. i would rather swap out a western plane for a japanese plane and keep going if I get tired. Dimensioning rough wood, I usually run an iron dull before I get tired for the first hour I'm in the shop, and if I have push and pull planes, I can go indefinitely.

I don't like to stop to sharpen. For the irons with camber, though, I have gotten down to sharpening them with a belt grinder, a 1200 grit belt and a loaded leather wheel. Smoother irons still get only stones.

If someone likes to stop to take a break, good for them. I don't do this for a living and I take a break when I'm worn out after a couple of hours. Until then, I don't like unplanned stops. Maybe when I get older, I'll like the breaks better.

I mind this with chisels a whole lot less, they are not housed in anything and there is nothing to re-assemble and set.

Re: planing diversity

#16

the benefit of these discussions......

Bill Tindall

Many of us have settled on an approach to our woodworking and are not likely to change. It is definitely not my objective to try to change the mind of any established woodworker. But some are just joining the discussions to learn new skills and approaches and the evidence suggests we need more of them to keep this Forum alive. These discussions are of most benefit to these new arrivals and it is useful for them to see a diversity of perspectives and approaches to using hand tools.

I make stuff and my objectives are to make better stuff. A quick scan of the house reveals over 50 pieces of furniture I have made, plus small stuff like cutting boards and pepper grinders. I have made about half again this amount for others. My early furniture is less refined in design but things I made 40 years ago are still holding together and functional so I judge my former assembly skills tolerable. My design skills are evolving and my new assembly skills trying to catch up with my designs.

Some years ago after watching professional shops make stuff I realized that my lack of hand tool skills was constraining my woodworking. So I set out to learn the necessary hand tool skills. To that end this Forum and Badger Pond were/are valuable sources. However, I wish I had been exposed to more opinions of people whose objectives are more toward making furniture and less about the process. Such exposure would have helped me evaluate the relevance of some information to my needs, for example panel planing.

I soon found that for the finishes I use a hand planed surface provides no more benefit than a properly sanded surface. Hence, the only potential reason to plane would be speed. While I am no potential SAPFM Cartousch winner (I don't carve) I do make as good furniture as I see posted on this forum. If I am finding panel planing impractically difficult in building this furniture, while in fact it may not be impossible, it certainly isn't for everyone. I think it will serve the Forum participants best to know that planing a panel of typical domestic hardwood is slow and difficult, if not impossible, for the average woodworking.

In contrast, hand cut dovetails provide design benefits so I have found them worth learning to do, and indeed they can be done efficiently and reliably. While some dismiss the need for precision in woodworking in fact good joinery demands precision down to thousandths of an inch. Hand tools excel at removing precise amounts of material so they find utility in fitting. A drawer planed to precisely fit its opening returns a great satisfaction in its operation (they don't bind nor need hardware). To that end I have learned, and tolerate, planing and paring to fit something, but I remain un-fond of the sharpening that goes with it.

Re: planing diversity

#17

Re: the benefit of these discussions......

TomD

"If I am finding panel planing impractically difficult in building this furniture, while in fact it may not be impossible, it certainly isn't for everyone. I think it will serve the Forum participants best to know that planing a panel of typical domestic hardwood is slow and difficult, if not impossible, for the average woodworking."

I don't find that. I think while I enjoy planing maple, that gets to be hard work, but planing walnut, cherry, etc... is easy and fast. I think I may have got chest pains the other day whisking icing for my Mother in Law's birthday cake. I used to hang off frozen icicles... Some of this stuff is young people's work, or people they worked so hard they didn't remain young for long. So maybe amongst the largely "old tools" membership one shouldn't really Gage the utility of all these techniques. Any more than one judges a sword by puting it in the hands of a 60 year old. Maybe it is true of a lot of people here, but I took up hand tool woodworking when I was in my late teens so I remember what it was like. I get the feeling a lot of today's premium tool users, mostly got into it when they retired.

"To that end I have learned, and tolerate, planing and paring to fit something, but I remain un-fond of the sharpening that goes with it."

Seems like some useful stuff is coming out of all this, but it still does drop the jaw at the idea we are all taking these non-stop lectures on how we are all jerks for using anything but X steel, and Y sharpening tools (neither of which are commercially available for the most part) because you can't find a steel edge retentive enough to plane a postage stamp sized piece of wood. But then again, we don't have toilet paper because of all the folks who said "leaves, not only biodegradable, but biogeneratable!"

Re: planing diversity

#18

Re: Chalk me up for not liking to sharpen..

TomD

"I mind this with chisels a whole lot less, they are not housed in anything and there is nothing to re-assemble and set."

That's another sort of choice since there isn't any reason for a plane blade to require a lot of time to get out and get sharpened. Japanese planes don't present these problems, and western wedged planes aren't difficult to get out but do have to be reset. One would think for 5 grand some of the premium mechanical makers would take this on. This is one reason I like the Rali planes. The replaceable blades are pretty bad, don't even start out that sharp, but the mechanism is extremely easy to shuck a blade from, and pretty nearly instant to reset. The design could be adapted to a more serious blade and general quality in execution. If nothing else it demonstrate that a technical solution could be found.

Re: planing diversity

#19

Re: I do use...

David Weaver

..single iron western planes and single iron japanese planes on a regular basis.

