New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Sharpening

Posts

Sharpening

#1

Sharpening

Mike Donaldson

I have a set of my dad's Lie Nielson carving chisels and I remember him talking some about the 'art' of sharpening them. Does anyone know a good resource I could go to to learn how to properly sharpen them without ruining them? I really enjoy carving, and plan to do a lot of it.

-Mike

Re: Sharpening

#2

Re: Sharpening

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I can't really help on your question, but I am flat thrilled to see the joy of wood beginning to grab you.

There will, no doubt, be someone along any minute who can help.

One warning: sharpening is a subject filled - filled - with different theories as to the right material/substrate/product. Ultimately, they all work; people develop preferences through their own experiences, and there are surely methods that don't work as well, but, within the methods that do work well, you can't go much wrong. So, when the posts start contradicting each other, just sit back, absorb, and then try what seems like it would work best for you (or with what your dad used).

I don't know how close you are to any WC members, but, if someone can do a hands-on lesson, you'd get there a lot faster than struggling along alone.

You might go to the "Wood Central articles" section - link in the box that you should find at the top left of your screen, under "Articles," and look around there. Lots of good stuff.

Re: Sharpening

#4

Re: Sharpening

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

So far as I know, LN doesn't make carving chisels. It can make a difference in what kind of steel you're sharpening (e.g., LN's are made of A2 steel and benefit from one type of stone, whereas carving chisels are most likely O1 and would benefit from another type of stone/sharpening method). So first thing to do is to know what you have. Maybe post a photo of the chisels.

I'd bet your Dad has some way of sharpening them already; so probably a good idea to look through his stuff.

Pam

Re: Sharpening

#5

Second that!

Bob Hackett

Re: Sharpening

#6

find a mentor

Bill Tindall

People that carve are fairly common. Most areas have a woodworking club and someone in the club will carve. Or check out craft fairs. Or take a class. Mary May,( Google her), offers excellent classes on carving which include sharpening.

Re: Sharpening

#7

Re: Third!

David Weaver

Re: Sharpening

#8

I agree with Bill

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Carving clubs abound, and they're very good at teaching the mysteries of sharpening. I have a good friend who is very involved in a local carving club, and he assures me that they take it very seriously and are just as smitten by the various methods of sharpening as we are.

Re: Sharpening

#9

Clubs

Phil Joines

The magazine "Chip Chats" has a list of clubs in the back. It may be on their web site too.

Re: Sharpening

#10

Michael Donaldson

Re: Sharpening

Michael Donaldson

I guess I assumed the chisels were LN because they made most of his hand planes and I know he talked about LN a lot. The chisels have no brand on them, they just say "Swiss made". Now that I think about it, being Swiss, they would not be LN.

My dad had some sharpening supplies, but I left them in his shop in Washington State, and I am now home in Virginia. I will get that book and look for a mentor. Are there any WC people in Southern Virginia/Northern North Carolina?

Thanks for the help.

-Mike

Re: Sharpening

#11

Re: Sharpening

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"Swiss made" is the marketing name for Pfeil tools, sold in the U.S. through Woodcraft.

Incidentally, I notice you've posted as both "Mike" and "Michael" Donaldson. Wood Central's software's not smart enough to recognize those as the same person, so when you post as Mike, you won't get full access to posting privileges: seeing other folks' e-mail addresses in case you want to make contact outside WC, editing your posts - and, most important, loading pictures of your work from your computer to messages.

Re: Sharpening

#12

Re: Sharpening

Ron Hock

I used Chris Pye's book, Woodcarving: Tools, Material & Equipment, Volume 1, extensively while researching for the carving chapter of my book, The Perfect Edge (theperfectedgebook.com). While I highlight the fundamentals in an encyclopedic effort to cover all aspects of sharpening, Pye gives an exceptionally detailed explanation of sharpening just for carving tools. Highly recommended.

PS: please try to find/order it from your local bookstore before going to Amazon, etc.

Re: Sharpening

#13

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Ron

Ellis Walentine

It's good to see you weighing in on this topic. Your book "The Perfect Edge" is excellent and has a chapter dedicated to sharpening carving tools.

Ellis

Re: Sharpening

#14

Re: Sharpening

bugbear

One warning: sharpening is a subject filled - filled - with different theories as to the right material/substrate/product.

For some reason, carvers don't seem to have the heated arguments that bench oriented wood workers do.

Despite the more complex sharpening the shaped tools of a carver require.

Odd.

BugBear

Re: Sharpening

#15

Re: Sharpening

Mike in Suffolk Virginia

Hello Mike,

I am in Suffolk, VA. Is that close enough? Both Northern Virginia and the Norfolk area have a WoodCraft Store. They usually have a Carving Club or offer classes. The Richmond store has a a carving club that is pretty active. It is not really that far from either of the two places that you listed. I attend meetings in Richmond on a regular basis. I belong to Richmond Antique Tool Society (RATS). They meet at Pocahontas Middle School. It is not too long of a haul to make, but it does make for a full evening on meeting nights.

Willing to help with your endeavors,

Mike in Suffolk

Re: Sharpening

#16

All in favor say "I"

Kevin French

Motion carried

Re: Sharpening

#17

no

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have to agree with Ron Hock on this one. If it is carving tools you are interested in, Chris Pye's book is far and away the best sharpening information.

Re: Sharpening

#18

Lee is a Great place to start...

Kevin French

for any sharpening.

Before Mike can hope to sharpen a curved gouge, he's going to have to learn to "Sharpen".

My dog-eared, highlighted copy is my most used WW'n books.

Having said that, I don't carve, yet. But I do have a 12 piece freud set I found in the dump.

Re: Sharpening

#19

Re: Lee is a Great place to start...

David Weaver

Carving tools won't be the only thing he ever sharpens, either.

Lee's book is available inexpensively, and it pretty much opens the door to anything, from gouges to an axe. It is an excellent book to have.

Re: Sharpening

#20

Re: Lee is a Great place to start...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Kevin, you can recommend whatever book you want, but if you have no carving experience and you have never even read Pye's book, please don't pretend to speak for all of us.

Re: Sharpening

#21

You and that dump of yours.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

We can't even go to ours, and the last one I was at wouldn't let me pick up an unused piece of pegboard.

Re: Sharpening

#22

Michael Donaldson

Re: Sharpening

Michael Donaldson

I got the books suggested, now I just need to read them, and get a sacrificial chisel to practice on. Thanks for your help. I will let you know how it goes, but being in the military special operations, I don't get a lot of free time, so it may be a while.

-Mike

Re: Sharpening

#23

Re: Sharpening

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

A few years ago I was visiting relatives in New England. My cousin, Howard, sells the Shapton ceramic stones (his website is theperfectedge.com) and I wanted to test them out before buying some. I had forgotten to bring any of my chisels with me, so I picked up an inexpensive Buck or Stanley 1/4" chisel in a Home Depot up there. That chisel has since become one of my favorite chisels, holds an edge pretty well, and slices right through most wood easily.