My jack is a cheap japanese plane, one that I sharpen on the belt grinder and spinning leather hone. It is a good way to alternate push and pull planes to keep working, and as you say, there is no consideration for screwing around assembling an iron or dealing with any screws or anything. Pop the iron out, run it across the belt grinder, belt strop it, lap the back quickly on a finish stone, pop it back in the plane - less than a minute. Back to work.

I'm less satisfied with the older planes edge holding - they are soft, and while they don't chip out, they wear fairly fast compared to a harder iron (like visible wear bevel and dullness after half the time), presumably because the blacksmith wanted them to be easy to sharpen on oilstones.

My favorite smoother is a western hock-ironed single iron infill with a tiny mouth. It will plane anything domestic, and it is quick to take apart and quick to reassemble, and very stable.

Re: planing diversity

#20

Re: the benefit of these discussions......

Frank D. in Montreal

"I soon found that for the finishes I use a hand planed surface provides no more benefit than a properly sanded surface. Hence, the only potential reason to plane would be speed. While I am no potential SAPFM Cartousch winner (I don't carve) I do make as good furniture as I see posted on this forum. If I am finding panel planing impractically difficult in building this furniture, while in fact it may not be impossible, it certainly isn't for everyone. I think it will serve the Forum participants best to know that planing a panel of typical domestic hardwood is slow and difficult, if not impossible, for the average woodworking."

I agree that proper sanding does a god job. I always finish my hand-planed surfaces with a hand sanding. For me the advantage of using a smoothing plane is that I can reliably see when the surface is adequately prepared (If I used a planer, I can see with great precision when the marks are all gone...and sometimes they run quite deep). I can also preserve the geometry of the work more easily than by sanding alone.

I strongly disagree that telling someone that it's nearly impossible to hand plan a panel is doing them a favor. Using domestic hardwoods, planing a panel is basic and easy, one of the easier planing jobs one encounters, and I'd say it's an example of a job that actually validates the use of hand planes at all, insofar as it is easy and greatly reduces the need for sanding, not to mention eliminating the need for a power planerand jointer, all advantages in a home shop.

"In contrast, hand cut dovetails provide design benefits so I have found them worth learning to do, and indeed they can be done efficiently and reliably. While some dismiss the need for precision in woodworking in fact good joinery demands precision down to thousandths of an inch. Hand tools excel at removing precise amounts of material so they find utility in fitting. A drawer planed to precisely fit its opening returns a great satisfaction in its operation (they don't bind nor need hardware). To that end I have learned, and tolerate, planing and paring to fit something, but I remain un-fond of the sharpening that goes with it."

While I do a lot of my joinery by hand, I have to disagree somewhat here again. I think Krenov is a valuable reference: while hand made joints can certainly be solid and well-made, machines will almost always do a beter job. While hand-made joints, like hand finishing and dimensioning, reduce or eliminate the need for large power tools (great for a lot of home shops), I think Krenov got it right when he said that hand tools excel at shaping and finishing, power tools at joinery.

Re: planing diversity

#21

Re: the benefit of these discussions......

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

I soon found that for the finishes I use a hand planed surface provides no more benefit than a properly sanded surface. Hence, the only potential reason to plane would be speed.

I think another major reason is to avoid the saw dust created by sanding.

Pam

Re: planing diversity

#22

I had a similar problem to the letter author...

John in NM

Planing smooth some drawer fronts made with shop sawn veneer in a matched quarter pattern. They were mesquite, which is difficult to plane even a single board without some tear out as the grain goes every which way in an average 3' piece.

I resorted to frequent touching up on a soft arkansas followed by buffing on a hard felt wheel on a hand crank with some fine polishing compound. Taking the cap iron off took longer than sharpening, and the method worked on a very tough situation. I might have gone over the fronts with some 220 before finishing, I really don't remember.

Re: planing diversity

#23

Good point...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

Re: planing diversity

#24

Re: the benefit of these discussions......

TomD

"I think Krenov got it right when he said that hand tools excel at shaping and finishing, power tools at joinery."

I think that he was right most of the time, but not in any absolute sense. Krenov is basically known as the guy who got the juices flowing for amateurs, and later the guy who ran a school. Most of what he is writing is slanted at people who are starting out. It is true that stuff like slip joints sorta beg to be cut by a table saw. But the reality is that there aren't 2 joints in woodworking, there are thousands, and there are quite a few even in the fine woodworking end of things, many of them will have no simple machine method. Learning to cut these joints by hand is what the Journeyman does.

Also, there is a lot of successful art furniture out there that is shaped with power tools. Going back to the 70s there was all the rounded organic stuff from California, and Wendells stacked stuff. Also the Maloof School, which currently has many adherants, all those chair seats, lot of grinding going on there.

In the lutherie field, as well as others, duplicators have been a staple, and CNC is well moved in. The various CNC woodworking forums are a lot more active than this place.

I think the real division is just whether you are making more of one of something. If you are making multiples of something it makes sense to tool up.

Similarly size mater. You want to shape something 50 feet long, power tools start to look aluring. You can make some quite lovely boats with little more than a sander polisher and a jigsaw.

Re: planing diversity

#25

Re: the benefit of these discussions......

wilbur

"I think it will serve the Forum participants best to know that planing a panel of typical domestic hardwood is slow and difficult, if not impossible, for the average woodworker."

I have to say, I would completely disagree with this statement. It didn't take me that long to figure out this process, at least for typical domestic hardwoods. If I can do it, a lot of people can.

And I don't see a significant increase in the amount of time it takes to plane a surface smooth and using a ROS for the same purpose.